Cellular Augmentation of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Surgery Is Not Currently Evidence Based: A Systematic Review of Clinical Studies

Preparation of Bone Patellar Tendon Bone Allograft With Biocomposite Scaffold Augmentation

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries and subsequent surgical reconstruction are exceedingly common orthopaedic procedures. Surgical technique and graft preparation techniques continue to evolve as surgeons seek to increase surgical outcomes and decrease recovery time. As such, there is significant interest in identifying tools and techniques that may enhance the surgical process for patients undergoing an ACL reconstruction. Recently, there has been significant interest in evaluating biologic scaffolds that may augment graft healing. This Technical Note describes our technique for the preparation of a bone-patellar tendon-bone ACL graft with a BioBrace biocomposite scaffold augmentation.

The Second Annual Musculoskeletal Biologics Special Issue Highlights Evidence-Based Therapies

Orthopaedic biologics continues to hold great promise. The editors of Arthroscopy; Arthroscopy Techniques; and Arthroscopy, Sports Medicine, and Rehabilitation once again Call for Papers and invite authors to submit clinical musculoskeletal biologics original scientific research and technical notes with video. Our top articles are awarded inclusion in the Annual Musculoskeletal Biologics Special Issue.

Orthopaedic Musculoskeletal Biologics Research Impacts Patient Care: The Second Annual Arthroscopy Orthobiologics Virtual Special Issue

The field of orthobiologics is rapidly evolving, offering clinicians a shift in treatment from symptom relief to the potential for disease modification and tissue repair. These agents, derived from autologous tissues, components of blood, and growth factors, are used as surgical adjuncts or as standalone treatments. Their clinical applications are expanding to encompass a variety of conditions, supported by a growing base of research efforts. Arthroscopy and its companion publications are committed to evidence-based research with a robust history of publications that enhance clinical decision-making and impact patient care. This curated collection of articles highlights the year's most compelling advancements in orthopaedic musculoskeletal biologics research.

Cells Remain Viable When Collected With an In-Line-Suction Tissue Collector From Byproducts of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Surgery

Purpose

To investigate the viability of cells collected with an in-line-suction autologous tissue collector from the tissue byproducts of arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, to characterize cells from different tissue types, and to identify mesenchymal stem cells.

Methods

Patients aged 14 to 50 years with ACL injuries requiring arthroscopic reconstruction surgery were offered enrollment and screened for participation. In total, 12 patients were enrolled in the descriptive laboratory study. Arthroscopic byproduct tissue was collected with an in-line-suction autologous tissue collector from 4 intraoperative collection sites for each patient: ACL stump, ACL fat pad, notchplasty debris, and tunnel drilling debris. All tissue samples were digested using collagenase, and the derived cellular populations were analyzed in vitro, characterizing cellular viability, proliferative potential, qualitative multipotent differentiation capacity, and cell-surface marker presence.

Results

An equivalent mass of arthroscopic byproduct tissue was taken from each of the 4 intraoperative collection sites (1.12-1.61 g, P = .433), which all showed an average viability of at least 99.95% and high average total nucleated cells (≥1.37 × 107 cells/mL). No significant differences in collected mass (P = .433), cellular viability (P = .880), or total nucleated cells (P = .692) were observed between the 4 byproduct tissues. The byproduct tissues did exhibit significant differences in monocyte (P = .037) and red blood cell (P = .038) concentrations, specifically with greater values present in the ACL stump tissue. Cells from all byproduct tissues adhered to plastic cell culture flasks. Significant differences were found between colony-forming unit fibroblast counts of the 4 byproduct tissues when plated at 106 (P = .003) and 103 (P = .016) cells as the initial seeding density. There was a significant relationship found between both the starting concentration (χ2 = 32.7, P < .001) and the byproduct tissue type (χ2 = 30.4, P < .001) to the presence of ≥80% confluency status at 10 days. Cells obtained from all 4 byproduct tissues qualitatively showed positive tri-lineage (adipocyte, osteoblast, chondroblast) differentiation potential compared with negative controls under standardized in vitro differentiation conditions. Cells derived from all 4 byproduct tissues expressed cell-surface antigens CD105+, CD73+, CD90+, CD45-, CD14-, and CD19- (>75%), and did not express CD45 (<10%). There were no statistically significant differences in cell-surface antigens between the four byproduct tissues.

Conclusions

This descriptive laboratory study demonstrated that cells derived from arthroscopic byproduct tissues of ACL reconstruction remain viable when collected with an in-line-suction autologous tissue collector and these cells meet the ISCT criteria to qualify as mesenchymal stem cells.

Clinical Relevance

It is known that viable mesenchymal stem cells reside in byproduct tissue of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery (ACLR). Practical methods to harvest these cells at the point of care require further development. This study validates the use of an in-line-suction autologous tissue collector for the harvest of viable mesenchymal stem cells after ACLR.

Optimizing repair of tendon ruptures and chronic tendinopathies: Integrating the use of biomarkers with biological interventions to improve patient outcomes and clinical trial design

Tendons are dense connective tissues of the musculoskeletal system that link bones with muscles to foster mobility. They have complex structures and exist in varying biomechanical, metabolic and biological environments. In addition, tendon composition and mechanical properties can change over the lifespan as an individual ages. Many tendons function in high stress conditions with a low vascular and neuronal supply, conditions often leading to development of chronic tendinopathies, and in some cases, overt rupture of the tissues. Given their essential nature for human mobility and navigation through the environment, the effective repair and regeneration of different tendons after injury or damage is critical for quality of life, and for elite athletes, the return to sport participation at a high level. However, for mainly unknown reasons, the outcomes following injury are not always successful and lead to functional compromise and risk for re-injury. Thus, there is a need to identify those patients who are at risk for developing tendon problems, as well those at risk for poor outcomes after injury and to design interventions to improve outcomes after injury or rupture to specific tendons. This review will discuss recent advances in the identification of biomarkers prognostic for successful and less successful outcomes after tendon injury, and the mechanistic implications of such biomarkers, as well as the potential for specific biologic interventions to enhance outcomes to improve both quality of life and a return to participation in sports. In addition, the implication of these biomarkers for clinical trial design is discussed, as is the issue of whether such biomarkers for successful healing of one tendon can be extended to all tendons or are valid only for tendons in specific biomechanical and biological environments. As maintaining an active lifestyle is critical for health, the successful implementation of these advances will benefit the large number of individuals at risk.

Intraoperative Administration of Adipose Stromal Vascular Fraction Does Not Improve Functional Outcomes in Young Patients with Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

Adipose stromal vascular fraction (SVF) has a versatile cellular system for biologically augmented therapies. However, there have been no clinical studies investigating the benefits of the augmentation of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) with SVF. We conducted a retrospective study in assessing the effects of intraoperative SVF administration on the functional outcomes in young patients with ACLR. The enrolled patients were divided into the control group (ACLR only) and the SVF group (ACLR with SVF). The functional outcomes in both groups were assessed by the Lysholm knee scoring system, the Tegner activity scale, and the International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) subjective evaluation form, and compared at several time points during a 12-month follow-up. We found that the sex distribution and pre-surgery scores were similar in the two groups, whereas the mean age of the SVF group was higher than that of the control group (p = 0.046). The between-group analysis and generalized estimating equation model analysis revealed that, while patients in the SVF group significantly improved all their functional outcomes at 12 months after surgery, this improvement was not significantly different from the results of patients in the control group (Lysholm, p = 0.553; Tegner, p = 0.197; IKDC, p = 0.486). No side effects were observed in either group. We concluded that the intraoperative administration of SVF does not improve or accelerate functional recovery after ACLR in young patients.

Editorial Commentary: Bone Marrow Aspirate Concentrate May Accelerate Anterior Cruciate Ligament Allograft Using Bone Patellar Tendon Bone Maturation on Magnetic Resonance Imaging, but Clinical Differences Have Not Been Demonstrated

Accelerating graft healing in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) continues to be an elusive proposition. In vivo assessments of graft histology are challenging to perform, especially in human subjects. Multiple authors have reported on the utility of magnetic resonance imaging as a noninvasive modality in characterizing postoperative changes, suggestive of graft maturation. However, previous literature, by and large, has been limited by heterogenous scanning protocols and underpowered comparisons of dissimilar treatment techniques, and these issues complicate efforts to assess the benefits (if any) of adjuncts focused on improving graft healing after ACLR. Particularly in cases of allograft ACLR, where concerns persist regarding the pace and quality of tissue healing and graft integration, the use of orthobiologic adjuncts represents a promising area for ongoing investigation. Although there has been great enthusiasm for the use of bone marrow aspirate concentrate as an adjunct in a variety of applications, high level evidence substantiating its use in ACLR is lacking. Even when significant differences between groups treated with and without such adjuncts may be apparent radiographically, demonstrating a concrete, clinical benefit will continue to be a difficult proposition.