Understanding factors that impact on public and patient's risk perceptions and responses toward Clostridium difficile and other health care-associated infections: a structured literature review

Adding Infectious Insult to Traumatic Injury: The Impact of Infectious Complications in End-of-Life Decision Making

Background: Trauma increases the risk for infection, but it is unknown how infection affects goals-of-care (GOC) decision making. We sought to determine how infections impact transition to comfort measures only (CMO), hypothesizing that infectious complications would expedite withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment (WOLST). Patients and Methods: We performed a retrospective review at a level-one trauma center over two years for adult patients without pre-existing advance directives who were made CMO with length of stay longer than one day. Demographics, injuries, and hospital course including infections and the GOC timeline were collected. Patients were divided on the basis of infection development, defined as an infectious complication requiring antibiotics or more invasive intervention, with subgroup analysis comparing those with single versus multiple infections. The primary end point was time to death or discharge. Results: Two hundred thirty-two patients met inclusion criteria and 72 developed an infection. Pneumonia was the most common infection (53.8%). Although those in the infection group had no substantial difference in demographics or comorbidities, they had higher emergency department Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS; 14 vs. 13), lower rate of head injury (28.6 vs. 49%), and higher time to death or discharge (12 vs. 2 days). Goals-of-care discussions were initiated later based on time to first family meeting (7 vs. 1 days), most occurring after the first infection. Subsequent analysis showed that versus those with a single infection (n = 38), those with multiple infections (n = 34) had a higher time to death or discharge (16.5 vs. 10.5 days) despite no difference in demographics, comorbidities, or trauma severity. Time to first family meeting was longer (8.5 vs. 4.5 days) with most occurring after the first infection. Conclusions: We did not find that development of an infection shortens time to WOLST. The increased time to death or discharge in the setting of multiple infections and similar patient populations may be a marker of provider approach to GOC plus family beliefs. Infectious complications play an uncertain role in end-of-life discussions after trauma.

Effective infection prevention and control: the nurse's role

Healthcare-associated infections and antimicrobial resistance are significant threats to public health. As resistant organisms continue to emerge and evolve, and antimicrobial agents become less effective, infection prevention and control remains a vital aspect of maintaining public health, particularly among vulnerable patient groups such as older people and young children. Because of the increasing complexity of healthcare treatments and interventions, patients are becoming increasingly susceptible to healthcare-associated infections and resistant organisms. This article outlines some of the challenges that nurses may experience in ensuring effective infection prevention and control, and how these can be addressed.

Previous antibiotic-related adverse drug reactions do not reduce expectations for antibiotic treatment of upper respiratory tract infections

BACKGROUND

Patients' expectations may influence prescribers' decisions about antibiotic prescribing for upper respiratory tract infection (URTI). We examined whether a history of an antibiotic related adverse drug reaction (aADR) influenced a person's perception about the safety of antibiotics or their expectation of receiving an antibiotic prescription for an URTI.

METHODS

We developed a questionnaire and surveyed 103 hospital inpatients, 38 of whom (37%) reported past experience of aADR.

RESULTS

Of the 88 participants who reported recent antibiotic use, participants with a history of aADR reported increased perception of harm from their last antibiotic treatment (P<0.05). Overall, 41/103 (40%) participants expected their doctors to prescribe antibiotics to treat an URTI. Participants' perceptions of antibiotic safety or expectation of antibiotic treatment for an URTI did not differ between those who had personal experience of an aADR compared with those with no history of aADR.

CONCLUSIONS

The almost universal belief that antibiotics are safe, beneficial medications, even among people with prior aADR, helps to explain the strong patient expectations for antibiotic treatment in a range of conditions. Educational campaigns about the prescription of antibiotics for viral URTI should include information that the risk of harm far outweighs any potential benefits.

Understanding risk perceptions and responses of the public and health care professionals toward Clostridium difficile: A qualitative interpretive description study

BACKGROUND

The occurrence of Clostridium difficile infection is a major health-related risk. How the public and health care professionals perceive and respond to a health-related risk is shaped by socially and contextually structured evaluations and interpretations. Risk perceptions and responses are context dependent and therefore need to be understood within the context in which they are perceived and experienced.

METHODS

This interpretive description study used 8 public focus groups (39 participants) and 7 health care professional focus groups (29 participants) in 2 geographic areas (an area that had experienced a C difficile outbreak and an area that had not).

RESULTS

Both the public and health care professionals expressed varying concerns about the perceived consequences of C difficile occurring and the potential influence on emotional and physical health and well-being. In doing so, they drew upon a range of direct and indirect experiences and accounts from the media. Conceptual factors found to be important in influencing risk perceptions and responses included feelings of vulnerability, attribution of responsibility, judgments about competence, and evaluations of risk communicators.

CONCLUSIONS

If risk management and communication strategies are to achieve desired responses toward C difficile and wider risks, those responsible for managing risk must consider already established risk perceptions in addition to factors that have influenced them.

Understanding factors that impact on health care professionals' risk perceptions and responses toward Clostridium difficile and meticillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus: a structured literature review

BACKGROUND

Clostridium difficile is the most common health care-associated infection. Despite considerable efforts to prevent and manage C difficile, poor clinical practice and nonadherence to policy continues to compromise patient safety. Risk perception research is essential in gaining understanding about how health care professionals respond.

METHODS

A structured literature review examined empirical evidence regarding health care professionals' risk perceptions and responses toward C difficile. Because of limited evidence available, the review was extended to include other health care-associated infections. Only studies related to methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) could be identified.

RESULTS

Eleven studies were included. Four were specific to C difficile and 7 to MRSA. All studies found that technical understanding of C difficile was poor and that staff were concerned about risks to patients and themselves. Technical understanding for MRSA, however, was good, and staff were less concerned about their own health. Information provision was perceived to be inadequate and untrustworthy, which included the media. Practice in most studies was poor.

CONCLUSION

There is a need to build on the efforts of risk perception research from other disciplines to understand how health care professionals think and make decisions about C difficile. This can help inform the development of effective management and communication strategies to maximize the quality of care provided.