Improvement of the association between self-reported pill count and varenicline levels following exclusion of participants with misreported pill count: A commentary on Peng et al. (2017)

Stability of Varenicline Concentration in Saliva Over 21 Days at Three Storage Temperatures

INTRODUCTION

Varenicline is the most efficacious drug for smoking cessation; saliva varenicline concentrations can be useful for the evaluation of adherence in smoking cessation trials. Saliva is a useful noninvasive matrix for mail-in specimen collection, if stable. We investigated the stability of varenicline in saliva at different storage temperatures simulating the time it takes to mail in a sample.

METHODS

We evaluated the concentrations of varenicline, nicotine, cotinine, 3'-hydroxycotinine, and 3'-hydroxycotinine/cotinine (3HC/COT) ratio in quality control saliva samples (and after repeated freezing and thawing), and in smokers' saliva samples, stored for up to 21 days at room temperature (~25°C), 4°C, and -80°C.

RESULTS

In saliva quality control samples, concentrations of varenicline, nicotine, cotinine, 3'-hydroxycotinine, and 3HC/COT remained unchanged and showed little within-sample variation (CV ≤ 5.5%) for up to 21 days at the three storage temperatures; they were also not altered after three thaw-freeze cycles. In smokers' saliva, a significant main effect of storage duration, but not temperature, was observed for varenicline, cotinine, and 3'-hydroxycotinine, but not for nicotine or the 3HC/COT ratio. However, these changes were within analytical (i.e., equipment) variation resulting in little within-sample variation (CV ≤ 5.8%) for all analytes in smokers' saliva.

CONCLUSIONS

Varenicline, the other analytes, and the 3HC/COT ratio remained stable in saliva during storage for 21 days at all temperatures tested and after repeated freezing and thawing with only minor changes in concentration over time. These findings support the potential use of mail-in approach for saliva samples in varenicline smoking cessation clinical trials.

IMPLICATIONS

Assessing saliva varenicline concentrations can be useful for the evaluation of adherence in smoking cessation trials. Saliva is a noninvasive matrix suitable for mail-in specimen collection. This is the first investigation of stability of varenicline in saliva. Varenicline, nicotine, cotinine, 3'-hydroxycotinine, and 3HC/COT were stable in saliva for up to 21 days at room temperature (~25°C), 4°C, and -80°C, supporting the use of a mail-in approach for saliva specimen in smoking cessation trials.

Impact of early nausea on varenicline adherence and smoking cessation

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Varenicline effectiveness may be related to the level of adherence, which might be reduced by adverse effects such as nausea. The aim of the study was to test a possible effect of nausea on smoking cessation outcomes mediated by adherence.

DESIGN

Mediation path analysis.

SETTING

Multiple sites within Canada and the United States.

PARTICIPANTS

Treatment-seeking smokers receiving varenicline from two smoking cessation clinical trials: Quit2Live (NCT01836276; n = 449) and Pharmacogenetics of Nicotine Addiction Treatment (PNAT) (NCT01314001; n = 421).

MEASUREMENTS

Nausea severity was collected through self-report and adherence was biologically assessed using varenicline concentrations (Quit2Live, plasma sample at week 4; PNAT, saliva sample at week 2). In Quit2Live, the end-points were cotinine-verified abstinence at weeks 4, 12 and 26. In PNAT, the end-points were carbon monoxide-verified abstinence at weeks 2, 12 and 26.

FINDINGS

Early nausea was not directly associated with abstinence [odds ratio (OR) ranging from 0.73-1.28; P ≥ 0.26]. However early nausea was indirectly associated with lower cessation rates at multiple timepoints (ORs ranging from 0.92-0.94; 95% CI between 0.83-0.99) in a relationship mediated by reduced varenicline adherence (assessed by plasma varenicline concentrations) in the primary trial (Quit2Live). This relationship between nausea, adherence and cessation was similar in direction but weaker in effect size (ORs ranging from 0.98-0.99; 95% CI between 0.90-1.03) in a secondary trial (PNAT), where adherence was assessed using salivary varenicline concentrations.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that early nausea during varenicline treatment may be indirectly associated with lower likelihood of smoking cessation through reducing varenicline adherence. Differences in robustness between the trials may be due to the different biological matrices (plasma vs. saliva) and/or timing used to assess varenicline adherence. The results of the first study suggest that improved management of early nausea during varenicline treatment may positively impact smoking cessation success through increasing varenicline adherence.

Predicting smoking abstinence with biological and self-report measures of adherence to varenicline: Impact on pharmacogenetic trial outcomes

INTRODUCTION

Adherence to pharmacotherapies for tobacco dependence, such as varenicline, is necessary for effective treatment. The relationship between varenicline adherence, determined by commonly used indirect (i.e., self-reported pill counts) and infrequently used direct (i.e., varenicline levels) methods, and abstinence outcomes have not been previously examined, nor has their impact on the outcomes of a genetically randomized clinical trial been assessed.

METHODS

At Week 1 following target quit date, self-reported pill count and salivary varenicline levels were obtained from participants (N = 376) in a smoking cessation clinical trial (NCT01314001). Point-prevalence abstinence was biochemically-verified by salivary cotinine at Week 1 and by exhaled carbon monoxide at Week 1, end-of-treatment, 6 and 12 months following treatment. Blood nicotine metabolite ratio (NMR) was obtained at baseline.

RESULTS

Adherent individuals based on varenicline levels were significantly more likely to be abstinent than non-adherent individuals at Week 1 (odds ratios [ORs] 1.92-3.16, p's≤0.006), end-of-treatment (OR = 2.53, p = .004), and six months following treatment (OR = 2.30, p = .03). In contrast, pill counts did not consistently predict abstinence. Including direct measures of adherence enhanced the association between rate of nicotine metabolism (NMR) and end-of-treatment abstinence; normal metabolizers (NMR ≥ 0.31) were significantly more likely than slow metabolizers (NMR < 0.31) to be abstinent at end-of-treatment (OR = 2.00, p = .005).

CONCLUSION

Adherence based on salivary varenicline, rather than on pill counts, is predictive of Week 1 abstinence, irrespective of the biomarker of abstinence assessed, and of long-term abstinence. Direct measures of adherence enhance the ability to assess the impact of a biomarker or genetic marker on abstinence outcomes.

The association between self-reported varenicline adherence and varenicline blood levels in a sample of cancer patients receiving treatment for tobacco dependence

Introduction

The degree to which smokers quit successfully with varenicline is strongly associated with their adherence to the medication regimen. Thus, measuring varenicline adherence to identify smokers needing additional intervention is a priority. Few studies, however, have examined the validity of self-reported varenicline adherence, using a biological assessment of adherence as a reference. No study has examined this issue among cancer patients trying to quit smoking, who may show unique patterns of adherence given their medical comorbidity.

Methods

This study used data from 76 cancer patients who received varenicline and provided self-reported varenicline adherence data (pill count) and a blood sample to determine varenicline metabolites 4 weeks after initiating varenicline.

Results

Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analyses of plasma varenicline levels showed that 4 ng/ml was the optimal cut-point for differentiating adherence with significant (p's < 0.04) area under the curve values, ranging from 0.73–0.80 for 3-day, 7-day, and 4-week self-reported pill count; specificity values ranged from 0.63–0.78 and sensitivity values ranged from 0.82–0.94. Using this cut-point, adherence was high (88%). However, plasma varenicline levels were weakly correlated with 3-day and 4-week pill count and total pill count (12 weeks) was not correlated with plasma varenicline levels. Patients with head and neck cancer, gastrointestinal cancer, and more advanced disease showed lower varenicline adherence and lower plasma varenicline.

Conclusions

Using the 4 ng/ml cut-point, this study suggests validity of short-term self-reported varenicline adherence among cancer patients undergoing tobacco dependence treatment in contrast to studies in the general population, which supported 12-week pill count.

•

First study of the validity of self-reported varenicline use among cancer patients

•

Identified cut-point for varenicline plasma adherence

•

Supports the validity of short-term self-reported varenicline adherence

•

Cancer-related variables influence varenicline adherence

•

Varenicline adherence may be higher among cancer patients