Lid Wiper Microvascular Responses as an Indicator of Contact Lens Discomfort

Changes in bulbar conjunctival microcirculation and microvasculature during short-term scleral lens wearing and their associated factors

OBJECTIVE

To explore the changes in microcirculation and microvasculature of the bulbar conjunctiva during the short-term wearing of the scleral lenses (ScCL). And investigate the factors affecting the microcirculation and microvasculature of the bulbar conjunctiva.

METHODS

In this prospective cross-sectional study, functional slit lamp biomicroscopy (FSLB) was used to image the ocular surface microcirculation and microvascular images at two different sites (under the area of ScCL and outside of the area of ScCL) before (baseline) and during the wearing of ScCL at 0 h, 1 h, 2 h and 3 h. Anterior segment optical coherence tomography (AS-OCT) (RTVue, Optovue Inc, USA) was also used to image central post-lens tear film (PoLTF) and the morphology changes of the conjunctiva under the landing zone at the same time period. The semi-automatic quantification of microcirculation and microvasculature including vessel density (Dbox), vessel diameter (D), axial blood flow velocity (Va) and blood flow volume (Q). And the morphological changes of conjunctiva and PoLTF fogging grading were evaluated manually. The changes in the microcirculation and microvasculature of the ocular surface, PoLTF fogging grade and conjunctival morphology were compared before and during the ScCL wearing at different time periods, and the relationship between them was analyzed.

RESULTS

Nineteen eyes (11 right eyes, 8 left eyes) were analyzed in this study. Outside of the area of ScCL, the Dbox before wearing lenses was less than that at 0 h (P = 0.041). The Q at baseline was greater than that after 1 h ScCL wearing (P = 0.026). Under the area of the ScCL, the Q at 1 h was less than that at baseline and 3 h. During the ScCL wearing, statistically significant conjunctival morphology changes were found among different time stages (baseline (0 μm), 0 h (113.18 μm), 2 h (138.97 μm), 3 h (143.83 μm) (all P ＜0.05). Outside the area of the ScCL, the morphology changes of the conjunctiva were negatively correlated with the changes of Va (P＜0.001,r = -0.471) and Q (P = 0.003,r = -0.348),but positively correlated with the Dbox (P = 0.001,r = 0.386). Under the area of ScCL, the morphology changes of the conjunctiva were negatively correlated with the Q (P = 0.012, r = -0.291). The fogging grade was positively correlated with the Q under the area of the ScCL (P = 0.005, r = 0.331).

CONCLUSIONS

The microcirculation and microvasculature of the ocular surface and conjunctival morphology were changed after wearing ScCL in wearers, which indicated that the microvascular responses happened in the ScCL wearers and the severity of microvascular responses of the ocular surface related to the morphology changes of the conjunctiva. The quantification methods and findings in this study provide clues for the safety of ScCL wearing and may supervise the health of the wearer's ocular surface.

End-of-day assessment of asymptomatic versus highly symptomatic soft contact lens wearers

PURPOSE

To investigate differences in key clinical parameters between asymptomatic and highly symptomatic soft contact lens (CL) wearers after 14 h of wear.

METHODS

In this pilot investigation, Phase 1 identified asymptomatic (CLDEQ-8 score ≤ 7) and highly symptomatic (CLDEQ-8 score ≥ 20) subjects after fitting with nelfilcon A CLs. Phase 2 investigated the following over a single nelfilcon A CL-wearing day (14 ± 2 h): blinking characteristics, tear meniscus height (TMH), non-invasive tear break-up time (NIBUT), tear film osmolarity and eyelid margin staining. Parameters for the two groups were compared using linear mixed models and post-hoc testing. The relationship between comfort scores and the clinical parameters was also investigated.

RESULTS

Overall, 161 and 42 subjects were enrolled into Phase 1 and 2, respectively. Twenty-five asymptomatic and 17 symptomatic subjects completed Phase 2. Lower eyelid TMH was decreased after 14 h in symptomatic compared with asymptomatic subjects (least square mean [LSM] difference -0.04 mm, 95% CI: -0.07, -0.01). Osmolarity was lower in symptomatic than in asymptomatic subjects at fitting (LSM difference -9.89, 95% CI: -18.91, -0.86). Upper eyelid margin staining was greater after 14 h in symptomatic than in asymptomatic subjects (LSM difference 0.53, 95% CI: 0.01, 1.05) and greater after 14 h than baseline in the symptomatic group (LSM difference 0.61, 95% CI: 0.16, 1.07). There was a significant relationship between comfort and upper eyelid margin staining (r = -0.40, 95% CI: -0.63, -0.11) and blink rate (r = -0.31, 95% CI: -0.57, -0.003).

CONCLUSION

The potential parameters most effective in differentiating asymptomatic from symptomatic wearers were upper eyelid margin staining and lower TMH. The parameter with the strongest relationship to comfort was upper eyelid margin staining, where higher comfort scores were associated with lower levels of staining.

Associations Between Lid Wiper Microvascular Responses, Lens Fit, and Comfort After One Day of Contact Lens Adaptation by Neophytes

PURPOSE

To determine associations between lid wiper microvascular responses, lens fit, and comfort after 1 day of contact lens adaptation by neophytes.

METHODS

Functional slitlamp biomicroscopy was used to image the microvascular network of the upper tarsal conjunctiva, lid wiper, and bulbar conjunctiva. Fractal dimension was obtained to represent vessel density. Ultra-high-resolution optical coherence tomography was used to image the lens edge and fitting characteristics, including lens movement and lens-induced conjunctival indentation. Ocular comfort was rated using a 50-point visual analogue scale (VAS). Forty-nine healthy subjects without a history of contact lens wear were recruited. A contact lens was then fitted in the right eye. Imaging was taken at baseline and 6 hr after lens wear.

RESULTS

The changes of VAS comfort score were negatively related to the changes of the vessel density in the lid-wiper (R 2 =0.18, P =0.002) and bulbar conjunctiva (R 2 =0.13, P =0.009). However, the changes of VAS were positively related to the changes in vessel density of the tarsal conjunctiva (R 2 =0.11, P =0.02). The changes of ocular microvasculature were not related to the objective metrics of the lens-fitting characteristics ( P >0.05). Similarly, the changes in the VAS comfort score were not related to the objective metrics of the lens-fitting characteristics ( P >0.05).

CONCLUSION

Contact lens discomfort seemed to relate to lid wiper microvascular responses rather than fitting characteristics after 1 day of contact lens adaptation by neophytes.

Ocular surface microvascular response and its relation to contact lens fitting and ocular comfort: an update of recent research

This review examines vascular responses in the ocular surface to contact lens wear and its relation to lens fitting characteristics and contact lens-related discomfort. A search of PubMed was performed to find original research in English, within the past 10 years, that studied the ocular surface, including lid-wiper vascular responses to the lens. The interaction between the lens and ocular surface triggers vascular responses, impacting the lens fitting and contact lens-related discomfort. Contact lens-related discomfort is a multifactorial event, which is affected by lens characteristics. Overall, contact lenses with low modulus and a relatively tight fit produce significant ocular comfort. If an appropriate lens fit is achieved, lens fitting characteristics may not play a critical role in contact lens-related discomfort. On the other hand, the pathogenic and vascular changes of lid-wiper vascular responses appear to play an essential role in developing contact lens-related discomfort, in concert with reactions of the cornea (compression and staining) and conjunctiva (indentation and staining). Robust evaluation of lid-wiper changes at the cellular and microvascular level may hold the key to better understanding the mechanism of contact lens-related discomfort and reveal strategies for eliminating lid wiper epitheliopathy and improving ocular comfort in contact lens wearers.

CLEAR - Effect of contact lens materials and designs on the anatomy and physiology of the eye

This paper outlines changes to the ocular surface caused by contact lenses and their degree of clinical significance. Substantial research and development to improve oxygen permeability of rigid and soft contact lenses has meant that in many countries the issues caused by hypoxia to the ocular surface have largely been negated. The ability of contact lenses to change the axial growth characteristics of the globe is being utilised to help reduce the myopia pandemic and several studies and meta-analyses have shown that wearing orthokeratology lenses or soft multifocal contact lenses can reduce axial length growth (and hence myopia). However, effects on blinking, ptosis, the function of Meibomian glands, fluorescein and lissamine green staining of the conjunctiva and cornea, production of lid-parallel conjunctival folds and lid wiper epitheliopathy have received less research attention. Contact lens wear produces a subclinical inflammatory response manifested by increases in the number of dendritiform cells in the conjunctiva, cornea and limbus. Papillary conjunctivitis is also a complication of all types of contact lenses. Changes to wear schedule (daily disposable from overnight wear) or lens materials (hydrogel from SiHy) can reduce papillary conjunctivitis, but the effect of such changes on dendritic cell migration needs further study. These changes may be associated with decreased comfort but confirmatory studies are needed. Contact lenses can affect the sensitivity of the ocular surface to mechanical stimulation, but whether these changes affect comfort requires further investigation. In conclusion, there have been changes to lens materials, design and wear schedules over the past 20+ years that have improved their safety and seen the development of lenses that can reduce the myopia development. However, several changes to the ocular surface still occur and warrant further research effort in order to optimise the lens wearing experience.

Improved conjunctival microcirculation in diabetic retinopathy patients with MTHFR polymorphisms after Ocufolin™ Administration

PURPOSE

To investigate conjunctival microvascular responses in patients with mild diabetic retinopathy (MDR) and methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) polymorphisms (D + PM) after administration of Ocufolin™, a medical food containing 900 μg l-methylfolate (levomefolate calcium or [6S]-5-methyltetrahydrofolic acid, calcium salt), methylcobalamin, and other ingredients.

METHODS

Eight D + PM patients received Ocufolin™ for six months (6 M). Bulbar conjunctival microvasculature and microcirculation metrics, including vessel diameter (D), axial blood flow velocity (Va), cross-sectional blood flow velocity (Vs), flow rate (Q), and vessel density (VD, Dbox), were measured at baseline, 4 M, and 6 M.

RESULTS

The mean age was 54 ± 7 years. No significant demographic differences were found. Conjunctival microcirculation, measured as Va, Vs, and Q was significantly increased at 4 M and 6 M, compared to baseline. Va was 0.44 ± 0.10 mm/s, 0.58 ± 0.13 mm/s, 0.59 ± 0.13 mm/s in baseline, 4 M, and 6 M, respectively (P < 0.01). Similarly, Vs was 0.31 ± 0.07 mm/s, 0.40 ± 0.09 mm/s, 0.41 ± 0.09 mm/s in baseline, 4 M, and 6 M, respectively (P < 0.05). Q was 107.8 ± 49.4 pl/s, 178.0 ± 125.8 pl/s, 163.3 ± 85.8 mm/s in baseline, 4 M, and 6 M, respectively (P < 0.05). The VD at 6 M was significantly higher than that at baseline (P = 0.017). Changes of D were positively correlated with changes of Va, Q, and VD. Effects of MTHFR and haptoglobin polymorphisms on the improvements of conjunctival microcirculation and microvasculature were found.

CONCLUSIONS

Ocufolin™ supplementation improves conjunctival microcirculation in patients with diabetic retinopathy and common folate polymorphisms.

Conjunctival Vascular Adaptation Related to Ocular Comfort in Habitual Contact Lens Wearers

PURPOSE

We sought to investigate the bulbar conjunctival vascular responses in habitual contact lens (HCL) and non-contact lens (NCL) wearers after short-term lens wear and their relationships with ocular comfort.

DESIGN

A prospective, comparative before-and-after study.

METHODS

Twenty-seven subjects (13 HCL and 14 NCL wearers) were enrolled. Microvasculature and microcirculation on the temporal bulbar conjunctiva were imaged at baseline and 0.5 and 6 hours after wearing contact lenses (1-Day Acuvue TruEye; base curve, 8.5 mm; power, -0.50 diopters) on both eyes. The measurements included vessel diameter (D), axial (VA), and cross-sectional (VS) blood flow velocities, blood flow volume (Q), and vessel density (Dbox) and complexity (D0). A Contact Lens User Experience (CLUE) questionnaire was used to assess ocular comfort.

RESULTS

No significant change (P > .05) was observed in D, VA, VS, Q, Dbox, and D0 in the HCL wearers after contact lens wear. By contrast, VA, VS, Q, Dbox, and D0 increased significantly after lens wear (after 0.5 and 6 hours) in NCL wearers compared with baseline (P < .05). Moreover, the changes from the baseline to 0.5 hours (VA, VS, and Dbox) and 6 hours (VA, VS, Q, Dbox, and D0) after contact lens wear in NCL wearers were significantly greater than that in HCL wearers (P < .05). The CLUE score 6 hours after lens wear was higher in HCL wearers than in NCL wearers (P < .05). It was also significantly correlated with VA, VS, and D0 after 6-hour lens wear in HCL wearers (P < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study to reveal the relationship between ocular comfort and conjunctival vascular responses in habitual contact lens wearers.

The impact of contact lens wear on ocular surface mucins using a novel clinical fluorescence imaging system

PURPOSE

Fluorescein-labelled wheat germ agglutinin (F-WGA) acts as a marker for ocular surface mucins. This clinical study sought to investigate whether the degree of F-WGA fluorescence observed at the ocular surface differed between symptomatic contact lens wearers, asymptomatic contact lens wearers and non-contact lens wearers, using a novel imaging system.

METHODS

Twenty-five participants (10 symptomatic contact lens wearers, 10 asymptomatic contact lens wearers and 5 non-contact lens wearers) attended a single study visit. Photographs of the cornea, bulbar and tarsal conjunctiva were captured following application of F-WGA solution.

RESULTS

The imaging system captured high-resolution images of F-WGA fluorescence at the ocular surface. The degree of fluorescence differed between the ocular surface regions (p < 0.001). A significant difference in fluorescence was observed between participant groups for the cornea (p = 0.01), with both the symptomatic and asymptomatic contact lens wearers showing lower fluorescence than the non-lens wearers. F-WGA associated fluorescence appeared diminished in the lid wiper region of the symptomatic lens wearers, compared to the asymptomatic group (p = 0.025).

CONCLUSION

The use of F-WGA as a clinical marker for ocular surface mucins allows an improved understanding of their distribution across the ocular surface. Contact lens wear appears to negatively impact mucin density across the ocular surface, with the most marked effect on the cornea. F-WGA fluorescence appeared diminished in the lid wiper region for the symptomatic contact lens wearing group, indicating that mechanical interaction in this region may play a role in the aetiology of contact lens discomfort. Given the ability of F-WGA to disclose mucin distribution across the ocular surface it is likely to be a key clinical tool in furthering our understanding of (i) the aetiology of contact lens related discomfort, (ii) contact lens designs/materials to minimise interaction with the ocular surface and (iii) dry eye disease and other ocular surface diseases.

A review of functional slit lamp biomicroscopy

Functional slit lamp biomicroscopy (FSLB) is a novel device which consists of a traditional slit-lamp and a digital camera. It can quantitatively assess vessel diameter, blood flow velocity, and blood flow rate and can create noninvasive microvascular perfusion maps (nMPMs). At present, FSLB is mainly used in contact lens (CL) and dry eye disease (DED) studies to advance our understanding of ocular surface microcirculation. FSLB-derived blood flow and vessel density measures are significantly altered in CL wearers and DED patients compared to normal people. These subtle changes in the ocular surface microcirculation may contribute to the monitoring of potential diseases of the body and provide a new way to diagnose dry eye disease. Therefore, this may also indicate that FSLB can be more widely applied in the study of other diseases to reveal the relationship between changes in ocular surface microcirculation and systemic diseases. The purpose of this paper is to summarize the functions of FSLB and the related studies especially in CL and DED.

Inter-visit measurement variability of conjunctival vasculature and circulation in habitual contact lens wearers and non-lens wearers

Background

The inter-visit variation of measuring bulbar conjunctival microvasculature and microcirculation needs to be considered when the results from multiple visits are interpreted. This study examined the inter-visit variability of measuring conjunctival microvasculature and microcirculation in habitual contact lens (HCL) wearers and non-contact lens (NCL) wearers.

Methods

Twenty-eight subjects were recruited including 13 HCL wearers (10 females and 3 males; mean age ± standard deviation, 25.8 ± 4.6 years) who had worn contact lenses on a daily basis for at least 3 years and 15 NCL wearers (10 females and 5 males, age 25.5 ± 4.0 years) were recruited. The temporal bulbar conjunctiva was imaged using a functional slit-lamp bio-microscope (FSLB) imaging system. FSLB imaging was performed in the morning when the HCL wearers did not wear their lenses. The measurements included conjunctival vessel diameter, vessel density, blood flow velocity and flow volume. In addition, conjunctival microvasculature was analyzed using monofractal (Dbox, representing vessel density) and multifractal (D0 representing vessel complexity) analyses. The repeated measurement was conducted at least one week after the first visit and both eyes of each participant were imaged. The coefficient of variation (CV) was calculated as the standard deviation of the differences between test and re-test then divided by the mean of the measurements. The intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) was also calculated.

Results

No significant differences of all vascular measurements in both the right and left eyes were found between two groups (P > 0.05). Between two measurements on two different visits, the CV was from 2.4% (vessel density D0) to 63.5% (blood flow volume Q) in HCL wearers and from 3.4% (D0) to 40.6% (blood flow volume) in NCL wearers. The ICC was from 0.60 (vessel diameter) to 0.81 (axial blood flow velocity VA) in HCL wearers and from 0.44 (Q) to 0.68 (cross-sectional blood flow velocity VS) in NCL wearers.

Conclusions

The measurement variability of the vessel density of the bulbar conjunctiva appeared to have the smallest inter-visit variation. The measurement variability of the vasculature and circulation in HCL wearers were similar to that in NCL wearers.

Quantitative analysis of conjunctival microvasculature imaged using optical coherence tomography angiography

Background

The goal was to quantitatively analyze the bulbar conjunctival microvascular density using optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) and compare it to the vessel density using functional slit-lamp biomicroscopy (FSLB).

Methods

Temporal bulbar conjunctiva of 20 eyes (10 healthy subjects) was imaged using both OCTA and FSLB. Image processing was performed including equalization, de-noising, thresholding, and skeletonization. The vessel density was measured by fractal analysis (box counting, Dbox) and pixel counting (%).

Results

Vessel density (Dbox) of the bulbar conjunctiva obtained using OCTA was 1.28 ± 0.01 Dbox, which was significantly lower than the result (1.32 ± 0.01 Dbox, P < 0.001) obtained using FSLB. Furthermore, the vessel density (%) obtained using OCTA was 3.31 ± 0.12%, which was also significantly lower than the result (3.69 ± 0.16%, P < 0.001) obtained using FSLB. No significant correlations (r ranged from 0.21 to 0.32, P > 0.05) between both instruments were found in both vessel density methods (Dbox and percentage). However, in each of the devices, vessel density in Dbox was significantly correlated with the vessel density in percentage (r = 1.0 for FSLB and r = 0.98 for OCTA, both P < 0.001).

Conclusion

This study demonstrated that the vessel density of the bulbar conjunctiva obtained using OCTA can be quantified, and the results were not compatible with that obtained using slit-lamp biomicroscopy photography.

Factors Affecting Microvascular Responses in the Bulbar Conjunctiva in Habitual Contact Lens Wearers

Purpose

To investigate the factors affecting microvascular responses in the bulbar conjunctiva of habitual contact lens (HCL) wearers.

Methods

A functional slit-lamp biomicroscope (FSLB) was used to image the temporal bulbar conjunctiva of habitual contact lens (HCL) wearers and non-contact lens (NCL) wearers. The vessel diameters and blood flow velocities (BFVs) were measured. Fractal analysis using Dbox as vessel density and D0 as vessel complexity were used to quantitatively analyze the microvascular network. One eye each of 91 NCL wearers and 75 HCL wearers was imaged.

Results

The BFV of NCL wearers was 0.50 ± 0.14 mm/s, which was negatively correlated with age (r = -0.22, P < 0.05). The BFV, vessel diameter, Dbox, and D0 of HCL wearers was significantly higher than NCL wearers (P < 0.05). In these HCL wearers, BFVs were positively correlated with contact lens (CL) hours of wear per day and CL days of wear per week. BFV, Dbox, and D0 were not related to CL years of wear, CL power, CL base curve, and CL diameter (P > 0.05).

Conclusions

Vascular responses on the bulbar conjunctiva occurred in HCL wearers and appeared to be unrelated to sex or age, CL years of wear, and lens parameters, indicating that wearing a CL itself may be the predominant factor inducing these responses.

Contact lens wear and dry eyes: challenges and solutions

The number of contact lens wearers worldwide has remained relatively stable over the past decade, despite the investment that has gone into contact lens technology. This is largely because 10%-50% of wearers dropout of contact lens wear within 3 years of commencement; the most common reason cited being contact lens discomfort (CLD). Of the symptoms reported, sensation of dry eye is the most common. Given the outcome of reduced wearing time, increased chair time, and ultimate contact lens discontinuation, the challenge is to identify the warning signs of CLD early on. Clinically detectable changes such as conjunctival staining, conjunctival indentation, conjunctival epithelial flap formation, lid wiper epitheliopathy, Demodex blepharitis, and meibomian gland dysfunction have been linked to CLD, highlighting the need to perform regular aftercare visits to identify these changes. At a cellular level, conjunctival metaplasia and reduced goblet cell density have been linked to CLD, leading to a downstream effect on the tear film breakup time of contact lens wearers. These factors suggest a strong link between CLD and friction, raising the need to target this as a means of minimizing CLD. The purpose of this review is to identify the clinical signs that relate to CLD as a means of earlier detection and management in order to combat contact lens dropout.