Desmin in myology. 24th European Neuromuscular Center-sponsored workshop held 5-6 November 1993, Naarden, The Netherlands

Genetic Mutations and Demographic, Clinical, and Morphological Aspects of Myofibrillar Myopathy in a French Cohort

BACKGROUND

Protein aggregate myopathies (PAM) represent a group of familial or sporadic neuromuscular conditions with marked clinical and genetic heterogeneity that occur in children and adults. Familial PAM includes myofibrillar myopathies defined by the presence of desmin-positive protein aggregates and degenerative intermyofibrillar network changes. PAM is often caused by dysfunctional genes, such as DES, PLEC 1, CRYAB, FLNC, MYOT, ZASP, BAG3, FHL1, and DNAJB6.

OBJECTIVE

To retrospectively analyze genetic mutations and demographic, clinical, and morphological aspects of PAM in a French population.

METHODS

Forty-eight PAM patients (29 men, 19 women) were divided into two groups, those with genetically (GIM) and nongenetically identified (NGIM) mutations associated with myofibrillar myopathy.

RESULTS

Age of myopathy onset ranged from 13 to 68 years. GIM group mutations (81.25%) included DES (14), ZASP (8), FLNC (4), MYOT (4), BAG3 (1), CRYAB (2), and DNAJB6 (6). The MYOT subgroup displayed a significantly older onset age (p = 0.029). Autosomal dominant inheritance was found in 74.3% of GIM and 44.4% of NGIM subjects. Overall, 22.9% had Maghrebian heritage, 72.9% Caucasian, and 4.2% Asian. The most common clinical sign was distal muscle weakness (66%) followed by simultaneous distal and proximal weakness in 49%. Eleven patients had contractures, one had a rigid spine, and five had respiratory dysfunction. GIM subjects had greater cardiac involvement (51.7%) versus the NGIM group (33.3%). The average serum creatine kinase level was 393 U/L in GIM and 382 U/L in NGIM subjects. Morphological analysis showed significant differences among GIM subgroups, including the number of vacuoles and regenerated fibers (ZASP), group atrophy (ZASP), and rubbed out fibers (MYOT). Ultrastructural findings showed significant differences in intranuclear rods, Z-disc thickness, and intranuclear inclusions between gene mutation subgroups. Paracrystalline inclusions were present in three patients (DNAJB6). The most frequent mutation in was in DES, followed by ZASP.

CONCLUSIONS

GIM and NGIM PAM subjects showed similar results, suggesting that any unknown genes, which cause this disease have characteristics similar to those already described. Considering the complexity of clinical, morphological, and genetic data related to PAM, particularly myofibrillar myopathies, physicians should be careful when diagnosing patients with sporadic PAM.

Desmin-related myopathy with mallory body-like inclusions is caused by mutations of the selenoprotein N gene

Desmin-related myopathies (DRMs) are a heterogeneous group of muscle disorders, morphologically defined by intrasarcoplasmic aggregates of desmin. Mutations in the desmin and the alpha-B crystallin genes account for approximately one third of the DRM cases. The genetic basis of the other forms remain unknown, including the early-onset, recessive form with Mallory body-like inclusions (MB-DRMs), first described in five related German patients. Recently, we identified the selenoprotein N gene (SEPN1) as responsible for SEPN-related myopathy (SEPN-RM), a unique early-onset myopathy formerly divided in two different nosological categories: rigid spine muscular dystrophy and the severe form of classical multiminicore disease. The finding of Mallory body-like inclusions in two cases of genetically documented SEPN-RM led us to suspect a relationship between MB-DRM and SEPN1. In the original MB-DRM German family, we demonstrated a linkage of the disease to the SEPN1 locus (1p36), and subsequently a homozygous SEPN1 deletion (del 92 nucleotide -19/+73) in the affected patients. A comparative reevaluation showed that MB-DRM and SEPN-RM share identical clinical features. Therefore, we propose that MB-DRM should be categorized as SEPN-RM. These findings substantiate the molecular heterogeneity of DRM, expand the morphological spectrum of SEPN-RM, and implicate a necessary reassessment of the nosological boundaries in early-onset myopathies.

Congenital myopathies with inclusion bodies: a brief review

Based on morphological abnormalities, congenital myopathies can be classified into several categories: (1) enzyme histochemically abnormal appearance without structural pathology, e.g., congenital fibre type disproportion or congenital fibre type uniformity; (2) abnormally placed nuclei, e.g. myotubular and centronuclear myopathies; (3) disruption of normal intrinsic structures, largely sarcomeres, e.g. central cores and minicores; (4) abnormal inclusions within muscle fibres. Several such inclusions are derived from pre-existing structures, most notably rods or nemaline bodies. Other derivatives of Z-band material are cytoplasmic bodies and possibly related inclusions as spheroid bodies, sarcoplasmic bodies or Mallory body-like inclusions. These inclusions share accumulation of desmin, the muscle fibre-specific intermediate filament, and of other proteins, some of them physiological, but others quite abnormal. Inclusions without identified precursors are fingerprint bodies, reducing bodies, cylindrical spirals, and Zebra bodies. Experimental models and tissue culture reproduction are necessary to further clarify significance of these inclusions in congenital myopathy pathology.

Spheroid body myopathy revisited

Having reported spheroid body myopathy from Indiana (IN) inherited in an autosomal-dominant fashion several years ago, we now describe additional findings from the Oregon branch--briefly recorded earlier--and confirm earlier studies in another clinically affected IN member of this kinship demonstrating identical spheroid bodies within the myopathic muscle specimens. The spheroid bodies also contained increased amounts of desmin, alpha-B crystallin, and ubiquitin within muscle fibers. Our studies now have established that spheroid body myopathy is a member of the growing family of desminopathic neuromuscular conditions.

Familial mixed congenital myopathy with rigid spine phenotype

We describe a father and daughter with a rigid spine syndrome and proximal myopathy. The index patient was a 42-year-old man, who died from respiratory failure after a lifelong, slowly progressive proximal myopathy and a rigid spine phenotype. This was morphologically characterized by cytoplasmic bodies, increased desmin, features of reducing-body myopathy, and sarcoplasmic and intranuclear tubulofilamentous inclusions. These cases are characterized by an early onset and possibly autosomal-dominant inheritance, with associated complex structural hallmarks of both desmin-related and inclusion body myopathies. Together they may be defined as a complex mixed congenital myopathy with a rigid spine phenotype.