CT colonography computer-aided polyp detection: Effect on radiologist observers of polyp identification by CAD on both the supine and prone scans

Computer aided diagnosis of prostate cancer: A texton based approach

PURPOSE

In this paper the authors propose a texton based prostate computer aided diagnosis approach which bypasses the typical feature extraction process such as filtering and convolution which can be computationally expensive. The study focuses the peripheral zone because 75% of prostate cancers start within this region and the majority of prostate cancers arising within this region are more aggressive than those arising in the transitional zone.

METHODS

For the model development, square patches were extracted at random locations from malignant and benign regions. Subsequently, extracted patches were aggregated and clustered using k-means clustering to generate textons that represent both regions. All textons together form a texton dictionary, which was used to construct a texton map for every peripheral zone in the training images. Based on the texton map, histogram models for each malignant and benign tissue samples were constructed and used as a feature vector to train our classifiers. In the testing phase, four machine learning algorithms were employed to classify each unknown sample tissue based on its corresponding feature vector.

RESULTS

The proposed method was tested on 418 T2-W MR images taken from 45 patients. Evaluation results show that the best three classifiers were Bayesian network (Az = 92.8% ± 5.9%), random forest (89.5% ± 7.1%), and k-NN (86.9% ± 7.5%). These results are comparable to the state-of-the-art in the literature.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors have developed a prostate computer aided diagnosis method based on textons using a single modality of T2-W MRI without the need for the typical feature extraction methods, such as filtering and convolution. The proposed method could form a solid basis for a multimodality magnetic resonance imaging based systems.

Computer-aided detection of prostate cancer in MRI

Prostate cancer is one of the major causes of cancer death for men in the western world. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is being increasingly used as a modality to detect prostate cancer. Therefore, computer-aided detection of prostate cancer in MRI images has become an active area of research. In this paper we investigate a fully automated computer-aided detection system which consists of two stages. In the first stage, we detect initial candidates using multi-atlas-based prostate segmentation, voxel feature extraction, classification and local maxima detection. The second stage segments the candidate regions and using classification we obtain cancer likelihoods for each candidate. Features represent pharmacokinetic behavior, symmetry and appearance, among others. The system is evaluated on a large consecutive cohort of 347 patients with MR-guided biopsy as the reference standard. This set contained 165 patients with cancer and 182 patients without prostate cancer. Performance evaluation is based on lesion-based free-response receiver operating characteristic curve and patient-based receiver operating characteristic analysis. The system is also compared to the prospective clinical performance of radiologists. Results show a sensitivity of 0.42, 0.75, and 0.89 at 0.1, 1, and 10 false positives per normal case. In clinical workflow the system could potentially be used to improve the sensitivity of the radiologist. At the high specificity reading setting, which is typical in screening situations, the system does not perform significantly different from the radiologist and could be used as an independent second reader instead of a second radiologist. Furthermore, the system has potential in a first-reader setting.

CT colonography: preliminary assessment of a double-read paradigm that uses computer-aided detection as the first reader

PURPOSE

To compare diagnostic performance and time efficiency of double-reading first-reader computer-aided detection (CAD) (DR FR CAD) followed by radiologist interpretation with that of an unassisted read using segmentally unblinded colonoscopy as reference standard.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The local ethical committee approved this study. Written consent to use examinations was obtained from patients. Three experienced radiologists searched for polyps 6 mm or larger in 155 computed tomographic (CT) colonographic studies (57 containing 10 masses and 79 polyps ≥ 6 mm). Reading was randomized to either unassisted read or DR FR CAD. Data sets were reread 6 weeks later by using the opposite paradigm. DR FR CAD consists of evaluation of CAD prompts, followed by fast two-dimensional review for mass detection. CAD sensitivity was calculated. Readers' diagnoses and reviewing times with and without CAD were compared by using McNemar and Student t tests, respectively. Association between missed polyps and lesion characteristics was explored with multiple regression analysis.

RESULTS

With mean rate of 19 (standard deviation, 14; median, 15; range, 4-127) false-positive results per patient, CAD sensitivity was 90% for lesions 6 mm or larger. Readers' sensitivity and specificity for lesions 6 mm or larger were 74% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 65%, 84%) and 93% (95% CI: 89%, 97%), respectively, for the unassisted read and 77% (95% CI: 67%, 85%) and 90% (95% CI: 85%, 95%), respectively, for DR FR CAD (P = .343 and P = .189, respectively). Overall unassisted and DR FR CAD reviewing times were similar (243 vs 239 seconds; P = .623); DR FR CAD was faster when the number of CAD marks per patient was 20 or fewer (187 vs 220 seconds, P <01). Odds ratio of missing a polyp with CAD decreased as polyp size increased (0.6) and for polyps visible on both prone and supine scans (0.12); it increased for flat lesions (9.1).

CONCLUSION

DR FR CAD paradigm had similar performance compared with unassisted interpretation but better time efficiency when 20 or fewer CAD prompts per patient were generated.

CAD-associated reader error in CT colonography

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

Computed tomographic colonographic interpretation with computer-aided detection (CAD) may be superior to unaided viewing, although polyp characteristics may influence accuracy. Reader error due to polyp characteristics was evaluated in a multiple-case, multiple-reader trial of computed tomographic colonography with CAD.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Two experts retrospectively reviewed 52 positive cases (74 polyps) and categorized them as hard, moderate, or easy to detect. Each case was evaluated without and with CAD. Features that may influence a reader's ability to detect a polyp or to accept or reject a CAD mark were tabulated. The association between polyp characteristics and detection rates in the trial was assessed. The difference in detection rates (CAD vs unassisted) was calculated, and regression analysis was performed.

RESULTS

Of 64 polyps found by CAD, experts categorized 20 as hard, 28 as moderate, and 16 as easy to detect. Reader characterization errors predominated (47.3%) over other errors. Factors associated with lower detection rates included small size, flat morphology, and resemblance to a thickened fold. CAD was superior for polyps resembling lipomas compared to those that did not resemble lipomas (average increase in detection rate with CAD, 12.8% vs 5.5%; P < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

Polyp characteristic may impair computed tomographic colonographic interpretation augmented by CAD. Readers can avoid errors of measurement by evaluating diminutive polyp candidates with sample measurements. Caution should be taken when evaluating focally thick folds and when using visual impression to dismiss a polyp candidate as a lipoma when it is submerged in densely tagged fluid.

Automatic computer-aided detection of prostate cancer based on multiparametric magnetic resonance image analysis

In this paper, a fully automatic computer-aided detection (CAD) method is proposed for the detection of prostate cancer. The CAD method consists of multiple sequential steps in order to detect locations that are suspicious for prostate cancer. In the initial stage, a voxel classification is performed using a Hessian-based blob detection algorithm at multiple scales on an apparent diffusion coefficient map. Next, a parametric multi-object segmentation method is applied and the resulting segmentation is used as a mask to restrict the candidate detection to the prostate. The remaining candidates are characterized by performing histogram analysis on multiparametric MR images. The resulting feature set is summarized into a malignancy likelihood by a supervised classifier in a two-stage classification approach. The detection performance for prostate cancer was tested on a screening population of 200 consecutive patients and evaluated using the free response operating characteristic methodology. The results show that the CAD method obtained sensitivities of 0.41, 0.65 and 0.74 at false positive (FP) levels of 1, 3 and 5 per patient, respectively. In conclusion, this study showed that it is feasible to automatically detect prostate cancer at a FP rate lower than systematic biopsy. The CAD method may assist the radiologist to detect prostate cancer locations and could potentially guide biopsy towards the most aggressive part of the tumour.

Predicting readers' diagnostic accuracy with a new CAD algorithm

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

Before computer-aided detection (CAD) algorithms can be used in clinical practice, they must be shown to improve readers' diagnostic accuracy over their unaided performance. This is usually accomplished through a large multireader, multicase (MRMC) clinical trial. It is burdensome, however, for an MRMC study to be performed with each new release of a CAD algorithm. The aim of this report is to present an approach for building models to predict readers' accuracy with a new CAD algorithm.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A modeling approach for predicting readers' results with a new CAD algorithm is described. Multiple-variable logistic regression was used to build models for readers' sensitivity and false-positive rate, given the results of an MRMC study with an older CAD algorithm and the stand-alone performance results of a new CAD algorithm. Data from a large lung MRMC CAD trial are used to illustrate the modeling approach and test the ability of the models to predict readers' accuracy with the new CAD algorithm.

RESULTS

The model overestimated the readers' actual sensitivity with the new CAD algorithm, but this did not reach statistical significance (0.621 vs 0.603, P = .147). The observed and predicted false-positive rates also did not differ significantly (0.275 vs 0.285, P = .250).

CONCLUSIONS

Using one clinical study as a test case, it is shown that the modeling approach is feasible. More testing of the approach is needed to determine if and under what circumstances it can be used as an alternative to a full-scale MRMC study. Meanwhile, the approach can be used to determine if a new CAD algorithm is likely to improve readers' accuracy before embarking on a full-scale MRMC study.

Evidence review and status update on computed tomography colonography

Computed tomographic (CT) colonography is being implemented increasingly in the USA and Europe, and in many centers it has become the radiological technique of choice for imaging the whole colorectum. Although high diagnostic accuracy has been demonstrated in both screening and symptomatic populations, controversy persists regarding implementation, who should interpret the examination, and its cost effectiveness, particularly in the context of primary colorectal cancer screening. Published research in recent years has demonstrated efficacy in a wide range of patient groups, striking technical improvements, and high levels of patient acceptability. New developments continue in the fields of computer aided detection, digital cleansing, and integration into positron emission tomography. The purpose of this review is to bring the reader up-to-date with the latest developments in CT colonography, in particular, those of the last year.