Insight et comportements violents chez les patients souffrant d’une schizophrénie

Violent behaviour in early psychosis patients: Can we identify clinical risk profiles?

AIMS

The objective of this study is to explore, within a sample of early psychosis patients (EPP), if subgroups regarding rate of violent behaviour (VB) against others can be identified on the basis of dynamic risk factors (treatment modifiable characteristics).

METHODS

In a sample of 265 EPP, treated at the Treatment and Early Intervention in Psychosis Program in Lausanne, we conducted a latent-class analysis on the basis of the main dynamic VB risk factors (substance use disorder [SUD], positive symptoms, insight, and impulsivity). VB were restricted to "serious violence" and were assessed through patients self-report, interview with relatives or forensic services and with a standardized instrument.

RESULTS

The analysis confirmed the heterogeneity of the sample regarding rate of VB. Patients could be stratified within 4 subgroups, 3 of which were at increased risk of VB. The two groups with the highest rates of VB displayed specific clinical profiles. The first one was characterized by high levels of impulsivity, hostility, positive symptoms and SUD, and the second, by low level of insight and low social functioning. These patterns suggest that significant difficulties in social interaction may contribute to the emergence of aggressive reactions against others.

CONCLUSIONS

Identification of EPP at increased risk of VB seems possible on the basis of dynamic risk factors. If confirmed prospectively, this could pave the way to the development of preventive strategies and specific interventions.

[Insight and Violent Behavior in a Cohort of Early Psychosis Patients]

OBJECTIVES:

An important proportion of patients with first episode psychosis behave in a violent, hetero-aggressive manner. This study aims to explore the association between insight and violent behavior (VB), and insight evolution in the follow-up period.

METHOD:

The study was carried out with a prospective cohort of 265 patients recruited from the early treatment and intervention for psychotic disorders program, and followed for a 3-year period. Insight assessing is based on a 3-item scale and the insight item in Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS). VBs were evaluated by case managers, information from forensic services and through a record of VBs noted during hospitalization. Univariate and multivariate logistic regression analyses, t-tests and correlations were conducted.

RESULTS:

The significant effect of insight as a factor associated with VBs that was found in univariate analyses disappears after controlling for the effect of positive symptoms, substance addiction diagnosis, impulsivity and treatment compliance.

CONCLUSION:

If patient insight in their illness develops positively during treatment, our results suggest that the risk of VBs occurring is not influenced by insight level. On the other hand, it is significantly linked to substance abuse and impulsivity, which might implicate focusing on these 2 dimensions in preventive strategies. Insight impact on VB should be further explored in more focused prospective analyses.