Bioartificial reconstruction of peripheral nerves using the rat median nerve model

The effect of a gap concept on peripheral nerve recovery in modified epineurial neurorrhaphy: An experimental study in rats

BACKGROUND

Several factors such as surgical approach that only consider topographic anatomy; inadequate fascicular alignment, extraepineurial sprouting in the repair zone; contact of axons with the suture area are the disadvantages of epineurial neurorrhaphy. Accordingly, axonal mismatch, neuroma, and unfavorable nerve recovery become inevitable. Neurotropism is the theory clarifying appropriate matching of the nerve fibers independently without needing surgical approach. The studies comparing the primary nerve repair with the nerve defects bridged in different ways demonstrated better outcomes of nerve recovery in the groups with a nerve gap. In this study, we aimed to demonstrate the effects of the gap concept in primary nerve repair bridged by own epineurium. We hypothesized that this technique will provide better results in terms of peripheral nerve recovery and will significantly eliminate the occurrence of a neuroma, which is quite possible in epineurial neurorrhaphy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 35 Wistar female rats weighing 200 ~ 250 g were randomly divided into five groups each with seven rats. Sham controls constituted Group 1, while the rats with epineural neurorrhaphy were included in Group 2. The remaining three groups were the study groups. In Group 3, after the sciatic nerve transection, epineurium of the distal segment was sleeved and preserved. A 2-mm axonal segment was removed from the epineurium free distal ending and no any procedure was applied to the proximal ending of the transected sciatic nerve. Epineuriums of the both sides were approximated and repaired. In Group 4, a 2-mm axonal segment was removed from the proximal ending of the sciatic nerve after preservation of epineurium and no any procedure was applied to the distal part of sciatic nerve. Epineuriums of the both sides were approximated and repaired. In addition, in Group 5, after epineuriums were sleeved in the both distal and proximal stumps, a 1-mm nerve segment was removed from both endings and epineuriums were repaired in the middle bridging a 2-mm axonal gap again. After a 3 months follow-up period Sciatic Functional Index (SFI) was measured by walking track analysis; the area under the evoked compound muscle action potential (CMAP) and latency periods were calculated via electromyographic (EMG) analysis; and histopathological evaluation were performed to compare the parameters of edema, fibrosis, inflammation, vascularization, axonal degeneration, axonal density, myelination, disorganization, and neuroma occurrence. Vascular structures and nerve fibers were counted at ×200 magnification: +1, +2, and +3 indicated the presence of 0-15, 16-30, and >30 structures, respectively. For uncountable parameters (edema, disorganization, myelination, fibrosis, and inflammation): +1 indicated mild, +2 indicated moderate, and +3 indicated severe.

RESULTS

The differences between the groups with axonal gap repair and epineural neurorrhaphy were not significant regarding to SFI. The areas under CMAP were as follows: 27.9 ± 5.9 (Δ = 12.1%) in Group 1; 16.5 ± 5.5 (Δ = 6.3%) in Group 2; 14.1 ± 6.2 (Δ = 4.8%) in group 3; 13.8 ± 2.3 (Δ = 9.2%) in Group 4, and 22.5 ± 18.3 (Δ = 2.2%) in Group 5. Group 5 (1 mm gap in the distal +1 mm gap in the proximal segments) had a significantly better result in terms of the area under CMAP with the value of 22.5 ± 18.3 m/Mv (p = .031). Axonal density was 0.9 ± 0.6 (Δ = 2.2%) in Group 2, 2.4 ± 0.3 (Δ = 5.1%) in Group 3, 2.8 ± 0.1 (Δ = 7.7%) in Group 4, and 2.8 ± 0.2 (Δ = 4.8%) in Group 5. Myelination was 1.1 ± 0.5 (Δ = 3.4%) in group 2, 2.2 ± 0.2 (Δ = 6.7%) in group 3, 2.4 ± 0.4 (Δ = 6.0%) in Group 4, and 2.7 ± 0.3 (Δ = 4.6%) in Group 5. Disorganization was 2.3 ± 0.4 (Δ = 4.1%) in Group 2, 1.2 ± 0.2 (Δ = 7.7%) in Group 3, 1.3 ± 0.2 (Δ = 6.5%) in Group 4, and 1 ± 0.3 (Δ = 5.9%) in Group 5. And, neuroma occurrence was found 2.2 ± 0.6 (Δ = 2.8%) in Group 2 and 0.3 ± 0.2 (Δ = 0.1%) in Group 4 while neuroma was not encountered in Group 3 and Group 5. Comparison between the epineurial neurorrhaphy group and the groups with axonal defect revealed the statistically significant results in the factors of axonal density (p = .001), myelination (p = .028), disorganization (p = .016) and neuroma (p = .001).

CONCLUSIONS

Creating axonal gap bridged by own epineurium showed favorable results comparing with epineurial neurorrhaphy. Resection of a 1 mm axonal segment from the proximal and distal stumps following the epineurial sleeve procedure and performing the epineurium- only repair can facilitate the nerve regeneration. The feasibility of the described technique has been demonstrated in a small rat model and must be further validated in larger animals before clinical testing.

Anatomic description of the basivertebral nerve and meningeal branch of the spinal nerve in the dog

PURPOSE

The existence of the basivertebral nerve and meningeal branch of the spinal nerve has not been proven in dogs to date. The objectives of this study are to 1) determine whether dogs have a meningeal branch of the spinal nerve (MBSN) and a basivertebral nerve (BVN) and to (2) describe anatomical characteristics of these two nerves. Authors also put forward a discussion on the possible clinical relevance of these findings.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Dissections were performed on six embalmed dogs at the Veterinary Faculty of Barcelona with the use of stereomicroscopy and microsurgery equipment.

RESULTS

The MBSN (grossly) and BVN (grossly and histologically) were identified in the cervical, thoracic, and lumbar region in all dog specimens. In addition, other small fibers (suspected nerves) entering the vertebral body through small foramina close to the end plates were identified. Histological examination of the tissues confirmed the presence of nerve fibers (myelinated and unmyelinated) in suspected BVN samples. Results of the present study indicated that dogs have BVNs. Also, suspected nerve fibers were identified among the epidural fat, running from the intervertebral foramina, that likely represent the MBSN.

CONCLUSION

These findings open up the discussion on extrapolation of treatment options employed in human medicine for "low back pain", such as BVN ablation, which is discussed in this article. Further anatomic and clinical studies of the innervation for the vertebral body, periosteum, vasculature, dorsal longitudinal ligament and anulus fibrosus are necessary to elucidate possible anatomical variants and breed differences as well as potential clinical (e.g., therapeutic) relevance.

Peripheral nerve regeneration: A comparative study of the effects of autologous bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells, platelet-rich plasma, and lateral saphenous vein graft as a conduit in a dog model

BACKGROUND

The quality of healing of peripheral nerve injuries remains a common challenge causing pain and poor quality of life for millions of people and animals annually.

AIMS

The objectives of this study were to evaluate the healing quality of facial nerve injury in a dog model following local treatment using an autologous injection of platelet-rich plasma (PRP) or bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (BM-MSCs) at the injury site in combination with the application of an autologous saphenous vein graft as a conduit.

METHODS

20 apparently healthy adult Mongrel dogs were randomly divided into 4 equal groups. Dogs in groups 1, 2, and 3 were subjected to facial nerve neurectomy and saphenous vein conduit graft implantation at the site of facial nerve injury. Dogs in groups 2 and 3 received 1 ml of autologous PRP and BM-MSCs, respectively. Injections were administered directly in the vein conduit immediately after nerve injury. Dogs in group 1 (grafted but not treated; control) received only an autologous vein graft, and those in group 4 (normal control) received no graft and no PRP or BM-MSCs treatment. The dogs were monitored daily for 8 weeks after surgery. Clinical evaluation of the facial nerve, including lower eyelid, ear drooping, upper lip, and tongue functions, was carried out once per week using a numerical scoring system of 0-3. At the end of the study period (week 8), the facial nerve injury site was evaluated grossly for the presence of adhesions using a numerical scoring system of 0-3. The facial nerve injury site was histopathologically assessed for the existence of perivascular mononuclear cell infiltration, fibrous tissue deposition, and axonal injury using H&E-stained tissue sections.

RESULTS

Clinically, BM-MSCs treated dogs experienced significant (p < 0.05) improvement in the lower eyelid, ear, lip, and tongue functions 4 weeks postoperatively compared to other groups. Grossly, the facial nerve graft site in the BM-MSCs treated group showed significantly (p < 0.05) lesser adhesion scores than the other groups. Histopathologically, there was significantly (p < 0.05) less perivascular mononuclear cell infiltration, less collagen deposition, and more normal axons at the facial nerve injury site in the BM-MSCs treated group compared to the other groups.

CONCLUSION

This study showed clinically significant enhancement of nerve regeneration by applying autologous BM-MSCs and autologous vein grafting at the site of facial nerve injury. However, further clinical trials are warranted before this application can be recommended to treat traumatic nerve injuries in the field.

The Median Nerve Injury Model in Pre-clinical Research - A Critical Review on Benefits and Limitations

The successful introduction of innovative treatment strategies into clinical practise strongly depends on the availability of effective experimental models and their reliable pre-clinical assessment. Considering pre-clinical research for peripheral nerve repair and reconstruction, the far most used nerve regeneration model in the last decades is the sciatic nerve injury and repair model. More recently, the use of the median nerve injury and repair model has gained increasing attention due to some significant advantages it provides compared to sciatic nerve injury. Outstanding advantages are the availability of reliable behavioural tests for assessing posttraumatic voluntary motor recovery and a much lower impact on the animal wellbeing. In this article, the potential application of the median nerve injury and repair model in pre-clinical research is reviewed. In addition, we provide a synthetic overview of a variety of methods that can be applied in this model for nerve regeneration assessment. This article is aimed at helping researchers in adequately adopting this in vivo model for pre-clinical evaluation of peripheral nerve reconstruction as well as for interpreting the results in a translational perspective.

Can a Small Intestine Segment Be an Alternative Biological Conduit for Peripheral Nerve Regeneration?

BACKGROUND

Autologous nerve grafts are used to bridge peripheral nerve defects. Limited sources and donor site morbidity are the major problems with peripheral nerve grafts. Although various types of autologous grafts such as arteries, veins and muscles have been recommended, an ideal conduit has not yet been described.

AIMS

To investigate the effectiveness of a small intestinal conduit for peripheral nerve defects.

STUDY DESIGN

Animal experimentation.

METHODS

Twenty-one rats were divided into three groups (n=7). Following anaesthesia, sciatic nerve exploration was performed in the Sham group. The 10 mm nerve gap was bridged with a 15 mm ileal segment in the small intestinal conduit group and the defect was replaced with orthotopic nerve in autologous nerve graft group. The functional recovery was tested monthly by walking-track analysis and the sciatic functional index. Histological evaluation was performed on the 12th week.

RESULTS

Sciatic functional index tests are better in autologous nerve graft group (-55.09±6.35); however, during follow-up, progress in sciatic functional index was demonstrated, along with axonal regeneration and innervation of target muscles in the small intestinal conduit group (-76.36±12.08) (p<0.05). In histologic sections, distinctive sciatic nerve regeneration was examined in the small intestinal conduit group. The expression of S-100 and neurofilament was observed in small intestinal conduit group but was less organised than in the autologous nerve graft group. Although the counted number (7459.79±1833.50 vs. 4226.51±1063.06 mm2), measured diameter [2.19 (2.15-2.88) vs. 1.74 (1.50-2.09) µm] and myelin sheath thickness [1.18 (1.09-1.44) vs. 0.66 (0.40-1.07) µm] of axons is significantly high in the middle sections of autologous nerve graft compared to the small intestinal conduit group, respectively (p<0.05), the peripheral nerve regeneration was also observed in the small intestinal conduit group.

CONCLUSION

Small intestinal conduit should not be considered as an alternative to autologous nerve grafts in its current form; however, the results are promising. Even though the results are no better than autologous nerve grafts, with additional procedures, it might be a good alternative due to harvesting abundant sources without donor site morbidity.

Sensory perturbations using suture and sutureless repair of transected median nerve in rats

The effects of changes to cold, mechanical, and heat thresholds following median nerve transection with repair by sutures (Su) or Rose Bengal adhesion (RA) were compared to sham-operated animals. Both nerve-injured groups showed a transient, ipsilateral hyposensitivity to mechanical and heat stimuli followed by a robust and long-lasting hypersensitivity (6-7 weeks) with gradual recovery towards pre-injury levels by 90 days post-repair. Both tactile and thermal hypersensitivity were seen in the contralateral limb that was similar in onset but differed in magnitude and resolved more rapidly compared to the injured limb. Prior to injury, no animals showed any signs of aversion to cold plate temperatures of 4-16 °C. After injury, animals showed cold allodynia, lasting for 7 weeks in RA-repaired rats before recovering towards pre-injury levels, but were still present at 12 weeks in Su-repaired rats. Additionally, sensory recovery in the RA group was faster compared to the Su group in all behavioural tests. Surprisingly, sham-operated rats showed similar bilateral behavioural changes to all sensory stimuli that were comparable in onset and magnitude to the nerve-injured groups but resolved more quickly compared to nerve-injured rats. These results suggest that nerve repair using a sutureless approach produces an accelerated recovery with reduced sensorimotor disturbances compared to direct suturing. They also describe, for the first time, that unilateral forelimb nerve injury produces mirror-image-like sensory perturbations in the contralateral limb, suggesting that the contralateral side is not a true control for sensory testing. The potential mechanisms involved in this altered behaviour are discussed.

A simple model of radial nerve injury in the rhesus monkey to evaluate peripheral nerve repair

Current research on bone marrow stem cell transplantation and autologous or xenogenic nerve transplantation for peripheral nerve regeneration has mainly focused on the repair of peripheral nerve defects in rodents. In this study, we established a standardized experimental model of radial nerve defects in primates and evaluated the effect of repair on peripheral nerve injury. We repaired 2.5-cm lesions in the radial nerve of rhesus monkeys by transplantation of autografts, acellular allografts, or acellular allografts seeded with autologous bone marrow stem cells. Five months after surgery, regenerated nerve tissue was assessed for function, electrophysiology, and histomorphometry. Postoperative functional recovery was evaluated by the wrist-extension test. Compared with the simple autografts, the acellular allografts and allografts seeded with bone marrow stem cells facilitated remarkable recovery of the wrist-extension functions in the rhesus monkeys. This functional improvement was coupled with radial nerve distal axon growth, a higher percentage of neuron survival, increased nerve fiber density and diameter, increased myelin sheath thickness, and increased nerve conduction velocities and peak amplitudes of compound motor action potentials. Furthermore, the quality of nerve regeneration in the bone marrow stem cells-laden allografts group was comparable to that achieved with autografts. The wrist-extension test is a simple behavioral method for objective quantification of peripheral nerve regeneration.

Does pulsed magnetic field therapy influence nerve regeneration in the median nerve model of the rat?

The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of pulsed magnetic field therapy on peripheral nerve regeneration after median nerve injury and primary coaptation in the rat. Both median nerves were surgically exposed and denervated in 24 female Wistar rats. A microsurgical coaptation was performed on the right side, whereas on the left side a spontaneous healing was prevented. The study group underwent a daily pulsed magnetic field therapy; the other group served as a control group. The grasping force was recorded 2 weeks after the surgical intervention for a period of 12 weeks. The right median nerve was excised and histologically examined. The histomorphometric data and the functional assessments were analyzed by t-test statistics and one-way ANOVA. One-way ANOVA indicated a statistically significant influence of group affiliation and grasping force (P = 0.0078). Grasping strength was higher on a significant level in the experimental group compared to the control group permanently from the 9th week to the end of the study. T-test statistics revealed a significantly higher weight of the flexor digitorum sublimis muscle (P = 0.0385) in the experimental group. The histological evaluation did not reveal any statistically significant differences concerning the histomorphometric parameters. Our results suggest that the pulsed magnetic field therapy has a positive influence on the functional aspects of neural regeneration. More studies are needed to precisely evaluate and optimize the intensity and duration of the application.

Repairing nerve gaps by vein conduits filled with lipoaspirate-derived entire adipose tissue hinders nerve regeneration

In spite of great recent advancements, the definition of the optimal strategy for bridging a nerve defect, especially across long gaps, still remains an open issue since the amount of autologous nerve graft material is limited while the outcome after alternative tubulization techniques is often unsatisfactory. The aim of this study was to investigate a new tubulization technique based on the employment of vein conduits filled with whole subcutaneous adipose tissue obtained by lipoaspiration. In adult rats, a 1cm-long defect of the left median nerve was repaired by adipose tissue-vein-combined conduits and compared with fresh skeletal muscle tissue-vein-combined conduits and autologous nerve grafts made by the excised nerve segment rotated by 180°. Throughout the postoperative period, functional recovery was assessed using the grasping test. Regenerated nerve samples were withdrawn at postoperative month-6 and processed for light and electron microscopy and stereology of regenerated nerve fibers. Results showed that functional recovery was significantly slower in the adipose tissue-enriched group in comparison to both control groups. Light and electron microscopy showed that a large amount of adipose tissue was still present inside the vein conduits at postoperative month-6. Stereology showed that all quantitative morphological predictors analyzed performed significantly worse in the adipose tissue-enriched group in comparison to the two control groups. On the basis of this experimental study in the rat, the use of whole adipose tissue for tissue engineering of peripheral nerves should be discouraged. Pre-treatment of adipose tissue aimed at isolating stromal vascular fraction and/or adipose derived stem/precursor cells should be considered a fundamental requisite for nerve repair.