Satisfaction and treatment adherence in erectile dysfunction in the medium and long term

Men's beliefs about treatment for erectile dysfunction-what influences treatment use? A systematic review

Successful treatment of erectile dysfunction (ED) is associated with improvements in quality of life; however, treatment utilisation is sub-optimal. The aim of this systematic review was to identify the rates of ED treatment utilisation and the barriers and enablers men experience when using treatment. We searched: MEDLINE^®, Embase, the Cochrane library; AMED; HMIC; HTA; CINAHL; PsychARTICLES; PsychINFO up to August 2018. Data on rates of treatment utilisation and barriers and enablers of utilisation were extracted and summarised. Fifty studies were included. Discontinuation rates ranged from 4.4 to 76% for phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitors, 18.6 to 79.9% for intracavernosal injections, and 32 to 69.2% for urethral suppositories. In relation to those with a penile prosthesis, 30% discontinued having sex due to, e.g. device complications, lack of partner or a loss of sexual interest. Most research included in the current review examined barriers to treatment utilisation and therefore focussed on reasons for discontinuing treatment. However, a small number explored factors that men found helpful with regards to treatment utilisation. The most prevalent barriers to utilisation were treatment ineffectiveness, side effects, the quality of men's intimate relationships and treatment costs. With regards to treatment enablers, the most salient finding was that men who reported side effects to a healthcare professionals (HCPs) were significantly less likely to discontinue treatment. There were limitations in methodology in that the studies did not use validated measures of treatment utilisation or barriers and enablers and no study used psychological theory to inform the examination of factors that influenced treatment utilisation. This review identifies a number of influential factors relating to ED treatment utilisation and highlights the importance of men's beliefs with regards to ED and its treatment. Beliefs are potentially modifiable and therefore the findings of this review highlight important considerations for HCPs with regards to supporting men to make better use of treatment.

National Health and Wellness Survey exploratory cluster analysis of males 40-70 years old focused on erectile dysfunction and associated risk factors across the USA, Italy, Brazil and China

OBJECTIVES

Prior studies of erectile dysfunction (ED) tend to narrowly focus on relationships with specific comorbidities, rather than evaluating a more comprehensive array of risk factors and assessing naturalistic patterns among them. This study identifies natural clusters of male characteristics from a general population sample per country, quantifies ED dynamics in these profiles and compares profiles across the US, Italy, Brazil and China samples.

METHODS

National Health and Wellness Survey 2015 and 2016 patient-reported data on men aged 40-70 years (USA n = 15,652; Italy n = 2,521; Brazil n = 2,822; China n = 5,553) were analysed. Hierarchical agglomerative clustering identified clusters where predictors included demographics, health characteristics/behaviours, ED risk factors and provider visits in the past 6 months. Multinomial logistic regression assessed the independent utility of variables in predicting cluster membership, compared with the healthiest control cluster per country.

RESULTS

Different natural clusters were found across countries, with four clusters for the USA, Italy and China and three clusters for Brazil. Age, income, employment, health behaviours and ED risk factors predicted different cluster membership across countries. In the USA, Italy and Brazil, younger clusters were predicted by ED, unhealthy behaviours and ED risk factors. Unique cluster profiles were identified in China, with ED and ED risk factors (aside from hypertension) not predicting cluster membership, while socio-demographics and health behaviours were strongly predictive.

CONCLUSIONS

Natural cluster profiles revealed notable ED rates among adult males of age 40-70 in four different countries. Clusters were mainly predicted by unhealthy behaviours, ED risk factors and ED, regardless of level or presence of positive health characteristics and behaviours. This analysis identified meaningful subgroups of men with heightened ED risk factors, which can help healthcare providers to better recognise specific populations with the greatest need for intervention.