Optimization of melting analysis with TaqMan probes for detection of KRAS, NRAS, and BRAF mutations

Aberrant methylation scanning by quantitative DNA melting analysis with hybridization probes as exemplified by liquid biopsy of SEPT9 and HIST1H4F in colorectal cancer

OBJECTIVE

The generally accepted method of quantifying hypermethylated DNA by qPCR using methylation-specific primers has the risk of underestimating DNA methylation and requires data normalization. This makes the analysis complicated and less reliable.

METHODS

The end-point PCR method, called qDMA-HP (for quantitative DNA Melting Analysis with hybridization probes), which excludes the normalization procedure, is multiplexed and quantitative, has been proposed. qDMA-HP is characterized by the following features: (i) asymmetric PCR with methylation-independent primers; (ii) fluorescent dual-labeled, self-quenched probes (commonly known as TaqMan probes) covering several interrogated CpGs; (iii) post-PCR melting analysis of amplicon/probe hybrids; (iv) quantitation of unmethylated and methylated DNA alleles by measuring the areas under the corresponding melt peaks.

RESULTS

qDMA-HP was tested in liquid biopsy of colorectal cancer by evaluating SEPT9 and HIST1H4F methylations simultaneously in the single-tube reaction. Differences in the methylation levels in healthy donors versus cancer patients were statistically significant (p < 0.0001), AUCROC values were 0.795-0.921 for various marker combinations.

CONCLUSIONS

This proof-of-concept study shows that qDMA-HP is a simple, normalization-independent, quantitative, multiplex and "closed tube" method easily adapted to clinical settings. It is demonstrated, for the first time, that HIST1H4F is a perspective marker for liquid biopsy of colorectal cancer.

Single probe PCR melting curve analysis MTHFR C677T SNP sites

BACKGROUND

The detection and analysis of methylene tetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) C677T single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) from blood samples is time-consuming and costly. We aimed to establish a method to detect these SNPs by direct whole blood PCR and without DNA extraction.

METHODS

Probes modified by different fluorescent groups on the same sequence were designed. Various MTHFR genotypes from direct blood PCR experiments were used to verify the similarity of the obtained and sequencing results. The SNP sites adjacent to the MTHFR C677T SNP were used to verify whether the method can accurately distinguish these sites.

RESULTS

The ROX probe was found to be the most suitable for this study. We tested 291 samples with 1 μL whole blood as a template, and obtained 126, 43, and 122 cases of C677C, C677T, and C677 C/T genotypes, respectively. The melting curve was consistent with the sequencing results. The detection limit was approximately 1000 white blood cells/μL. Through PCR and the melting curve method, the adjacent sites were accurately distinguished.

CONCLUSION

We established a reliable, simple, rapid, and low-cost direct blood PCR method for the detection of MTHFR C677T SNPs. This could also be used as a potential diagnostic tool for a variety of diseases.

Ultrasensitive Multiplex Detection of Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms Based on Short-Chain Hybridization Combined with Online Preconcentration of Capillary Electrophoresis

Reliable multiple single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) detection at low abundance is of great significance for disease diagnosis and biomedical research. Herein, we have developed a novel and simple method for multiple SNPs detection combining solid-phase capture by specific hybridization with online preconcentration of capillary gel electrophoresis-laser-induced fluorescence (CGE-LIF). The method presents an excellent performance due to its favorable traits: the solid-phase short-chain hybridization ensures the high specificity of SNP detection; the effective separation ability of CGE can easily achieve multiplex detection; the simple online preconcentration significantly improves the detection sensitivity of fluorescent probe by nearly 100-fold. For a single SNP target, the assay achieves a limit of detection as low as 0.01-0.02% for three different NRAS mutations in the same codon. For multiple SNP targets, as low as 0.05% abundance can be easily realized. Our method is simple, efficient, ultrasensitive, and universal for multiple SNPs detection without complex enzymatic or chemical ligation reaction, which shows great potential in early clinical diagnosis.

SLAM-MS: Mutation scanning of stem-loop amplicons with TaqMan probes by quantitative DNA melting analysis

DNA Melting Analysis (DMA) with a TaqMan probe covering the mutation “hot spot” is a simple, sensitive, and “closed tube” method of mutation detection. However, DMA requires asymmetric PCR to produce single-stranded amplicons capable of interacting with TaqMan probes. This makes quantitative analysis impossible owing to low amplification efficiency. Moreover, bi-strand mutation detection necessitates two independent PCRs. The SLAM-MS (Stem-Loop AMplicon Mutation Scanning) assay, in which symmetric PCR is performed using primers with 5'-universal primer sequence (UPS), has been developed to detect KRAS mutations. Some of the resulting amplicons, sense and antisense, adopt single-stranded stem-loop conformation and become unable to renature, but able to hybridize with TaqMan probes. Hybrids of stem-loops and complementary TaqMan probes are suitable for melting analysis and simultaneous bi-strand mutation scanning. In addition, the areas under the melting peaks are determined by the PeakFit software, a non-linear iterative curve fitting program, to evaluate the wild-type/mutant allele ratio. Thus, the SLAM-MS assay permits quantification of both the number of copies of the target sequence and the percentage of mutant alleles. For mutant enrichment, the SLAM-MS assay uses TaqMan probes as PCR blocking agents allowing an ~10 times higher mutation detection sensitivity than High Resolution Melting (HRM) assay.

Asymmetric mutant-enriched polymerase chain reaction and quantitative DNA melting analysis of KRAS mutation in colorectal cancer

Identification of mutant genes in tumor tissues and blood plasma (solid and liquid biopsy samples, respectively) is a necessity for individualized treatment of cancer patients. Here we report the use of a novel mutant-enriched PCR - quantitative DNA melting curve analysis (mePCR-qDMA) with TaqMan probes. The TaqMan probes served as blocking agents during PCR and as hybridization probes during DNA melting curve analyses. The end-point measurement of melt peaks areas by PeakFit software, a nonlinear iterative curve-fitting program, permitted quantification of the mutant/wild-type allele ratios. Approximately 6% and 0.1% of mutant KRAS allele in an excess of wild-type allele is detected with the standard and mePCR-qDMA processes, respectively. The application of the approach was tested for detecting the KRAS codon 12/13 mutation in paired tumor and blood plasma samples from 20 colorectal cancer patients. KRAS mutants were detected in 7 and 18 FFPE tumor samples, and in 3 and 7 plasma samples by the standard and mePCR-qDMA process, respectively. The results were confirmed by Sanger sequencing. This simple, rapid, cost-effective, and quantitative method carried out in a closed-tube format could be applied for the clinical analyses of other cancer genes.

A novel multiplex PCR for virus detection by melting curve analysis

•

Taqman probe based melting curve analysis can detect and distinguish six respiratory viruses simultaneously.

•

The multiplex PCR established here has a good analytical sensitivity and specificity.

•

The accordance rate between the multiplex PCR and direct fluorescent antibody testing was high.

•

Taqman probe based melting curve analysis is well suited to multiple virus detection.

Background

Rapid and accurate laboratory diagnoses of viral infections are crucial for the management and treatment of patients with viral infections. Conventional methods for virus detection are labourious, time consuming, and only a single virus can be analysed in one assay.

Objectives

The objective of this study was to develop a novel real-time PCR method for multiple virus detection by melting curve analysis using Taqman probes in a single reaction.

Study design

As a model, six respiratory viruses were detected in one tube using three fluorophores. The specificity was assessed by cross-reaction tests with other common respiratory pathogens. The analytical sensitivity was assessed by testing the limit of detection of the assay using artificial plasmids as the positive template. The clinical evaluation of the established assay was evaluated for the detection of respiratory viruses in clinical samples, and the results were compared with direct fluorescent antibody testing (DFA).

Results

The six respiratory viruses were clearly distinguished by their respective melting temperature values in the corresponding fluorescence detection channels. No cross reactions were observed by cross reaction tests. The detection limits of this assay were 2 to 2 × 10³ copies per reaction for each virus. The clinical evaluation of this assay was demonstrated by analysing 352 clinical samples, and 67(19.0%) samples were positive for at least one virus. The accordance rate between the established PCR and DFA testing was high, and ranged from 94.57% to 100%.

Conclusions

Taqman probe-based melting curve analysis is well suited for detection of multiple viruses in clinical and research laboratories because of its high throughput, reliability, and cost savings.

Impact of fixation artifacts and threshold selection on high resolution melting analysis for KRAS mutation screening

INTRODUCTION

Treatment in metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC) has expanded with monoclonal antibodies targeting epidermal growth factor receptor, but is restricted to patients with a wild-type (WT) KRAS mutational status. The most sensitive assays for KRAS mutation detection in formalin-fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE) tissues are based on real-time PCR. Among them, high resolution melting analysis (HRMA), is a simple, fast, highly sensitive, specific and cost-effective method, proposed as adjunct for KRAS mutation detection. However the method to categorize WT vs mutant sequences in HRMA is not clearly specified in available studies, besides the impact of FFPE artifacts on HRMA performance hasn't been addressed either.

METHODS

Avowedly adequate samples from 104 consecutive mCRC patients were tested for KRAS mutations by Therascreen™ (FDA Validated test), HRMA, and HRMA with UDG pre-treatment to reverse FFPE fixation artifacts. Comparisons of KRAS status allocation among the three methods were done. Focusing on HRMA as screening test, ROC curve analyses were performed for HRMA and HMRA-UDG against Therascreen™, in order to evaluate their discriminative power and to determine the threshold of profile concordance between WT control and sample for KRAS status determination.

RESULTS

Comparing HRMA and HRMA-UDG against Therascreen™ as surrogate gold standard, sensitivity was 1 for both HRMA and HRMA-UDG; and specificity and positive predictive values were respectively 0.838 and 0.939; and 0.777 and 0.913. As evaluated by the McNemar test, HRMA-UDG allocated samples to a WT/mutated genotype in a significatively different way from HRMA (p > 0.001). On the other hand HRMA-UDG did not differ from Therascreen™ (p = 0.125). ROC-curve analysis showed a significant discriminative power for both HRMA and HRMA-UDG against Therascreen™ (respectively, AUC of 0.978, p > 0.0001, CI 95% 0.957-0.999; and AUC of 0.98, p > 0.0001, CI 95% 0.000-1.0). For HRMA as a screening tool, the best threshold (degree of concordance between sample curves and WT control) was attained at 92.14% for HRMA (specificity of 0.887), and at 92.55% for HRMA-UDG (specificity of 0.952).

CONCLUSIONS

HRMA is a highly sensitive method for KRAS mutation detection, with apparently adequate and statistically significant discriminative power. FFPE sample fixation artifacts have an impact on HRMA results, so for HRMA on FFPE samples pre-treatment with UDG should be strongly suggested. The choice of the threshold for melting curve concordance has also great impact on HRMA performance. A threshold of 93% or greater might be adequate if using HRMA as a screening tool. Further validation of this threshold is required.

TaqMan probes as blocking agents for enriched PCR amplification and DNA melting analysis of mutant genes

Asymmetric PCR and DNA melting analysis with TaqMan probes applied for mutation detection is effectively used in clinical diagnostics. The method is simple, cost-effective, and carried out in a closed-tube format, minimizing time, labor, and risk of sample cross-contamination. Although DNA melting analysis is more sensitive than Sanger sequencing (mutation detection thresholds are ∼5% and 15%–20%, respectively), it is less sensitive than more labor-intensive and expensive techniques such as pyrosequencing and droplet digital PCR. Here, we demonstrate that, under specially selected conditions of asymmetric PCR, TaqMan probes can play the role of blocking agents. Preferential blocking of the wild-type allele brings about enriched amplification of mutant alleles. As a result, an ∼10-fold increase in the detection sensitivity for mutant BRAF and NRAS genes was achieved.

A rational two-step approach to KRAS mutation testing in colorectal cancer using high resolution melting analysis and pyrosequencing

Background

KRAS mutation testing is mandatory in the management of metastatic colorectal cancer prior to treatment with anti-EGFR antibodies as patients whose tumors express mutant KRAS do not benefit from these agents. Although the U.S. Food and Drug Administration has recently approved two in-vitro diagnostics kits for determination of KRAS status, there is generally no consensus on the preferred method and new tests are continuously being developed. Most of these techniques focus on the hotspot mutations at codons 12 and 13 of the KRAS gene.

Methods

We describe a two-step approach to KRAS codon 12/13 mutation testing involving high resolution melting analysis (HRM) followed by pyrosequencing using the Therascreen KRAS Pyro kit (Qiagen) of only those samples that are not clearly identified as KRAS wildtype or mutant by HRM. First, we determined KRAS status in a panel of 61 colorectal cancer samples using both methods to compare technical performance and concordance of results. Subsequently, we evaluated practicability and costs of our concept in an independent set of 120 colorectal cancer samples in a routine diagnostic setting.

Results

HRM and pyrosequencing appeared to be equally sensitive, allowing for clear detection of mutant alleles at a mutant allele frequency ≥12.5 %. Pyrosequencing yielded more exploitable results due to lower input requirements and a lower rate of analysis failures. KRAS codon 12/13 status was called concordantly for 98.2 % (56/57) of all samples that could be successfully analysed by both methods and 100 % (19/19) of samples that were identified mutant by HRM. Reviewing the actual effort and expenses for KRAS mutation testing in our laboratory revealed, that the selective use of pyrosequencing for only those samples that could not be analysed by HRM increased the fraction of valid results from 87.5 % for HRM alone to 99.2 % (119/120) while allowing for a net reduction of operational costs of >75 % compared to pyrosequencing alone.

Conclusions

Combination of HRM and pyrosequencing in a two-step diagnostic procedure constitutes a reliable and economic analysis platform for KRAS mutation testing in colorectal cancer in a clinical setting.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12885-016-2589-2) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

High specific genotyping method using short target probe and helper probe

Differentiating 1-bp differences using real-time PCR often leads to false-positive results. Therefore, we developed a fluorescence melting curve analysis (FMCA) method with a short target probe and helper probe labeled with a fluorophore and quencher, respectively. This fluorophore and quencher were designed to be near each other when the probes were hybridized to template DNA. The target probe was designed with a shorter length to facilitate a dramatic shift in melting temperature (Tm) upon encountering mismatched hybridization. In FMCA, when the temperature approached the target probe Tm, the target probe would begin to denature from the template DNA, and at the target probe Tm, the fluorescence signal increased markedly. Here, we examined 1-bp differences using the developed method with mitochondrial DNA from Larimichthys polyactis and Larimichthys crocea. Application of this method permitted specific genotype identification for all cases with no cross-reactivity, even when both templates were added to the same tube.

Asymmetric real-time PCR and multiplex melting curve analysis with TaqMan probes for detecting PIK3CA mutations

The data in this article are related to the research article entitled "Optimization of melting analysis with TaqMan probes for detection of KRAS, NRAS, and BRAF mutations" Botezatu et al. [1]. Somatic mutations in the PIK3CA gene ("hot spots" in exons 9 and 20) are found in many human cancers, and their presence can determine prognosis and a treatment strategy. An effective method of mutation scanning PIK3CA in clinical laboratories is DNA Melting Analysis (DMA) (Vorkas et al., 2010; Simi et al., 2008) [2], [3]. It was demonstrated recently that the TaqMan probes which have been long used in Real Time PCR may also be utilized in DMA (Huang et al., 2011) [4]. After optimization of this method Botezatu et al. [1], it was used for multiplex scanning PIK3CA hotspot mutations in formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) samples from patients with colorectal and lung cancer.