Investigations on TDCR measurements with the HIDEX 300 SL using a free parameter model

Development of a TDCR counting system with anti-coincidence detectors

When employing the TDCR method for standardization of low-activity liquid scintillation samples, fluctuations in system background can significantly impact both measurement uncertainties and minimum detectable activity (MDA). To mitigate this impact, a TDCR counting system with anti-coincidence detectors was developed. By analyzing the time difference distribution spectrum between the anti-coincidence channel and β channel, optimal parameters for the anti-coincidence module are determined. The objective of the study is to enhance the effectiveness of the anti-coincidence technique while minimizing the removal of real events. Finally, two sets of 3H and 14C samples with known activities of around 1 Bq are prepared via dilution to validate the performance of the system. Compared to without anti-coincidence, the background has been reduced by nearly 84%, leading to decreased fluctuations in the activity results.

Test of a digitizer to process the pulse signal from the 3 photomultiplier tubes of a TDCR liquid scintillation counter

The BIPM is developing a new service for international key comparisons in radionuclide metrology. The system, called ESIR, is based on a liquid scintillation counter using the Triple-to-Double Coincidence Ratio (TDCR) technique. The aim is to produce an international reference that can be reproduced over several decades of time in order to compare the calibration capabilities of National Metrology Institutes (NMIs). The maintainability of the electronics performing the signal processing is a challenge. To ensure the long-term sustainability of the electronics, the strategy is to set up redundant systems including at least one digital electronics module. The analogue modules developed in the 1990s and 2000s are less and less maintained and digital electronics are increasingly available on the market. In this context, a digitizer was tested and its suitability for the TDCR measurements compared to the currently used module based on an analogue front-end. This first implementation directly linking the photomultiplier anode to the CAEN digitizer without any analogue preconditioning shows a significant loss of detection efficiency and a lower signal to noise ratio observed on distributions of single photoelectrons. Although the TDCR method can correct for these efficiency losses, the loss of symmetry between the channels is too great to provide a sufficiently robust measurement. The use of low-pass filters upstream of the ADC will be considered to make this digital measurement system more reliable.

TRITIUM ANALYSIS IN URINE BY THE TRIPLE-TO-DOUBLE COINCIDENCE RATIO METHOD WITH THE HIDEX 300 SL LIQUID SCINTILLATION COUNTER

The triple-to-double coincidence ratio (TDCR) method is a liquid scintillation primary method for the absolute activity measurement of pure β- and pure electron capture emitters. This method requires specific three-photomultiplier liquid scintillation counters. The aim of the present work is to assess the TDCR method performance for routine tritium analysis in urine using an HIDEX 300 SL, the only three-photomultiplier liquid scintillation counter designed for routine laboratories. The physical parameters and the semi-empirical Birks parameter (kB) of the prepared liquid scintillation source were firstly determined. TDCR model equations solving and detection efficiencies calculations for measured samples were performed by TDCR07c computing program. Accuracy, uncertainties and detection limit of TDCR method were assessed through the tritium analysis of six intercomparison urine samples. The results demonstrate that the analytical performance of the TDCR method implemented on the HIDEX 300 SL is conform to the recommendations for the monitoring of workers exposed to tritium.

Comparison of (14)C liquid scintillation counting at NIST and NRC Canada

An informal bilateral comparison of (14)C liquid scintillation (LS) counting at the National Research Council of Canada (NRC) and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has been completed. Two solutions, one containing (14)C-labeled sodium benzoate and one containing (14)C-labeled n-hexadecane, were measured at both laboratories. Despite observed LS cocktail instabilities, the two laboratories achieved accord in their standardizations of both solutions. At the conclusion of the comparison, the beta spectrum used for efficiency calculations was identified as inadequate and the data were reanalyzed with different inputs, improving accord.

Set-up of a new TDCR counter at IRA-METAS

A triple-to-double coincidence ratio (TDCR) counter was recently constructed at IRA-METAS for liquid scintillation based primary activity standardisations. A description of its optical chamber, efficiency change tools, photomultiplier tubes (PMTs) and electronics is given. This TDCR system was validated by measuring several standard solutions of beta emitters including (45)Ca, (14)C, (63)Ni and (3)H. The activity concentrations, obtained from these measurements and efficiencies computed with a FORTRAN code we developed for symmetric and asymmetric PMTs, agree with the certified values within uncertainties.

Activity determination of (59)Fe

Iron-59 was measured in three commercial and two custom-built liquid scintillation counters. The counting efficiencies were determined using CIEMAT/NIST efficiency tracing and the triple-to-double coincidence ratio (TDCR) method, respectively. The efficiency computation for the TDCR method was realized by means of the MICELLE2 program, applying a stochastic model for the computation of electron emission spectra. The program was extended to make calculations of spectra originating from complex decay schemes possible. In addition, a new parameterization of electron stopping powers for 10 commercial liquid scintillation cocktails was included in the software. The activities determined with the two methods were in very good agreement; the relative standard uncertainty of the combined result was found to be 0.16%. It was used to calibrate a 4π ionization chamber at PTB for future calibrations of this isotope which is used for investigations of iron metabolism. A standardized solution was submitted to the Bureau International des Poids et Mesures (BIPM) to be measured in the ionization chambers of the International Reference System (SIR) for comparison purposes. The liquid scintillation samples were also measured in a new portable TDCR system with three channel photomultipliers. Although this system has a much lower counting efficiency, the activity was in satisfactory agreement with the conventional TDCR system. The usage of the portable TDCR system, thus, provides an important test of the free parameter model.

A prototype of a portable TDCR system at ENEA

A prototype of a portable liquid scintillation counting system based on the Triple-to-Double Coincidence Ratio (TDCR) technique was developed at ENEA-INMRI in the framework of the European Metrofission project. The new device equipped with the CAEN digitizers was tested for the activity measurements of pure β-emitters ((99)Tc and (63)Ni). The list-mode data recorded by the digitizers were analyzed by software implemented in the CERN ROOT environment, which allows the application of pulse shape discrimination using the new device.

Comparison of the TriCarb and Hidex 300 SL technique using measurements of (241)Pu and (90)Sr on various samples

Soil and radioactive slurries were analyzed for the presence of beta emitting (241)Pu and (90)Sr. The comparison study between two different LSC apparatus, TriCarb 2200/2550 and Hidex 300 SL, shows good agreement for the quench corrected (241)Pu activity concentrations. The (90)Sr activity concentrations of most soil samples were in agreement, and were confirmed by the recommended IAEA-375 value. The Hidex 300 SL is an excellent apparatus to measure pure β-emitters of routine samples.

Bilateral comparison between PTB and ENEA to check the performance of a commercial TDCR system for activity measurements

The only commercial TDCR counter from Hidex Oy (Finland), comprising three photomultiplier tubes, was tested at the two National Metrology Institutes (NMIs) PTB and ENEA. To this end, the two NMIs purchased a Hidex 300 SL TDCR counter (METRO version) each and carried out various tests at their laboratories. In addition, the two institutions agreed to organize a bilateral comparison in order to acquire information on the reproducibility of the results obtained with the counters. To achieve this, PTB prepared some (89)Sr liquid scintillation samples, which were first measured in various counters at PTB and then shipped to ENEA for comparative measurements. The aim of this paper is to summarize the findings on the counter characteristics and adjustments. In addition, the results of the bilateral comparison between PTB and ENEA are presented and the results from various commercial counters using the CIEMAT/NIST efficiency tracing and the TDCR method are discussed.

Improved Čerenkov counting techniques based on a free parameter model

In the past few years, two Čerenkov methods were developed to make activity measurements of high-energy beta emitters in liquid scintillation counters with two or three photomultiplier tubes (PMTs) possible. Both methods are based on a free parameter model and make use of the Frank and Tamm theory for the emission of Čerenkov light. In this article, additional effects are discussed and further improvements are presented. The dependence of the refractive index of water on the wavelength can now be taken into account, which has also an influence on the upper limit of the wavelength region for the production of Čerenkov light. In addition, the dependence of the PMT response on the wavelength is taken into account. Finally, it is possible to take a potential asymmetry of efficiencies in a system with three PMTs into account. To this end, three free parameters are assigned to each individual PMT and then determined by means of a downhill simplex optimization algorithm. The computed counting efficiencies for a triple-to-double coincidence ratio (TDCR) system were compared with experimental data for (32)P, (89)Sr, and (90)Y.