Factors affecting side of ovulation in heifers and mares—A comparative study

Contributions to Mare Reproduction Research by the Ginther Team

Examples of research discoveries and first reports on mare reproduction by the O.J. Ginther team are (1) determined daily circulating concentrations of four hormones during the estrous cycle, (2) showed that mares can be induced to ovulate and superovulate by hormone treatment during both ovulatory and anovulatory seasons, (3) demonstrated that prostaglandin F2α was the luteolysin in mares, (4) described the mare's elaborate hormonal and biochemical mechanism for selecting the ovulatory follicle from a pool of like follicles, (5) developed the method for diagnosing fetal sex by Day 60 using location of the genital tubercle, (6) refuted the dogma that the primary corpus luteum regresses at about one month of pregnancy, (7) demonstrated that the uterus induces luteolysis in nonpregnant mares through a systemic pathway unlike the local uteroovarian venoarterial pathway in ruminants, (8) developed the method for greatly reducing the devastating twinning problem, and (9) discovered intrauterine embryo mobility and fixation and thereby solved several enigmas in mare reproduction. During 56 years on the University of Wisconsin faculty, Ginther was sole author of seven hard cover texts and reference books. He supervised 112 graduate-students, postdoctorates, and research trainees from 17 countries. His team published 680 full-length journal papers that were cited 43,034 times according to Google Scholar. The Institute for Scientific Information ranked him among the top 1% of the world's scientists in all fields. According to a survey in 2012-23 by Expertscape, he published more scientific manuscripts than anyone on ovarian follicles, corpora lutea, and luteolysis.

Effect of the presence and location of corpus luteum on competence of bovine cumulus-oocyte complexes

This study aimed to determine the effect of presence of the corpus luteum (CL) and its influence on cumulus–oocyte complexes (COCs) obtained from the ipsilateral or contralateral ovary in bovine on the recovery and capacity of the oocytes to sustain mono-spermic fertilization, undergo preimplantation development, and develop to the blastocyst stage. Ovaries were collected at a local slaughterhouse and kept in pairs corresponding to the same animal. In the first experiment the variables evaluated were compared between cows with (CCL⁺) and without (CCL^-) CL, and for the second experiment, comparisons were made between ovaries with an ipsilateral (CL⁺), contralateral (CL⁻), and no (NCL). The recovery rate of COCs was higher in ovaries from CCL⁻ cows, and a higher proportion of grade 1 COCs were recovered from this group. A higher proportion of metaphase I oocytes at 7 h of maturation, and a higher rate of cleavage were observed in the CCL⁺ group; however, a higher proportion of embryos were obtained from the CCL⁻ group. Besides, COCs from the CL⁺ group had a lower proportion of grades 1 and 2 morphological qualities, lower rate of metaphase II oocytes at 22 h of maturation, and lower rate of formation of two pronuclei, whereas a higher proportion of unfertilized oocytes after in vitro fertilization. On the other hand, the COCs from the CL⁻ group displayed a lower proportion of oocytes with more than two pronuclei, higher cleavage rate, and higher final blastocyst production were obtained when compared to CL+. Thus, the effects of CL on the competence of bovine COCs are different depending on the anatomical proximity of their location in the animal, negatively affecting the quality of COCs located in the same ovary, but not having negative effects on the competence of COCs in the ovaries contralateral to their location.

Switching of follicle destiny so that the second largest follicle becomes dominant in monovulatory species

During an ovulatory follicular wave in the monovulatory species of heifers, mares, and women, the two largest follicles deviate in diameter at the end of a common follicle growth phase. The largest follicle before deviation becomes the future ovulatory follicle in most ovulatory waves. In 10-30% of the ovulatory waves, the destiny of the two follicles switches just before or at deviation so that the second-largest follicle becomes the future ovulatory follicle, and the largest follicle becomes a subordinate. In FSH-driven switching in heifers, mares, and women, the wave-stimulating FSH surge decreases to a low concentration before the largest follicle has developed the ability to utilize the low concentrations. The concentrations of FSH then increase (mares, women) or cease to decrease (heifers), and the next largest follicle acquires the capability of becoming the future ovulatory follicle. Luteolysis-driven switching has been reported in heifers but not in mares and women. The switching in heifers occurs during ovulatory wave 3 of three wave interovulatory intervals (IOI) when the wave of follicles is in the common growth phase in synchrony with the time of luteolysis. Regression of the CL during the common growth phase of ovulatory wave 3 is accompanied by decreased activity of follicles that are adjacent to the regressing CL but not when follicles and CL are separated or in opposite ovaries. The role of luteolysis in switching in heifers has been tested by treating with PGF2α when the largest follicle of wave 2 was near the end of the common growth phase. Switching in destiny of the largest follicle from the expected future dominant to a future subordinate occurred in most waves (10 of 17) when the largest follicle and regressing CL were in the same ovary and adjacent but not when separated in the same ovary or when in opposite ovaries (0 of 11). The newly selected future ovulatory follicle may develop in the opposite ovary. Thereby, frequency of the contralateral vs ipsilateral relationship between the preovulatory follicle and CL in heifers is greater in three-wave IOI than in two-wave IOI. In summary, the second largest predeviation follicle becomes the postdeviation dominant follicle when the decreasing FSH is out of phase with the largest predeviation follicle in heifers, mares, and women or when luteolysis and predeviation are in synchrony in heifers.

Relationships among the corpus luteum, follicles and conceptus in sheep

This study aimed to investigate the intra- and interovarian relationships among the corpus luteum (CL), the largest follicle (LF) and follicular population in non-pregnant and between the conceptus and ovarian structures in pregnant ewes. In experiment 1, the follicular and luteal structures were examined in 538 reproductive systems of non-pregnant Awassi ewes. The follicular population was categorised into small (SF), medium (MF) and large (LF) groups. Inter-relationships between CL and follicular population and between LF and subordinate follicles were determined. In experiment 2, the location and number of conceptuses were identified and correlated with the ovarian structures in 58 reproductive systems of pregnant ewes. Effects of pregnancy status, stage of pregnancy, pregnancy side and conceptual number on follicular population were determined. The results showed that the right ovary was more active than the left ovary. CL had intraovarian positive effect on the number of medium and large follicles. LF had no local suppressive effect on the subordinate follicles. Side and stage of pregnancy and the conceptual number did not affect the follicular population. Accordingly, it can be concluded that the LF has no local suppressive effect on the subordinate follicles. The CL has intraovarian positive effect on the follicular population. Follicular population does not show remarkable changes during the first term of pregnancy. The present study probably provides information which may help in the understanding of the ovarian dynamics during pregnancy in sheep.

Selection of side of ovulation by intraovarianism in Bos taurus heifers†

Intraovarianism refers to mechanisms within an ovary that affect the local follicle and luteal dynamics and is well-represented in heifers by greater frequency of ovulation from the right ovary (RO) than the left ovary (LO). On average, the RO has more 6-mm follicles than the LO before one follicle is selected to deviate in diameter and become the future ovulatory follicle. Therefore, the ovulatory follicle is more frequently selected from the RO. More follicles in the RO likely develop before birth as indicated by greater weight of the RO with more 0.3- to 4.8-mm follicles in recently born calves. It has been proposed that differences in intraovarianism between sides are a consequence of differences between sides in the inherent intraovarian angioarchitecture. The frequency of the pair of ovulations at the beginning and end of 900 interovulatory intervals (IOI) was lowest for the left/left (LL) pair (16%) and higher and similar among the RR, LR, and RL pairs (28% each). The lower frequency of LO ovulation was entirely a function of the LL pair as indicated by the lower frequency of the LL than RR pairs without a difference among the RR, LR, and RL pairs. Ovulations from the opposite sides at the beginning and end of an IOI (LR and RL pairs) would not have contributed to a difference in ovulation frequency between LO and RO. In conclusion, the greater frequency of RO (56%) than LO (44%) ovulation was mathematically and functionally a direct consequence of the low frequency of the LL pair of ovulations.

Intraovarianism and differences in ovulation frequency between left and right ovaries in Bos taurus heifers

Sides of ovulation at beginning and end of an interovulatory interval (IOI) were studied for 10 successive ovulations in each of 100 heifers (1000 ovulations, 900 IOI). The frequency of side for 1000 ovulations was less (P < 0.0002) for the left ovary (LO or L; 44.4 %) than for the right ovary (RO or R; 55.6 %). Number of observed ratios of L to R was determined within each of 100 sets of 10 ovulations per set (eg, L2 to R8, L6 to R4). Expected ratios were calculated by combinatorics using the criterion that side of ovulation was an independent event. Differences in ratios between observed and expected were significant supporting the hypothesis that side of ovulation is dependent on the side of the previous ovulation. Number of pairs of ovulations for each end of the 900 IOI was significantly less for the LL pair (144, 16.0 %) than for the pairs of RR (255, 28.3 %), LR (247, 27.5 %), and RL (254, 28.2 %). The hypothesis was supported that the frequency of the pairs of ovulations at the beginning and end of an IOI differed among LL, RR, LR, and RL pairs. Novel observations were that frequency was lowest for the LL pair and similar among the the RR, LR, and RL pairs. These observations indicated that the greater frequency of RO ovulation was mathematically and functionally related to lower frequency of LO ovulation. The interpretation was that intraovarianism in the LL pair accounted for the lower frequency of LO than RO ovulation.

Relationship between more follicles in right than left ovary in recently born calves and right ovary propensity for ovulation in cattle

The mechanism for more frequent ovulation from right ovary (RO) than left ovary (LO) was considered by determining if RO of recently born calves had a propensity for more follicles. Rationale was from reports that RO in heifers has more 6-mm follicles before selection of the future ovulatory follicle as well as greater frequency of RO ovulation. Dimensions, weight, and number of follicles per ovary were compared between LO and RO in 10 Holstein calves (age, 1 to 7 days). Weight of an ovary was greater (P < 0.05) for RO (0.393 ± 0.04 g) than LO (0.355 ± 0.05 g). Follicles were delineated by translucency of follicular fluid from transmitted light. Follicles from 0.3 mm diameter (smallest identified) to 4.8 mm (largest present) were counted. Mean number of translucent antral follicles (8.1 ± 1.8 vs 5.3 ± 1.2 follicles) and means for follicle diameter, fluid volume, and surface area were each greater (P < 0.01) for RO than LO. Combined for all diameters (0.3-4.8 mm), the hypothesis was supported that more follicles are present in RO than LO in calves 1 to 7 days of age. Although follicle activity in the fetus has not been compared between LO and RO, more follicles in RO than LO in recently born calves is consistent with the concept that the propensity for RO ovulation is congenital.

Role of intraovarian mechanisms and side of ovary on characteristics of follicle selection in Bos taurus heifers

Intraovarian effects on diameter of future dominant follicle (DF or F1) and future largest subordinate follicle (F2) during the few days before selection of the future DF and subordinate follicles were studied in 147 bovine interovulatory intervals. Follicle selection involves diameter deviation or the beginning of separation of growth rates between F1 and F2. Diameter deviation is classified as conventional (F2 ≥ 7.0 mm when F1 is 8.5 mm or at expected deviation) and as undersized (F2 < 7.0 mm when F1 is 8.5 mm). Diameter separation of F1 and F2 in conventional and undersized deviations is characteristically abrupt and gradual, respectively. The predeviation diameter of F2 when located in an ovary that later becomes the F1 intraovarian patterns of DF-CL, devoid (ovary without a DF or CL), DF alone, or CL alone and in left or right ovaries (LO, RO) was compared between conventional and undersized deviations. In conventional deviation, ovaries with the future DF (combined DF-CL and DF patterns) were associated with greater (P < 0.02) predeviation growth rate of F2 when the DF was in the right ovary (DF/RO, 1.6 ± 0.1 mm/d) than when in the left ovary (DF/LO, 1.2 ± 0.1 mm/d). The F2 was in DF/RO more frequently (75%, P < 0.002) than in non-DF/RO. When F2 was in the future devoid F1 pattern and F1 was 6 mm, F2 was smaller (P < 0.002) in the undersized class (5.3 ± 0.2 mm) than in the conventional class (6.3 ± 0.1) but not when F2 was in one of the other future F1 patterns. Only the devoid pattern was greater in frequency (P < 0.03) in the undersized class than in the conventional class. The novel hypothesis was supported that location of F2 in ovaries with different future F1 intraovarian patterns and on different sides affects the predeviation diameter and growth rate of F2 and thereby the frequencies of conventional and undersized deviations during follicle selection.