A Biomechanical Comparison of Six Suture Configurations for Soft Tissue-Based Graft Traction and Fixation

Assessment of formalin preserved and fresh frozen quadriceps tendon graft-suture constructs for load to failure testing: a biomechanical cadaveric study

PURPOSE

Fresh-frozen specimen availability and cost may be a barrier for initiation of biomechanical studies where soft tissue is used in a construct with other medical devices. The impact of soft tissue preservation method on the outcomes of biomechanical studies in the specific case of graft-suture constructs is relatively unexplored. This study aimed to observe peak loads and failure modes in biomechanical testing of fresh-frozen (FF) versus formalin embalmed (FE) quadriceps tendon (QT) graft-suture constructs for soft tissue fixation in ACLR and assess suitability of FE QT graft constructs for load-to-fail testing.

METHODS

Twenty QT grafts were harvested from human cadaver specimens. Ten grafts came from fresh-frozen donors and 10 from embalmed donors. All grafts were prepared with the modified Prusik knot using a braided composite suture and subjected to tensile loading. Comparisons between the biomechanical properties of the graft-suture constructs were made with unpaired t tests with α = 0.05.

RESULTS

FE and FF constructs displayed similar peak loads and failure modes. FF constructs had greater elongation after pre-tensioning than FE (7.3 vs. 5.5 mm, p = 0.02) and greater elongation after cyclic loading than FE constructs (17.5 vs. 10.5 mm, p = 0.01). Hysteresis was greater for FF constructs at the 50th, 100th, 150th, and 200th cycle (p = 0.02, p = 0.07, p < 0.001, p = 0.004, respectively). FE constructs were stiffer than fresh-frozen (103 vs. 84 N/mm, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

FE constructs were significantly stiffer but displayed similar peak load and failure mode to FF which was reflective of the strength of the suture material. FE grafts can offer an alternative to FF grafts in graft-suture constructs for biomechanical studies where load at failure and knot security and strength is of main interest.

Biomechanical and histological comparison of two suture configurations for soft tissue grafts: speedtrap™ versus krackow stitch

To compare 2 different graft preparation techniques to determine biomechanical strength and resultant tissue trauma evaluated by histology. Twelve common flexors of the finger's tendons were prepared with either tubulization (SpeedTrap™) or transtendon stiches (Orthocord™). The stiffness, resistance and energy at maximum load were tested for biomechanical assessment in both groups. After load testing, Samples were stained with hematoxylin and eosin (HE) to evaluate histological damage. We observe that the time to prepare tendons with SpeedTrap™ was 8.3 times faster (1:25 min) than traditional ones (15:02 min). In all cases, the mean values for SpeedTrap™ were higher in terms of strength, stiffness and energy at maximum load than for traditional suture but without significant difference (p > 0.05). The Krackow stitch produces greater structural damage to the collagen fibers while SpeedTrap™ maintains better organized arrangement of the fibers after tubulization preparation. With the results obtained, we can conclude that the tubulization technique allows faster graft preparation with less structural damage to the manipulated tissue without altering the biomechanical resistance provided by the transtendon suture technique.

Graft Suturing Method Affects on Graft Diameter in Hamstring-Based Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

INTRODUCTION

 Various benefits of needleless suture loop techniques in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction graft preparation have been discussed, yet their impact on graft diameter remains unexplored. We hypothesized that the suture loop technique would reduce the graft diameter compared to the conventional locking suture technique.

METHODS

 Fifty-seven patients whose grafts were made with the Krackow stitch (group K) and 54 patients with the suture loop (group SL) were analyzed retrospectively. (1) The distal (sutured side) diameter of each anteromedial bundle and posterolateral bundle was compared to the proximal (non-sutured side) diameter, and (2) the average of the proximal and distal graft diameters in each group was calculated.

RESULTS

 In group K, 78.9% of anteromedial bundles and 40.3% of posterolateral bundles exhibited a larger distal diameter than the proximal, while in group SL, 42.6% of anteromedial bundles and 3.7% of posterolateral bundles showed a larger distal diameter. In both bundles, there were significantly fewer grafts with larger distal diameters in group SL (p < 0.001). The mean distal diameter of anteromedial bundles was smaller in group SL (6.33 ± 0.43 mm vs. 6.07 ± 0.43 mm, p < 0.005). Consequently, the distal cross-sectional area of anteromedial bundles in group SL was 8% smaller than that in group K.

CONCLUSION

 The use of the suture loop technique resulted in a significantly smaller distal diameter of the anteromedial bundle. This reduces the size of the tibial tunnel and may contribute to a reduction in potential damage to adjacent structures.

Whip-Lock Stitch Is Biomechanically Superior to Whipstitch for Semitendinosus Tendons

Purpose

To assess the biomechanical performance of different stitching methods using a suturing device by comparing the elongation, stiffness, failure load, and time to stitch completion in cadaveric semitendinosus tendons (STs) and quadriceps tendons (QTs).

Methods

A total of 24 STs and 16 QTs were harvested from cadaveric knee specimens (N = 40). Samples were randomly divided into 2 groups: whipstitch (WS) and whip-lock (WL) stitch. Both tendon ends were clamped to a graft preparation stand, and a 2-part needle was used to place 5 stitches, each 0.5 cm apart. Stitching time was recorded. Samples were preconditioned and then underwent cyclic loading from 50 to 200 N at 1 Hz for 500 cycles, followed by load-to-failure testing at 20 mm/min. Stiffness (in newtons per millimeter), ultimate failure load (in newtons), peak-to-peak displacement (in millimeters), elongation (in millimeters), and failure displacement (in millimeters) were recorded.

Results

Completion of the WS was significantly faster than the WL stitch in the ST (P < .001) and QT (P = .004). For the ST, the WL stitch exhibited higher ultimate failure loads and construct stiffness than the WS. Regarding the QT, the WL stitch showed higher stiffness and displacement than the WS; however, the ultimate failure load was higher for the WS in the QT. The ultimate failure load in the QT was higher than that in the ST for both stitches. In the ST, only 25% of WSs and 100% of WL stitches failed due to suture breakage. In the QT, suture breakage led to the failure of 100% of both the WL stitches and WSs.

Conclusions

In the ST, the WL stitch resulted in improved biomechanical performance through higher ultimate load and fewer failures from tissue damage compared with the WS. In the QT, both the WS and the WL stitch showed similar biomechanical performance with ultimate failure loads above established clinical failure thresholds.

Clinical Relevance

Various types of ligament and tendon injuries require suturing to enable repair or reconstruction. The success of ligament or tendon surgery often relies on soft-tissue quality. It is important to investigate the biomechanical properties of stitching techniques that help preserve soft-tissue quality as a step to determining their clinical suitability.

Biomechanical Comparison of Distal Radioulnar Joint Reconstruction Graft Preparation Techniques

Background  Graft preparation techniques for the Adams-Berger distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) reconstruction vary among surgeons with insufficient evidence to support any specific technique. Questions/Purposes  We compared survival with cyclic loading, absolute elongation, elongation rate, and modes of failure of four graft preparation techniques. Methods  Fifteen porcine extensor tendons were divided into three equal groups: tendon only; tendon augmented along its full length with nonlocking 2-0 FiberLoop suture spaced at 6 mm intervals; and tendon with suture at 12 mm intervals. Suture only was also tested. Samples were woven through custom radius- and ulna-simulating jigs mounted on a mechanical testing machine. Samples underwent a staircase cyclic loading protocol and were then inspected visually for the mode of failure. Survival with cyclic loading, absolute elongation, and elongation rate was compared. Results  Average survival with cyclic loading of suture-augmented tendon was significantly higher than tendon only. All tendon groups had significantly higher survival compared with suture only. Absolute elongation was subject to variability due to initial nonlinear elongation behavior of samples. The elongation rate was significantly lower with suture compared with all tendon groups. Modes of failure included rupture of the tendon and/or suture at the simulated graft-bone interface and elongation of the entire construct without rupture. Conclusions  In this biomechanical study, augmentation of porcine tendons with suture spaced at either 6 or 12 mm for DRUJ reconstruction significantly increased survival to a staircase cyclic loading protocol Clinical Relevance  For the Adams-Berger reconstruction, tendon grafts augmented along their entire length by nonabsorbable braided suture are biomechanically superior to tendon alone.

Tape-Reinforced Graft Suturing and Retensioning of Adjustable-Loop Cortical Buttons Improve Quadriceps Tendon Autograft Biomechanics in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Cadaveric Study

PURPOSE

To investigate the biomechanical effects of tape-reinforced graft suturing and graft retensioning for all-soft tissue quadriceps tendon (ASTQT) anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) in a full-construct human cadaveric model.

METHODS

Harvested cadaveric ASTQT grafts were assigned to either (1) double-suspensory adjustable-loop cortical button device (ALD) fixation in which both graft ends were fixed with a suspensory fixation device with (n = 5) or without (n = 5) tape-reinforced suturing or (2) single-suspensory distal tendon fixation in which only the patellar end was fixed with an ALD (n = 5) or fixed-loop cortical button device (FLD) (n = 5). All specimens were prepared using a No. 2 whipstitch technique, and tape-reinforced specimens had an integrated braided tape implant. Graft preparation time was recorded for double-suspensory constructs. Samples were tested on an electromechanical testing machine using a previously published protocol simulating rehabilitative kinematics and loading.

RESULTS

Tape-reinforced graft suturing resulted in greater graft load retention after cycling (11.9% difference, P = .021), less total elongation (mean [95% confidence interval (CI)], 5.57 mm [3.50-7.65 mm] vs 32.14 mm [25.38-38.90 mm]; P < .001), greater ultimate failure stiffness (mean [95% CI], 171.9 N/mm [158.8-185.0 N/mm] vs 119.4 N/mm [108.7-130.0 N/mm]; P < .001), and less graft preparation time (36.4% difference, P < .001) when compared with unreinforced specimens. Retensioned ALD constructs had less cyclic elongation compared with FLD constructs (mean total elongation [95% CI], 7.04 mm [5.47-8.61 mm] vs 12.96 mm [8.67-17.26 mm]; P = .004).

CONCLUSIONS

Tape-reinforced graft suturing improves time-zero ASTQT ACLR construct biomechanics in a cadaveric model with 83% less total elongation, 44% greater stiffness, and reduced preparation time compared with a whipstitched graft without tape reinforcement. ALD fixation improves construct mechanics when compared with FLD fixation as evidenced by 46% less total elongation.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Tape-reinforced implants and graft retensioning using ALDs improve time-zero ACLR graft construct biomechanics in a time-zero biomechanical model. Clinical studies will be necessary to determine whether these implants improve clinical outcomes including knee laxity and the incidence of graft rupture.

Speed whip ripstop technique during anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using quadriceps tendon results in higher fixation strength

PURPOSE

To compare the biomechanical strength of different fixation configurations using a suspensory button in a soft-tissue quadriceps tendon graft for Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) reconstruction.

METHODS

Thirty fresh-frozen bovine Achilles tendons (10 mm wide, 50 mm long, and 4 mm thick) were used in this study. Tendons were assigned to three groups (n = 10 per group) with different suture configurations using adjustable loops with a suspensory button: group A, with the threads of an adjustable loop fixed by crossing at the tip of the loop and the entire loop; group B, continuous loops with hanging buttons were directly sutured to the tendon with eight simple sutures; group C, fixation was performed using the speed whip ripstop technique. Tensile tests with five cycles of preloading were performed at 50 N, held at 50 N for 1 min, and load-to-failure testing was conducted until rupture at 5 mm/min. The difference in the elongation and the maximum load-to-failure force were measured.

RESULTS

The average elongation was significantly larger in group B (16.6 ± 2.2 mm) than in groups A (10.3 ± 2.4 mm) and C (10.0 ± 1.0 mm), (p < 0.001). The average load-to-failure force varied significantly between the three groups, 157.5 ± 33.4 N in group A, 253.4 ± 45.5 N in group B, and 337.7 ± 21.0 N in group C, (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Fixation using the speed whip ripstop technique to fix the suspensory button and soft-tissue transplant tendon resulted in minimal elongation and higher fixation strength. Simple devices that use this method have already been developed. Since it can be fixed using a relatively simple method, speed whip ripstop technique was shown to be advantageous for femoral fixation in ACL reconstruction using soft-tissue quadriceps tendon. The findings of this study could help surgeons reduce graft re-tear rates in ACL reconstruction using quadriceps tendons.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

N/A, laboratory control study.

Biomechanical Comparison of a Novel Multiplanar, Perpendicular Whipstitch With the Krackow Stitch and Standard Commercial Whipstitch

Background:

Using alternating orthogonal suture throws with the looped whipstitch technique may allow enhanced suture fixation.

Hypothesis:

It was hypothesized that this novel multiplanar, perpendicular looped whipstitch (MP) technique would have improved biomechanical properties compared with the standard looped whipstitch (WS) and Krackow stitch (KS).

Study Design:

Controlled laboratory study.

Methods:

A total of 30 cadaveric tibialis anterior tendons were randomly assigned into 3 groups of 10. Tendons were secured to a custom clamp, and the other end was sutured using 1 of 3 techniques: the KS, WS, or novel MP. The MP was performed with alternating orthogonal throws starting right to left, then front to back, left to right, and back to front. Each technique used 4 passes of No. 2 FiberWire spaced 5 mm apart and ending 10 mm from the tendon end. Tendons were preloaded to 5 N, pretensioned to 50 N at 100 mm/min for 3 cycles, returned to 5 N for 1 minute, cycled from 5 to 100 N at 200 mm/min for 100 cycles, and then loaded to failure at 20 mm/min. Elongation was recorded after pretensioning and cycling and was measured both across the suture-tendon interface and from the base of the suture-tendon interface to markings on the suture limbs (construct elongation). One-way analyses of variance were performed, with Bonferroni post hoc analysis when appropriate.

Results:

There were no differences in cross-sectional area or stiffness among the 3 techniques. The ultimate load for WS (183.33 ± 57.44 N) was less compared with both MP (270.76 ± 39.36 N) and KS (298.90 ± 25.94 N) (P ≤ .001 for both). There was less construct elongation for KS compared with WS and MP for total displacement, measured from pretensioning to the end of cycling (P < .001). All 3 techniques saw a decrease in length (shortening) at the suture-tendon interface during testing. There was more shortening at the suture-tendon interface for WS compared with KS (P = .006).

Conclusion:

The KS appears superior, as it maximized strength while minimizing construct elongation or graft shortening. The ultimate load of the MP technique was greater than that of the standard technique but not significantly different from that of the KS technique.

Clinical Relevance:

The KS is preferred. If using a WS, multiplanar, perpendicular passes should be considered.

Direct suturing quadriceps tendon to a continuous loop with a suspensory button provides biomechanically superior fixation in ACL reconstruction

PURPOSE

To compare the biomechanical strength of different fixation configurations using suspensory buttons in a soft-tissue quadriceps tendon (QT) grafts in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction.

METHODS

Forty bovine QTs, 6-cm long and 10-mm wide, were allocated into four groups with different suture configurations using suspensory buttons (n = 10 in each group): Group A, a baseball suture with a knot tied to the continuous loop with a suspensory button; Group B, same configuration as in Group A but with the knot tied at the opposite end of the baseball suture; Group C, a continuous loop with a suspensory button stitched directly to the QT with simple sutures, and Group D, a baseball suture tied directly to a suspensory button. Biomechanical testing was performed by preloading followed by cyclic loading for 500 cycles between 10 and 100 N. The length of elongation (mm) and maximum load to failure (N) were recorded, and compared among the four groups.

RESULTS

Group C showed significantly smaller elongation (4.1 mm [95% CI 3.1-5.2]) than Group A (8.2 mm [95% CI 7.0-9.4]), Group B (10.5 mm [95% CI 7.7-13.3]), and Group D (8.5 mm [95% CI 7.0-9.9]) (A-C; P = 0.004, B-C; P = 0.0001, C-D; P = 0.0018). The maximum load to failure in Group C (386 N [95%CI 306-466]) was significantly higher than that in Group A (196 N [95% CI 141-251]), Group B (226 N [95% CI 164-289]), and Group D (212 N [95%CI 171-253]) (A-C; P = 0.0001, B-C; P = 0.0009, C-D; P = 0.0002). No significant differences were observed between Group A, B, and D in terms of elongation and maximum load to failure.

CONCLUSION

The soft-tissue QT graft fixation configuration stitched directly to a continuous loop with suspensory button using simple sutures exhibits small elongation and high maximum load to failure among the four configurations. Regarding clinical relevance, direct suturing of the soft-tissue QT to a continuous loop with a suspensory button may be advantageous for femoral fixation in ACL reconstruction from a biomechanical perspective, and warrant future development of a novel fixation device using this principle.

Does the Nice Knot Offer Less Elongation Than the Modified Prusik Knot? An In Vitro Study in Cadaver Quadriceps Tendons

BACKGROUND

ACL graft-suture fixation can be constructed with needle or needleless techniques. Needleless techniques have the advantage of decreased injury, preparation time, and cost. The Nice knot is common among upper extremity procedures, and has been shown to have higher load to failure and less elongation compared with other double loop knots; however, there are no studies that have looked at its use for ACL graft-suture construct to determine whether it offers less elongation relative to other needleless techniques.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

In a cadaver quadriceps tendon model, we asked: (1) Does the Nice knot have less elongation than the Prusik knot? (2) Does the Nice knot have increased peak load and stiffness compared with the Prusik knot? (3) What were the modes of failure of each knot?

METHODS

Sixteen quadriceps tendon grafts were harvested from 16 cadaver knee specimens. The median (range) age of the donors was 80 years (70 to 96) and included three male and five female donors. Eight grafts were prepared with the Prusik knot and eight with the Nice knot using a braided polyblend suture. The graft-suture constructs were mounted in a materials testing machine and subjected to a tensile loading protocol beginning with pretensioning of three cycles from 0 to 100 N at 1 Hz followed by a constant load of 50 N for 1 minute then cyclic loading of 200 cycles from 50 to 200 N at 1 Hz. The constructs were loaded to failure as the final step of the loading protocol. Elongations of the construct after each loading step, peak load, stiffness, and graft cross-sectional area were compared.

RESULTS

Construct elongations (median [IQR]) for the Nice knot were lower than that of the Prusik knot after pretensioning (4.4 mm [0.8] versus 5.7 mm [1.4]; p = 0.02), preloading (0.6 mm [0.3] versus 1.0 mm [0.3]; p = 0.005), and cyclic loading (7.4 mm [1.4] versus 10.9 mm [2.1]; p = 0.005). Peak load was not different for the Prusik knot construct compared with the Nice knot (334 N [43] versus 312 N [13]; p = 0.08). Stiffness of the Prusik knot construct (103 N/mm [17]) was no different than the Nice knot construct (110 N/mm [13]; p = 0.13). Graft cross-sectional area of the Prusik knot constructs (85 mm2 [35]) were similar to the grafts of the Nice knot constructs (97 mm2 [31]; p = 0.28). Failure mode of the constructs did not differ between groups; it was caused by suture rupture near the knots that secured the free suture ends to the machine and was seen in all 16 tests.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this biomechanical study show that the Nice knot construct has similar or greater biomechanical properties compared with the Prusik knot in the graft suture construct, although the magnitude of the differences are not likely to the level of clinical importance.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The Nice knot offers an attractive alternative option for needleless ACL graft preparation technique. Future studies should consider comparison to established needle techniques such as Krackow or whipstitch and testing in an intraarticular component in an in vivo model.

An Efficient Needleless Grasping Suture Technique for Graft Preparation in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

Objective

Several needleless techniques have been developed to outcome the inherent disadvantages of the traditional needle stitching technique for graft preparation, such as tendon damage through the needle, time consumption, and the potential risk of needlestick injury. The purpose of the present study is to compare the graft preparation time and the biomechanical performance between an efficient needleless technique and the traditional needle stitching technique for graft preparation in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR).

Methods

The time required to perform a complete suture on 20 hamstring tendons during ACLRs was measured. The grafts from one side were prepared using the needle stitching technique. The grafts from the other side used the needleless grasping suture technique. For the second part of the study, 12 fresh-frozen porcine flexor tendons were divided into two groups using two techniques and were mounted in an electric tensile test system. Each group was pretensioned to 100 N to simulate the maximum initial graft tension. The suturing state of sutures and graft (intact and damaged) and the load-elongation curve were recorded for each group. A Student’s t-test was used to compare the means of the two groups.

Results

In operation, the needleless grasping suture technique group (19.8 ± 4.8, range: 13.5–32.9 s) was significantly faster (p &lt; 0.05) than the needle stitching technique group (52.7 ± 12.7, range: 36.0–87.5 s). The state of sutures in each group was intact. The mean elongation was 11.75 ± 1.38 (range: 9.47–12.99) mm and 10.59 ± 1.02 (range: 9.12–11.76) mm in the needleless stitching technique group and the needle grasping suture technique group, respectively. There was no statistically significant difference in the elongation between the two groups (p &gt; 0.05).

Conclusion

The needleless grasping suture technique was a convenient and efficient method for graft preparation in ACLR.

How a Human-Centered Design Process Transformed the User Experience of Graft Preparation in the Operating Room

In this case study, the human-centered design process used by the Industrial Design and Human Factors (IDHF) team at Johnson & Johnson MedTech in developing the SPEEDTRAP™ Graft Preparation System is overviewed. This article describes three broad efforts to “Understand” needs within knee soft tissue repair procedures and potential opportunities; “Explore” possible solutions through conceptual development, prototyping, and usability testing; and “Materialize” the refinement and delivery of the SPEEDTRAP™ Graft Preparation System. The key results for each broad effort are described.

Suture Slippage During Anterior Cruciate Ligament Graft Passage Is Significantly Lower Using a Krackow Suture

Purpose

To compare the suture slippage on a hamstring tendon graft prepared with a modified finger-trap device (SPEEDTRAP) with one prepared with Krackow stitch during graft passage through the tibial tunnel in ACL reconstruction.

Methods

Thirty-eight patients underwent anatomic triple-bundle anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with 2 femoral and 3 tibial tunnels. After semitendinosus tendon was cut in half to make 2 grafts, the free ends of the proximal membranous portion (posterolateral [PL] graft) were prepared together with 2 sutures: (1) one SPEEDTRAP and one Krackow stitch for 20 cases (group A) and (2) double Krackow stitches on both sides for 18 cases (group B). Then, the PL graft was dye-marked at the proximal suture of SPEEDTRAP in group A and Krackow suture in group B and was inserted into the joint via tibial tunnel ahead of the loop side. The distance between the mark on the graft and the proximal suture of SPEEDTRAP or Krackow stitch was measured under arthroscopy after graft fixation at femur. Slippage was defined as 1 mm and more of distance between the mark and the proximal suture.

Results

Slippage was observed in 16 cases for SPEEDTRAP and in 2 for Krackow suture in group A, whereas one case showed slippage in group B. The slippage distance was 4.0 ± 2.9 mm for SPEEDTRAP and 0.2 ± 0.5 mm for Krackow stitch in group A (P < .001), whereas it was 0.1 ± 0.2 mm for double Krackow stitch in group B, showing a significant difference from SPEEDTRAP suture (P < .001).

Conclusions

At the time of PL graft passage through the tibial tunnel in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, there was significantly less slippage observed with the Krackow stitch compared with the SPEEDTRAP stitch.

Level of Evidence

Level IV, therapeutic case series.

A Biomechanical Comparison of High-Tensile Strength Tape Versus High-Tensile Strength Suture for Tendon Fixation Under Cyclic Loading

PURPOSE

To compare the biomechanical properties of high-tensile strength tape and high-tensile strength suture across 2 selected stitch techniques, the Krackow and whip stitch, in securing tendinous tissue during 5,000 cycles of nondestructive loading followed by a load to failure.

METHODS

Fourteen matched pairs each of cadaveric Achilles, quadriceps, and patellar tendons (n = 84) were randomly assigned to either Krackow or whip stitch and sutured with either 2-mm high-tensile strength tape or No. 2 high-tensile strength suture. Specimens were preloaded to 20 N, cyclically loaded from 20 to 200 N for 5,000 cycles at 2 Hz, and then loaded to failure at 200 mm/min. Linear mixed models evaluated the effects of suture material and stitch technique on cyclic normalized tendon-suture elongation, total normalized tendon-suture elongation at 5,000 cycles, and maximum load at failure.

RESULTS

Across all suture constructs, normalized elongation was greater during the initial 10 cycles, compared with all subsequent cycling intervals (all P < .001). There was less total normalized elongation (β = -0.239; P = .007) and greater maximum load at failure in tape (β = 163.71; P = .014) when used in the Krackow stitch compared with the whip stitch.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings indicate that tape used in the Krackow stitch maintains the most favorable fixation strength after enduring cyclic loading, with greater maximum load at failure. In addition, overall normalized elongation during long-term cyclic loading was predominately affected by the stitch technique used, regardless of the suture material; however, tape allowed less normalized elongation during the initial loading cycles, especially when placed in the whip stitch.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Understanding the potential short- and long-term outcomes of suture material and stitch technique on securing tendinous tissue under repetitive stresses can help inform clinicians on optimal tendon fixation techniques for early postoperative activities.

Editorial Commentary: Suture Type or Technique Has Little Influence on Outcome After Acute Lower-Extremity Tendon Rupture

Operative repair of Achilles tendon rupture significantly decreases the rerupture rate, regardless of type of surgical suture technique. Likewise, regarding repair of either the quadriceps or patellar tendon, surgical repair technique does not significantly influence the generally excellent outcomes achieved, whereas too-early mobilization should be avoided. In terms of the use of suture versus suture tape, load to failure is similar. Many factors impact tendon rupture repair success, including postoperative care, the quality of the tendon, underlying medical issues, and patient compliance, but suture type or technique has little influence on outcome after acute lower-extremity tendon rupture.

Does using high-tensile strength tape improve the fixation strength in tendon graft fixation with needleless suture wrapping techniques compared to a suture?

PURPOSE

To compare the biomechanical properties of a high-tensile strength suture and high-tensile strength tape in tendon graft fixation using two needleless suture wrapping techniques, the modified Prusik knot and modified rolling hitch.

METHODS

Two needleless suture wrapping techniques, the modified rolling hitch (MR) and modified Prusik knot (MP), were utilized. Meanwhile, two kinds of suture materials, a No. 2 braided nonabsorbable high-strength suture (S) and a 1.3 mm high-tensile strength tape (T), were used. A total of 40 porcine tendons were used, which were randomly divided into four groups. Each group was assigned to one of the following groups: MRS, MRT, MPS, and MPT. Each specimen was pretensioned to 100 N for three cycles, cyclically loaded from 50 to 200 N for 200 cycles, and finally loaded to failure.

RESULTS

The MRT group (34.1 ± 3.5%) had a significantly higher value compared with the MRS (29.7 ± 2.3%), MPS (27.1 ± 3.6%) and MPT (29.5 ± 4.0%) groups in term of elongation after cyclic loadings (p = 0.002). In terms of ultimate failure load, there were no significant differences in the MRS (401 ± 27 N), MRT (380 ± 27 N), MPS (398 ± 44 N) and MPT (406 ± 49 N) values (p = 0.539). All specimens failed due to suture breakage at the knots.

CONCLUSION

Compared with the high-tensile strength suture, using the high-tensile strength tape lead to greater elongation after cyclic loading when the modified rolling hitch was used. No differences in terms of elongation after cyclic loading and load to failure were found between the high-tensile strength suture and tape using the modified Prusik knot.

The Biomechanical Properties of a High-Tensile Strength Tape for Tendon Graft Fixation Using the Krackow Configuration

Purpose

To compare the biomechanical properties of a high-tensile strength suture with the high-tensile strength tape for tendon graft fixation.

Methods

A total of 24 porcine tendons were used and were randomly divided into 2 groups. Two kinds of suture materials, a braided nonabsorbable high-strength suture (group S) and a high-tensile strength tape (group T), were used to complete 3 pairs of Krackow stitches on the tendons. Each specimen was pretensioned to 100 N for 3 cycles, cyclically loaded from 50 to 200 N for 200 cycles, and finally loaded to failure. Elongation after cyclic loading, ultimate failure load, and the mode of failure were recorded.

Results

The elongation after cyclic loading between group S (26% ± 5%) and group T (24% ± 5%) were not significantly different (P = .378). The ultimate failure loads in group T (400 ± 38 N) were significantly greater than those in group S (358 ± 21 N) (P = .010). All specimens failed because of suture material breakage.

Conclusions

Compared with the braided nonabsorbable high-strength suture, the high-tensile strength tape had similar elongation values after cyclic loading, but significantly greater ultimate failure load in this porcine in vitro biomechanical model.

Clinical Relevance

A secure suture-tendon construct is especially important when a post-tie fixation technique is used because the mitigating construct may potentially lead to graft loosening and affect graft healing.

A Biomechanical Comparison of Different Suture Materials Used for Arthroscopic Shoulder Procedures

PURPOSE

To evaluate the viscoelastic properties of 4 commercially available cord-like sutures and 2 commercially available suture tapes when subjected to physiological loads, as well as to compare them with each other and to identify the clinically most desirable combination of suture material properties.

METHODS

Six suture materials (Ethibond, FiberWire, FiberTape, Orthocord, Ultrabraid, and Ultratape) underwent creep testing (n = 7, 60 N, 10 minutes) to determine specimen stiffness, initial elongation at 60 N of load, static creep (during 10 minutes of loading), and relaxed elongation (material recovery 3 minutes after removal of load). Furthermore, cyclic testing (n = 7, 10-45 N, 0.5 Hz, 500 cycles) was carried out to determine dynamic creep, peak-to-peak displacement, and relaxed elongation. Mechanical testing was conducted on a material testing machine in 37°C phosphate-buffered saline solution.

RESULTS

FiberTape showed the greatest stiffness (23.9 ± 3.2 N/mm, P < .001), the smallest amounts of static (0.38 ± 0.10 mm, P < .001) and dynamic (0.16 ± 0.09 mm, P = .003) creep, and the smallest peak-to-peak displacement (0.20 ± 0.02 mm, P < .001). FiberTape and FiberWire showed the smallest initial elongation (1.17 ± 0.17 mm and 1.63 ± 0.25 mm, respectively; P < .001). Ultrabraid showed the greatest relaxed elongation, both statically (4.73 ± 0.73 mm, P < .001) and dynamically (4.18 ± 0.83 mm, P = .002).

CONCLUSIONS

FiberTape consistently displayed less creep, greater stiffness, and less extensibility than the other suture types. Ultrabraid showed the largest amount of relaxed elongation on both static and dynamic testing.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

When considering high stiffness in combination with low initial extension and low static creep to be ideal parameters to achieve optimal initial construct stability and considering low dynamic creep in combination with low peak-to-peak displacement to be ideal conditions for the repetitive loading of the construct during the healing process, tapes seem to be superior to cord-like sutures for performing rotator cuff repair.

Soft Tissue Fixation Strategies of Human Quadriceps Tendon Grafts: A Biomechanical Study

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effects of different stitching methods and suture diameters on the graft fixation of soft tissue human quadriceps tendon grafts for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction.

METHODS

The Krackow locking stitch (K), whipstitch (W), and baseball stitch (B) were combined with either a 2× no. 2 (#2) or a 1× no. 5 (#5) braided composite suture for graft fixation of 36 human quadriceps tendons in 6 groups. Biomechanical testing was performed using a cyclic protocol with loads between 0 and 100 N. The maximum load until failure, cyclic elongation, and failure mode were recorded.

RESULTS

The highest mean maximum load to failure was observed in the 2 Krackow stitch groups. The K#2 group had significantly higher load to failure values compared with those of the W#2 and B#2 groups (K#2, 553 ± 82 N vs W#2, 392 ± 107 N, P = .0349; K#2 vs B#2 366 ± 118 N, P = .0129). The mean cyclic elongation was lowest in the Krackow groups (K#2, 10.59 ± 2.63 mm; K#5, 13.66 ± 2.3 mm). The regular failure mode was the rupture of the suture for the Krackow stitch (8 of 12) and suture pullout for the whipstitch (11 of 12) and baseball stitch groups (12 of 12).

CONCLUSIONS

The double Krackow stitch with no. 2 braided composite suture exhibits a high maximum load to failure combined with a low amount of elongation in a biomechanical study for human quadriceps tendon soft tissue graft fixation. Unlike the whipstitch and the baseball stitch, it can solidly prevent suture pullout.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

A safe soft tissue graft fixation technique is especially important for quadriceps tendon grafts with their laminar anatomical structure and physiologically varying diameter. Unlike other grafts for ACL replacement, it fully relies on the soft tissue suture fixation to resist the pullout force.

Editorial Commentary: Stronger and Faster Suture Configuration-But Is It Better? Challenges of Surgical Innovation in the Modern Era

When evaluating the characteristics of a new surgical technique, it is important to consider practical effects of the technique on clinical practice, as it would be inappropriate to advocate for cost-prohibitive or excessively time-consuming methods, even if biomechanically superior. The Krackow stitch has long been considered the gold standard for suture-graft fixation; potential limitations with this technique include the risk of needle sticks to the surgical team and the time required to perform the stitch. A new proprietary method (SpeedTrap, DePuy-Mitek, Raynham, MA) offers a significantly faster solution with equivalent or better biomechanics; however, elongation of the suture-graft construct is still a concern, and the cost effectiveness remains unclear. Regardless, we are fortunate to be practicing in an era when we can have great appreciation for the problem-solving innovations of surgeons who practiced in prior decades as well as witness the continued effort to optimize clinical outcomes now and in the future.