A simple "proximity" correction for Förster resonance energy transfer efficiency determination in membranes using lifetime measurements

Fӧrster resonance energy transfer analysis of amyloid state of proteins

The Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is a well-established and versatile spectroscopic technique extensively used for exploring a variety of biomolecular interactions and processes. The present review is intended to cover the main results of our FRET studies focused on amyloid fibrils, a particular type of disease-associated protein aggregates. Based on the examples of several fibril-forming proteins including insulin, lysozyme and amyloidogenic variants of N-terminal fragment of apolipoprotein A-I, it was demonstrated that: (i) the two- and three-step FRET with the classical amyloid marker Thioflavin T as an input donor has a high amyloid-sensing potential and can be used to refine the amyloid detection assays; (ii) the intermolecular time-resolved and single-molecule pulse interleaved excitation FRET can give quantitative information on the nucleation of amyloid fibrils; (iii) FRET between the membrane fluorescent probes and protein-associated intrinsic or extrinsic fluorophores is suitable for monitoring the membrane binding of fibrillar proteins, exploring their location relative to lipid-water interface and restructuring on a lipid matrix; (iv) the FRET-based distance estimation between fibril-bound donor and acceptor fluorophores can serve as one of the verification criteria upon structural modeling of amyloid fibrils.

Toward the design of bio-solar cells: high efficiency cascade energy transfer among four donor–acceptor dyes self-assembled in a highly ordered protein–DNA matrix

Artificial antenna complexes built via self-assembly are reported, indicating efficient cascade energy transfer, unprecedented thermal stability, and ease of formation.

The FRET signatures of noninteracting proteins in membranes: simulations and experiments

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) experiments are often used to study interactions between integral membrane proteins in cellular membranes. However, in addition to the FRET of sequence-specific interactions, these experiments invariably record a contribution due to proximity FRET, which occurs when a donor and an acceptor approach each other by chance within distances of ∼100 Å. This effect does not reflect specific interactions in the membrane and is frequently unappreciated, despite the fact that its magnitude can be significant. Here we develop a computational description of proximity FRET, simulating the cases of proximity FRET when fluorescent proteins are used to tag monomeric, dimeric, trimeric, and tetrameric membrane proteins, as well as membrane proteins existing in monomer-dimer equilibria. We also perform rigorous experimental measurements of this effect, by identifying membrane receptors that do not associate in mammalian membranes. We measure the FRET efficiencies between yellow fluorescent protein and mCherry-tagged versions of these receptors in plasma-membrane-derived vesicles as a function of receptor concentration. Finally, we demonstrate that the experimental measurements are well described by our predictions. The work presented here brings additional rigor to FRET-based studies of membrane protein interactions, and should have broad utility in membrane biophysics research.

Strong dimerization of wild-type ErbB2/Neu transmembrane domain and the oncogenic Val664Glu mutant in mammalian plasma membranes

Here, we study the homodimerization of the transmembrane domain of Neu, as well as an oncogenic mutant (V664E), in vesicles derived from the plasma membrane of mammalian cells. For the characterization, we use a Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based method termed Quantitative Imaging-FRET (QI-FRET), which yields the donor and acceptor concentrations in addition to the FRET efficiencies in individual plasma membrane-derived vesicles. Our results demonstrate that both the wild-type and the mutant are 100% dimeric, suggesting that the Neu TM helix dimerizes more efficiently than other RTK TM domains in mammalian membranes. Furthermore, the data suggest that the V664E mutation causes a very small, but statistically significant change in dimer structure. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Interfacially Active Peptides and Proteins. Guest Editors: William C. Wimley and Kalina Hristova.

FGFR3 transmembrane domain interactions persist in the presence of its extracellular domain

Isolated receptor tyrosine kinase transmembrane (TM) domains have been shown to form sequence-specific dimers in membranes. Yet, it is not clear whether studies of isolated TM domains yield knowledge that is relevant to full-length receptors or whether the large glycosylated extracellular domains alter the interactions between the TM helices. Here, we address this question by quantifying the effect of the pathogenic A391E TM domain mutation on the stability of the fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 dimer in the presence of the extracellular domain and comparing these results to the case of the isolated TM fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 domains. We perform the measurements in plasma membrane-derived vesicles using a Förster-resonance-energy-transfer-based method. The effect of the mutation on dimer stability in both cases is the same (∼-1.5 kcal/mol), suggesting that the interactions observed in simple TM-peptide model systems are relevant in a biological context.

The transmembrane domains of the bacterial cell division proteins FtsB and FtsL form a stable high-order oligomer

FtsB and FtsL are two essential integral membrane proteins of the bacterial division complex or "divisome", both characterized by a single transmembrane helix and a juxtamembrane coiled coil domain. The two domains are important for the association of FtsB and FtsL, a key event for their recruitment to the divisome, which in turn allows the recruitment of the late divisomal components to the Z-ring and subsequent completion of the division process. Here we present a biophysical analysis performed in vitro that shows that the transmembrane domains of FtsB and FtsL associate strongly in isolation. Using Förster resonance energy transfer, we have measured the oligomerization of fluorophore-labeled transmembrane domains of FtsB and FtsL in both detergent and lipid. The data indicate that the transmembrane helices are likely a major contributor to the stability of the FtsB-FtsL complex. Our analyses show that FtsB and FtsL form a 1:1 higher-order oligomeric complex, possibly a tetramer. This finding suggests that the FtsB-FtsL complex is capable of multivalent binding to FtsQ and other divisome components, a hypothesis that is consistent with the possibility that the FtsB-FtsL complex has a structural role in the stabilization of the Z-ring.

Glycophorin A transmembrane domain dimerization in plasma membrane vesicles derived from CHO, HEK 293T, and A431 cells

Membrane protein interactions, which underlie biological function, take place in the complex cellular membrane environment. Plasma membrane derived vesicles are a model system which allows the interactions between membrane proteins to be studied without the need for their extraction, purification, and reconstitution into lipid bilayers. Plasma membrane vesicles can be produced from different cell lines and by different methods, providing a rich variety of native-like model systems. With these choices, however, questions arise as to how the different types of vesicle preparations affect the interactions between membrane proteins. Here we address this question using the glycophorin A transmembrane domain (GpA) as a model system. We compare the dimerization of GpA in six different vesicle preparations derived from Chinese hamster ovary (CHO), Human Embryonic Kidney 293T (HEK 293T) and A431 cells. We accomplish this with the use of a FRET-based method which yields the FRET efficiency, the donor concentration, and the acceptor concentration in each vesicle. We show that the vesicle preparation protocol has no statistically significant effect on GpA dimerization. Based on these results, we propose that any of the six plasma membrane preparations investigated here can be used as a model system for studies of membrane protein interactions.

Measurement of transmembrane peptide interactions in liposomes using Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET)

Present day understanding of the thermodynamic properties of integral membrane proteins (IMPs) lags behind that of water-soluble proteins due to difficulties in mimicking the physiological environment of the IMPs in order to obtain a reversible folded system. Despite such challenges faced in studying these systems, significant progress has been made in the study of the oligomerization of single span transmembrane helices. One of the primary methods available to characterize these systems is based on Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET). FRET is a widely used spectroscopic tool that provides proximity data that can be fitted to obtain the energetics of a system. Here we discuss various technical aspects related to the application of FRET to study transmembrane peptide oligomerization in liposomes. The analysis is based on FRET efficiency relative to the concentration of the peptides in the bilayer (peptide:lipid ratio). Some important parameters that will be discussed include labeling efficiency, sample homogeneity, and equilibration. Furthermore, data analysis has to be performed keeping in mind random colocalization of donors and acceptors in liposome vesicles.

Highly adaptable and sensitive protease assay based on fluorescence resonance energy transfer

Proteases are widely used in analytical sciences and play a central role in several widespread diseases. Thus, there is an immense need for highly adaptable and sensitive assays for the detection and monitoring of various proteolytic enzymes. We established a simple protease fluorescence resonance energy transfer (pro-FRET) assay for the determination of protease activities, which could in principle be adapted for the detection of all proteases. As proof of principle, we demonstrated the potential of our method using trypsin and enteropeptidase in complex biological mixtures. Briefly, the assay is based on the cleavage of a FRET peptide substrate, which results in a dramatic increase of the donor fluorescence. The assay was highly sensitive and fast for both proteases. The detection limits for trypsin and enteropeptidase in Escherichia coli lysate were 100 and 10 amol, respectively. The improved sensitivity for enteropeptidase was due to the application of an enzyme cascade, which leads to signal amplification. The pro-FRET assay is highly specific as even high concentrations of other proteases did not result in significant background signals. In conclusion, this sensitive and simple assay can be performed in complex biological mixtures and can be easily adapted to act as a versatile tool for the sensitive detection of proteases.

Physical-chemical principles underlying RTK activation, and their implications for human disease

RTKs, the second largest family of membrane receptors, exert control over cell proliferation, differentiation and migration. In recent years, our understanding of RTK structure and activation in health and disease has skyrocketed. Here we describe experimental approaches used to interrogate RTKs, and we review the quantitative biophysical frameworks and structural considerations that shape our understanding of RTK function. We discuss current knowledge about RTK interactions, focusing on the role of different domains in RTK homodimerization, and on the importance and challenges in RTK heterodimerization studies. We also review our understanding of pathogenic RTK mutations, and the underlying physical-chemical causes for the pathologies. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Protein Folding in Membranes.

Assembly of the m2 tetramer is strongly modulated by lipid chain length

The influenza virus matrix protein 2 (M2) assembles into a tetramer in the host membrane during viral uncoating and maturation. It has been used as a model system to understand the relative contributions of protein-lipid and protein-protein interactions to membrane protein structure and association. Here we investigate the effect of lipid chain length on the association of the M2 transmembrane domain into tetramers using Förster resonance energy transfer. We observe that the interactions between the M2 helices are much stronger in 1,2-dilauroyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine than in 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine bilayers. Thus, lipid chain length and bilayer thickness not only modulate peptide interactions, but could also be a major determinant of the association of transmembrane helices into functional membrane protein oligomers.

The extracellular domain of fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 inhibits ligand-independent dimerization

Dysregulation of the ligand-independent dimerization of receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs), which is the first step in the activation of RTKs, leads to various pathologies. A mechanistic understanding of the dimerization process is lacking, and this lack of basic knowledge is one bottleneck in the development of effective RTK-targeted therapies. For example, the roles and relative contributions of the different domains of RTKs to receptor dimerization are unknown. Here, we used quantitative imaging Förster resonance energy transfer (QI-FRET) to determine the contribution of the extracellular domain of fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3) to the dimerization of the receptor. We provide evidence that the contribution of the extracellular domain of FGFR3 to dimerization is repulsive in the absence of ligand and is on the order of ~1 kcal/mol. The repulsive contribution of the extracellular domain is similar in magnitude, but opposite in sign, to the contribution of pathogenic single-amino acid mutations to RTK signaling, and is therefore likely to be important for biological function. Together, these results highlight the fine balance in the domain interactions that regulate RTK dimerization and signaling.

Measuring the energetics of membrane protein dimerization in mammalian membranes

Thus far, quantitative studies of lateral protein interactions in membranes have been restricted peptides or simplified protein constructs in lipid vesicles or bacterial membranes. Here we show how free energies of membrane protein dimerization can be measured in mammalian plasma membrane-derived vesicles. The measurements, performed in single vesicles, utilize the quantitative imaging FRET (QI-FRET) method. The experiments are described in a step-by-step protocol. The protein characterized is the transmembrane domain of glycophorin A, the most extensively studied membrane protein, known to form homodimers in hydrophobic environments. The results suggest that molecular crowding in cellular membranes has a dramatic effect on the strength of membrane protein interactions.

Energetics of ErbB1 transmembrane domain dimerization in lipid bilayers

One of the most extensively studied receptor tyrosine kinases is EGFR/ErbB1. Although our knowledge of the role of the extracellular domains and ligands in ErbB1 activation has increased dramatically based on solved domain structures, the exact mechanism of signal transduction across the membrane remains unknown. The transmembrane domains are expected to play an important role in the dimerization process, but the contribution of ErbB1 TM domain to dimer stability is not known, with published results contradicting one another. We address this controversy by showing that ErbB1 TM domain dimerizes in lipid bilayers and by calculating its contribution to stability as -2.5 kcal/mol. The stability calculations use two different methods based on Förster resonance energy transfer, which give the same result. The ErbB1 TM domain contribution to stability exceeds the change in receptor tyrosine kinases dimerization propensities that can convert normal signaling processes into pathogenic processes, and is thus likely important for biological function.

Hill coefficient analysis of transmembrane helix dimerization

Here, we employed the Hill equation, used broadly to characterize cooperativity in protein-ligand binding, to describe the dimerization of transmembrane (TM) helices in hydrophobic environments. The Hill analysis of wild-type fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3) TM domain dimerization gives a Hill coefficient of approximately 1 for lipid bilayers but only approximately 0.2 for sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micelles. We propose that this finding is indicative of heterogeneity in FGFR3 TM dimer structure and stability in SDS micelles. We further speculate that (1) the Hill equation can be used as a tool to assess the existence of multiple structural states of TM dimers in different hydrophobic environments and (2) the structural heterogeneity, detectable by Hill analysis, may be the underlying reason for the broad peaks and the low resolution NMR studies of peptides in detergents.