Assessment of human allergic diseases

Assessment of Total/Specific IgE Levels Against 7 Inhalant Allergens in Children Aged 3 to 6 Years in Seoul, Korea

PURPOSE

Childhood allergies are a serious problem, as they may lead to lifetime chronic disease. Determination of total and specific IgE levels is known to be a diagnostic tool for allergic sensitization; however, IgE levels are affected by various factors, such as age, sex, ethnicity, and geographic area. Thus, we evaluated the distribution of total and specific serum IgE levels against seven inhalant allergens in preschool children and examined their association with allergic diseases in Seoul, Korea.

METHODS

Total/specific serum IgE determination and skin prick tests for seven common allergens were performed on 509 children aged 3 to 6 years from 16 child care centers in Seoul, Korea. Demographic characteristics were surveyed from parents using a modified International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC) questionnaire. A diagnosis of atopic dermatitis was made by physicians.

RESULTS

The geometric mean of total IgE was 80.48±3.80 kU/L in preschool children. IgE levels were higher in boys (boys, 102.34±3.52 kU/L; girls, 62.37±3.93 kU/L; P<0.001) and atopic subjects (atopic, 158.00±3.35 kU/L; non-atopic, 52.75±3.44 kU/L; P<0.001). An increased prevalence of atopy was associated with a high monthly household income (P=0.004) and higher maternal education level (above university-level education; P=0.009), as well as increased total IgE levels (P=0.036). Physician-diagnosed atopic dermatitis was associated with sensitization to inhalant allergens.

CONCLUSIONS

Total IgE levels were very high as compared with those in previous reports from other countries. The most common sensitized allergen was Dermatophagoides farinae, and the positive response rate peaked at age 3 years and was maintained thereafter, particularly in boys. Specific IgE levels for seven inhalant allergens varied with age in preschool children. Although further investigations are needed with a broad range of ages and various allergens, the distribution of the total and specific serum IgE levels in preschool children might help to serve as a reference value to diagnose atopy.

IgE antibody-specific activity in human allergic disease

IgE antibody concentration, affinity, clonality and specific activity (also known as the allergen-specific IgE to total IgE ratio) influence the translation of IgE responses into clinically evident allergic symptoms following allergen exposure. Reported IgE-specific activity levels >3-4% place allergic individuals undergoing anti-IgE (Omalizumab((R))) therapy at a disadvantage for poor resolution of their allergy symptoms following manufacturer's recommended dosing schemes. We investigated the hypothesis that the specific activity of the IgE antibody response is highly variable with respect to age, allergen specificity and an individual's total serum IgE level. Second, we investigated whether the IgE-specific activity level influences the extent and rate of loss of effector cell mediator release. IgE-specific activity distributions were plotted against age, allergen specificity and total serum IgE using 18,950 paired total IgE and allergen-specific IgE antibody data obtained from the analysis of sera from 3,614 allergic subjects and covering 182 allergen specificities. The fraction of specific IgE antibody of the total serum IgE was dependent on age of the individual, epitope specificity (clonality) and total serum IgE. The youngest group of allergic individuals with the lowest total serum IgE levels tended to have the highest allergen-specific IgE to total IgE ratios. Hymenoptera venom (54%), peanut (33%) and milk (27%) were the three allergen specificities that elicited the highest frequency of IgE-specific activities >4% among sensitized individuals. A prospective double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical study involving anti-IgE treatment of cat-allergic subjects showed IgE-specific activity was remarkably constant over the 16-week course of treatment, despite the up to 8-fold rise in total serum IgE following repetitive Omalizumab administration. Changes in specific and total IgE levels paralleled each other in patients receiving anti-IgE therapy. The fastest rate of reduction in cat allergen-induced basophil histamine release following anti-IgE therapy was observed when the cat-specific IgE to total IgE ratio was <2.5%. This reflected the more rapid loss of surface cat-specific IgE antibody with anti-IgE therapy in allergic individuals who displayed a more diverse IgE antibody repertoire. We conclude that IgE-specific activity is an age-, IgE heterogeneity- and total serum IgE-dependent variable that influences the magnitude of effector cell mediator release, and by inference, ultimate allergic symptom induction.

Proficiency survey-based evaluation of clinical total and allergen-specific IgE assay performance

CONTEXT

The diagnostic algorithm for human allergic disease involves confirmation of sensitization by detection of allergen-specific immunoglobulin E (IgE) antibody in individuals suspected of having allergic disease because of a history of allergic symptoms after known allergen exposure. Previous studies showed wide disparity among clinically reported allergen-specific IgE levels from different serologic assays.

OBJECTIVE

To validate the relative analytic performance (sensitivity, interassay reproducibility, linearity/parallelism, intermethod agreement) of clinically used total and allergen-specific IgE assays by using College of American Pathologists' Diagnostic Allergy "SE" Proficiency Survey data.

DESIGN

Data from 2 SE survey cycles were used to assess relative analytic performance of the ImmunoCAP (Phadia), Immulite (Siemens Healthcare-Diagnostics), and HYTEC 288 (HYCOR-Agilent Technologies) total and allergen-specific IgE assays. In each cycle, 2 recalcified plasma pools from atopic donors were diluted twice with IgE-negative serum and evaluated in approximately 200 federally certified clinical laboratories for total IgE and IgE antibody to 5 allergen specificities. Statistical analysis evaluated analytic sensitivity, linearity, reproducibility, and intermethod agreement.

RESULTS

Interlaboratory intramethod, intermethod, and interdilution agreement of all 6 clinically used total serum IgE assays were excellent, with coefficients of variation (CVs) below 15%. Interlaboratory intramethod, and interdilution agreement of 3 clinically used allergen-specific IgE assays were also excellent with CVs below 15%. However, intermethod CVs identified between-assay disagreement greater than 20% in 80% of allergen-specific IgE measurements. Allergen reagents and patients' immune response heterogeneity are suggested probable causes.

CONCLUSIONS

Clinical total and allergen-specific IgE assays display excellent analytic sensitivity, precision, reproducibility, and linearity. Marked variability in quantitative estimates of allergen-specific IgE from clinically used automated immunoassays is a concern that may be ameliorated with component allergen use.