HIV Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis in the Emergency Department: A Systematic Review

Characterizing syndemic HIV risk profiles and mHealth intervention acceptability among patients in the emergency department

Syndemic theory proposes that co-occurring, mutually reinforcing psychosocial challenges (mental health, substance use, minority stress [discrimination/stigma], abuse, unmet basic needs) drive HIV risk behavior and create barriers to care for marginalized populations. It is thus necessary to address this holistic, complex picture in HIV prevention. Emergency department (ED) visits are a prime opportunity to engage key risk groups, given their low engagement in regular clinic-based care and high utilization of drop-in care via EDs. Yet, EDs are overburdened and under-resourced; mHealth may be a vehicle for intervention delivery in this context. This study aimed to 1) characterize demographics, syndemic profiles, and HIV risk behavior among ED patients and 2) assess the acceptability of addressing syndemic issues, particularly via an mHealth approach, in the ED. A sample of N = 198 ED patients with an indication of HIV risk completed a cross-sectional psychosocial assessment. Descriptive statistics and bivariate correlations between syndemic issues were examined. Patients presenting to the ED reported marginalized identities and complex syndemic profiles including mental health issues (77%), at risk substance use (30%), childhood abuse (35%), adult abuse (31%), minority stress (63%), and unmet basic needs (37%). Over half the sample reported at least three syndemic issues (54%). All syndemic issues were significantly correlated with each other, supporting a synergistic nature. The sample reported indicators of HIV risk including lack of PrEP awareness (33%)/uptake (94%), condomless sex (37%), and not testing for HIV (41%). Majority reported syndemic profiles have never been addressed in the ED (71%), think it would be helpful (88%), and willing to utilize mHealth during an ED visit (76%). The current study provides information to guide next steps for ED-based point-of-care HIV prevention, and more broadly, working towards equitable HIV prevention services reaching those missed by existing interventions.

Feasibility and assessment of a comprehensive emergency department-based intervention for patients at risk of HIV

Behavioral factors increase the risk of contracting HIV. A comprehensive prevention services (CPS) intervention includes risk assessment and referral for those with confirmed risk. This project sought to assess the feasibility of an emergency department (ED)-based CPS program. A prospective cross-sectional assessment was conducted from October, 2021 through May, 2023, at a single ED in Birmingham, Alabama. Either of two screening methods were subjected to HIV negative adults: 1) manual chief complaint review or 2) objective electronic medical record (EMR) query. Manual and EMR screening methods considered sexually transmitted infections (STIs) or a positive urine drug test (to observe for commonly injectable drugs) within 12 months of current ED visit. Identified patients were approached in the ED (manual review) or via phone (EMR alert). Persons confirmed at risk for HIV following engagement questionnaire completion were made aware of their risk and offered referral to local CPS clinics. Primary outcome was CPS linkage. Descriptive analysis was performed. Of 184 patients approached, 147 agreed to engagement (79.9%), 117 in-person and 30 via phone; 125 (85.1%) were confirmed at risk for HIV; majority were white (66.4%), male (63.2%), between the ages of 30 and 49 (64.8%), uninsured (78.4%), and without a primary care provider (93.6%). Sexual behavior was identified as a recent (within six months) risk factor in 97 (77.6%) patients. Injection drug use was identified as a recent (within six months) risk factor in 71 (56.8%) patients. Fifty-four (43.2%) expressed interest in obtaining CPS follow-up. To-date, ten patients (18.5%) have connected with a CPS counsellor via phone and five (9.3%) have had a subsequent follow-up appointment to discuss CPS with a medical provider. Thirty at-risk patients (24.0%) received ED-initiated buprenorphine/naloxone. Targeted screening tools can aid in the identification of persons at risk for HIV in the ED; further, subsequent engagement and CPS implementation amongst this cohort is feasible. CPS clinic linkage may be challenging however, a CPS definition inclusive of ED-initiated medication for opioid use disorder, may offer opportunity for increased uptake.

Get2PrEP2-A Provider Messaging Strategy to Improve PrEP Uptake: A Randomized Controlled Quality Improvement Project

Introduction

HIV preexposure prophylaxis (PrEP), a key strategy for preventing HIV transmission, requires awareness and access to PrEP services. Although all patients should be made aware of HIV PrEP; the diagnosis of bacterial sexually transmitted infections (STIs) is an important indicator of potential HIV PrEP need. In a previous evaluation of Get2PrEP (G2P), we found that an electronic medical record laboratory comments did not increase the frequency of PrEP discussions between patients and providers. In Get2PrEP2 (G2P2), we hypothesized that active, personalized messaging to providers about HIV PrEP would increase the documentation of PrEP discussions, referrals, and/or provision of HIV PrEP to individuals diagnosed with an STI.

Methods

G2P2 was a parallel 3-arm, unblinded, randomized controlled design. Participants were allocated 2:1 to intervention or control. Participants in the intervention arm were further allocated to receive provider messaging through the electronic medical record chat message or e-mail.

Results

The 191 randomized encounters resulted in a modest 7.8% (odds ratio, 1.078; confidence interval, 1.02-1.13) increase in documented PrEP discussions in intervention encounters versus none in the standard care group. There was no statistical difference by intervention modality. All documented discussions occurred in the outpatient or emergency department and were more frequent in women and those aged <25 years.

Discussion

An e-mail or electronic medical record chat message sent to providers of patients testing positive for an STI had a small but significant effect on documented patient-provider PrEP discussions. Further investigation is required to determine whether provider messaging can increase PrEP uptake among eligible patients and longer-term outcomes.

A Systematic Review of HIV Pre-exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) Implementation in U.S. Emergency Departments: Patient Screening, Prescribing, and Linkage to Care

In the pursuit of ending the HIV epidemic, U.S. emergency departments (EDs) have emerged as a valuable setting to increase HIV testing and linkage to care. There is limited data available, however, describing the incorporation of HIV prevention initiatives in U.S. EDs. Over the last decade, HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) has significantly changed the HIV prevention landscape globally and very little is known about the provision of PrEP in U.S. EDs. To address this gap in the literature, we conducted a systematic review of peer-reviewed quantitative studies and conference abstracts spanning July 2012 - October 2022. Of 433 citations, 11 articles and 13 abstracts meet our inclusion criteria, representing 18 unique studies addressing PrEP screening, prescribing, and/or linkage to PrEP care.Most studies describe screening processes to identify PrEP-eligible patients (n = 17); most studies leveraged a patient's STI history as initial PrEP eligibility screening criteria. Fewer studies describe PrEP prescribing (n = 2) and/or linkage to PrEP care (n = 8).Findings from this systematic review highlight the potential for U.S. EDs to increase PrEP uptake among individuals at risk for HIV infection. Despite a growing number of studies exploring processes for incorporating PrEP into the ED setting, such studies are small-scale and time limited. Models providing prescribing PrEP in the ED show higher initiation rates than post-discharge engagement models. Electronic health record (EHR)-based HIV screening is valuable, but post-ED linkage rates are low. Our findings emphasize the need to establish best practices for initiating and supporting prevention effective PrEP use in the ED setting.

Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis Care Continuum for HIV Risk Populations: An Umbrella Review of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses

Pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) is an effective biomedical strategy for HIV prevention. This umbrella review is aimed at providing a comprehensive summary of the current status of each stage of the PrEP care cascade. A systematic literature search was conducted in PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane. Additionally, a Measurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews 2 (AMSTAR-2) tool and Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) checklist were used to evaluate their methodological and reporting quality, respectively. A total of 30 systematic reviews met the inclusion criteria. According to the results of methodological quality assessment, 3 reviews were rated as low, while 27 as critically low. Furthermore, the results of the reporting quality evaluation revealed a mean score of 23.03 for the included reviews. Across all the reviews, awareness of PrEP was generally moderate in all populations, and the acceptability was even higher compared with awareness. Unfortunately, the PrEP uptake among different groups was even less optimal, although the adherence was almost above moderate, and several barriers that hindered the utilization of PrEP were identified, and the most common are as follows: cost, stigma, lack of knowledge, mistrust, low risk perception, and more. Although PrEP has proven to be an effective prevention method to date, the promotion of PrEP failed to achieve the anticipated outcome. To reinforce the generalization of and use of PrEP, and effectively control HIV transmission, it is urgent to identify the underlying causes of low uptake rates so that efficient interventions can be implemented.

A survey with interventional components delivered on tablet devices versus usual care to increase pre-exposure prophylaxis uptake among cisgender Black women: a pilot randomized controlled trial

BACKGROUND

Cisgender (cis) Black women in the USA are more likely to become HIV positive during their lifetime than other women. We developed and implemented a behavioral intervention, Increasing PrEP (iPrEP), the first pilot randomized controlled trial (RCT) aimed at motivating cis Black women to be willing to use PrEP for HIV prevention and attend an initial PrEP clinic visit following an emergency department visit.

METHODS

Eligible participants were Black cisgender women ages 18-55 years who acknowledged recent condomless sex and substance use. Participants were randomized to iPrEP or usual care (UC). iPrEP is a survey-based intervention designed to raise awareness and knowledge about PrEP. Participants completed an assessment of knowledge of and willingness to use PrEP before and after the intervention, then received a warm-hand off with referral to a local PrEP clinic. Enrolled participants were followed for 6 months.

RESULTS

Forty enrolled participants were ages 18-54 years. Education levels varied evenly between some high school education and graduate education. Most participants were single (n = 25) or married (n = 7). Twenty-two participants were employed full-time. Pre-test results indicated that 21 of 40 participants had heard of PrEP. All participants identified PrEP as a daily HIV prevention medication. For those randomized to iPrEP, the odds of knowing about PrEP at post-test, when controlling for baseline, were higher relative to UC (OR = 5.22, 95%CrI = 0.50, 94.1]. iPrEP did not have any effect on willingness relative to UC. The estimate for iPrEP on willingness is marginally higher (4.16 vs. 4.04; i.e., 0.12 points higher); however, the posterior probability of 67.9% does not suggest a strong degree of evidence in favor of an effect. During the post-test, those receiving iPrEP were less ready to take PrEP than those receiving UC.

CONCLUSIONS

Findings suggest that iPrEP increased knowledge about the PrEP medication but had a negative impact on readiness to take PrEP relative to UC. It is imperative that future research among cisgender Black women carefully considers the content provided in interventions designed to increase PrEP use, balancing the benefits of PrEP with the side effects and daily pill burden.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

clinicaltrial.gov Identifier: NCT03930654, 29/04/2019.