Hb S-São Paulo: a new sickling hemoglobin with stable polymers and decreased oxygen affinity

Functional characterization of compound heterozygosity Hb S/Hb Deer Lodge in Brazil

INTRODUCTION

The Hb Deer Lodge (β2 His>Arg; HBB:c.8A>G) is a structural hemoglobin variant described in some populations around the world, characterized by increased oxygen affinity, but does not confer clinical symptoms to its carriers. The coinheritance of the Hb Deer Lodge with the most common hemoglobin variant, Hb S, has been reported only once; however, functional data were not described. Here we show a case of the Hb S and Hb Deer Lodge carrier in heterozygosity.

METHODS

The Hb S and Hb Deer Lodge association was identified by High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC), reverse phase HPLC and the β globin gene sequencing. The functional characterization of this interaction was obtained using the O2 dissociation curve, determination of the cooperativity between the globin chains and the Bohr effect in the presence and absence of organic phosphates.

RESULTS

When the Hb S and Hb Deer Lodge were associated, there was a decrease in cooperativity, no significant changes in oxygen affinity and no significant Bohr effect changes.

CONCLUSION

Despite these genetic variations, the carrier showed no hematological alterations and no clinical symptoms, possibly due to the high oxygen affinity of the Hb Deer Lodge, which interferes with the Hb S polymerization.

IVS-II-16 (G>C) (HBB: c.315+16G>C) or IVS-II-666 (C>T) (HBB: c.316-185C>T) Mutations Trigger an Hb S (HBB: c.20A>T)/β+-Thalassemia Phenotype in an Hb S Trait Patient

Sickle cell trait is a medical condition caused by the presence of both mutant Hb S (HBB: c.20A>T) and normal Hb A alleles. Although sickle cell trait is typically considered to be asymptomatic and benign, genetic modifiers and mutations can lead to severe clinical complications. In this study, the possible pathogenicity of the IVS-II-16 (G>C) (HBB: c.315+16G>C) and IVS-II-666 (C>T) (HBB: c.316-185C>T) mutations, which are considered to be neutral polymorphisms, and the association between the Hb S mutation are presented. To the best of our knowledge, these polymorphisms have not been previously reported in any sickle cell trait patient, and no relevant studies have been conducted. We recently studied a 40-year-old woman (proband), diagnosed to be an Hb S/β-thalassemia (β-thal) carrier. β-Globin mutations were analyzed using a DNA sequencer based on the Sanger method. The HbVar and ClinVar databases show IVS-II-16 and IVS-II-666 to be intronic mutations. However, statements in these data banks contradict our findings. In the present study, a transfusion-dependent Hb S patient, behaving as an Hb S/β-thal case due to these mutations, was reported. These mutations have not been previously reported in an Hb S patient. Although the IVS-II-16 and IVS-II-666 mutations were previously reported as benign, they converted the Hb S phenotype to transfusion-dependent Hb S/β-thal when combined with Hb S. In this regard, IVS-II-16 and IVS-II-666 mutations may not be innocent, as previously thought.

Non-S Sickling Hemoglobin Variants: Historical, Genetic, Diagnostic, and Clinical Perspectives

Apart from hemoglobin-S (HbS), there are other Hb variants (non-S sickling Hb variants) that cause sickle cell disease. However, the profiles of these non-S sickling Hb variants have neither been collated nor harmonized. A literature search revealed 14 non-S sickling Hb variants (HbC-Harlem, HbC-Ziguinchor, HbS-Travis, HbS-Antilles, HbS-Providence, HbS-Oman, HbS-Cameroon, HbS-South End, Hb Jamaica Plain, HbC-Ndjamena, HbS-Clichy, HbS-San Martin, HbS-Wake, and HbS-São Paulo). Generally, the non-S sickling Hb variants are double mutants with the HbS mutation (GAG>GTG: βGlu6Val) and additional β-chain mutations. Consequently, non-S sickling Hb variants give positive solubility and sickling tests, but they differ from HbS with respect to stability, oxygen affinity, and electro-chromatographic characteristics. Similarities and discrepancies between HbS and non-S sickling Hb variants create diagnostic pitfalls that can only be resolved by elaborate electro-chromatographic and/or genetic tests. It is therefore imperative that tropical hematologists should have a thorough understanding of these atypical sickling Hb variants. Collated and harmonized appraisal of the non-S sickling Hb variants have not been previously undertaken. Hence, this paper aims to provide a comprehensive but concise historical, genetic, comparative, diagnostic, and clinical overview of non-S sickling Hb variants. The elaborate techniques often required for precise diagnosis of non-S sickling Hb variants are regrettably not readily available in low resource tropical countries, which paradoxically carry the heaviest burden of sickling disorders. We strongly recommend that tropical countries should upgrade their diagnostic laboratory facilities to avoid misdiagnosis of these atypical Hb mutants.

Alpha chain hemoglobins with electrophoretic mobility similar to that of hemoglobin S in a newborn screening program

Objective

To characterize alpha-chain variant hemoglobins with electric mobility similar to that of hemoglobin S in a newborn screening program.

Methods

β^S allele and alpha-thalassemia deletions were investigated in 14 children who had undefined hemoglobin at birth and an electrophoretic profile similar to that of hemoglobin S when they were six months old. Gene sequencing and restriction enzymes (DdeI, BsaJI, NlaIV, Bsu36I and TaqI) were used to identify hemoglobins. Clinical and hematological data were obtained from children who attended scheduled medical visits.

Results

The following alpha chain variants were found: seven children with hemoglobin Hasharon [alpha2 47(CE5) Asp>His, HbA2:c.142G>C], all associated with alpha-thalassemia, five with hemoglobin Ottawa [alpha1 15(A13) Gly>Arg, HBA1:c.46G>C], one with hemoglobin St Luke's [alpha1 95(G2) Pro>Arg, HBA1:c.287C>G] and another one with hemoglobin Etobicoke [alpha212 84(F5) Ser>Arg, HBA212:c.255C>G]. Two associations with hemoglobin S were found: one with hemoglobin Ottawa and one with hemoglobin St Luke's. The mutation underlying hemoglobin Etobicoke was located in a hybrid α212 allele in one child. There was no evidence of clinically relevant hemoglobins detected in this study.

Conclusion

Apparently these are the first cases of hemoglobin Ottawa, St Luke's, Etobicoke and the α212 gene described in Brazil. The hemoglobins detected in this study may lead to false diagnosis of sickle cell trait or sickle cell disease when only isoelectric focusing is used in neonatal screening. Additional tests are necessary for the correct identification of hemoglobin variants.

Pitfalls in the genetic diagnosis of Hb S

Patients homozygous for Hb S need to be properly identified to start as early as possible a treatment that should avoid complications. For prevention and genetic counseling, carriers of Hb S have to be screened. Hb S is easily detected by several analytical systems, but other variants, usually harmless, may behave as Hb S, leading to false positive diagnosis. Some interactions may also cause difficulties in the qualitative or quantitative interpretation of a chromatography or electrophoresis profile. These problems may result from several causes among which the simultaneous presence of an α chain variant leading to the formation of tetramers having both an α and a β chain modified, the presence of a second mutation within the Hb S allele, the existence of a compound heterozygous state leading to some "Hb S trait with dominantly transmitted sickle cell disease (SCD)", and the presence of thalassemic allele affecting the intracellular proportion of Hb S. In case of any "dominant Hb S trait" a thorough Hb study is always required. This work reports some of the difficulties observed by us, or reported in the literature, and propose how to avoid them and reach a correct diagnosis.