The anatomical basis and rational for the transoral approach during the surgical excision of the sublingual salivary gland for the management of plunging ranula

An unusual clinical presentation of a plunging ranula-The plunging ranula with extension to the vallecula

Key Clinical Message

A plunging ranula may present initially as an extensive vallecular cyst and correct diagnosis may be reached with the use of ultrasound, fluid aspiration for amylase detection, and MRI imaging.

Abstract

The ranula is a pseudocyst of the sublingual salivary gland and can be divided into two known subtypes. The simple ranula and plunging ranula. While the simple type can be found in the floor of the mouth, the plunging ranula usually pervades the mylohoid muscle and presents as a cervical swelling. The presented case should outline the difficulties in diagnostic and treatment of an uncommon expression of a mucocele above the mylohoid muscle without presenting either a cervical or an intraoral swelling, only extending towards the vallecula. We present a previously unreported clinical manifestation of a ranula of an 18-year old male, which extends posteriorly, remaining confined in the supramylohyoid muscle space. The cystic lesion protrudes in the oropharynx, and clinically appears as an extensive vallecular cyst. On magnetic resonance imaging the initial suspected diagnosis of a vallecular cyst was changed to the final diagnosis of a plunging ranula. The marsupialization of the cyst sac was performed. Outpatient follow-up revealed a persisting ostium, indicating a continuous extravasation of the sublingual gland. The present case report describes an unusual clinical presentation of a plunging ranula, remaining above the mylohyoid muscle and protruding into the oropharynx, misdirecting to the first suspected diagnosis of a vallecular cyst. The case highlights the useful contribution of the MRI imaging for differential diagnoses and the need for criteria to indicate further investigations.

Diagnostic Difficulties of Plunging Ranula: A Review of 18 Cases

OBJECTIVE(S)

Despite advancements in imaging techniques and cytological analysis, plunging ranula remains a challenging surgical, radiologic, and pathologic phenomenon. Of the 18 patients we evaluated at our institution, we highlight three cases that illustrate the high rate of misleading imaging and cytological results when assessing plunging ranula.

METHODS

Imaging results, biopsy findings, operative techniques, and pathological reports were reviewed from patients who had either a preoperative or postoperative diagnosis of ranula and underwent surgery by a single head and neck surgeon at a tertiary care center.

RESULTS

Of the 18 identified patients, computed tomography was correct on preoperative imaging 73% of the time and magnetic resonance imaging was correct on preoperative imaging 71% of the time. Two patients underwent preoperative ultrasound and their ultrasound reports did not accurately diagnose the presence of a ranula. Two patients underwent preoperative fine needle aspiration biopsy due to inconclusive preoperative imaging, in which results suggested either a ranula or epidermal cyst. Both ultimately did not match the final pathology. Three of eighteen patients (17%) underwent an inappropriate initial surgery due to incorrect imaging diagnoses and/or biopsy findings.

CONCLUSION

Despite use of preoperative modalities to distinguish plunging ranula from other cystic floor of mouth lesions, surgeons must be aware that no workup modality is fully precise. The potential for revision surgery must be included in all preoperative discussions for presumed plunging ranula.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Laryngoscope, 134:2689-2696, 2024.

Surgical Treatment of Sublingual Gland Ranulas

Introduction Ranulas are divided into oral (OR) and plunging (PR) and comprise the most common pathology of the sublingual gland. This study presents a case series of patients operated due to OR and PR within different type of modalities in a 1-year period.

Objective The aim of this study is to determine the optimal surgical treatment of ranulas based on our results as well as in the literature review.

Methods The medical charts of 7 patients with sublingual gland ranulas treated in 2020 were reviewed.

Results The median age of the patients was 19. Three patients with OR were treated by marsupialization, micromarsupialization, and sublingual gland excision. Four patients with PR were operated via cervical approach in three cases and intraoral approach in one case. No recurrence was observed in 14 months of follow-up, on average.

Conclusion Micromarsupialization should be consider as the primary treatment for OR. In case of recurrent OR and primary or recurrent PR, the best results might be obtained by radical excision of the sublingual gland, which can be performed without resection of the ranula sac with the intraoral approach.

Ultrasound in the diagnosis and differential diagnosis of enoral and plunging ranula: a detailed and comparative analysis

Purpose

To develop sonographic criteria for ranula that to allow rapid and precise diagnosis, differentiation between enoral (ER) and plunging ranula (PR), and differential diagnosis from other competing pathologies in this region.

Methods

Patients who presented with or were referred with ranula between 2002 and 2022 were assessed in a retrospective study. After clinical investigation, ultrasound examinations were performed in all cases. Several sonographic parameters describing the echotexture, shape and size of ranulas, their relationship to important surrounding anatomical landmarks and the characteristic spreading pattern of ERs and PRs were elaborated and evaluated.

Results

207 ranulas were included (82.12% ERs and 17.87% PRs). The ranulas were all in close anatomical relationship to the sublingual gland (SLG) and mylohyoid muscle (MM). The echo texture was hypoechoic to anechoic in 97.6% of the lesions. In comparison with ERs, PRs were larger and irregular in shape significantly more often (P = 0.0001). There were significant differences between ERs and PRs in their exact location relative to the SLG (superficial, deep, anterior, each P = 0.0001; posterior, P = 0.03) and level of the MM (above, below, above and below, P = 0.0001 each). The exact extent and plunging pattern were depicted in all PRs, but naturally in none of the ERs.

Conclusions

The ultrasound criteria developed in this study, confirming previously published results, indicate that ultrasound is an excellent diagnostic tool for diagnosing ranula and differentiating between ERs and PRs.

Salivary Gland Disorders in Pediatric Patients: A 20 Years’ Experience

Salivary gland disorders are uncommon in children; they show a lower prevalence when compared to adults. The literature has a relative lack of information about the management and the different treatment protocols regarding these diseases. The aim of this research is to investigate the prevalence of both benign and malignant salivary gland disorders, focusing on diagnostic and therapy. An audit of patients diagnosed with salivary gland disorders was conducted from 2000 to 2020. 99 patients’ records were selected and analyzed: 51 males’ and 48 females’, age 10 ± 4 SD. Obstructive pathologies were the most frequently diagnosed (49 patients) followed by oncologic (21 patients), inflammatory (20 patients), rheumatologic (4 patients), malformative (3 patients) and infective disorders (2 patients). The parotid was the most affected major gland in 47 cases with a prevalence of diagnosis of juvenile recurrent parotitis (JRP) (40.4%), followed by the sublingual gland in 14 cases of ranula (100%) and the submandibular gland in 11 patients suffering from sialolithiasis (84.6%). Swelling was the most common symptom (75.7% of patients). Seven different neoplasms were documented. A greater prevalence of low-grade mucoepidermoid carcinoma among the malignant group (38.1% of oncologic cases) was noted. In regards to benign tumors, pleomorphic adenoma was the most common diagnosis (47.6% of cases). The symptoms and outcomes showed statistical significance concerning gender. Although salivary gland diseases in children and adolescents are rare, it is essential to observe and monitor all of the symptoms to intervene if necessary, as painless swelling is a symptom common from both benign and malignant diseases.

Transoral Complete vs Partial Excision of the Sublingual Gland for Plunging Ranula

OBJECTIVES

Plunging ranula is a pseudocyst of saliva extravasated from the sublingual gland (SLG) to the submandibular space. This is treated by transoral excision of the SLG or transcervical cyst excision that might differently affect surgical morbidity and recurrence. This study compared the clinical outcomes of complete vs partial excision of the SLG for plunging ranula.

STUDY DESIGN

A nonrandomized comparative study.

SETTING

Academic medical center.

METHODS

This study included 42 patients with plunging ranula who underwent complete or partial excision of the SLG with the evacuation of cystic content. Two surgical methods of complete or partial SLG resection were alternatively allocated to consecutive patients without randomization. The primary outcome was a postoperative recurrence. Secondary outcomes were operation time and complications.

RESULTS

Complete and partial excision of the SLG was performed in 22 and 20 patients, respectively, without injury to the Wharton's duct or the lingual nerve. Postoperative complications in 42 patients were minor with temporary events: hematoma, 1 (5%); tongue numbness, 2 (5%); dysgeusia, 4 (9%); and dysphagia, 2 (5%), which did not differ between patients with complete and partial excision of the SLG (P > .1). However, recurrence occurred in only 5 of 20 patients with partial SLG excision but none of 22 patients with complete SLG excision for a median follow-up of 36 months.

CONCLUSIONS

Complete SLG excision is preferred over partial SLG excision to treat plunging ranula for reducing postsurgical risks of complications and recurrence.