Human Radiation Cytogenetics

Radiobiological shot noise explains Three Mile Island biodosimetry indicating nearly 1,000 mSv exposures

The 1979 accident at the Three Mile Island nuclear power station in Pennsylvania released about 22 million Curies of xenon-133 into the environment. Because physical dosimetry indicated exposures to the nearby population of less than about 2 mSv, discernible impacts to the health of the exposed population are not generally believed to have resulted. However, there is contrary evidence, including especially the results of biodosimetry via cytogenetic analysis using the FISH method. This report examines the discrepancy between the results of physical dosimetry and biodosimetry, which among the small number of persons examined indicated exposures between 600 and 900 mSv. The paradox reveals a fundamental error in the health physics body of knowledge: the definition of the energy imparted to tissue, ε, fails to properly account for the temporal distribution of ionization products resulting from dilute contamination with an internally incorporated beta-emitting radionuclide. Application of a century-old result describing "shot noise" in an electronic system repairs the deficiency. The Xe-133 concentration in the tissue of those individuals exposed to the most intense portion of the radioactive plume released from the TMI facility is shown to have been on the order of 0.1 μCi/l, persisting for multiple hours. Shot noise reference doses in the range from 820 to 1,700 mSv follow, a result which is consistent with biodosimetric analysis. The finding should motivate a comprehensive re-evaluation of the conventional understanding of the 1979 accident at the Three Mile Island nuclear power station, especially regarding its impact upon the population of the surrounding area.

Dose-effect relationship for 14.5 MeV (d + T) neutron-induced chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes irradiated in a man phantom

Human lymphocytes were irradiated with 14.5 MeV (d + T) neutrons at the positions sternal, retrosternal, liver and gonads of a waterfilled Plexiglas man phantom of 37 degrees C. After BUdR treatment of lymphocyte cultures and FPG-staining of metaphases, exclusively first post-irradiation divisions (M1-cells) were analysed. A regression analysis was carried out by means of a weighted least-squares method. Dose-effect relations of dicentrics and acentrics could be fitted by the linear-quadratic model. A comparison of the dose-effect curves established with either conventional or FPG-staining technique revealed statistically significant differences. The M1-evaluation yielded about 46 per cent more dicentrics and about 37 per cent more acentrics. The consequences of these results are discussed in relation to the application of chromosome analysis in 'biological dosimetry'.

Survival and PHA-stimulation of gamma-irradiated human peripheral blood T lymphocyte subpopulations

Human peripheral blood T lymphocyte subpopulations were identified and isolated on the basis of their ability to bind IgG (T-G), IgM (T-M), or neither immunoglobulin class (T-null). Lymphocytes were exposed to 0, 0.5, 1.0, 2.5 or 5.0 Gy of 60Co gamma-rays either as a T-cell suspension or as separated T cell subsets. Survival curves, determined 5 days after irradiation, revealed that each subset has radiosensitive and radioresistant portions, and that the T-G cell is the most sensitive subset. Mitotic indices of 48-h cultures showed that the response of unirradiated T lymphocytes to PHA varied greatly among the subsets, the highest indices being obtained for the T-M and the lowest for the T-G cells. With the possible exception of the T-G cells, the subsets are relatively resistant to mitotic effects of gamma-rays. T-G cells suppress the PHA-induced mitotic response of the other T lymphocyte subsets, and this suppressor effect is radiosensitive, being abolished by 1.0 Gy. It is concluded that lymphocytes exposed to greater than or equal to 1 Gy of gamma-rays will have very few dividing B lymphocytes or T-G cells. This together with radiation-induced loss of T-G suppressor action means that the predominant lymphocyte types in mitosis after greater than or equal to 1 Gy are the radioresistant T-M and T-null cells.

A comparison of chromosomal radiosensitivities of somatic cells of mouse and man

A cell culture technique for quantitative analysis of radiation-induced chromosome aberrations in somatic cells has been developed and used for the comparison of chromosomal sensitivity of skin cells of mouse and man to 60Co-gamma-rays. This includes culture of irradiated tissues or cells in culture in arginine and isoleucine-deficient medium and subsequent refeeding with complete medium (CM). With this technique, radiation-induced chromosome aberrations can be analyzed selectively in the cells exposed in G1 phase and recovered at their first post-irradiation mitosis. When tested on the human embryonic cells, the dicentric yield was essentially the same whether they were skin cells irradiated in silu or cultured cells at various in vitro passages irradiated in vitro. In contrast, when studied in the skin cells irradiated in silu, mouse embryos and newborns were insensitive to the induction of dicentrics. In young mice on day II however, the sensitivity was at a level comparable to that in human embryonic cells and it was intermediate on day 4. Such embryonic insensitivity of the mouse cells was rapidly lost during serial transfer in vitro; and, when tested at 4th or later subculture generations, mouse and human cells were equally sensitive to the induction of dicentrics. These results suggest that the chromosomal radiosensitivity is essentially the same for mouse and human cells but can be modified by some biological factors, possibly DNA repair mechanisms, which differ between species as well as among the states of differentiation of particular cell types. Special attention was paid to the parellelism between the age-dependent changes in the chromosomal, mutational and carcinogenic radiosensitivities in the mouse. If this parallelism can be carried over to man, human pre-natal irradiation will not present any reduced genetic hazards.

The relationship between chromosome aberrations and low LET radiation dose to human lymphocytes

In vitro dose-response curves of unstable chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes have been obtained for 250 kV X-rays and cobalt-60gamma-radiation. The aberration yields have been fitted to the quadratic function Y = alphaD +betaD2, which is consistent with the single-track and two-track model for aberration formation. The values of the coefficients alpha and beta support the hypothesis that the dose-rate effect is limited to the D2 term. The main difference between the coefficients for X- and gamma-radiation is in the alpha values, indicating that X-rays are slightly more efficient, at lower doses, in producing two lesions with a single ionizing track. The lower limits of dose estimate, with 500 cells analysed, are 4 rad for X-rays and 10 rad gamma-radiation. Further evidence is presented confirming that, for cytogenetic dosimetry, in vitro dose-response curves should be prepared by irradiating whole blood maintained at 37 degrees C and prior to PHA stimulation. Curves were plotted showing the variation of the number of cells without aberrations with radiation dose and the shape of these curves were compared with those from human cell survival experiments.

The yield of chromosomal aberrations in rabbit lymphocytes after irradiation in vitro and in vivo

The culture time of rabbit lymphocytes (41-42h) that provides cells in their first post-stimulation mitosis, was estimated on the basis of the mitotic index, dicentric yield and presence of the cells with these aberrations unaccompanied by acentric fragments, studied as a function of culture duration. The cells obtained in metaphase from cultures terminated at this time displayed no donor-to-donor variation where induction of dicentrics by x-rays was concerned. Rabbit venous blood was irradiated in vitro with a range of X-and gamma-ray doses, and dose-effect curves were obtained by regression analysis. Sixteen rabbits were irradiated in vivo (uniform whole-body irradiation), and blood was sampled 10 min, 6, 24, and 48 h after exposure. The frequency of dicentrics in the lymphocytes cultured did not change significantly over the first 24 h after irradiation. Dose-effect relationships in vivo fell within one standard error confidence limits of the respective curves in vitro. The authors conclude that the latter may be used for estimation of dose in vivo under conditions of homogeneous whole-body irradiation.