Diagnostic and reporting issues of preneoplastic polyps of the large intestine with early carcinoma

A balance of clinical assessment and use of diagnostic imaging: A CT colonography comparative case report

Computer tomography colonography (CTC) is a non-invasive procedure which has replaced barium enema. CTC uses helical images of a cleansed and gas-distended colon for the diagnosis and treatment of colonic neoplasms. This case study compares 2 patients: one with positive pathology (patient A) and another as comparator (patient B) with a similar pathology to discuss and debate possible treatment pathways. Patient (A) CTC showed 2 polyps: 6 mm and 10 mm, which the colorectal surgeons thought only needed follow-up. Our comparator (patient B) displayed a similar pathology which measured 9 mm. In this case (patient B), there was mutual agreement with the surgeons for polypectomy but without haematology involvement which was atypical of the usual pathway. The surgeons did not see the 9 mm polyp at polypectomy which could be due to observer error or radiology reporter error. Given that conventional colonoscopy is more sensitive in detecting polyps; a repeat of both tests could confirm the presence of polyp, however, the surgeons gave patient (B) a virtual appointment and requested a repeat CTC in 12 months. In colorectal medicine there can be variations in the treatment of patients with polyps. While a repeat of both tests could confirm the presence of polyp in patient (B), the surgeons' decisions regarding the patient's treatment reflected a balance of confidence in clinical assessment and use of diagnostic imaging which can reduce unnecessary requests and use of diagnostic tests.

Human fecal alpha-glucosidase activity and its relationship with gut microbiota profiles and early stages of intestinal mucosa damage

OBJECTIVES

We investigated potential relationships among initial lesions of the intestinal mucosa, fecal enzymatic activities and microbiota profiles.

METHODS

Fecal samples from 54 volunteers were collected after recruitment among individuals participating in a colorectal cancer (CRC) screening program in our region (Northern Spain) or attending for consultation due to clinical symptoms; intestinal mucosa samples were resected during colonoscopy. Enzymatic activities were determined in fecal supernatants by a semi-quantitative method. The fecal microbiota composition was determined by 16S rRNA gene-based sequencing. The results were compared between samples from clinical diagnosis groups (controls and polyps), according with the type of polyp (hyperplastic polyps or conventional adenomas) and considering the grade of dysplasia for conventional adenomas (low and high grade dysplasia).

RESULTS

High levels of α-glucosidase activity were more frequent among samples from individuals diagnosed with intestinal polyps, reaching statistical significance for conventional adenomas and for low grade dysplasia adenomas when compared to controls. Regarding the microbiota profiles, higher abundance of Christensenellaceae_R-7 group and Oscillospiraceae_UCG-002 were found in fecal samples displaying low α-glucosidase activity as compared with those with higher activity as well as in controls with respect to conventional adenomas. A relationship was evidenced among intestinal mucosal lesions, gut glucosidase activities and intestinal microbiota profiles.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings suggest a relationship among altered fecal α-glucosidase levels, the presence of intestinal mucosal lesions, which can be precursors of CRC, and shifts in defined microbial groups of the fecal microbiota.

Commensal Fecal Microbiota Profiles Associated with Initial Stages of Intestinal Mucosa Damage: A Pilot Study

Progressive intestinal mucosal damage occurs over years prior to colorectal cancer (CRC) development. The endoscopic screening of polyps and histopathological examination are used clinically to determine the risk and progression of mucosal lesions. We analyzed fecal microbiota compositions using 16S rRNA gene-based metataxonomic analyses and the levels of short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) using gas chromatography in volunteers undergoing colonoscopy and histopathological analyses to determine the microbiota shifts occurring at the early stages of intestinal mucosa alterations. The results were compared between diagnosis groups (nonpathological controls and polyps), between samples from individuals with hyperplastic polyps or conventional adenomas, and between grades of dysplasia in conventional adenomas. Some microbial taxa from the Bacillota and Euryarchaeota phyla were the most affected when comparing the diagnosis and histopathological groups. Deeper microbiota alterations were found in the conventional adenomas than in the hyperplastic polyps. The Ruminococcus torques group was enriched in both the hyperplastic polyps and conventional adenomas, whereas the family Eggerthellaceae was enriched only in the hyperplastic polyps. The abundance of Prevotellaceae, Oscillospiraceae, Methanobacteriaceae, Streptococcaceae, Christensenellaceae, Erysipelotrichaceae, and Clostridiaceae shifted in conventional adenomas depending on the grade of dysplasia, without affecting the major SCFAs. Our results suggest a reorganization of microbial consortia involved in gut fermentative processes.

Disentangling tumorigenesis-associated DNA methylation changes in colorectal tissues from those associated with ageing

Physiological ageing and tumorigenesis are both associated with epigenomic alterations in human tissue cells, the most extensively investigated of which entails de novo cytosine methylation (i.e., hypermethylation) within the CpG dinucleotides of CpG islands. Genomic regions that become hypermethylated during tumorigenesis are generally believed to overlap regions that acquire methylation in normal tissues as an effect of ageing. To define the extension of this overlap, we analysed the DNA methylomes of 48 large-bowel tissue samples taken from women of different ages during screening colonoscopy: 18 paired samples of normal and lesional tissues from donors harbouring a precancerous lesion and 12 samples of normal mucosa from tumour-free donors. Each sample was subjected to targeted, genome-wide bisulphite sequencing of ~2.5% of the genome, including all CpG islands. In terms of both its magnitude and extension along the chromatin, tumour-associated DNA hypermethylation in these regions was much more conspicuous than that observed in the normal mucosal samples from older (vs. younger) tumour-free donors. 83% of the ageing-associated hypermethylated regions (n = 2501) coincided with hypermethylated regions observed in tumour samples. However, 86% of the regions displaying hypermethylation in precancerous lesions (n = 16,772) showed no methylation changes in the ageing normal mucosa. The tumour-specificity of this latter hypermethylation was validated using published sets of data on DNA methylation in normal and neoplastic colon tissues. This extensive set of genomic regions displaying tumour-specific hypermethylation represents a rich vein of putative biomarkers for the early, non-invasive detection of colorectal tumours in women of all ages.

The spectrum of serrated colorectal lesions-new entities and unanswered questions

Hyperplastic polyps (HPs) of the colon and rectum were historically thought not to be associated with an increased risk of development of colorectal cancer (CRC). The recognition of variants of serrated colorectal lesions that possessed relatively subtle but significant morphological differences from those of HPs and that could be associated with epithelial dysplasia and CRC led to the characterisation of sessile serrated lesions (SSLs) and traditional serrated adenomas (TSAs). These links were supported by the identification of genetic alterations that are commonly found in HPs, SSLs, TSAs, and CRC, e.g. BRAF and KRAS mutations. The 'serrated pathway' to CRC may progress faster than the traditional 'adenoma-carcinoma sequence', underlining the importance of identifying these lesions. The diagnostic histological criteria for SSLs have since been more clearly defined, in parallel with a drive to increase the recognition of these lesions at endoscopy. The existence of lesions showing overlapping morphological and molecular features with those of HPs, SSLs and TSAs has most recently been highlighted-including mucin-rich TSA, serrated tubulovillous adenoma, and those showing mixed histological features, e.g. comprising differing combinations of HP, SSL, and TSA. Morphological and molecular studies of this range of lesions are providing insights into the relationships of serrated colorectal lesions with each other and with CRC. This article provides an overview of the current understanding of serrated colorectal lesions, including a discussion of those with overlapping and mixed features.

An "expressionistic" look at serrated precancerous colorectal lesions

Background

Approximately 60% of colorectal cancer (CRC) precursor lesions are the genuinely-dysplastic conventional adenomas (cADNs). The others include hyperplastic polyps (HPs), sessile serrated lesions (SSL), and traditional serrated adenomas (TSAs), subtypes of a class of lesions collectively referred to as “serrated.” Endoscopic and histologic differentiation between cADNs and serrated lesions, and between serrated lesion subtypes can be difficult.

Methods

We used in situ hybridization to verify the expression patterns in CRC precursors of 21 RNA molecules that appear to be promising differentiation markers on the basis of previous RNA sequencing studies.

Results

SSLs could be clearly differentiated from cADNs by the expression patterns of 9 of the 12 RNAs tested for this purpose (VSIG1, ANXA10, ACHE, SEMG1, AQP5, LINC00520, ZIC5/2, FOXD1, NKD1). Expression patterns of all 9 in HPs were similar to those in SSLs. Nine putatively HP-specific RNAs were also investigated, but none could be confirmed as such: most (e.g., HOXD13 and HOXB13), proved instead to be markers of the normal mucosa in the distal colon and rectum, where most HPs arise. TSAs displayed mixed staining patterns reflecting the presence of serrated and dysplastic glands in the same lesion.

Conclusions

Using a robust in situ hybridization protocol, we identified promising tissue-staining markers that, if validated in larger series of lesions, could facilitate more precise histologic classification of CRC precursors and, consequently, more tailored clinical follow-up of their carriers. Our findings should also fuel functional studies on the pathogenic significance of specific gene expression alterations in the initiation and evolution of CRC precursor subtypes.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13000-020-01064-1.

From Mixed Hyperplastic/Adenomatous Polyp to Sessile Serrated Lesion: A Long and Winding Road for Long and Winding Crypts

CONTEXT.—

During the past 3 decades, numerous articles in the literature have offered terminology, diagnostic criteria, and consensus recommendations regarding the entity currently referred to by the World Health Organization as sessile serrated lesion. Given the many names and various, variably reproducible diagnostic criteria ascribed to sessile serrated lesion, confusion persists for many pathologists and gastroenterologists regarding the diagnosis. This distinction is important, as sessile serrated lesion can progress to malignancy, unlike its main differential diagnosis, hyperplastic polyp. Research studies have shed light on the characteristic architecture and morphology, immunohistochemical patterns, and molecular alterations of sessile serrated lesion, and multiple consensus meetings around the globe have developed their criteria and nomenclature, often clashing or mixing terms.

OBJECTIVE.—

To provide a narrative review from the entity's early description to our current understanding.

DATA SOURCES.—

The existing scientific and clinical literature, published texts, medical society recommendations, and specialty consensus guidelines.

CONCLUSIONS.—

The current World Health Organization criteria are a distillation of this scientific process, but terminology is still a point of contention worldwide.

Hyperplastic polyp or sessile serrated lesion? The contribution of serial sections to reclassification

BACKGROUND

The histological discrimination of hyperplastic polyps from sessile serrated lesions can be difficult. Sessile serrated lesions and hyperplastic polyps are types of serrated polyps which confer different malignancy risks, and surveillance intervals, and are sometimes difficult to discriminate. Our aim was to reclassify previously diagnosed hyperplastic polyps as sessile serrated lesions or confirmed hyperplastic polyps, using additional serial sections.

METHODS

Clinicopathological data for all colorectal hyperplastic polyps diagnosed in 2016 and 2017 was collected. The slides were reviewed and classified as hyperplastic polyps, sessile serrated lesion, or other, using current World Health Organization criteria. Eight additional serial sections were performed for the confirmed hyperplastic polyp group and reviewed.

RESULTS

Of an initial 147 hyperplastic polyps from 93 patients, 9 (6.1%) were classified as sessile serrated lesions, 103 as hyperplastic polyps, and 35 as other. Of the 103 confirmed hyperplastic polyps, 7 (6.8%) were proximal, and 8 (7.8%) had a largest fragment size of ≥5 mm and < 10 mm. After 8 additional serial sections, 11 (10.7%) were reclassified as sessile serrated lesions. They were all less than 5 mm and represented 14.3% of proximal polyps and 10.4% of distal polyps. An average of 3.6 serial sections were required for a change in diagnosis.

CONCLUSION

Histopathological distinction between hyperplastic polyps and sessile serrated lesions remains a challenge. This study has uncovered a potential role for the use of additional serial sections in the morphological reappraisal of small hyperplastic polyps, especially when proximally located.

Incidental morphological findings in colorectal adenomas

Owing to a sharp increase in the frequency of diagnosis of colorectal adenomas in the current era of population screening, distinctive morphological features are increasingly being observed. These may present diagnostic challenges and cause clinical management issues. Paneth cell metaplasia is a more common occurrence, but the incidence rates of squamous metaplasia, clear cell metaplasia, osseous metaplasia, neuroendocrine differentiation and signet‐ring cell‐like lesion are low, and they can be seen in <1% of colorectal adenomas. Their histomorphological characteristics are quite unique; ancillary studies are not very helpful and often not needed. In this review, we give an overview and describe the potential clinical consequences of such incidental and special morphological findings in colorectal adenomas.

Gastric and small intestinal traditional serrated adenomas: a detailed morphologic and immunohistochemical analysis

BACKGROUND/AIMS

Traditional serrated adenomas (TSAs), despite their low incidence in colorectum, may originate in other parts of the gastrointestinal (GI) tract, including stomach and small intestine. Malignant transformation for upper GI TSAs has recently been reported in the literature. Here, we present a series of gastric and small intestinal TSAs with the aim to characterize their morphologic and immunophenotypic features as well as their neoplastic potential in a compartmental manner using digitalized images.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study comprised 12 GI polyps with TSA features-5 gastric and 7 small intestinal. The extent of the characteristic features of TSA, including eosinophilic cells, ectopic crypt foci (ECF), slit-like serration, foveolar epithelium, goblet cells, together with dysplastic-carcinomatous foci were assessed on digitalized H-E images and were used as reference for immunohistochemical analysis.

RESULTS

All polyps in the cohort contained eosinophilic cells as the most extensive morphologic feature followed by ECF and slit-like serration in decreasing order. Serrated dysplasia was more common in gastric polyps, which more frequently showed neoplastic progression compared with the intestinal ones. CK20 was the most widely expressed marker with a preference to eosinophilic cells while ECFs were mostly negative. Ki67 showed the opposite pattern of CK20. MUC6 and MUC2 were selectively expressed in the basal zone and goblet cells, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Our results showed that the presence of eosinophilic cells with pencillate nuclei commonly accompanied by ECF and slit-like serration are the defining features of gastric and small intestinal TSAs. They frequently harbor neoplastic foci, particularly in gastric location where serrated dysplasia seems to be more common.

Traditional serrated adenoma: an overview of pathology and emphasis on molecular pathogenesis

Objective

To provide an overview of the pathology and molecular pathogenesis of traditional serrated adenomas (TSA).

Design

Describe the morphology and molecules that play a role in their pathogenesis.

Results

These exuberant polypoid lesions are typified by tall cells with deeply eosinophilic cytoplasm, elongated nuclei bearing delicate chromatin, ectopic crypt foci, deep clefting of the lining mucosa and an overall resemblance to small bowel mucosa.

Broadly, TSAs arise via three mechanisms. They may be BRAF mutated and CpG island methylator phenotype (CIMP)-high: right sided, mediated through a microvesicular hyperplastic polyp or a sessile serrated adenoma, may also have RNF43 mutations and result in microsatellite stable (MSS) colorectal cancers (CRC). The second pathway that is mutually exclusive of the first is mediated through KRAS mutation with CIMP-low TSAs. These are left-sided TSAs, are not associated with another serrated polyp and result in MSS CRC. These TSAs also have RSPO3, RNF43 and p53 mutations together with aberrant nuclear localisation of β-catenin. Third, there is a smaller group of TSAs that are BRAF and KRAS wild type and arise by as yet unknown molecular events. All TSAs show retention of mismatch repair proteins.

Conclusion

These are characteristic unusual polyps with a complex molecular landscape.