Exploring the relationship between object realism and object-based attention effects

Excess success in articles on object-based attention

Twenty-five years of research has explored the object-based attention effect using the two-rectangles paradigm and closely related paradigms. While reading this literature, we noticed statistical attributes that are sometimes related to questionable research practices, which can undermine the reported conclusions. To quantify these attributes, we applied the Test for Excess Success (TES) individually to 37 articles that investigate various properties of object-based attention and comprise four or more experiments. A TES analysis estimates the probability that a direct replication of the experiments in a given article with the same sample sizes would have the same success (or better) as the original article. If the probability is low, then readers should be skeptical about the conclusions that are based on those experimental results. We find that 19 of the 37 analyzed articles (51%) seem too good to be true in that they have a replication probability below 0.1. In a new large sample study, we do find evidence for the basic object-based attention effect in the two-rectangles paradigm, which this literature builds on. A power analysis using this data shows that commonly used sample sizes in studies that investigate properties of object-based attention with the two-rectangles paradigm are, in fact, much too small to reliably detect even the basic effect.

The influence of object similarity on real object-based attention: The disassociation of perceptual and semantic similarity

Perceptual and semantic similarity have an impact on object-based attention for the geometric objects. However, no previous studies have disassociated perceptual properties from the semantic ones of real objects that combine perceptual and semantic properties. It is unclear whether the perceptual and semantic similarity of real objects jointly or independently guides attentional deployment. The aim of the present study was to explore the influence of object similarity on object-based attention by using a variant of the two-rectangle paradigm and disassociating the perceptual and semantic similarity of real objects. The results indicated that when the semantic of objects was similar, the object-based effect was larger for the perceptually dissimilar condition than for the perceptually similar condition, because of slower response to invalid different-object location in a dissimilar condition. Moreover, when the perception of objects was similar, the object-based effect was larger for the semantically dissimilar condition than for the semantically similar condition, due to slower response to invalid different-object location in a dissimilar condition. These results suggest that perceptual and semantic similarity can independently guide attentional allocation to real objects and the similarity may constrain the object-based attention in a way of grouping. The current study implies that the attentional prioritization hypothesis is more flexible and effective to explain the real object-based attention and also has some implication to advertising design.

Attentional modulation of unconscious inhibitory visuomotor processes: An EEG study

The present study examined the role of attention in unconscious inhibitory visuomotor processes in three experiments that employed a mixed paradigm including a spatial cueing task and masked prime task. Spatial attention to the prime was manipulated. Specifically, the valid-cue condition (in which the prime obtained more attentional resources) and invalid-cue condition (in which the prime obtained fewer attentional resources) were included. The behavioral results showed that the negative compatibility effect (a behavioral indicator of inhibitory visuomotor processing) in the valid-cue condition was larger than that in the invalid-cue condition. Most importantly, lateralized readiness potential results indicated that the prime-related activation was stronger in the valid-cue condition than in the invalid-cue condition and that the followed inhibition in the compatible trials was also stronger in the valid-cue condition than in the invalid-cue condition. In line with the proposed attentional modulation model, unconscious visuomotor inhibitory processing is modulated by attentional resources.