Butterfly cartilage tympanoplasty outcomes: A single-institution experience and literature review

Butterfly Cartilage Inlay Technique for Repairing Medium-to-Large-Sized Tympanic Membrane Perforations

OBJECTIVE

The butterfly cartilage inlay technique was originally developed for repairing small tympanic membrane (TM) perforations but is now increasingly used for repairing large TM perforations. Although studies have evaluated the effectiveness of butterfly tympanoplasty for repairing medium-to-large-sized TM perforations, no study has compared its effectiveness with that of the conventional underlay cartilage technique. Therefore, we aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of butterfly tympanoplasty for repairing medium-to-large-sized TM perforations compared with that of the conventional underlay cartilage.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective chart review.

SETTING

This retrospective study analyzed patients treated for medium-to-large-sized TM perforations at a tertiary medical center between January 2017 and July 2024.

METHODS

We compared the outcomes of butterfly cartilage tympanoplasty with those of the conventional underlay technique, focusing on graft success rate, postoperative hearing outcomes, perioperative complications, and operating time. TM perforation sizes were precisely measured using the ImageJ software.

RESULTS

Among a total of 52 patients, 28 underwent butterfly tympanoplasty and 24 underwent underlay tympanoplasty. Both techniques showed comparable graft success rates (butterfly technique, 92.9%; underlay technique, 83.3%) and minimal perioperative complications. The butterfly technique had a significantly shorter operating time compared with that of underlay tympanoplasty and was performed under local anesthesia. Both groups showed a significant postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) reduction, with no significant difference in the ABG improvement.

CONCLUSION

The butterfly technique is effective for medium-to-large-sized TM perforations, offering comparable outcomes to the conventional underlay technique, with the advantages of reduced operating time and the use of only local anesthesia.

Endoscopic butterfly cartilage myringoplasty: our long term results

BACKGROUND

Myringoplasty is one of the treatments used for perforated tympanic membrane.

AIM/OBJECTIVE

We aimed to evaluate the long-term anatomical and functional outcomes of patients who underwent endoscopic inlay butterfly cartilage myringoplasty.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed 74 patients who had undergone endoscopic butterfly cartilage myringoplasty were followed for at least five years. The evaluation included age, sex, duration of follow-up, perforation location, size, preoperative and postoperative pure tone audiometry thresholds (years 2 and 5), air-bone gap, follow-up complications, and postoperative graft and tympanic membrane status.

RESULTS

The study included 74 patients with a mean follow-up duration of 76.7 months (range: 60-125 months). The graft success rates were 89.1% at two years and 82.4% at five years postoperatively. There was a significant improvement in air conduction thresholds when comparing preoperative levels to those at two and five years postoperatively (p = 0.003). The air-bone gap showed a significant reduction from preoperative levels to those observed at two and five years postoperatively (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSION AND SIGNIFICANCE

Our study demonstrates that endoscopic butterfly cartilage myringoplasty is safe and effective for achieving long-term anatomical and functional success. We recommend extending the follow-up period to five years with additional annual assessments thereafter.

Outcomes of endoscopic modified cartilage-perichondrium tympanoplasty on different sized perforations

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the anatomic and functional outcomes of type1 tympanoplasty with endoscopic modified butterfly cartilage-perichondrium technique.

METHODS

In our modification, perichondrium was elevated circumferentially till the attached part of the composite graft was approximately same size and shape of the perforation, cartilage was trimmed based on the perforation but 0.5 mm larger. Cartilage portion of the graft was placed medial to the edge of the perforation, then perichondrium was rolled out and draped on the circumferential raw surface of remaining tympanic membrane around.

RESULTS

At 4 months postop, the anatomic integrity rate of the tympanic membrane perforation for small & medium sized perforation and large sized perforation group were 100 % and 94 % (p > 0.05). For the small & medium perforation group, the mean pre and 4 months postop ACs were 30 ± 8 dB and 18 ± 6.4 dB (p < 0.01). The mean pre and 4 months postop ABGs were 19 ± 11 dB and 9 ± 3 dB (p < 0.01). For the large perforation group, the mean pre and 4 months postop ACs were 43 ± 12.5 dB and 21.5 ± 7 dB (p < 0.01). The mean pre and 4 months postop ABGs were 34 ± 8.5 dB and 12.5 ± 6 dB (p < 0.01). The differences of mean 4 months postop ACs and mean 4 months postop ABGs between the two groups were not significant (p > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Compared to the conventional inlay butterfly cartilage tympanoplasty technique, large or marginal perforations can be sealed more securely by this modification.

Comparison of the Extended Perichondrium-Cartilage Butterfly Inlay Technique and Over-Underlay Technique for Repairing Subtotal Perforation: A 2-Year Follow-up Study

OBJECTIVE

To compare graft outcomes and postoperative complications between the extended perichondrium-cartilage butterfly inlay (PCBI) technique and the perichondrium-cartilage over-underlay (PCOU) technique for repairing subtotal perforations over a 2-year follow-up period.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Patients with subtotal perforations were prospectively randomized to either the extended PCBI (n = 52) or PCOU (n = 51) group. Evaluation metrics included operation time, graft success rate, hearing gain, and complications at 24 months postoperatively.

RESULTS

The study included 103 patients with 103 ears. Follow-up loss occurred in 11 of 52 patients (21.2%) in the PCBI group and 13 of 51 patients (25.5%) in the PCOU group (P = .773). The final analysis included 41 of 52 patients (78.9%) in the PCBI group and 38 of 51 patients (74.5%) in the PCOU group. The average operation time was significantly shorter in the PCBI group (31.2 ± 1.9 min) compared to the PCOU group (52.8 ± 6.3 min, P < .001). At 24 months postoperatively, the graft success rate was 82.9% (34 patients) in the PCBI group and 92.1% (35 patients) in the PCOU group (P = .374). No significant group difference was noted in mean air-bone gap (ABG) gain (P = .759). High-resolution computed tomography (HRCT) demonstrated well-pneumatized mastoids and middle ears in both groups. Altered taste was reported in no PCBI group patients and 23.7% (9 patients) of the PCOU group patients (P < .05). Graft cholesteatoma was found in 4.9% (two patients) in the PCBI group and 7.9% (three patients) in the PCOU group (P = .930).

CONCLUSION

The endoscopic extended PCBI technique is safe and effective for repairing subtotal perforation. It avoids raising a tympanomeatal flap and demonstrates high long-term graft success with minimal complications.

Influence of the Size and Location of the Perforation on the Anatomical Results of Myringoplasty

INTRODUCTION

Type 1 tympanoplasty (myringoplasty) is the surgical closure of a perforated eardrum. Its purpose is to restore the integrity of the tympanic membrane and to improve hearing in the affected ear. Nowadays, we note the increasing use of cartilage as material for the reconstruction of the tympanic membrane. The main objective of our study is to evaluate the influence of size and perforation site on the results of type 1 tympanoplasties performed in our department.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

 We carried out a retrospective study of a series of myringoplasties spread over a period of four years and five months from January 1, 2017, to May 31, 2021. For every patient, we collected data regarding age, sex, perforation size, location, and closure of the tympanic membrane after myringoplasty. The audiological results for air conduction (AC) and bone conduction (BC), as well as air-bone gap reduction following surgery, were noted. Follow-up audiograms were performed at the following intervals: two months, four months, and eight months postoperatively. The frequencies tested included 250, 500, 1000, 2000, and 4000 Hz. Similarly, the air-bone gap was estimated on the mean of all frequencies. A chi-squared test and Mann-Whitney test were used to compare qualitative and quantitative variables, respectively.

RESULTS

A total of 123 myringoplasties were included in this study. Closure of the tympanic membrane was achieved successfully in 85.7% for one-quadrant-size perforations (24 cases), and in 76.2% for two-quadrant-size perforations (16 cases). When 50-75% of the tympanic membrane was absent at the time of diagnosis, full repairment was achieved in 89.6% of the patients (n = 24), and in 85.0% (n = 34) when the perforation was subtotal. Recurrences have not happened more significantly for one location of the tympanic defect compared to another. Indeed, failures for anterior quadrant perforations were 14 whereas other sites represented 19 cases of non-integrated grafts. The audition was significantly improved from pre-operatively (AC mean of 48.7 dBs with ranges from 24 to 90 dBs) to post-operatively (30.7 dBs AC with ranges from 10-80 dBs) (p = 0,002). The average postoperative audiometric Rinne was 18 dBs with a gain of 15.37 dBs.

DISCUSSION

Patients with bilateral perforations (tubal dysfunction, allergic rhinitis) are more likely to develop recurrences. Thus, the series considering many patients operated on twice has high failure rates. Good compliance with anti-allergic treatment and with hygiene rules (in particular ear sealing) is essential for the closure of anterior perforations.

CONCLUSION

 It seems through our study that there is no correlation between the size and location of the perforation and its postoperative closure. Risk factors such as smoking, anemia, intraoperative bleeding, and gastroesophageal reflux are important and determining in the healing process.

Comparison between endoscopic and microscopic butterfly cartilage graft inlay tympanoplasty: a systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to compare the effectiveness of endoscopic and microscopic approaches for butterfly cartilage graft inlay tympanoplasty regarding anatomical and hearing outcomes through a systematic review and meta-analysis.

METHODS

A search of PubMed, Embase, MEDLINE, and Virtual Health Library was performed from inception to July 3rd, 2021, using keywords, such as tympanoplasty, cartilage graft, and inlay technique. Data from articles that met inclusion criteria were extracted by two authors independently. The PRISMA statement was followed. RoB-2 and ROBINS-I tools were used to assess risk of bias. The primary outcome was tympanic membrane closure rate. The secondary outcome was improvement of the air-bone gap.

RESULTS

Five studies were included, one randomized clinical trial and four retrospective cohorts, in which a total of 318 patients were included. Graft take rate was 91.3% in the endoscopic group and 93.6% in the microscopic group (RR 0.98; 95% CI 0.93-1.03; I² 0%; P = 0.68). Four studies provided data about the secondary outcome, all showing significant reductions in air-bone gap, ranging from 5.7 to 11.0 in the endoscope group and from 5.8 to 11.6 in the microscope group, with a mean difference between groups of 0.85 (95% CI - 0.79 to 2.48).

CONCLUSION

Although the overall evidence of the included studies was low, endoscopic and microscopic butterfly cartilage graft inlay tympanoplasties have similar results on anatomical and hearing outcomes, making the selection between such approaches an individual choice for the surgeon.

Tympanic membrane perforations: a critical analysis of 1003 ears and proposal of a new classification based on pathogenesis

PURPOSE

To present a large series ears with tympanic membrane perforations (TMP), to describe their characteristics, and to propose a new classification system based on the pathogenesis of TMP.

METHODS

This cross-sectional study was conducted at a tertiary university hospital with 1003 ears (792 consecutive patients with TMP in at least 1 ear). Otoendoscopy and audiometry were performed. Perforation measurements and their locations were digitally assessed. TMP with no suggestive signs of previous retraction were classified as Group 1, and those with possible previous retraction were classified as Group 2. Signs of retraction previous to the TMP, symptom length, perforation size and location, status of the contralateral ear, and hearing status were compared.

RESULTS

Group 1 comprised 63.5% of the included ears. Compared to Group 2, Group 1 presented a higher rate of central perforations (99% vs. 53%), a shorter duration of symptoms, smaller perforations (mean area: 18.5% vs. 41.4%), a higher rate of perforations in the anterior quadrants, better hearing levels (mean tritonal gap: 23.9 dB vs. 29.2 dB), and a lower rate of abnormal contralateral ears (28% vs. 66%).

CONCLUSION

The classification of TMP into two groups based on signs of previous retractions is feasible and indicates two different levels of disease severity. While the group without previous signs of retraction comprises ears with more limited disease, membranes with previous retraction seem to show more severe disease and, consequently, a less functional middle ear.

Effect of middle ear gelfoam on hearing and healing process after tympanoplasty: A prospective randomized case-control study

PURPOSE

This prospective randomized case-control study was performed to compare the surgical outcomes of our swing-door overlay tympanoplasty with or without absorbable gelatine sponge (AGS, gelfoam) packing in the middle ear cavity, according to the surgical procedure.

METHODS

Fifty-seven patients who underwent swing-door overlay tympanoplasty by a single surgeon were enrolled in the study. The data of 30 patients of the gelfoam-packing group (GPG) and 27 patients of the non-gelfoam-packing group (NGPG) were prospectively collected and compared.

RESULTS

Closure of the tympanic membrane was found to be successful in all patients at postoperative 3 months evaluation. NGPG showed a statistically better healing process compared to GPG; earlier epithelialization and less fascia edema in NGPG than in GPG (P < 0.05). The air-bone gap (ABG) measured at postoperative 1 and 2 months was smaller in NGPG than GPG, although there were no statistical differences.

CONCLUSION

This study revealed earlier healing process and faster recovery of ABG in NGPG, thereby indicating that the gelfoam in the middle ear may interfere with both hearing recovery and the healing process of neodrum.

Myringoplasty without tympanomeatal flap elevation in children: A systematic review

OBJECTIVES

Systematic review of the literature on myringoplasty techniques without tympanomeatal flap elevation in children.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A systematic review following PRISMA guidelines reported papers on patients under 18years of age undergoing myringoplasty for chronic tympanic perforation on a transcanal approach without tympanomeatal flap elevation. Tympanic closure rates and audiometric results were analyzed.

RESULTS

Twenty studies were included. Nine reported the butterfly technique, using a microscope or endoscope, with closure rate of 82.3% (246/299), for perforations of various sizes. Ten reported the fat-plug technique, with closure rate of 86.8% (869/1001), mostly for perforations of less than one-third of the tympanum. Both techniques improved audiometric results. Morbidity was very low. The absence of chronic otitis or co-morbidities (contralateral otitis media with effusion, craniofacial malformations, Down's syndrome) implies that patient selection technique may be necessary to obtain the best results.

CONCLUSION

Fat-plug myringoplasty, for small perforations, and butterfly cartilage myringoplasty seem to be reliable procedures in selected patients, with low morbidity in children.

Evaluating butterfly inlay tympanoplasty

OBJECTIVE

To compare closure rate, reduction in air-bone-gap, and operative time of butterfly tympanoplasty (BT) to underlay tympanoplasty (UT).

METHODS

Retrospective cohort study of children (age <18y) undergoing Type I tympanoplasty between 2009 and 2017. Patients were excluded if they had <6 months of follow up, mastoidectomy, fat graft or cholesteatoma.

RESULTS

Twenty-one patients (mean age 13.4) underwent BT while forty-one patients (mean age 13.5) underwent UT. The mean size of perforation in 30.6% in BT patients and 43.6% in UT patients (p = 0.01). Preoperative audiogram showed a similar air-bone-gap between the two groups of 31.7, 22.7, and 17.9 dB in BT vs 29.6, 24.8, and 17.6 dB in UT at 500, 1000, and 2000 Hz, respectively (p = 0.65, 0.63, and 0.94). Operative time was reduced in BT as compared to UT (94.0 min vs. 150.9, p = 0.01). Closure rate was similar at 85.7% in BT vs 75.6% in UT patients (p = 0.40). Average reductions in air-bone gap were similar with 19.2, 11.7, and 13.2 dB for BT vs 16.6, 12.1, and 10.3 dB for UT at 500, 1000, and 2000 hz, respectively (p = 0.66, 0.93, 0.40).

CONCLUSION

BT has become a reliable tool for the pediatric otolaryngologist. This retrospective study shows that pediatric BT results in similar outcomes with reduced operative time.

Transcanal endoscopic type 1 tympanoplasty in children: Cartilage butterfly and fascia temporalis graft

INTRODUCTION

Endoscopic type 1 tympanoplasty is every day gaining numerous adepts for tympanic membrane repair. Due to the value of reducing postauricular approaches, decreasing postoperative morbidity and hospitalization time. The objective of this study is to present surgical results of endoscopic type 1 tympanoplasty in the pediatric population using fascia temporalis or cartilage butterfly graft.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Prospective study regarding the pediatric population, mean age of 10.7 years old. Patients diagnosed with chronic otitis media without cholesteatoma and intact ossicular chain. Tympanic membrane reconstruction using inlay cartilage butterfly graft or underlay fascia temporalis graft according to surgical needs. Audiograms were evaluated preoperatively and 6 months after surgery. No postauricular approaches were performed.

RESULTS

A total of 54 ears were operated, 25 utilizing underlay fascia temporalis graft and 29 using inlay cartilage butterfly graft. Six months following surgery, dry and closed tympanic membranes were obtained in 54 cases (92.6%). Preoperative and postoperative air conduction (AC) thresholds, bone conduction (BC) thresholds and air-bone gaps (ABG) were assessed. Preoperative AC of 24.6 dB, BC of 8.9 dB and an ABG of 15.5 dB. Postoperative AC of 16.3 dB, BC of 8.9 and an ABG of 6.9 dB. A postoperative ABG reduction of 8.5 dB was reached.

CONCLUSION

Transcanal endoscopic type 1 tympanoplasty can be achieved in every pediatric patient with chronic otitis media without cholesteatoma, and, is a safe and efficient procedure.

The Effect of Nitrous Oxide on the Outcomes of Underlay Tympanoplasty: A Prospective Study

The main aims of tympanoplasty are eradication of chronic middle ear disease, repair of the tympanic membrane, and restoration of hearing. Nitrous oxide (N₂O) is not a commonly preferred anesthetic agent for tympanoplasty because this agent may increase middle ear pressure and displace the graft. In this study, we researched the surgical outcomes of the underlay tympanoplasty performed with N₂O anesthesia. Patients who underwent tympanoplasty were included in this prospective study. A type 1 tympanoplasty was performed in all patients using the underlay technique. Patients were randomized to groups that did and did not receive N₂O. Preoperative and postoperative hearing thresholds were evaluated, postoperative pain scores were recorded, and the differences between the groups were statistically evaluated. There were 44 patients who received N₂O and 44 who did not. The graft success rate was 93.2% in the N₂O-receiving group and 84.1% in the nonreceiving group (P > .05). Hearing levels improved significantly after surgery in each group (P < .05), but the difference between the groups was not significant (P > .05). The postoperative pain score was 3.72 ± 1.3 in the N₂O-receiving group and 4.45 ± 2.3 in the nonreceiving group (P > .05). Nitrous oxide is a cheap, safe, and readily available anesthetic agent that provides acceptable success rates in patients undergoing tympanoplasty.

Can Endoscopic Tympanoplasty Be a Good Alternative to Microscopic Tympanoplasty? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Although efficacies and proportions of tympanoplasty performed via endoscopic ear surgery (EES) have gradually introduced, it remains unclear whether total EES is a good alternative to microscopic ear surgery (MES). Herein, we aimed to compare therapeutic effects of EES and MES in patients receiving tympanoplasty or myringoplasty. A search of MEDLINE, PubMed, and Embase databases was conducted to compare the efficacies of EES and MES. Two investigators independently reviewed all studies and extracted data with a standardized form. We assessed risk of bias and calculated pooled odds ratio (OR) estimates with a 95% confidence interval (CI). Thirteen studies (607 EES patients and 678 MES patients) met inclusion criteria for quantitative meta-analysis. In pooled analysis, those who undergo EES have 0.99 times the OR of graft success compared to those with MES (95% CI, 0.84 to 1.16; P=0.894). In qualitative analysis, comparable hearing improvement was observed between the two groups, despite inconsistent audiometric evaluation. The air-bone gaps (ABGs) improved 2.02 dB less in EES than in MES (mean difference of improvements of ABGs, 2.02; 95% CI, –3.84 to –0.20; P=0.029); however, substantial heterogeneity and publication bias limited the integrity of this analysis. Further, EES significantly decreased canalplasty rate, wound complications, and operation time, compared to MES. Moreover, patients receiving EES reported higher cosmetic satisfaction than patients receiving MES. EES can be a good alternative to MES in terms of comparable graft success rate and hearing outcomes in patients receiving tympanoplasty or myringoplasty. Moreover, EES was less invasive, resulting in higher cosmetic satisfaction, reduced morbidity, and shorter operation time. Our results may affect decision-making and outcome prediction in cases of EES; however, confirmation is needed to clarify potential bias.