Guided by electrostatics, a textbook protein comes of age

Design and engineering of a man-made diffusive electron-transport protein

Maquettes are man-made cofactor-binding oxidoreductases designed from first principles with minimal reference to natural protein sequences. Here we focus on water-soluble maquettes designed and engineered to perform diffusive electron transport of the kind typically carried out by cytochromes, ferredoxins and flavodoxins and other small proteins in photosynthetic and respiratory energy conversion and oxido-reductive metabolism. Our designs were tested by analysis of electron transfer between heme maquettes and the well-known natural electron transporter, cytochrome c. Electron-transfer kinetics were measured from seconds to milliseconds by stopped-flow, while sub-millisecond resolution was achieved through laser photolysis of the carbon monoxide maquette heme complex. These measurements demonstrate electron transfer from the maquette to cytochrome c, reproducing the timescales and charge complementarity modulation observed in natural systems. The ionic strength dependence of inter-protein electron transfer from 9.7×10(6) M(-1) s(-1) to 1.2×10(9) M(-1) s(-1) follows a simple Debye-Hückel model for attraction between +8 net charged oxidized cytochrome c and -19 net charged heme maquette, with no indication of significant protein dipole moment steering. Successfully recreating essential components of energy conversion and downstream metabolism in man-made proteins holds promise for in vivo clinical intervention and for the production of fuel or other industrial products. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Biodesign for Bioenergetics--the design and engineering of electronic transfer cofactors, proteins and protein networks, edited by Ronald L. Koder and J.L. Ross Anderson.

The identification of an integral membrane, cytochrome c urate oxidase completes the catalytic repertoire of a therapeutic enzyme

In living organisms, the conversion of urate into allantoin requires three consecutive enzymes. The pathway was lost in hominid, predisposing humans to hyperuricemia and gout. Among other species, the genomic distribution of the two last enzymes of the pathway is wider than that of urate oxidase (Uox), suggesting the presence of unknown genes encoding Uox. Here we combine gene network analysis with association rule learning to identify the missing urate oxidase. In contrast with the known soluble Uox, the identified gene (puuD) encodes a membrane protein with a C-terminal cytochrome c. The 8-helix transmembrane domain corresponds to DUF989, a family without similarity to known proteins. Gene deletion in a PuuD-encoding organism (Agrobacterium fabrum) abolished urate degradation capacity; the phenotype was fully restored by complementation with a cytosolic Uox from zebrafish. Consistent with H₂O₂ production by zfUox, urate oxidation in the complemented strain caused a four-fold increase of catalase. No increase was observed in the wild-type, suggesting that urate oxidation by PuuD proceeds through cytochrome c-mediated electron transfer. These findings identify a missing link in purine catabolism, assign a biochemical activity to a domain of unknown function (DUF989), and complete the catalytic repertoire of an enzyme useful for human therapy.

Elementary tetrahelical protein design for diverse oxidoreductase functions

Emulating functions of natural enzymes in man-made constructs has proven challenging. Here we describe a man-made protein platform that reproduces many of the diverse functions of natural oxidoreductases without importing the complex and obscure interactions common to natural proteins. Our design is founded on an elementary, structurally stable 4-α-helix protein monomer with a minimalist interior malleable enough to accommodate various light- and redox-active cofactors and with an exterior tolerating extensive charge patterning for modulation of redox cofactor potentials and environmental interactions. Despite its modest size, the construct offers several independent domains for functional engineering that targets diverse natural activities, including dioxygen binding and superoxide and peroxide generation, interprotein electron transfer to natural cytochrome c and light-activated intraprotein energy transfer and charge separation approximating the core reactions of photosynthesis, cryptochrome and photolyase. The highly stable, readily expressible and biocompatible characteristics of these open-ended designs promise development of practical in vitro and in vivo applications.

Evolving the [myoglobin, cytochrome b(5)] complex from dynamic toward simple docking: charging the electron transfer reactive patch

We describe photoinitiated electron transfer (ET) from a suite of Zn-substituted myoglobin (Mb) variants to cytochrome b(5) (b(5)). An electrostatic interface redesign strategy has led to the introduction of positive charges into the vicinity of the heme edge through D/E → K charge-reversal mutation combinations at "hot spot" residues (D44, D60, and E85), augmented by the elimination of negative charges from Mb or b(5) by neutralization of heme propionates. These variations create an unprecedentedly large range in the product of the ET partners' total charges (-5 < -q(Mb)q(b(5)) < 40). The binding affinity (K(a)) increases 1000-fold as -q(Mb)q(b(5)) increases through this range and exhibits a surprisingly simple, exponential dependence on -q(Mb)q(b(5)). This is explained in terms of electrostatic interactions between a "charged reactive patch" (crp) on each partner's surface, defined as a compact region around the heme edge that (i) contains the total protein charge of each variant and (ii) encompasses a major fraction of the "reactive region" (Rr) comprising surface atoms with large matrix elements for electron tunneling to the heme. As -q(Mb)q(b(5)) increases, the complex undergoes a transition from fast to slow-exchange dynamics on the triplet ET time scale, with a correlated progression in the rate constants for intracomplex (k(et)) and bimolecular (k(2)) ET. This progression is analyzed by integrating the crp and Rr descriptions of ET into the textbook steady-state treatment of reversible binding between partners that undergo intracomplex ET and found to encompass the full range of behaviors predicted by the model. The generality of this approach is demonstrated by its application to the extensive body of data for the ET complex between the photosynthetic reaction center and cytochrome c(2). Deviations from this model also are discussed.

The structure and function of eukaryotic photosystem I

Eukaryotic photosystem I consists of two functional moieties: the photosystem I core, harboring the components for the light-driven charge separation and the subsequent electron transfer, and the peripheral light-harvesting complex (LHCI). While the photosystem I-core remained highly conserved throughout the evolution, with the exception of the oxidizing side of photosystem I, the LHCI complex shows a high degree of variability in size, subunits composition and bound pigments, which is due to the large variety of different habitats photosynthetic organisms dwell in. Besides summarizing the most current knowledge on the photosystem I-core structure, we will discuss the composition and structure of the LHCI complex from different eukaryotic organisms, both from the red and the green clade. Furthermore, mechanistic insights into electron transfer between the donor and acceptor side of photosystem I and its soluble electron transfer carrier proteins will be given. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Regulation of Electron Transport in Chloroplasts.

Electron transfer and energy transduction in the terminal part of the respiratory chain - lessons from bacterial model systems

This review focuses on the terminal part of the respiratory chain where, macroscopically speaking, electron transfer (ET) switches from the two-electron donor, ubiquinol, to the single-electron carrier, cytochrome c, to finally reduce the four-electron acceptor dioxygen. With 3-D structures of prominent representatives of such multi-subunit membrane complexes known for some time, this section of the ET chain still leaves a number of key questions unanswered. The two relevant enzymes, ubiquinol:cytochrome c oxidoreductase and cytochrome c oxidase, appear as rather diverse modules, differing largely in their design for substrate interaction, internal ET, and moreover, in their mechanisms of energy transduction. While the canonical mitochondrial complexes have been investigated for almost five decades, the corresponding bacterial enzymes have been established only recently as attractive model systems to address basic reactions in ET and energy transduction. Lacking the intricate coding background and mitochondrial assembly pathways, bacterial respiratory enzymes typically offer a much simpler subunit composition, while maintaining all fundamental functions established for their complex "relatives". Moreover, related issues ranging from primary steps in cofactor insertion to supramolecular architecture of ET complexes, can also be favourably addressed in prokaryotic systems to hone our views on prototypic structures and mechanisms common to all family members.

Tuning the Rate and pH Accessibility of a Conformational Electron Transfer Gate

Methods to fine-tune the rate of a fast conformational electron transfer (ET) gate involving a His-heme alkaline conformer of iso-1-cytochrome c (iso-1-Cytc) and to adjust the pH accessibility of a slow ET gate involving a Lys-heme alkaline conformer are described. Fine-tuning the fast ET gate employs a strategy of making surface mutations in a substructure unfolded in the alkaline conformer. To make the slow ET gate accessible at neutral pH, the strategy involves mutations at buried sequence positions which are expected to more strongly perturb the stability of native versus alkaline iso-1-Cytc. To fine-tune the rate of the fast His 73-heme ET gate, we mutate the surface-exposed Lys 79 to Ala (A79H73 variant). This mutation also simplifies ET gating by removing Lys 79, which can serve as a ligand in the alkaline conformer of iso-1-Cytc. To adjust the pH accessibility of the slow Lys 73-heme ET gate, we convert the buried side chain Asn 52 to Gly and also mutate Lys 79 to Ala to simplify ET gating (A79G52 variant). ET kinetics is studied as a function of pH using hexaammineruthenium(II) chloride (a6Ru2+) to reduce the variants. Both variants show fast direct ET reactions dependent on [a6Ru2+] and slower gated ET reactions that are independent of [a6Ru2+]. The observed gated ET rates correlate well with rates for the alkaline-to-native state conformational change measured independently. Together with the previously reported H73 variant (Baddam, S.; Bowler, B. E. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2005, 127, 9702-9703), the A79H73 variant allows His 73-heme-mediated ET gating to be fine-tuned from 75 to 200 ms. The slower Lys 73-heme (15-20 s time scale) ET gate for the A79G52 variant is now accessible over the pH range 6-8.

Mitochondrial Release of Pro-apoptotic Proteins

A key step in the initiation of apoptosis is the release from the mitochondrial intermembrane space of cytochrome c and other pro-apoptotic proteins such as Smac/DIABLO, Omi/HtrA2, apoptosis-inducing factor (AIF), and endonuclease G (EndoG). Discrepancies have arisen, however, as to whether all these proteins are released in different systems. Our results suggest that failure to observe cytochrome c release may be due to the use of different buffers because after permeabilization by caspase-8 cleaved human Bid (tBid), cytochrome c dissociation from mitochondria was highly dependent on ionic strength and required 50-80 mm KCl, NaCl, or LiCl. In addition, mitochondria isolated from apoptotic cells using low ionic strength buffer bound a greater proportion of endogenous cytochrome c. In contrast to cytochrome c, Smac/DIABLO and Omi/HtrA2 were released independent of ionic strength, and AIF and EndoG behaved as if they are exposed to the intermembrane space but tethered to or within the inner membrane. AIF and EndoG were also not released by active caspases, which suggests their involvement in apoptosis may be limited. In summary, whereas tBid permeabilizes the outer membrane to cytochrome c, Smac/DIABLO, and Omi/HtrA2, the release of cytochrome c during apoptosis will be underestimated unless sufficient ionic strength is maintained to overcome the electrostatic association of cytochrome c with membranes.

Interaction of cytochrome c with cytochrome oxidase: two different docking scenarios

Cytochrome c is the specific and efficient electron transfer mediator between the two last redox complexes of the mitochondrial respiratory chain. Its interaction with both partner proteins, namely cytochrome c(1) (of complex III) and the hydrophilic Cu(A) domain (of subunit II of oxidase), is transient, and known to be guided mainly by electrostatic interactions, with a set of acidic residues on the presumed docking site on the Cu(A) domain surface and a complementary region of opposite charges exposed on cytochrome c. Information from recent structure determinations of oxidases from both mitochondria and bacteria, site-directed mutagenesis approaches, kinetic data obtained from the analysis of isolated soluble modules of interacting redox partners, and computational approaches have yielded new insights into the docking and electron transfer mechanisms. Here, we summarize and discuss recent results obtained from bacterial cytochrome c oxidases from both Paracoccus denitrificans, in which the primary electrostatic encounter most closely matches the mitochondrial situation, and the Thermus thermophilus ba(3) oxidase in which docking and electron transfer is predominantly based on hydrophobic interactions.

How do short neurotoxins bind to a muscular-type nicotinic acetylcholine receptor?

We investigated the interacting surface between a short curarimimetic toxin and a muscular-type nicotinic acetylcholine receptor, looking for the ability of various biotinylated Naja nigricollis alpha-neurotoxin analogues to bind simultaneously the receptor and streptavidin. All these derivatives, modified at positions 10 (loop I), 27, 30, 33, 35 (loop II), 46, and 47 (loop III) or the N-terminal (erabutoxin numbering), still shared high affinity for the receptor, and in the absence of receptor they all bound soluble streptavidin. However, the proportion of the toxin-receptor complex that bound to streptavidin-coated beads, varied both with the location of the modification and with the length of the linker between biotin and the toxin. In the receptor-toxin complex, the concave side of loops II and III was not accessible to streptavidin, unlike the N terminus of the toxin and, to a certain extent, loop I. On the convex face, loop III was the most accessible, whereas the tip of loop II, especially Arg-30, seemed to be closer to the receptor. The present data demonstrate that short toxins neither penetrate deeply into a crevice as proposed earlier nor lie parallel to the receptor extracellular wall. These data also suggest that they may not lie strictly perpendicular to the cylindrical wall of the receptor. These results fit nicely with three-dimensional models of interaction between long neurotoxins and their receptors and support the idea that short and long curarimimetic toxins share a similar overall topology of interaction when bound to nicotinic receptors.

Structure of the soluble domain of cytochrome c(552) from Paracoccus denitrificans in the oxidized and reduced states

The crystal structure of the soluble domain of the membrane bound cytochrome c(552) (cytochrome c(552)') from Paracoccus denitrificans was determined using the multiwavelength anomalous diffraction technique and refined at 1.5 A resolution for the oxidized and at 1. 4 A for the reduced state. This is the first high-resolution crystal structure of a cytochrome c at low ionic strength in both redox states. The atomic model allowed for a detailed assessment of the structural properties including the secondary structure, the heme geometry and interactions, and the redox-coupled structural changes. In general, the structure has the same features as that of known eukaryotic cytochromes c. However, the surface properties are very different. Cytochrome c(552)' has a large strongly negatively charged surface part and a smaller positively charged area around the solvent-exposed heme atoms. One of the internal water molecules conserved in all structures of eukaryotic cytochromes c is also present in this bacterial cytochrome c. It contributes to the interactions between the side-chain of Arg36 and the heme propionate connected to pyrrole ring A. Reduction of the oxidized crystals does not influence the conformation of cytochrome c(552)' in contrast to eukaryotic cytochromes c. The oxidized cytochrome c(552)', especially the region of amino acid residues 40 to 56, appears to be more flexible than the reduced one.

The pro-apoptotic proteins, Bid and Bax, cause a limited permeabilization of the mitochondrial outer membrane that is enhanced by cytosol

During apoptosis, an important pathway leading to caspase activation involves the release of cytochrome c from the intermembrane space of mitochondria. Using a cell-free system based on Xenopus egg extracts, we examined changes in the outer mitochondrial membrane accompanying cytochrome c efflux. The pro-apoptotic proteins, Bid and Bax, as well as factors present in Xenopus egg cytosol, each induced cytochrome c release when incubated with isolated mitochondria. These factors caused a permeabilization of the outer membrane that allowed the corelease of multiple intermembrane space proteins: cytochrome c, adenylate kinase and sulfite oxidase. The efflux process is thus nonspecific. None of the cytochrome c-releasing factors caused detectable mitochondrial swelling, arguing that matrix swelling is not required for outer membrane permeability in this system. Bid and Bax caused complete release of cytochrome c but only a limited permeabilization of the outer membrane, as measured by the accessibility of inner membrane-associated respiratory complexes III and IV to exogenously added cytochrome c. However, outer membrane permeability was strikingly increased by a macromolecular cytosolic factor, termed PEF (permeability enhancing factor). We hypothesize that PEF activity could help determine whether cells can recover from mitochondrial cytochrome c release.

The membrane-attached electron carrier cytochrome cy from Rhodobacter sphaeroides is functional in respiratory but not in photosynthetic electron transfer

Rhodobacter species are useful model organisms for studying the structure and function of c type cytochromes (Cyt c), which are ubiquitous electron carriers with essential functions in cellular energy and signal transduction. Among these species, Rhodobacter capsulatus has a periplasmic Cyt c2Rc and a membrane-bound bipartite Cyt cyRc. These electron carriers participate in both respiratory and photosynthetic electron-transfer chains. On the other hand, until recently, Rhodobacter sphaeroides was thought to have only one of these two cytochromes, the soluble Cyt c2Rs. Recent work indicated that this species has a gene, cycYRs, that is highly homologous to cycYRc, and in the work presented here, functional properties of its gene product (Cyt cyRs) are defined. It was found that Cyt cyRs is unable to participate in photosynthetic electron transfer, although it is active in respiratory electron transfer, unlike its R. capsulatus counterpart, Cyt cyRc. Chimeric constructs have shown that the photosynthetic incapability of Cyt cyRs is caused, at least in part, by its redox active subdomain, which carries the covalently bound heme. It, therefore, seems that this domain interacts differently with distinct redox partners, like the photochemical reaction center and the Cyt c oxidase, and allows the bacteria to funnel electrons efficiently to various destinations under different growth conditions. These findings raise an intriguing evolutionary issue in regard to cellular apoptosis: why do the mitochondria of higher organisms, unlike their bacterial ancestors, use only one soluble electron carrier in their respiratory electron-transport chains?

Dynamics of protein-protein docking: cytochrome c and cytochrome c peroxidase revisited

The dynamics of the docking step in the electron transfer reaction between yeast cytochrome c peroxidase and iso-1-cytochrome c has been studied using the Brownian dynamics method. In particular we have calculated the bimolecular rate constant at which a specific complex, the xray crystalline complex, can form in solution by translational and rotational diffusion in a field of force. Complexation criteria have been assessed based on the simultaneous alignment of three atom-atom contacts, as well as alternative criteria. The proteins are able to align one or two contacts at remarkably high rates, in fact, at rates approaching the diffusion-controlled limit for two spheres reactive over their entire surfaces. Three contacts may align, and hence the specific complex may dock, at rates on the order of 10(8) M(-1) s(-1), which is quite representative of the experimental association rate constant for ET-competent complex(es). The formation of the specific complex is strongly influenced by the favorable electrostatic interaction between these proteins. It is striking that a specific protein-protein complex can form within one order of magnitude as fast as two spherical proteins can touch at any orientation. It remains plausible that the high ET tunneling rate in this system can take place through a single highly favorable specific complex using a single high efficiency pathway. Still the contribution from a nonspecific set of complexes is not ruled out, particularly considering the marginal reproduction of the ionic strength dependence in the formation of the xray complex.

Electron entry in a CuA mutant of cytochrome c oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans. Conclusive evidence on the initial electron entry metal center

A cytochrome c oxidase subunit II C216S mutant from Paracoccus denitrificans in which the CuA site was changed by site-directed mutagenesis to a mononuclear copper site [Zickermann, V., Wittershagen, A., Kolbesen, B.O. and Ludwig, B. Biochemistry 36 (1997) 3232-3236] was investigated by stopped-flow spectroscopy. Contrary to the behavior of the wild type enzyme, in this mutant cytochrome a cannot be reduced by excess cytochrome c in the millisecond time scale in which cytochrome c oxidation is observed. The results conclusively identify and establish CuA as the initial electron entry site in cytochrome c oxidase. Partial rapid reduction (ca. 20%) of the modified CuA site suggests that the mononuclear copper ion has a redox potential ca. 100 mV lower than the wild type, and that internal electron transfer to cytochrome a is > or = 10(3)-fold slower than with the wild type enzyme.

Thermodynamic volume cycles for electron transfer in the cytochrome c oxidase and for the binding of cytochrome c to cytochrome c oxidase

Dilatometry is a sensitive technique for measuring volume changes occurring during a chemical reaction. We applied it to the reduction-oxidation cycle of cytochrome c oxidase, and to the binding of cytochrome c to the oxidase. We measured the volume changes that occur during the interconversion of oxidase intermediates. The numerical values of these volume changes have allowed the construction of a thermodynamic cycle that includes many of the redox intermediates. The system volume for each of the intermediates is different. We suggest that these differences arise by two mechanisms that are not mutually exclusive: intermediates in the catalytic cycle could be hydrated to different extents, and/or small voids in the protein could open and close. Based on our experience with osmotic stress, we believe that at least a portion of the volume changes represent the obligatory movement of solvent into and out of the oxidase during the combined electron and proton transfer process. The volume changes associated with the binding of cytochrome c to cytochrome c oxidase have been studied as a function of the redox state of the two proteins. The volume changes determined by dilatometry are large and negative. The data indicate quite clearly that there are structural alterations in the two proteins that occur on complex formation.

Diffusion-controlled DNA recognition by an unfolded, monomeric bZIP transcription factor

Basic leucine zipper (bZIP) transcription factors are dimers that recognize mainly palindromic DNA sites. It has been assumed that bZIP factors have to form a dimer in order to bind to their target DNA. We find that DNA binding of both monomeric and dimeric bZIP transcription factor GCN4 is diffusion-limited and that, therefore, the rate of dimerization of the bZIP domain does not affect the rate of DNA recognition and GCN4 need not dimerize in order to bind to its specific DNA site. The results have implications for the mechanism by which bZIP transcription factors find their target sites for transcriptional regulation.

Further characterization of the two tetraheme cytochromes c3 from Desulfovibiro africanus: nucleotide sequences, EPR spectroscopy and biological activity

The genes encoding the basic and acidic tetraheme cytochromes c3 from Desulfovibrio africanus have been sequenced. The corresponding amino acid sequences of the basic and acidic cytochromes c3 indicate that the mature proteins consist of a single polypeptide chain of 117 and 103 residues, respectively. Their molecular masses, 15102 and 13742 Da, respectively, determined by mass spectrometry, are in perfect agreement with those calculated from their amino acid sequences. Both D. africanus cytochromes c3 are synthesized as precursor proteins with signal peptides of 23 and 24 residues for the basic and acidic cytochromes, respectively. These cytochromes c3 exhibit the main structural features of the cytochrome c3 family and contain the 16 strictly conserved cysteine + histidine residues directly involved in the heme binding sites. The D. africanus acidic cytochrome c3 differs from all the other homologous cytochromes by its low content of basic residues and its distribution of charged residues in the amino acid sequence. The presence of four hemes per molecule was confirmed by EPR spectroscopy in both cytochromes c3. The g-value analysis suggests that in both cytochromes, the angle between imidazole planes of the axial histidine ligands is close to 90 degrees for one heme and much lower for the three others. Moreover, an unusually high exchange interaction (approximately 10[-2] cm[-1]) was evidenced between the highest potential heme (-90 mV) and one of the low potential hemes in the basic cytochrome c3. The reactivity of D. africanus cytochromes c3 with heterologous [NiFe] and [Fe] hydrogenases was investigated. Only the basic one interacts with the two types of hydrogenase to achieve efficient electron transfer, whereas the acidic cytochrome c3 exchanges electrons specifically with the basic cytochrome c3. The difference in the specificity of the two D. africanus cytochromes c3 has been correlated with their highly different content of basic and acidic residues.

Anion binding to cytochrome c2: implications on protein-Ion interactions in class I cytochromes c

The binding of several inorganic and carboxylate anions to cytochrome c2 from Rhodopseudomonas palustris has been investigated by monitoring the salt-induced changes in the redox potential of the heme, using an interpretative model based on the extended Debye-Hückel equation. Most anions were found to interact specifically with the protein at one or multiple sites. Binding constants to the oxidized protein in the range 10(1)-10(2) m-1 were determined from the anion concentration dependence of the chemical shift of the isotropically shifted heme methyl resonances. For several anions the stoichiometry and strength of the binding to cytochrome c2 were found comparable with those determined for mitochondrial cytochromes c, in spite of the limited sequence similarity (less than 40%) and the lower positive charge of the bacterial protein. These analogies were interpreted as indicative of the existence of common binding sites which are proposed to be located in the conserved lysine-rich domain around the solvent-exposed heme edge, which is also the surface area likely involved in the interaction with redox partners. The changes in E degrees due to partial neutralization of the positive charge of cytochrome c2 due to specific anion binding were found comparable with those for the mitochondrial species.

The influence of protein and interfacial structure on the self-assembly of oriented protein arrays

These results demonstrate the complexity of factors that impact the self-assembly of protein arrays via the specific binding to receptor-functionalized interfaces. Both the composition and colloidal properties of the protein and target membrane surfaces will affect the protein-surface interactions. However, different structural features control the interactions over different distance regimes and with different consequences. The long-range interactions that control the adsorption kinetics are sensitive not only to the charge on the target surface but also by the topological charge distribution on the protein exterior. Short-range repulsive interactions rooted in both the protein topology and in the membrane structure, by contrast, can significantly alter both the rates and strengths binding. Consequently, the effective design of self-assembling protein arrays must consider not only the recognition interactions that drive such self-organization, but also the details of the micro-environment and their impact on molecular recognition events.

Synergy in protein engineering. Mutagenic manipulation of protein structure to simplify semisynthesis

Semisynthesis is a chemical technique of protein engineering that provides a valuable complement to directed mutagenesis. It is the method of choice when the structural modification requires, for example, a noncoded amino acid. The process involves specific and limited protein fragmentation, structural manipulation of the target sequence, and subsequent religation of fragments to give the mutant holoprotein. We suggested and demonstrated that mutagenesis and semisynthesis could be used synergistically to achieve protein engineering goals otherwise unobtainable, if mutagenesis was used to shuffle methionine residues in the yeast cytochrome c sequence (Wallace, C. J. A., Guillemette, J. G., Hibiya, Y., and Smith, M. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 21355-21357). These residues can not only be sites of specific cleavage by CNBr but also of spontaneous peptide bond synthesis between fragments in noncovalent complexes, which greatly facilitates the semisynthetic process. We have now used an informed "methionine scan" of the protein sequence to discover other useful sites and to characterize the factors that promote this extraordinary and convenient autocatalytic religation. Of eight sites canvassed, in a wide range of settings, five efficiently provoked peptide bond synthesis. The principal factor determining efficiency seems to be the hydropathy of the religation site. The mutants created have also provided some new insights on structure-function relationships in the cytochrome.

Definition of a nucleotide binding site on cytochrome c by photoaffinity labeling

We have used TNP-8N3-AMP (2'(3')-O-(2,4,6-trinitrophenyl)-8-azidoadenosine monophosphate) and TNP-8N3-ATP to probe the ATP binding site(s) of cytochrome c. Irradiation of cytochrome c with close to stoichiometric amounts of TNP-8N3-AMP at low ionic strength derivatized approximately half of the protein, with the mono-derivatized species being associated with four peaks (B, 6%; C, 17%; D, 24%; E, 4%) eluted from a cation exchange column. Irradiation in the presence of ATP suggested that the main peaks C and D resulted from more specific nucleotide binding. Thermolysin digestion and TNP-peptide purification and sequencing revealed that peak C was associated with derivatization of mainly Lys-86 and to a lesser extent Lys-72 and peak D with mainly Lys-87 and less so with Lys-72. Minor peaks B and E could not be identified. TNP-8N3-ATP photolabeling produced similar results, showing favored interaction of the adenyl ring with Lys-86 and Lys-87 and to a lesser extent with Lys-72. The results are compatible with previous findings that suggest that the principal locus of ATP binding is at nearby Arg-91 (Corthesy, B. E., and Wallace, C. J. A.(1986) Biochem. J. 236, 359-364). Molecular modeling with energy-minimized docking of ATP between the 60s helix and the 80s stretch with the gamma-phosphate constrained to interact with Arg-91, places the 8 position close to Lys-86 and Lys-87 in the anti conformation about the glycosidic bond and to Lys-72 in the syn conformation, and the ribose hydroxyls within H-bonding distance of Glu-69.

Immobilization of proteins to lipid bilayers

Phospholipid bilayers deposited on sensor surfaces are excellent substrates for immobilizing proteins via a molecular anchor. An integrated optics sensing device was used to accurately measure the binding kinetics of proteins thus anchored. By comparing the results with measurements using proteins from which the anchor had been enzymatically removed, it was shown that the anchor accounts for essentially all the irreversible binding. The insertion of the anchor into the lipid bilayer is a spontaneous process. This method of immobilization should be widely applicable to many soluble protein molecules, to which an anchor can be attached by routine methods of molecular engineering.

A chemical modification of cytochrome-c lysines leading to changes in heme iron ligation

Although 13 lysines of horse cytochrome c are invariant, and three more are extremely conserved, the modification of their side-chain epsilon-amino groups by beta-thiopropionylation caused important changes in protein properties for only three of them; lysines 72,73 and 79. Optical spectroscopy, electron and nuclear paramagnetic resonance, electron spin echo envelope modulation, and molecular weight studies, as well as the unique features of their reaction with cytochrome-c oxidase, indicate that in the oxidized state the modification of these lysines resulted in equilibria between two different states of iron ligation: the native state, in which the metal is coordinated by the methionine-80 sulfur, and a new state in which this ligand is displaced by the sulfhydryl groups of the elongated side chains. The reduction potentials of the TP Lys-72 and the TP Lys-79 derivatives were 201 and 196 millivolt, respectively, indicating that the equilibria favored the sulfhydryl ligated state by 1.5 and 1.7 kcal/mol, respectively. In the ferric state, the protein modified at lysine 72 remained stable as a monomer, but that modified at lysine 73 dimerized rapidly through disulfide bond formation, while the TP Lys-79 cytochrome c dimerized with a half-time of approx. 3 h, both recovering the native-like iron ligation. By contrast, in the ferrous state the monomeric state and the native ligation were preserved in all cases, indicating that the affinity of the cytochrome-c ferrous iron for the methionine-80 sulfur is particularly strong. The dimerized derivatives lost most, but not all, of the capability of the native protein for electron transfer from ascorbate-TMPD to cytochrome-c oxidase.

Beta-thiopropionyl cytochromes c modified at lysyl residues: preparation and characterization of the monosubstituted horse cytochromes c

beta-Thiopropionyl derivatives of horse cytochrome c singly modified at each of 18 different lysine epsilon-amino groups have been prepared using sulfosuccinimidyl-2-(biotinamido)ethyl-1,3-dithiopropionate and purified to homogeneity by high-pressure liquid chromatography. These derivatives were characterized by determination of: (i) the location of the modification; (ii) reduction potentials; (iii) visible and NMR spectra: and by (iv) measurement of electron transfer activity with cytochrome-c oxidase. No significant changes in structure were indicated, except for the ferric forms of the derivatives modified at lysines 72, 73, and 79 which are discussed separately. The electron transfer activity of the beta-thiopropionyl cytochromes c with bovine heart cytochrome-c oxidase was decreased to extents dependent on the position of the modification. Aminoethylation, a secondary modification which reverses the charge change, restored the electron transfer rate to that observed with the unmodified cytochrome c, irrespective of the location of the primary modification. These results afford a direct experimental demonstration that alterations in kinetics with physiological electron transfer partners resulting from modifications which cause a change of the charge of surface side chains are solely due to the electrostatic effects. Of the many chemically modified cytochromes c prepared to date, the singly substituted beta-thiopropionyl cytochromes c are likely to be particularly useful as the thiol allows covalent linkage of any sulfhydryl-reactive reagent to a well-defined location on the protein surface by a simple procedure, even when the secondary modifier is relatively unstable, a crucial advantage not otherwise readily achieved.

The low ionic strength crystal structure of horse cytochrome c at 2.1 A resolution and comparison with its high ionic strength counterpart

BACKGROUND

Cytochrome c is an integral part of the mitochondrial respiratory chain. It is confined to the intermembrane space of mitochondria, and has the function of transferring electrons between its redox partners. Solution studies of cytochrome c indicate that the conformation of the molecule is sensitive to the ionic strength of the medium.

RESULTS

The crystal structures of cytochromes c from several species have been solved at extremely high ionic strengths of near-saturated solutions of ammonium sulfate. Here we present the first crystal structure of ferricytochrome c at low ionic strength refined at 2.1 A resolution. In general, the structure has the same features as those determined earlier. However, there are some differences in both backbone and side-chain conformations in several areas. These areas coincide with those observed by NMR and resonance Raman spectroscopy to be sensitive to ionic strength.

CONCLUSIONS

Neither ionic strength nor crystal-packing interactions have much influence on the conformation of horse cytochrome c. Nevertheless, some differences in the side-chain conformations at high and low ionic strengths may be important for understanding how the protein functions. Close examination of the gamma-turn (residues 27-29) conserved in cytochromes c leads us to propose the 'negative classical' gamma-turn to describe this unusual feature.

Persistence of cytochrome c binding to membranes at physiological mitochondrial intermembrane space ionic strength

We have shown that cytochrome c (cyt c) diffuses primarily in three dimensions in the intermembrane space (IMS) of intact mitochondria at physiological ionic strength (I). Recently, we found that a small percentage (11.2 +/- 2.1%) of endogenous cyt c remains bound to inner mitochondrial membranes (IMM) at high, physiological I (I = 150 mM), even after extensive washing with solutions at physiological I, overnight dialysis, changes in medium osmolarity, or further purification of IMM at high I using self-generating Percoll gradients. Measurements of heme c/heme a ratios, and electron transport (ET) reactions in which cyt c participates, confirmed the presence of a low amount of this I-resistant, membrane-bound form of cyt c (MB-cyt c), that had one third of the ET activity of electrostatically-bound cyt c (EB-cyt c), and which could not account for maximal ET rates. The amount of MB-cyt c was significantly increased above endogenous MB-cyt c by exposing KCl-washed IMM to increasing concentrations of exogenous cyt c. Also, subjecting large unilamellar vesicles (LUV) to successive cycles of cyt c binding/high I KCl-washes gave progressive increases in MB-cyt c. These protocols allowed in vitro characterization of MB-cyt c. The I at which binding takes place affects the affinity of cyt c for membranes, and oxidized cyt c had a greater intrinsic affinity for IMM or SUV than reduced cyt c. MB-cyt c appears to be bound partially by hydrophobic interactions since MB-cyt c was detected on negatively charged (asolectin) LUV and also on neutral, zwitterionic (phosphatidylcholine) LUV at high I. Consistent with the concentration-dependent changes in MB-cyt c, decreasing the IMS-volume of intact mitochondria (i.e., increasing th endogenous IMS-cyt c concentration) by metabolic or osmotic means increased the amount of MB-cyt c. After cyt c was delivered into the IMS by liposome-mediated low pH-induced fusion, resonance energy transfer showed a time-dependent cyt c-membrane proximity which was consistent with slow exchange of soluble IMS-entrapped cyt c molecules with a population bound to membranes at I = 150 mM. We conclude that, even though the majority of functional IMS-cyt c diffuses in three dimensions, a small portion remains firmly bound on the surface of the IMM under I conditions that are physiological for intact mitochondria. The occurrence of MB-cyt c may reflect an intrinsic conformational flexibility in cyt c, that allows a degree of membrane penetration and the formation of hydrophobic interactions which stabilize the membrane-bound form. The persistence of cyt c-membrane interactions under physiological I conditions indicates that cyt c-mediated ET in the IMS involves both fast (3D-diffusion) and slow (2D-diffusion) pathways for electron transfer.

Structure and function of a molecular machine: cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c is responsible for over 90% of the dioxygen consumption in the living cell and contributes to the build-up of a proton electrochemical gradient derived by the vectorial transfer of electrons between cytochrome c and molecular oxygen. The metal ions found in cytochrome oxidases play a crucial role in these processes and have been extensively studied. In this review we present and discuss some of the relevant spectroscopic and kinetic properties of the prosthetic groups of cytochrome c oxidase.

Thermodynamics of ferredoxin binding to ferredoxin:NADP+ reductase and the role of water at the complex interface

The association of ferredoxin with ferredoxin:NADP+ reductase (both proteins from spinach chloroplasts) was characterized by isothermal titration calorimetry and fluorescence quenching titration. The formation of the complex is mainly driven by a positive entropy change (delta S = 125 +/- 8 J mol-1 K-1). The calorimetric enthalpy of binding is small between 10 and 37 degrees C and either negative or positive, with an inversion temperature near 25 degrees C. The pH dependence of the association constant [Batie, C. J., & Kamin, H. (1981) J. Biol. Chem. 256, 7756-7763] was shown to correlate with the uptake of a single proton by a group exhibiting a heat of protonation of -26 kJ mol-1. This value agrees with the protonation of an imidazole group. Possible residues to become protonated in the complex are His-19 or His-90 of ferredoxin:NADP+ reductase. The temperature dependence of the free energy of binding, delta G, is weak because of the enthalpy-entropy compensation caused by a heat capacity change, delta Cp, of -680 +/- 44 J mol-1 K-1. The favorable binding entropy and the negative delta Cp indicate a large contribution to binding from hydrophobic effects, which seem to originate from dehydration of the protein-protein interface. Dehydration was demonstrated by osmotic stress experiments in which the association constant was found to increase by 2-4-fold in the presence of 52% (w/w) glycerol. The increase in the association constant with osmotic pressure points to the release of several water molecules from the complex interface.

Mutations of iso-1-cytochrome c at positions 13 and 90. Separate effects on physical and functional properties

Residues at positions 13 (lysine or arginine) and 90 (glutamate or aspartate) of eukaryotic cytochromes c have been conserved during evolution; Cys102, however, is found only in yeast cytochrome c. The positively charged residue at position 13 and the negatively charged residue at position 90 are close together in those cytochromes c for which three-dimensional structures are available. We have replaced the amino acids at these two positions by cysteine in Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c; in an earlier study, Cys102 was replaced by threonine without negatively influencing the physical or enzymic properties of the protein. The mutated proteins [R13C, C102T]cytochrome c (iso-1-cytochrome c containing Arg13-->Cys and Cys102-->Thr mutations), [D90C, C102T]cytochrome c (iso-1-cytochrome c containing Asp90-->Cys and Cys102-->Thr mutations) and [R13C, D90C, C102T]cytochrome c (iso-1-cytochrome c containing Arg13-->Cys, Asp90-->Cys, and Cys102-->Thr mutations) are functional in vivo. Free sulfhydryl titration shows that the doubly mutated forms each contain one sulfhydryl group while the triple mutant contains two sulfhydryl groups. The stability of mutant [R13C, C102T]cytochrome c resembles that of [C102T] cytochrome c, whereas the stability of [D90C, C102T]cytochrome c resembles the stability of [R13C, D90C, C102T]cytochrome c. The activity of cytochrome-c oxidase using cytochrome c was monitored polarographically. Compared to the wild-type or [C102T]cytochrome c, which shows two kinetic phases with cytochrome-c oxidase, [D90C, C102T]cytochrome c has much the same profile; [R13C, C102T]cytochrome c and [R13C, D90C, C102T]cytochrome c exhibit one kinetic phase with decreased activity. Electron-transfer activity of the mutant cytochromes c is inhibited by Hg2+. The inhibition is highest for the triple mutant, less for [R13C, C102T]cytochrome c, even less for [D90C, C102T]cytochrome c and insignificant for the wild type. It would appear as though the stability of the triple mutant follows the changes that result from the Asp90-->Cys mutation while the activity changes follow those of the Arg13-->Cys mutation.

Direct force measurements of specific and nonspecific protein interactions

Streptavidin-biotin (receptor-ligand) interaction forces were measured directly as a function of their intermolecular separation in various salt solutions and at various temperatures with a surface forces apparatus. Electrostatic and van der Waals forces were found to dominate the long-range streptavidin-biotin interaction at > 20 A. At intermediate separations, down to approximately 10 A, the interaction is governed by repulsive steric and attractive van der Waals and hydrophobic forces. A much stronger short-range attraction giving rise to the strong, specific adhesive binding was measured at molecular separations of less than 5 A. A decrease in the pH from 7.2 to 6.0 resulted in complete charge reversal on the binding surface of streptavidin (pK approximately 6) from net negative to net positive, while leaving the negatively charged biotin surface (pK approximately 3.0) unchanged, and the long-range interaction switched from repulsive to attractive. This observed behavior can be attributed to the titration of two histidines on the biotin binding surface of streptavidin. These results reveal a strong sensitivity of the long-range interaction forces to the detailed amino acid composition of the biotin binding surface. They also demonstrate the powerful regulatory potential conferred by small changes in local surface ionic conditions on protein interaction forces over different distance regimes. The effects of temperature on receptor-ligand dynamics and on the strength of intermembrane adhesion forces were studied by measuring the long-range force profiles and short-range adhesion forces above and below the chain melting temperature (Tc approximately 30 degrees C) of the lipids in the supporting bilayers. Increased bilayer fluidity due to a temperature increase to 33 degrees C (T > Tc) increased short-range adhesion by 7-fold relative to bilayers in the gel state at 25 degrees C (T < Tc). This effect was attributed to the enhanced rates of lateral diffusion and molecular rearrangements on the more fluid bilayer surfaces, which resulted in greater and more rapid intermembrane bond formation. A change in the rates of molecular rearrangements was also found to affect the repulsive part of the interaction potential at intermediate separations (10-20 A) via modulation of the steric repulsion between streptavidin and the highly flexible, polymer-like biotin molecules. This is expected to have a large effect on the association rates of receptor-ligand binding, even if it does not change the equilibrium binding energy.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Structural dynamics in an electron-transfer complex

The dynamic behaviour of the complex of horse cytochrome c with cytochrome c peroxidase, an electron-transfer complex, was studied in solution by a hydrogen exchange labelling method together with two-dimensional NMR analysis. Although cytochrome c hydrogens in the expected binding region exhibit slowed exchange, the measured slowing factors are very small, indicating that hydrogen-exchange occurs with little hindrance from within the binding interface. The complex in solution must therefore be highly mobile rather than rigidly defined, as implied by the crystalline complex. This result is in conflict with the concept that biological electron transfer occurs by way of predetermined covalent pathways.

Replacement of a conserved glycine residue in subunit II of cytochrome c oxidase interferes with protein function

In this paper we describe the isolation and characterization of a respiration-deficient yeast strain which is defective in the function of subunit II of cytochrome c oxidase. This strain, VC32, carries a mutation in the mitochondrial COX2 gene which converts a conserved glycine residue to arginine. The conserved glycine is in a region implicated as important for ligating the CuA redox center and for interaction with cytochrome c. We have also characterized five revertants of VC32 which have recovered respiratory function; all five were mapped to the mitochondrial genome. In three of the five revertants the wild-type glycine codon is restored, while in two of the five the mutant arginine codon is still present. These two strains are likely to possess alterations either in components of the mitochondrial translation machinery or in mitochondrially-encoded gene products that interact directly with subunit II to assemble an active oxidase complex.

Comparison of the binding sites of plant ferredoxin for two ferredoxin-dependent enzymes

Differential chemical modification of acidic residues was used to map the binding site of plant ferredoxin (Fd) for the chloroplast enzyme ferredoxin:thioredoxin reductase (FTR). Binding of FTR to Fd inhibits chemical modification of Fd residues D34, D65, E92, E93, E94 and C-terminal A97. The binding site demarcated by these residues differs from that for ferredoxin:NADP+ reductase (FNR). The FTR site includes C-terminal residues but not helix 24-31, which is part of the FNR site. Both sites enclose the [2Fe-2S] cluster.

Enzyme-substrate binding interactions of NADPH-cytochrome P-450 oxidoreductase characterized with pH and alternate substrate/inhibitor studies

The pH dependence of the kinetic parameters for the reaction catalyzed by NADPH-cytochrome P-450 oxidoreductase (P-450R) has been determined, using various substrates and inhibitors. All Vmax and (V/K) profiles show pKas of 6.2-7.3, for an acidic group that is preferentially unprotonated for catalysis, and of 8.1-9.6, for a basic group that is preferentially protonated for catalysis. The presence of the wrong ionization state for both of these groups is tolerated more at lower ionic strength (300 mM) than at higher ionic strength (850 mM). Ionization of the basic group has a more pronounced effect on binding of substrate (cytochrome c or dichloroindophenol) than on catalysis, since ionization has only a 2-fold effect on Vmax with cytochrome c, and only a 5-fold effect on Vmax with dichloroindophenol, while (V/K) for both substrates continues to drop at high pH with no sign of reaching a plateau. Therefore, this basic group affects predominantly substrate binding and, to a lesser extent, catalysis. It is most likely located on the surface of the protein at the cytochrome c/dichloroindophenol binding site, near the FMN prosthetic group. The NADP+ pKi profile shows a pKa of 5.95 for the 2'-phosphate of NADP+, which is bound to P-450R as the dianion, and a pKa of 9.53 for an enzyme group that must be protonated in order to bind NADP+.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Plastocyanin: Structure and function

The aim of this review is to analyze the current state of knowledge concerning the blue copper protein plastocyanin (PC) focusing on its interactions with its reaction partners cytochromef and P700. Plastocyanin is a 10 kD blue copper protein which is located in the lumen of the thylakoid where it functions as a mobileelectron carrier shuttling electrons from cytochromef to P700 in Photosystem I. PC is a typical β-barrel protein containing a single copper center which is ligated to two histidines, a methionine and a cysteine in a distorted tetrahedral geometry. PC has two potential binding sites for reaction partners. Site 1 consists of the H87 ligand to the copper and Site 2 consists of Y83 which is surrounded by two clusters of negative charges which are highly conserved in higher plant PCs.The interaction of PC with cytochromef has been studied extensively. It is electrostatic in nature with negative charges on PC interacting with positive charges on cytochromef. Evidence from cross-linking, chemical modification, kinetics and site-directed mutagenesis studies implicate Site 2 as the binding site for Cytf. The interaction is thought to occur in two stages: an initial diffusional approach guided by electrostatic interactions, followed by more precise docking to form a final electron transfer complex.Due to the multisubunit nature of the Photosystem I complex, the evidence is not as clear for the binding site for P700. However, a small positively-charged subunit (Subunit III) of Photosystem I has been implicated in PC binding. Also, both chemical modification and site-directed mutagenesis experiments have suggested that PC interacts with P700 via Site 1.

ATP binding to cytochrome c diminishes electron flow in the mitochondrial respiratory pathway

Eukaryotic cytochrome c possesses an ATP-binding site of substantial specificity and high affinity that is conserved between highly divergent species and which includes the invariant residue arginine91. Such evolutionary conservatism strongly suggests a physiological role for ATP binding that demands further investigation. We report the preparation of adducts of the protein and the affinity labels 8-azido adenosine 5'-triphosphate, adenosine 5'-triphosphate-2',3'-dialdehyde, and 5'-p-fluorosulfonylbenzoyladenosine. The two former reagents were seen to react at the arginine91-containing site, yet the reaction of the latter, although specific, occurred elsewhere, suggesting caution is necessary in its use. None of the adducts displayed significant modification of global structure, stability, or physicochemical properties, leading us to believe that the 8-N3-ATP and oATP adducts are good stabilized models of the noncovalent interaction; yet modification led to significant, and sometimes pronounced, effects on biological activity. We therefore propose that the role of ATP binding to this site, which we have shown to occur when the phosphorylation potential of the system is high under the equivalent of physiological conditions, is to cause a decrease in electron flow through the mitochondrial electron transport chain. Differences in the degree of inhibition produced by differences in adduct chemistry suggest that this putative regulatory role is mediated primarily by electrostatic effects.

The interaction between cytochrome c2 and the cytochrome bc1 complex in the photosynthetic purple bacteria Rhodobacter capsulatus and Rhodopseudomonas viridis

The rates of electron transfer from a ubiquinol analogue to cytochrome c2 catalyzed by the cytochrome bc1 complexes of Rhodobacter capsulatus and Rhodopseudomonas viridis were measured as a function of ionic strength. The effects of ionic strength on the kinetic parameters for the reactions are consistent with a role for electrostatic complex formation between cytochrome c2 and the cytochrome bc1 complex in the electron-transfer pathways in both photosynthetic purple non-sulfur bacteria. Additional support for a docking model in which positively charged lysines on cytochrome c2 interact with negatively charged groups on the Rb. capsulatus cytochrome bc1 complex was obtained from kinetic experiments using Rb. capsulatus cytochrome c2 and equine cytochrome c in which specific lysine residues were altered by site-directed mutagenesis and chemical modification, respectively. Equine cytochrome c, which is a poor electron donor to the reaction center of Rps. viridis, is an effective electron acceptor for the Rps. viridis cytochrome bc1 complex. Chemical modification of lysine residues on Rps. viridis cytochrome c2 has a substantially greater effect on the reduction of the Rps. viridis reaction center by ferrocytochrome c2 than on the oxidation of the Rps. viridis cytochrome bc1 complex by ferricytochrome c2. These data suggest that the docking site for Rps. viridis cytochrome c2 on the Rps. viridis reaction center tetraheme subunit differs in structure from the docking site for the cytochrome on the Rps. viridis cytochrome bc1 complex to a significant extent. In this respect, Rps. viridis differs from photosynthetic purple non-sulfur bacteria in which the reaction center does not contain a tetraheme subunit, where the binding sites for cytochrome c2 on the reaction center and the cytochrome bc1 complex appear to be quite similar.

Polytungstate binding to metmyoglobin: an access to various structural forms of the protein

Complex formation between metMb and three heteropolytungstates, offering various sizes and charges, has been studied in the pH range 6-8. 1:1 complexes are formed with (KAs4W40O140)27- and (NaSb9W21O86)18-, with an association constant of 10(6) and 4 x 10(5) M-1 respectively, at pH 7.3 and 10 mM ionic strength. Resulting structural changes of the metMb moiety have been investigated by absorption, CD and EPR spectroscopies. Besides an acid-denatured-like form, obtained at a pH as high as 6.5 with the largest polyanion, the formation of an hemichrome is generally observed. It can be reduced to the hemochrome, whereas the complexation of deoxyMb by the polytungstates leaves the deoxy structure unaltered.