Insights into the evolution of polymodal chemoreceptors

Fish gill chemosensing: knowledge gaps and inconsistencies

In this review, we explore the inconsistencies in the data and gaps in our knowledge that exist in what is currently known regarding gill chemosensors which drive the cardiorespiratory reflexes in fish. Although putative serotonergic neuroepithelial cells (NEC) dominate the literature, it is clear that other neurotransmitters are involved (adrenaline, noradrenaline, acetylcholine, purines, and dopamine). And although we assume that these agents act on neurons synapsing with the NECs or in the afferent or efferent limbs of the paths between chemosensors and central integration sites, this process remains elusive and may explain current discrepancies or species differences in the literature. To date it has been impossible to link the distribution of NECs to species sensitivity to different stimuli or fish lifestyles and while the gills have been shown to be the primary sensing site for respiratory gases, the location (gills, oro-branchial cavity or elsewhere) and orientation (external/water or internal/blood sensing) of the NECs are highly variable between species of water and air breathing fish. Much of what has been described so far comes from studies of hypoxic responses in fish, however, changes in CO2, ammonia and lactate have all been shown to elicit cardio-respiratory responses and all have been suggested to arise from stimulation of gill NECs. Our view of the role of NECs is broadening as we begin to understand the polymodal nature of these cells. We begin by presenting the fundamental picture of gill chemosensing that has developed, followed by some key unanswered questions about gill chemosensing in general.

Polymodal sensory perception drives settlement and metamorphosis of Ciona larvae

The Earth's oceans brim with an incredible diversity of microscopic lifeforms, including motile planktonic larvae, whose survival critically depends on effective dispersal in the water column and subsequent exploration of the seafloor to identify a suitable settlement site. How their nervous systems mediate sensing of diverse multimodal cues remains enigmatic. Here, we uncover that the tunicate Ciona intestinalis larvae employ ectodermal sensory cells to sense various mechanical and chemical cues. Combining whole-brain imaging and chemogenetics, we demonstrate that stimuli encoded at the periphery are sufficient to drive global brain-state changes to promote or impede both larval attachment and metamorphosis behaviors. The ability of C. intestinalis larvae to leverage polymodal sensory perception to support information coding and chemotactile behaviors may explain how marine larvae make complex decisions despite streamlined nervous systems.

A role for dopamine in control of the hypoxic ventilatory response via D2 receptors in the zebrafish gill

Dopamine is a neurotransmitter involved in oxygen sensing and control of reflex hyperventilation. In aquatic vertebrates, oxygen sensing occurs in the gills via chemoreceptive neuroepithelial cells (NECs), but a mechanism for dopamine in autonomic control of ventilation has not been defined. We used immunohistochemistry and confocal microscopy to map the distribution of tyrosine hydroxylase (TH), an enzyme necessary for dopamine synthesis, in the gills of zebrafish. TH was found in nerve fibers of the gill filaments and respiratory lamellae. We further identified dopamine active transporter (dat) and vesicular monoamine transporter (vmat2) expression in neurons of the gill filaments using transgenic lines. Moreover, TH- and dat-positive nerve fibers innervated NECs. In chemical screening assays, domperidone, a D2 receptor antagonist, increased ventilation frequency in zebrafish larvae in a dose-dependent manner. When larvae were confronted with acute hypoxia, the D2 agonist, quinpirole, abolished the hyperventilatory response. Quantitative polymerase chain reaction confirmed expression of drd2a and drd2b (genes encoding D2 receptors) in the gills, and their relative abundance decreased following acclimation to hypoxia for 48 h. We localized D2 receptor immunoreactivity to NECs in the efferent gill filament epithelium, and a novel cell type in the afferent filament epithelium. We provide evidence for the synthesis and storage of dopamine by sensory nerve terminals that innervate NECs. We further suggest that D2 receptors on presynaptic NECs provide a feedback mechanism that attenuates the chemoreceptor response to hypoxia. Our studies suggest that a fundamental, modulatory role for dopamine in oxygen sensing arose early in vertebrate evolution.

Gill structure and neurochemical markers in the African bonytongue (Heterotis niloticus): A preliminary study

We have conducted a morphological and immunohistochemical study of the gills of juvenile specimens of the obligate air-breathing fish Heterotis niloticus. The study has been performed under normoxic and hypoxic conditions. The gills showed a reduced respiratory surface area by development of an interlamellar cellular mass (ILCM). The ILCM persisted without changes under both normoxia and hypoxia. Neuroepithelial cells (NECs), the major oxygen and hypoxia sensing cell type, were located in the distal end of the gill filaments and along the ILCM edges. These cells expressed 5HT, the neuronal isoform of the nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) and the vesicular acetylcholine transporter (VAChT). Furthermore, NECs appeared associated with nitrergic nerve fibres. The O2 levels did not modify the location, number or the immunohistochemical characteristics of NECs. Pavement cells covering the ILCM were also positive to nNOS and VAChT. The mechanisms of O₂ sensing in the gills of Heterotis appears to involve several cell populations, the release of multiple neurotransmitters and a diversity of excitatory, inhibitory and modulatory mechanisms.

Neurochemical Signalling Associated With Gill Oxygen Sensing and Ventilation: A Receptor Focused Mini-Review

Despite the large body of work describing vertebrate ventilatory responses to hypoxia, remarkably little is known about the receptors and afferent pathways mediating these responses in fishes. In this review, we aim to summarize all receptor types to date implicated in the neurotransmission or neuromodulation associated with O2 sensing in the gills of fish. This includes serotonergic, cholinergic, purinergic, and dopaminergic receptor subtypes. Recent transcriptomic analysis of the gills of zebrafish using single-cell RNA sequencing has begun to elucidate specific receptor targets in the gill; however, the absence of receptor characterization at the cellular level in the gill remains a major limitation in understanding the neurochemical control of hypoxia signalling.

Quest for breathing: proliferation of alveolar type 1 cells

There is much evidence that the vertebrate lung originated from a progenitor structure which was present in bony fish. However, critical basic elements for the evolution of breathing in tetrapods, such as the central rhythm generator sensitive to CO₂/pH and the pulmonary surfactant, were present in the lungless primitive vertebrate. This suggests that the evolution of air breathing in all vertebrates may have evolved through exaptations. It appears that the capability for proliferation of alveolar type 1 (AT1) cells is the "critical factor" which rendered possible the most radical subsequent innovation-the possibility of air breathing. "Epithelial remodeling," which consists in proliferation of alveolar cells-the structural basis for gas diffusion-observed in the alimentary tract of the gut-breathing fishes (GBF) has great potential for application in biomedical research. Such a process probably led to the gradual evolutionary development of lungs in terrestrial vertebrates. Research on the cellular and molecular mechanisms controlling proliferation of squamous epithelial cells in the GBF should contribute to explaining the regeneration-associated phenomena that occur in mammal lungs, and especially to the understanding of signal pathways which govern the process.

Understanding ventilation and oxygen uptake of Pacific hagfish (Eptatretus stoutii), with particular emphasis on responses to ammonia and interactions with other respiratory gases

The hagfishes are an ancient and evolutionarily important group, with breathing mechanisms and gills very different from those of other fishes. Hagfish inhale through a single nostril via a velum pump, and exhale through multiple separate gill pouches. We assessed respiratory performance in E. stoutii (31 ppt, 12 ºC, 50-120 g) by measuring total ventilatory flow ([Formula: see text]) at the nostril, velar (respiratory) frequency (fr), and inspired (P_IO₂) and expired (P_EO₂) oxygen tensions at all 12 gill pouch exits plus the pharyngo-cutaneous duct (PCD) on the left side, and calculated ventilatory stroke volume (S[Formula: see text]), % O₂ utilization, and oxygen consumption (ṀO₂). At rest under normoxia, spontaneous changes in [Formula: see text] ranged from apnea to > 400 ml kg^-1 min^-1, due to variations in both fr and S[Formula: see text]; "normal" [Formula: see text] averaged 137 ml kg^-1 min^-1, ṀO₂ was 718 µmol kg^-1 h^-1, so the ventilatory convection requirement for O₂ was about 11 L mmol^-1. Relative to anterior gill pouches, lower P_EO₂ values (i.e. higher utilization) occurred in the more posterior pouches and PCD. Overall, O₂ utilization was 34% and did not change during hyperventilation but increased to > 90% during hypoventilation. Environmental hypoxia (P_IO₂ ~ 8% air saturation, 1.67 kPa, 13 Torr) caused hyperventilation, but neither acute hyperoxia (P_IO₂ ~ 275% air saturation, 57.6 kPa, 430 Torr) nor hypercapnia (P_ICO₂ ~ 1% CO₂, 1.0 kPa, 7.5 Torr) significantly altered [Formula: see text]. ṀO₂ decreased in hypoxia and increased in hyperoxia but did not change in hypercapnia. Acute exposure to high environmental ammonia (HEA, 10 mM NH₄HCO₃) caused an acute decrease in [Formula: see text], in contrast to the hyperventilation of long-term HEA exposure described in a previous study. The hypoventilatory response to HEA still occurred during hypoxia and hyperoxia, but was blunted during hypercapnia. Under all treatments, ṀO₂ increased with increases in [Formula: see text]. Overall, there were lower convection requirements for O₂ during hyperoxia, higher requirements during hypoxia and hypercapnia, but unchanged requirements during HEA. We conclude that this "primitive" fish operates a flexible respiratory system with considerable reserve capacity.

Brain and gills as internal and external ammonia sensing organs for ventilatory control in rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss

Ammonia is both a respiratory gas and a toxicant in teleost fish. Hyperventilation is a well-known response to elevations of both external and internal ammonia levels. Branchial neuroepithelial cells (NECs) are thought to serve as internal sensors of plasma ammonia (peripheral chemoreceptors), but little is known about other possible ammonia-sensors. Here, we investigated whether trout possess external sensors and/or internal central chemoreceptors for ammonia. For external sensors, we analyzed the time course of ventilatory changes at the start of exposure to high environmental ammonia (HEA, 1 mM). Hyperventilation developed gradually over 20 min, suggesting that it was a response to internal ammonia elevation. We also directly perfused ammonia solutions (0.01-1 mM) to the external surfaces of the first gill arches. Immediate hypoventilation occurred. For central chemoreceptors, we injected ammonia solutions (0.5-1.0 mM) directly onto the surface of the hindbrain of anesthetized trout. Immediate hyperventilation occurred. This is the first evidence of central chemoreception in teleost fish. We conclude that trout possess both external ammonia sensors, and dual internal ammonia sensors (perhaps for redundancy), but their roles differ. External sensors cause short term hypoventilation, which would help limit toxic waterborne ammonia uptake. When fish cannot avoid HEA, the diffusion of waterborne ammonia into the blood will stimulate both peripheral (NECs) and central (brain) chemoreceptors, resulting in hyperventilation. This hyperventilation will be beneficial in increasing ammonia excretion via the Rh metabolon system in the gills not only after HEA exposure, but also after endogenous ammonia loading from feeding or exercise.

Identification of oxygen-sensitive neuroepithelial cells through an endogenous reporter gene in larval and adult transgenic zebrafish

In teleost fish, specialized oxygen (O₂) chemoreceptors, called neuroepithelial cells (NECs), are found in the gill epithelium in adults. During development, NECs are present in the skin before the formation of functional gills. NECs are known for retaining the monoamine neurotransmitter, serotonin (5-HT) and are conventionally identified through immunoreactivity with antibodies against 5-HT or synaptic vesicle protein (SV2). However, identification of NECs in live tissue and isolated cell preparations has been challenging due to the lack of a specific marker. The present study explored the use of the transgenic zebrafish, ETvmat2:GFP, which expresses green fluorescent protein (GFP) under the control of the vesicular monoamine transporter 2 (vmat2) regulatory element, to identify NECs. Using immunohistochemistry and confocal microscopy, we confirmed that the endogenous GFP in ETvmat2:GFP labelled serotonergic NECs in the skin of larvae and in the gills of adults. NECs of the gill filaments expressed a higher level of endogenous GFP compared with other cells. The endogenous GFP also labelled intrabranchial neurons of the gill filaments. Flow cytometric analysis demonstrated that filamental NECs could be distinguished from other dissociated gill cells based on high GFP expression alone. Acclimation to 2 weeks of severe hypoxia (PO₂ = 35 mmHg) induced an increase in filamental NEC frequency, size and GFP gene expression. Here we present for the first time a transgenic tool that labels O₂ chemoreceptors in an aquatic vertebrate and its use in high-throughput experimentation.

Gills versus kidney for ionoregulation in the obligate air-breathing Arapaima gigas, a fish with a kidney in its air-breathing organ

In Arapaima gigas, an obligate air-breather endemic to ion-poor Amazonian waters, a large complex kidney runs through the air-breathing organ (ABO). Previous indirect evidence suggested that the kidney, relative to the small gills, may be exceptionally important in ionoregulation and nitrogen (N) waste excretion, with support of kidney function by direct O2 supply from the airspace. We tested these ideas by continuous urine collection and gill flux measurements in ∼700 g fish. ATPase activities were many-fold greater in kidney than gills. In normoxia, gill Na+ influx and efflux were in balance, with net losses of Cl- and K+ Urine flow rate (UFR, ∼11 ml kg-1 h-1) and urinary ions (< 0.2 mmol l-1) were exceptional, with [urine]:[plasma] ratios of 0.02-0.002 for K+, Na+, and Cl-, indicating strong reabsorption with negligible urinary ion losses. Urinary [ammonia] was very high (10 mmol l-1, [urine]:[plasma] ∼17) indicating strong secretion. The kidney accounted for 21-24% of N excretion, with ammonia dominating (95%) over urea-N through both routes. High urinary [ammonia] was coupled to high urinary [HCO3-]. Aerial hypoxia (15.3 kPa) and aerial hyperoxia (>40.9 kPa) had no effects on UFR, but both inhibited branchial Na+ influx, revealing novel aspects of the osmorespiratory compromise. Aquatic hypoxia (4.1 kPa), but not aquatic hyperoxia (>40.9 kPa), inhibited gill Na+ influx, UFR and branchial and urinary ammonia excretion. We conclude that the kidney is more important than gills in ionoregulation, and is significant in N excretion. Although not definitive, our results do not indicate direct O2 supply from the ABO for kidney function.

The role of TASK-2 channels in CO2 sensing in zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Peripheral chemosensitivity in fishes is thought to be mediated by serotonin-enriched neuroepithelial cells (NECs) that are localized to the gills of adults and the integument of larvae. In adult zebrafish (Danio rerio), branchial NECs are presumed to mediate the cardiorespiratory reflexes associated with hypoxia or hypercapnia, whereas in larvae, there is indirect evidence linking cutaneous NECs to hypoxic hyperventilation and hypercapnic tachycardia. No study yet has examined the ventilatory response of larval zebrafish to hypercapnia, and regardless of developmental stage, the signaling pathways involved in CO₂ sensing remain unclear. In the mouse, a background potassium channel (TASK-2) contributes to the sensitivity of chemoreceptor cells to CO₂. Zebrafish possess two TASK-2 channel paralogs, TASK-2 and TASK-2b, encoded by kcnk5a and kcnk5b, respectively. The present study aimed to determine whether TASK-2 channels are expressed in NECs of larval zebrafish and whether they are involved in CO₂ sensing. Using immunohistochemical approaches, TASK-2 protein was observed on the surface of NECs in larvae. Exposure of larvae to hypercapnia caused cardiac and breathing frequencies to increase, and these responses were blunted in fish experiencing TASK-2 and/or TASK-2b knockdown. The results of these experiments suggest that TASK-2 channels are involved in CO₂ sensing by NECs and contribute to the initiation of reflex cardiorespiratory responses during exposure of larvae to hypercapnia.

Expression of Acetylcholine- and G protein coupled Muscarinic receptor in the Neuroepithelial cells (NECs) of the obligated air-breathing fish, Arapaima gigas (Arapaimatidae: Teleostei)

The air-breathing specialization has evolved idependently in vertebrates, as many different organs can perfom gas exchange. The largest obligate air-breathing fish from South America Arapaima gigas breathe air using its gas bladder, and its dependence on air breathing increases during its growth. During its development, gill morphology shows a dramatic change, remodeling with a gradual reduction of gill lamellae during the transition from water breathing to air breathing . It has been suggested that in this species the gills remain the main site of O₂ and CO₂ sensing. Consistent with this, we demonstrate for the first time the occurrence of the neuroepithelial cells (NECs) in the glottis, and in the gill filament epithelia and their distal halves. These cells contain a broader spectrum of neurotransmitters (5-HT, acetylcholine, nNOS), G-protein subunits and the muscarininic receptors that are coupled to G proteins (G-protein coupled receptors). We report also for the first time the presence of G alpha proteins coupled with muscarinic receptors on the NECs, that are thought as receptors that initiate the cardiorespiratory reflexes in aquatic vertebrates. Based on the specific orientation in the epithelia and their closest vicinity to efferent vasculatures, the gill and glottal NECs of A. gigas could be regarded as potential O₂ and CO₂ sensing receptors. However, future studies are needed to ascertain the neurophysiological characterization of these cells.

Chemoreceptors as a key to understanding carcinogenesis process

The tissue organization field theory (TOFT) presented completely new, different from the previous one, perspective of research on neoplasm processes. It implicates that secretory neuroepithelial-like cells (NECs), putative chemoreceptors are probably responsible for the control of squamous epithelial cells proliferation in the digestive tract during hypoxia in gut breathing fish (GBF). On the other hand, chemoreceptors dysfunction can lead to uncontrolled proliferation and risk of cancer development in mammals, including humans. The studies on NECs like cells (signal capturing and transduction) may be crucial for understanding the processes of controlling the proliferation of squamous epithelial cells in the digestive tract of GBF fish during hypoxia states. This knowledge can contribute to the explanation of cancer processes.

From epithelial remodelling to carcinogenesis

The novel cancer theory named 'the tissue organization field theory' (TOFT) suggests that carcinogenesis is a process analogous to embryonic development, whereby organs are formed through interactions among different cell types. The suggested 'morphological remodelling' of the epithelium under hypoxia in gut breathing fish (GBF) has many common features with carcinogenesis. It appears that research into the relationship among epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), hypoxia inducible factor (HIF) as well as hypoxia and normoxia states in GBF fishes can be crucial in learning about the steering mechanisms of squamous epithelium proliferation, leading to a better understanding of carcinogenesis.

Central control of air breathing in fishes

The diversity of sites and surfaces that are utilized for gas transfer from air to blood in fish is remarkable. While a few species do utilize their gills for gas exchange in air, this is a rare occurrence and most air-breathing fish utilize other surfaces including air-breathing organs and lungs. At present almost nothing is known about the central sites that initiate and regulate air breathing although hypotheses can be put forward based on our rudimentary understanding of the sites involved in water breathing in lampreys and teleost fishes, and those involved in air breathing in pre-metamorphic anuran ampibians. The pumps involved in producing both water and air breathing in fishes are highly conserved, a buccal pump, assisted by pharyngeal and/or parabranchial/opercular pumps, produce both forms of ventilation. What varies between species are the manner in which air breaths are produced (in two versus four phases), and the 'valving' involved in producing water flow over the gills versus air flow in and out of air-breathing organs. The latter suggests that a major step in the evolution of air breathing was the evolution of the mechanisms that control the flow of the respiratory medium. The neural matrix that underlies the co-ordination of the pump and the valving events remains enigmatic and in much need of further research.