Ankle Proprioception Deficit Is the Strongest Factor Predicting Balance Impairment in Patients With Chronic Stroke

Ankle joint position sense acuity differences among stroke survivors at three walking ability levels: a cross-sectional study

Background

Despite the importance of lower limb sensation in walking highlighted in systematic reviews, there is limited research investigating the effect of proprioceptive deficits after stroke and any relationship with walking ability.

Objectives

With stroke survivors of different walking ability, this study aimed to (1) explore side (affected/unaffected) and movement direction (inversion/plantar flexion) effects in ankle joint position sense (JPS) acuity, and (2) compare ankle JPS acuity between groups of stroke survivors with different walking ability.

Methods

Seventy subacute stroke survivors were recruited and divided into three groups based on walking ability, as determined by their gait speed on the 10-Meter Walking Test: household (<0.4 m/s), limited community (0.4-0.8 m/s) and community (>0.8 m/s). Ankle JPS acuity was measured by the active movement extent discrimination apparatus (AMEDA).

Results

A significant difference was found between sides, with the AMEDA scores for the unaffected side significantly higher than for the affected side (F1.67 = 22.508, p < 0.001). The mean AMEDA scores for plantar flexion were significantly higher than for inversion (F1.67 = 21.366, p < 0.001). There was a significant linear increase in ankle JPS acuity with increasing walking ability among stroke survivors (F1.67 = 17.802, p < 0.001).

Conclusion

After stroke, ankle JPS acuity on the affected side was lower than the unaffected side. Stroke survivors had higher ankle JPS acuity in plantar-flexion movements, compared with inversion movements. Overall, stroke survivors with higher ankle JPS acuity tended to have higher walking ability, highlighting the importance of ankle JPS acuity in walking ability after stroke. These findings provide new insights into proprioceptive deficits after stroke and their relevance in neurorehabilitation.

Proprioception After Unilateral Stroke: Changes in the Affected and Unaffected Lower Limbs Over Time

BACKGROUND

Proprioceptive deficits are common among stroke survivors and can negatively impact their balance and postural control. However, there has been little evaluation of the change in proprioceptive deficits in the lower limbs over time after stroke. This study aimed to examine proprioceptive deficits over time after stroke in both the affected and "unaffected" lower limbs.

METHODS

This cross-sectional study included sixty first-time unilateral stroke survivors and twenty age-matched healthy individuals. Participants after stroke were divided into three subgroups based on different time points after stroke. The generally accepted clinical time points after stroke are the first 4 weeks-the acute stage; 5-24 weeks-the subacute stage; over 24 weeks-the chronic stage. The active movement extent discrimination apparatus (AMEDA) was used to quantify ankle proprioception in plantarflexion and inversion directions, on both the affected and "unaffected" sides.

RESULTS

Lower limb proprioception scores decreased linearly over time after stroke on both the affected and "unaffected" sides (p < 0.001). Overall, proprioception scores for the stroke groups were significantly lower than those for the healthy age-matched group (p < 0.01), with the only exception being ankle plantarflexion and inversion scores on the unaffected side in the acute stroke group, which were not significantly different from their healthy counterparts.

CONCLUSION

Ankle proprioception in both lower limbs decreased over time after a unilateral stroke, with proprioceptive acuity on the "unaffected" side diminishing linearly in the same way as that on the affected side. These observed continuing deficits in lower limb proprioception among stroke survivors raise implications for clinical neurorehabilitation.

The effects of trunk repositioning errors on trunk and extremity functions in stroke

AIM

The aim of this study was to analyze the TRE in three directions including forward flexion, lateral flexion to the hemiparetic side, and rotation to the hemiparetic side in patients with stroke and to compare the errors with age- and sex-matched healthy subjects. In addition, it was investigated which functional outcomes were explanatory for TRE in patients with stroke.

METHODS

Forty-one patients with subacute/chronic stroke (age 59 ± 14.5 years) and 41 healthy subjects (age 57 ± 12.8 years) were included in the study. Demographic and clinical data were collected. TREs were measured using an inclinometer. The Trunk Impairment Scale (TIS), Fugl-Meyer Assessment (FMA), Wolf Motor Function Test (WMFT), Timed Up and Go Test, and 10-m walk test (10MWT) were also used to assess trunk control, motor impairment, upper extremity function, and lower extremity function, respectively, in patients with stroke.

RESULTS

TRE scores in three directions were higher in patients with stroke than in healthy subjects (p < 0.001). TREs in three directions were significantly strongly correlated with all functional outcomes (ρ > 0.60, r < 0.001). Multiple regression analysis determined 10MWT, WMFT-Performance, TIS, and FMA-Upper Extremity as explanatory factors for TRE.

CONCLUSION

The model presented in this study could help clinicians and researchers to predict the TRE in patients with stroke. Gait speed, upper extremity motor ability, upper extremity motor impairment, and trunk control should be considered for TRE after a stroke.

Effects of Lower Limb Proprioceptive Training on Balance and Trunk Control Among the Adult Stroke Population

Background and objective Balance and trunk control are major concerns among older adults during stroke rehabilitation. Loss of proprioception in the affected limb has a greater influence on motor learning and reeducation during balance training. Available studies stress the relevance of strength and functional training in regaining balance and trunk control. Proprioception training, in addition to available rehabilitation, can optimize the balance among this population. Our study aimed to find out the effects of proprioceptive training on balance and trunk control among the chronic stroke population. Methodology Out of 45 subjects enrolled at the Indian Head Injury Foundation, New Delhi, India, 30 subjects were selected based on selection criteria and randomized into two groups using the chit method, with 15 subjects in each group. The control group received conventional training, which included a range of motion, stretching, and strengthening exercises, while the intervention group received additional proprioceptive training five days per week for four consecutive weeks. Subjects were assessed on the Berg Balance Scale and Trunk Control Test for balance and trunk control on day one and after four weeks. A paired t-test was used to analyze the difference within the groups, and unpaired t-tests were used between the groups, keeping p < 0.05 as a significance level. Results After four weeks of intervention, statistically significant improvements were seen in the balance and trunk control groups, with p < 0.05 in both groups. However, a significant improvement in balance was observed in the experimental group when compared across groups (p = 0.001), whereas no statistically significant improvement in trunk control was found (p = 0.061). Conclusion We conclude that proprioceptive training and conventional physiotherapy both help to improve balance. Proprioceptive training is better for improving balance, but it has no significant effects on trunk control. It is likely that an extended intervention time or a different form of intervention may be required to achieve substantial gains in these areas. Future research might look at other outcome measures or the impacts of other types of therapies to see which ones are most helpful at increasing trunk control.

Robot-aided assessment and associated brain lesions of impaired ankle proprioception in chronic stroke

BACKGROUND

Impaired ankle proprioception strongly predicts balance dysfunction in chronic stroke. However, only sparse data on ankle position sense and no systematic data on ankle motion sense dysfunction in stroke are available. Moreover, the lesion sites underlying impaired ankle proprioception have not been comprehensively delineated. Using robotic technology, this study quantified ankle proprioceptive deficits post-stroke and determined the associated brain lesions.

METHODS

Twelve adults with chronic stroke and 13 neurotypical adults participated. A robot passively plantarflexed a participant's ankle to two distinct positions or at two distinct velocities. Participants subsequently indicated which of the two movements was further/faster. Based on the stimulus-response data, psychometric just-noticeable-difference (JND) thresholds and intervals of uncertainty (IU) were derived as measures on proprioceptive bias and precision. To determine group differences, Welch's t-test and the Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test were performed for the JND threshold and IU, respectively. Voxel-based lesion subtraction analysis identified the brain lesions associated with observed proprioceptive deficits in adults with stroke.

RESULTS

83% of adults with stroke exhibited abnormalities in either position or motion sense, or both. JND and IU measures were significantly elevated compared to the control group (Position sense: + 77% in JND, + 148% in IU; Motion sense: +153% in JND, + 78% in IU). Adults with stroke with both impaired ankle position and motion sense had lesions in the parietal, frontal, and temporoparietal regions.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study to document the magnitude and frequency of ankle position and motion sense impairment in adults with chronic stroke. Proprioceptive dysfunction was characterized by elevated JND thresholds and increased uncertainty in perceiving ankle position/motion. Furthermore, the associated cortical lesions for impairment in both proprioceptive senses were largely overlapping.

Knee osteoarthritis patients assessed during walking for ankle inversion movement discrimination sensitivity

Background: Knee osteoarthritis (KOA) is a common musculoskeletal condition that affects dynamic balance control and increases the risk of falling during walking. However, the mechanisms underlying this are still unclear. Diminished ankle proprioception during walking has been found to be related to fear of falling in older adults, with a gender difference in incidence of falling. This study aimed to determine 1) whether ankle inversion proprioceptive acuity during walking is impaired in patients with KOA; and 2) whether there is any difference between genders. Methods: Thirty-two patients with KOA (F:M = 17:15, Median age = 52.5, BMI = 22.3 ± 3.0) and 34 healthy controls without KOA (HC) (F:M = 17:17; median age = 49.0, BMI = 22.5 ± 2.7) were recruited. In patients with KOA, ankle inversion proprioceptive acuity was measured on the affected side using the ankle inversion discrimination apparatus for walking (AIDAW), whilst HC were assessed on a randomly selected side. Two-way (2*2) analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed to determine the main effects and interaction between gender and KOA condition. Results: Two-way ANOVA showed a significant KOA main effect (F = 26.6, p < 0.001, ƞp 2 = 0.3) whereby AIDAW scores during walking for individuals with KOA were significantly lower than those without KOA (KOA vs. HC: 0.746 ± 0.057 vs. 0.807 ± 0.035). There was neither a gender main effect nor interaction (both p > 0.05). Conclusion: Individuals with KOA demonstrated lower ankle proprioception scores during walking compared to their healthy counterparts, with a similar level of impairment in ankle proprioceptive acuity between male and female patients. A low score may contribute to an increased risk of falling in the KOA population. The current findings suggest the need for global concern about lower limb proprioception in the clinical management of KOA.

Physiotherapy management focusing on proprioceptive impairment in a patient with gait and balance impairments following stroke: A case report

BACKGROUND

Proprioceptive impairment contributes to gait and balance impairments in patients with stroke. Diagnosis functional impairments and evaluation treatment efficacy require quantitative proprioception assessment. However, proprioception assessment has remained limited to ordinal scale measurement, with a lack of ratio scale measurements.

PURPOSE

This case report describes a physiotherapy management program focusing on proprioceptive impairment in patients with stroke using quantitative tests such as Threshold to Detect Passive Motion (TDPM) and Joint Position Sense (JPS).

CASE DESCRIPTION

A63-year-old male patient with an acute pontine lacunar infarction was admitted to our hospital. His muscle strength, selective movement, and trunk activity were preserved. However, the Berg Balance Scale (BBS) and Gait Assessment andIntervention Tool (GAIT) score were 42 and 9 points, observing balance impairment and the buckling knee pattern with hip ataxia during gait. Based on these, TDPM and JPS using image capture were performed. In physiotherapeuticdiagnosis, proprioceptive impairments in the hip and knee joints were the primary functional impairments related to balance and gait. To address these proprioceptive impairments, a 13-day treatment protocol incorporating transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (intensity: sensory threshold, frequency: 100 Hz) targeting the quadriceps femoris was performed.

OUTCOMES

The patient was discharged after achieving independent ambulation and improvement in BBS (56 points) and GAIT (2 points) scores, exceeding the minimum clinically important difference. Recovery of proprioceptive impairment corresponded withimproved balance and gait ability.

CONCLUSION

Quantitatively evaluating proprioceptive impairments may provide novel rehabilitation for patients with stroke who have proprioceptive impairments and contribute to clinical decision-making.

Ankle stiffness asymmetry is associated with balance function in individuals with chronic stroke

Ankle joint is one of important contributors on balance in stroke survivors. This study aimed to investigate the relationships of ankle stiffness symmetry ratios along the talocrural and subtalar axes with clinical balance measures and weight distribution during quiet standing in ambulatory chronic post-stroke survivors. The clinical trials involved 15 ambulatory elderly with chronic post-stroke hemiparesis and 15 healthy controls. Ankle stiffness was evaluated during non-weight-bearing isokinetic passive biaxial ankle movements, and ankle stiffness symmetry ratios between paretic and non-paretic ankle stiffness (SR: Inversion/Eversion SRIE & Dorsi-/Plantarflexion SRDP) were measured. A certified physiotherapist evaluated the Berg Balance Scale (BBS) and weight-distribution ratio (WDR) on bilateral force plates during quiet standing. Correlation coefficients, the factor analysis, and Pearson linear multiple regression were assessed with measured parameters. Correlation coefficients showed significances in-betweens; BBS and SRDP (r = -0.543, p = 0.022), WDR and SRIE (r = -0.667, p = 0.004), SRIE and SRDP (r = -0.604, p = 0.011). The exploratory factor analysis suggested four extracted factors; (1) Balance & Gait, (2) Stroke, (3) Symmetry and (4) Dimension. The first and second factors include general and pathological characteristics in stoke participants respectively. The third factor is associated with symmetrical characteristics explaining up to 99.9% of the variance. Multiple regression analysis showed ankle stiffness ratios predict BBS up to 60% of variance. The biaxial ankle stiffness ratio is a useful clinical variable that assesses balance function, in ambulatory chronic stroke survivors.

A Robotic Device for Measuring Human Ankle Motion Sense

Proprioceptive signals about ankle motion are essential for the control of balance and gait. However, objective, accurate methods for testing ankle motion sense in clinical settings are not established. This study presents a fast and accurate method to assess human ankle motion sense acuity. A one degree-of-freedom (DOF) robotic device was used to passively rotate the ankle under controlled conditions and applied a psychophysical forced-choice paradigm. Twenty healthy participants were recruited for study participation. Within a trial, participants experienced one of three reference velocities (10°/s, 15°/s, and 20°/s), and a smaller comparison velocity. Subsequently, they verbally indicated which of the two movements was faster. As outcome measures, a just-noticeable-difference (JND) threshold and interval of uncertainty (IU) were derived from the psychometric stimulus-response difference function for each participant. Our data show that mean JND threshold increased almost linearly from 0.53°/s at the 10°/s reference to 1.6°/s at 20°/s ( ). Perceptual uncertainty increased similarly (median IU = 0.33°/s at 10°/s and 0.97°/s at 20°/s; ). Both measures were strongly correlated ( r s = 0.70). This implies that the bias of the human ankle motion sense is approximately 5 - 8% of the experienced movement velocity. We demonstrate that this robot-aided test produces quantitative data on human ankle motion sense acuity. It provides a useful addition to the current measures of ankle proprioceptive function.

The Effects of Trunk and Extremity Functions on Activities of Daily Living, Balance, and Gait in Stroke

OBJECTIVES

The primary aim is to investigate the effect of the trunk, upper extremity, and lower extremity functions on activities of daily living (ADL), balance, and gait. The second aim is to investigate the effect of trunk position sense on trunk control.

METHODS

Thirty-six patients with chronic stroke were included in the study. The Trunk Impairment Scale (TIS), Barthel Index (BI), Berg Balance Scale (BBS), and 2-minute walking test (2MWT) were used for the assessment of trunk function, ADL, balance, and gait respectively. The Stroke Rehabilitation Assessment of Movement upper extremity (STREAM-UE) and lower extremity (STREAM-LE) sub-scales were used to evaluate extremity functions. The trunk position sense was measured with a digital inclinometer.

RESULTS

The mean age of the participants was 58.8 ± 12.6 years. In multiple regression analysis, TIS values were found to have a positive effect on BI and BBS (p < 0.05), and STREAM-LE values have a positive effect on BBS and 2MWT (p < 0.05). STREAM-UE values were no significant effect on BI, BBS, or 2MWT (p > 0.05). Trunk position sense was found to have a positive effect on TIS (p < 0.05).

DISCUSSION

The results of this study showed that trunk functions are more related to ADL and balance than extremity functions. Therefore, trunk training should be included as a basic application in physiotherapy programs for stroke patients.

Physical activity based on daily step-count in inpatient setting in stroke and traumatic brain injury patients in subacute stage: A cross-sectional observational study

BACKGROUND Daily step-count is important post-insult in the subacute phase to influence neuroplasticity, functional recovery and as a predictive factor for activity level one-year post event. OBJECTIVE Measure daily step-count in subacute patients follow-ing brain injury in an inpatient neurorehabilitation setting and compare these to evi-dence-based recommendations. METHODS 30 participants measured of daily step-count over a seven-day period, throughout the day to assess when and how activity varied. Step-counts were analyzed in sub-groups based on walking ability using the Functional Ambulation Categories (FAC). Correlations between steps-count and FAC level, walking speed, light touch, joint position sense, cognition, and fear of falling were calculated. RESULTS Median (IQR) daily steps for all patients was 2512 (568.5,4070.5). Not independently walkers took 336 (5–705), the value is below the recommendation. Participants walking with assistance took 700 (31–3080), significantly below recommended value (p = 0.002), independent walkers took 4093 (2327–5868) daily steps, significantly below recommended value (p = <  0.001). Step-count showed moderate to high and statistically-significant correlations: positive for walking speed, joint position sense, negative for fear of falling, and number of medications. CONCLUSIONS Only 10% of all participants reached the recommended daily steps. Interdisciplinary team-work and strategies to increase daily activity between therapies may be crucial to achieve recommended step-levels in subacute inpatient settings.

Influence of proprioceptive training based on ankle-foot robot on improving lower limbs function in patients after a stroke

Background

Proprioception is important for our everyday activity, as it indicates the position, movement, and force on the body. This is important not only for ambulation but also for patients who are diagnosed with stroke.

Objective

This study aimed to evaluate the influence of proprioceptive training on lower limb function in patients after a stroke using an ankle-foot robot.

Method

In total, 60 adult participants who met the criteria were randomly divided into a control group and an experimental group. The control group (RG) was given regular physical activity, and the sensory training group (SG) was given proprioceptive training based on an ankle-foot robot, the rest being the same as RG. Measurements for 10-meter walking time (10MWT), the Berg Balance Scale (BBS), the Fugl-Meyer assessment of lower extremity (FMA-LE), and active range of motion (AROM), passive range of motion (PROM), and ankle joint sensitivity before and after 6 weeks of treatment (30 sessions; five times per week) were assessed.

Results

There was a significant decrease in both 10MWT and ankle joint sensitivity in both groups (p < 0.05), while there was a significant increase in BBS, FMA-LE, AROM, and PROM in both groups (p < 0.05). A significant relationship was identified between the two groups, the SG group had greater degrees of improvement compared to the RG group.

Conclusion

The proprioceptive training based on an ankle-foot robot could improve proprioception and effectively improve the motor function and walking ability in patients after a stroke. Proprioceptive strength training is recommended to be emphasized in the regular rehabilitation of patients after a stroke.

Ankle strategy assistance to improve gait stability using controllers based on in-shoe center of pressure in 2 degree-of-freedom powered ankle-foot orthoses: a clinical study

Background

Although the ankle strategy is important for achieving frontal plane stability during one-leg stance, previously developed powered ankle–foot orthoses (PAFOs) did not involve ankle strategies because of hardware limitations. Weakness of movement in frontal plane is a factor that deteriorates gait stability and increases fall risk so it should not be overlooked in rehabilitation. Therefore, we used PAFO with subtalar joint for frontal plane movement and tried to confirm that the existence of it is important in balancing through clinical experiments.

Methods

We developed a proportional CoP controller to assist ankle strategy or stabilizing moment and enhance eversion to compensate for the tilting moment with 2 dof PAFO. It was true experimental study, and we recruited seven healthy subjects (30 ± 4 years) who did not experience any gait abnormality participated in walking experiments for evaluating the immediate effect of subtalar joint of PAFO on their gait stability. They walked on the treadmill with several cases of controllers for data acquisitions. Indices of gait stability and electromyography for muscle activity were measured and Wilcoxon signed-rank tests were used to identify meaningful changes.

Results

We found that subjects were most stable during walking (in terms of largest Lyapunov exponents, p < 0.008) with the assistance of the PAFO when their electromyographic activity was the most reduced (p < 0.008), although postural sway increased when a proportional CoP controller was used to assist the ankle strategy (p < 0.008). Other indices of gait stability, kinematic variability, showed no difference between the powered and unpowered conditions (p > 0.008). The results of the correlation analysis indicate that the actuator of the PAFO enhanced eversion and preserved the location of the CoP in the medial direction so that gait stability was not negatively affected or improved.

Conclusions

We verified that the developed 2 dof PAFO assists the ankle strategy by compensating for the tilting moment with proportional CoP controller and that wearer can walk in a stable state when the orthosis provides power for reducing muscle activity. This result is meaningful because an ankle strategy should be considered in the development of PAFOs for enhancing or even rehabilitating proprioception.

Trial registration 7001988-202003-HR-833-03

Assessing bilateral ankle proprioceptive acuity in stroke survivors: An exploratory study

Background

Bilateral proprioception deficits were reported in stroke survivors. However, whether bilateral proprioception deficits exist in the ankle joint after stroke was unclear. Ankle proprioception is a significant predictor of balance dysfunction after stroke, and previous studies to date are lacking appropriate evaluation methods.

Objectives

We want to determine whether the active movement extent discrimination apparatus (AMEDA) is a reliable tool for assessing ankle proprioceptive acuity in stroke survivors and the presence of deficits in ankle proprioception on the affected and unaffected sides in patients after stroke.

Methods

Bilateral ankle proprioception was assessed in 20 stroke patients and 20 age-matched healthy controls using AMEDA. Test-retest reliability was assessed using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC).

Results

The ICC in the affected and unaffected sides was 0.713 and 0.74, respectively. Analysis of variance revealed significant deficits in ankle proprioception in subacute stroke survivors vs. healthy controls (F = 2.719, p = 0.045). However, there were no significant differences in proprioception acuity scores between the affected and unaffected sides in patients after stroke (F = 1.14, p = 0.331).

Conclusions

Stroke survivors had bilateral deficits in ankle proprioceptive acuity during active movements compared with age-matched healthy controls, underscoring the need to evaluate these deficits on both sides of the body and develop effective sensorimotor rehabilitation methods for this patient population. The AMEDA can reliably determine bilateral ankle proprioceptive acuity in stroke survivors.