Modified Mouse Models of Chronic Secondary Lymphedema: Tail and Hind Limb Models

Efficacy of Neonatal Porcine Bone Marrow-Derived Mesenchymal Stem Cell Xenotransplantation for the Therapy of Hind Limb Lymphedema in Mice

Lymphedema is an intractable disease with few effective therapeutic options. Autologous mesenchymal stem cell (MSC) transplantation is a promising therapy for this disease. However, its use is limited by the cost and time for preparation. Recently, xenotransplantation of porcine MSCs has emerged as an alternative to autologous MSC transplantation. In this study, we aimed to clarify the usefulness of neonatal porcine bone marrow-derived MSC (NpBM-MSC) xenotransplantation for the treatment of lymphedema. One million NpBM-MSCs were xenotransplanted into the hind limbs of mice with severe lymphedema (MSC transplantation group). The therapeutic effects were assessed by measuring the femoral circumference, the volume of the hind limb, the number and diameter of lymphatic vessels in the hind limb, and lymphatic flow using a near-infrared fluorescence (NIRF) imaging system. We compared the effects using mice with lymphedema that did not undergo NpBM-MSC transplantation (negative control group). The condition of the transplanted NpBM-MSCs was also evaluated histologically. The femoral circumference and volume of the hind limb had been normalized by postoperative day (POD) 14 in the MSC transplantation group, but not in the negative control group (P = 0.041). NIRF imaging revealed that lymphatic flow had recovered in the MSC transplantation group by POD 14, as shown by an increase in luminance in the hind limb. Histological assessment also showed that the xenotransplantation of NpBM-MSC increased the proliferation of lymphatic vessels, but they had been rejected by POD 14. The xenotransplantation of NpBM-MSCs is an effective treatment for lymphedema, and this is mediated through the promotion of lymphangiogenesis.

Surgical lymphedema models in the mice hindlimb-A systematic review and quality assessment

BACKGROUND

Lymphedema constitutes a major unsolved problem in plastic surgery. To identify novel lymphedema treatments, preclinical studies are vital. The surgical mouse lymphedema model is popular and cost-effective; nonetheless, a synthesis and overview of the literature with evidence-based guidelines is needed. The aim of this review was to perform a systematic review to establish best practice and support future high-quality animal studies exploring lymphedema treatments.

METHODS

We performed a systematic review following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, searching four databases (PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, and Scopus) from inception-September 2022. The Animals in Research Reporting In Vivo Experiments 2.0 (ARRIVE 2.0) guidelines were used to evaluate reporting quality. Studies claiming to surgically induce lymphedema in the hindlimb of mice were included.

RESULTS

Thirty-seven studies were included. Four main models were used. (1) Irradiation+surgery. (2) A variation of the surgery used by (1) + irradiation. (3) Surgery only (SPDF-model). (4) Surgery only (PLND-model). Remaining studies used other techniques. The most common measurement modality was the caliper. Mean quality coefficient was 0.57. Eighteen studies (49%) successfully induced sustained lymphedema. Combination of methods seemed to yield the best results, with an overrepresentation of irradiation, the removal of two lymph nodes, and the disruption of both the deep and superficial lymph vessels in the 18 studies.

CONCLUSION

Surgical mouse hindlimb lymphedema models are challenged by two related problems: (1) retaining lymphedema for an extended period, that is, establishing a (chronic) lymphedema model (2) distinguishing lymphedema from post-operative edema. Most studies failed to induce lymphedema and used error-prone measurements. We provide an overview of studies claiming to induce lymphedema and advocate improved research via five evidence-based recommendations to use: (1) a proven lymphedema model; (2) sufficient follow-up time, (3) validated measurement methods; (4) ARRIVE-guidelines; (5) contralateral hindlimb as control.

Establishment of a Simple, Reproducible, and Long-lasting Hind Limb Animal Model of Lymphedema

Background

Lymphedema is an intractable disease for which there is currently no established curative therapy. A reliable and long-lasting lymphedema model is essential for development of better treatments. In this study, we aimed to establish a simple, reproducible and long-lasting mouse model of lymphedema.

Methods

Our model is characterized by a combination of a circumferential skin incision in the femoral region, complete dissection of regional lymph nodes, and ablation of the inguinal route in the femoral region. The characteristics of the lymphedema were evaluated and compared with those of two other models. One of these models involved dissection of the subiliac, popliteal, and sciatic lymph nodes (model A) and the other excision of the subiliac, popliteal, and sciatic lymph nodes with cauterization of lymphatic vessels and closure without a skin excision (model B).

Results

Although the lymphedema in models A and B resolved spontaneously, that in the new model lasted for a month with increases in femoral circumference and hind limb volume, thickening of the skin, especially subcutaneous tissue, and congestion of peripheral lymphatic vessels. Furthermore, this model could be used for assessing the therapeutic effects of syngeneic mesenchymal stem cell transplantation. The average operation time for the new model was 14.4 ± 1.3 minutes.

Conclusion

Long-lasting lymphedema can be achieved by our new model, making it suitable for assessing therapies for lymphedema.

Modulation of Burn Hypermetabolism in Preclinical Models

Severe burns elicit a state of physiological stress and increased metabolism to help the body compensate for the changes associated with the traumatic injury. However, this hypermetabolic state is associated with increased insulin resistance, cardiovascular dysfunction, skeletal muscle catabolism, impaired wound healing, and delayed recovery. Several interventions were attempted to modulate burn hypermetabolism, including nutritional support, early excision and grafting, and growth hormone application. However, burn hypermetabolism still imposes significant morbidity and mortality in burn patients. Due to the limitations of in vitro models, animal models are indispensable in burn research. Animal models provide researchers with invaluable tools to test the safety and efficacy of novel treatments or advance our knowledge of previously utilized agents. Several animal studies evaluated novel therapies to modulate burn hypermetabolism in the last few years, including recombinant human growth hormone, erythropoietin, acipimox, apelin, anti-interleukin-6 monoclonal antibody, and ghrelin therapies. Results from these studies are promising and may be effectively translated into human studies. In addition, other studies revisited drugs previously used in clinical practice, such as insulin and metformin, to further investigate their underlying mechanisms as modulators of burn hypermetabolism. This review aims to update burn experts with the novel therapies under investigation in burn hypermetabolism with a focus on applicability and translation. Furthermore, we aim to guide researchers in selecting the correct animal model for their experiments by providing a summary of the methodology and the rationale of the latest studies.

Role of Subcutaneous Adipose Tissues in the Pathophysiology of Secondary Lymphedema

Background: Secondary lymphedema (LE) occurs due to the disruption of lymphatic circulation. Lymphatic fluid accumulation in subcutaneous tissues induces adipocyte proliferation. Obesity is an important risk factor for the occurrence and deterioration of LE. Although the relationship between LE and subcutaneous adipose tissue increase has been reported clinically, their pathophysiological relationship remains unknown. Thus, we aimed to verify whether subcutaneous adipose tissue increase is involved in the pathophysiology of secondary LE. Methods and Results: The hindlimb model of secondary LE was created using male Sprague-Dawley rats (control and LE groups; n = 5 each). Skin samples were obtained on postoperative day 168. Histological examination and quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction analysis of inflammatory adipokines, tumor necrosis factor-alpha (Tnf-α), C-C chemokine ligand 2 (Ccl2), and interleukin-6 (Il-6) were performed. Limb volume and subcutaneous adipose tissues significantly increased in the LE group compared with those in the control. Macrophages aggregated in the augmented adipose tissues, around the adipocytes, and formed crown-like structures (CLSs). The number of CLSs significantly increased in the LE group. These macrophages expressed transforming growth factor-beta 1 (TGF-β1). Inflammatory adipokine secretion was not observed. Although Il-6 expression increased in the LE group, IL-6 was expressed in subcutaneous myofibroblasts but not in subcutaneous adipocytes. Conclusion: As TGF-β1 derived from subcutaneous myofibroblasts is involved in skin fibrosis during LE, TGF-β1 derived from adipose tissues may also play a similar role. Drug treatment for subcutaneous adipose tissue reduction may improve the skin condition in secondary LE and may be a new therapeutic strategy.

Current Advancements in Animal Models of Postsurgical Lymphedema: A Systematic Review

Significance: Secondary lymphedema is a debilitating disease caused by lymphatic dysfunction characterized by chronic swelling, dysregulated inflammation, disfigurement, and compromised wound healing. Since there is no effective cure, animal model systems that support basic science research into the mechanisms of secondary lymphedema are critical to advancing the field. Recent Advances: Over the last decade, lymphatic research has led to the improvement of existing animal lymphedema models and the establishment of new models. Although an ideal model does not exist, it is important to consider the strengths and limitations of currently available options. In a systematic review adhering to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, we present recent developments in the field of animal lymphedema models and provide a concise comparison of ease, cost, reliability, and clinical translatability. Critical Issues: The incidence of secondary lymphedema is increasing, and there is no gold standard of treatment or cure for secondary lymphedema. Future Directions: As we iterate and create animal models that more closely characterize human lymphedema, we can achieve a deeper understanding of the pathophysiology and potentially develop effective therapeutics for patients.

Animal models in lymph node transfer surgery: A systematic review

BACKGROUND AND AIM

Lymph node transfer surgery (LNTS) is indicated in secondary lymphedema (LE) patients who do not respond to conservative therapy. Animal models are the spearhead of LE research and were used to pioneer most of the surgical interventions currently in practice. We conducted a systematic review of the literature to explore animal models dedicated to LNTS to compare different species, techniques, and outcomes.

METHODS

Four databases were searched: PubMed, Cumulative Index of Nursing and Allied Health Literature, Scopus, and Web of Science. We used the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis as our basis of organization.

RESULTS

Avascular lymph node graft (ALNG) and vascularized lymph node transfer (VLNT) effectively treated LE and lead to better outcomes than controls. Whole ALNGs are superior to fragmented ALNGs. Larger fragments are more likely to be reintegrated into the lymphatic system than small fragments. VLNT was superior to whole and fragmented ALNG. Increasing the number of VLNT resulted in better outcomes. Adipose-derived stem cells improved outcomes of VLNT; vascular endothelial growth factor C and D and platelet-rich plasma improved outcomes for ALNG. Cryopreservation of lymph nodes (LNs) did not affect outcomes for ALNG. The critical ischemia and venous occlusion time for LN flaps were 4-5 and 4 h, respectively. The critical time for reperfusion injury was 2 h. Some of the novel models included venous LNT, and cervical adipocutaneous flap to groin.

CONCLUSION

Current evidence from animals favors VLNT over other surgical interventions. Several pharmacological therapies significantly improved outcomes of ALNG and VLNT.

RELEVANCE TO PATIENTS

LE is a chronic condition affecting millions of patients worldwide. LNTS is becoming more popular as a LE treatment. Animal models have led the LE research for decades and developing new models for LE are essential for LE research. This systematic review aims to summarize the existing animal models dedicated to LNTS. We believe that this review is critical to guide researchers in the selection of the model that is best fit for their hypothesis-driven experiments.

Development of Surgical and Visualization Procedures to Analyze Vasculatures by Mouse Tail Edema Model

Background

Because of the high frequency of chronic edema formation in the current “aged” society, analyses and detailed observation of post-surgical edema are getting more required. Post-surgical examination of the dynamic vasculature including L.V. (Lymphatic Vasculature) to monitor edema formation has not been efficiently performed. Hence, procedures for investigating such vasculature are essential. By inserting transparent sheet into the cutaneous layer of mouse tails as a novel surgery model (theTailEdema bySilicone sheet mediatedTransparency protocol; TEST), the novel procedures are introduced and analyzed by series of histological analyses including video-based L.V. observation and 3D histological reconstruction of vasculatures in mouse tails.

Results

The dynamic generation of post-surgical main and fine (neo) L.V. connective structure during the edematous recovery process was visualized by series of studies with a novel surgery model. Snapshot images taken from live binocular image recording for TEST samples suggested the presence of main and elongating fine (neo) L.V. structure. After the ligation of L.V., the enlargement of main L.V. was confirmed. In the case of light sheet fluorescence microscopy (LSFM) observation, such L.V. connections were also suggested by using transparent 3D samples. Finally, the generation of neo blood vessels particularly in the region adjacent to the silicone sheet and the operated boundary region was suggested in 3D reconstruction images. However, direct detection of elongating fine (neo) L.V. was not suitable for analysis by such LSFM and 3D reconstruction procedures. Thus, such methods utilizing fixed tissues are appropriate for general observation for the operated region including of L.V.

Conclusions

The current surgical procedures and analysis on the post-surgical status are the first case to observe vasculatures in vivo with a transparent sheet. Systematic analyses including the FITC-dextran mediated snap shot images observation suggest the elongation of fine (neo) lymphatic vasculature. Post-surgical analyses including LSFM and 3D histological structural reconstruction, are suitable to reveal the fixed structures of blood and lymphatic vessels formation.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12575-021-00159-3.

A Simple and Quick Method for Decalcification Using Mouse Tail as a Model for Preparation of Lymphedema Study

The disadvantage of 10% EDTA decalcification is a long time-consuming. It needs to identify a quick and straightforward decalcification method when the preparation of lymphedema models using mouse tail which was a sample of bone wrapped in other tissues. In the present study, mouse tail samples were decalcified in 10% EDTA at 25, 37, and 42°C, respectively, with continuous shaking (150 rpm/min). The histologic integrity of samples was evaluated by hematoxylin and eosin staining, and the preservation of antigenicity was tested by either immunohistochemistry or immunofluorescence. The decalcification was distinctly accelerated by temperature. Results of hematoxylin and eosin staining were similar among different temperature groups. Immunohistochemistry and immunofluorescence staining revealed almost no signals in samples decalcified at 42°C for 1 week. Clear signals were detected when samples were decalcified at 37 and 25°C.

A Murine Tail Lymphedema Model

Lymphedema is extremity swelling caused by lymphatic dysfunction. The affected limb enlarges because of accumulation of fluid, adipose, and fibrosis. There is no cure for this disease. A mouse tail model that uses a focal full thickness skin excision near the base of the tail, resulting in tail swelling, has been used to study lymphedema. However, this model may result in vascular comprise and consequent tail necrosis and early tail swelling resolution, limiting its clinical translatability. The chronic murine tail lymphedema model induces sustained lymphedema over 15 weeks and a reliable perfusion to the tail. Enhancements of the traditional murine tail lymphedema model include 1) precise full thickness excision and lymphatic clipping using a surgical microscope, 2) confirmation of post-operative arterial and venous perfusion using high resolution laser speckle, and 3) functional assessment using indocyanine green near infrared laser lymphangiography. We also use tissue nanotransfection technology (TNT) for novel non-viral, transcutaneous, focal delivery of genetic cargo to the mouse tail vasculature.

Potential role of transforming growth factor-beta 1/Smad signaling in secondary lymphedema after cancer surgery

Secondary lymphedema often develops after cancer surgery, and over 250 million patients suffer from this complication. A major symptom of secondary lymphedema is swelling with fibrosis, which lowers the patient's quality of life, even if cancer does not recur. Nonetheless, the pathophysiology of secondary lymphedema remains unclear, with therapeutic approaches limited to physical or surgical therapy. There is no effective pharmacological therapy for secondary lymphedema. Notably, the lack of animal models that accurately mimic human secondary lymphedema has hindered pathophysiological investigations of the disease. Here, we developed a novel rat hindlimb model of secondary lymphedema and showed that our rat model mimics human secondary lymphedema from early to late stages in terms of cell proliferation, lymphatic fluid accumulation, and skin fibrosis. Using our animal model, we investigated the disease progression and found that transforming growth factor‐beta 1 (TGFB1) was produced by macrophages in the acute phase and by fibroblasts in the chronic phase of the disease. TGFB1 promoted the transition of fibroblasts into myofibroblasts and accelerated collagen synthesis, resulting in fibrosis, which further indicates that myofibroblasts and TGFB1/Smad signaling play key roles in fibrotic diseases. Furthermore, the presence of myofibroblasts in skin samples from lymphedema patients after cancer surgery emphasizes the role of these cells in promoting fibrosis. Suppression of myofibroblast‐dependent TGFB1 production may therefore represent an effective pharmacological treatment for inhibiting skin fibrosis in human secondary lymphedema after cancer surgery.

The Unresolved Pathophysiology of Lymphedema

Lymphedema is the clinical manifestation of impaired lymphatic transport. It remains an under-recognized and under-documented clinical condition that still lacks a cure. Despite the substantial advances in the understanding of lymphatic vessel biology and function in the past two decades, there are still unsolved questions regarding the pathophysiology of lymphedema, especially in humans. As a consequence of impaired lymphatic drainage, proteins and lipids accumulate in the interstitial space, causing the regional tissue to undergo extensive and progressive architectural changes, including adipose tissue deposition and fibrosis. These changes are also associated with inflammation. However, the temporal sequence of these events, the relationship between these events, and their interplay during the progression are not clearly understood. Here, we review our current knowledge on the pathophysiology of lymphedema derived from human and animal studies. We also discuss the possible cellular and molecular mechanisms involved in adipose tissue and collagen accumulation during lymphedema. We suggest that more studies should be dedicated to enhancing our understanding of the human pathophysiology of lymphedema to pave the way for new diagnostic and therapeutic avenues for this condition.

EW-7197, a Transforming Growth Factor-Beta Type I Receptor Kinase Inhibitor, Ameliorates Acquired Lymphedema in a Mouse Tail Model

Background: Acquired lymphedema is a common consequence of cancer surgery. Fibrosis is one of the main causes of chronic lymphedema since it hinders lymphatic regeneration and this causes a significant decrease in lymphatic flow and accumulation of excessive protein-rich fluid. The transforming growth factor-β1 (TGF-β1) signaling pathway is known in a process of wound repair and fibrosis. In our study, the purpose was to evaluate the efficacy of EW-7197, a peroral TGF-β type I receptor kinase inhibitor, in treating acquired lymphedema. Methods and Results: For lymphedema mouse tail model, we used 10- to 12-week-old female C57BL/6 mice. The skin was circumferentially excised, making a circular band followed by cauterization of lymphatic collecting vessels. Two groups were made in this study: control and treatment. The treatment group (n = 12) received a solution consisting of 0.1 mL of artificial gastric juice and 20 mg/kg EW-7197 by gavage once daily. For evaluation, tail diameter measurement, fluorescence lymphography, and immunofluorescence images were used. EW-7197 treatment ameliorates acquired lymphedema in a mouse tail model by increasing lymphangiogenesis and interstitial flow of the lymphatics by inhibition of the fibrosis. The differences in maximal tail thicknesses between the control and treatment groups were statistically significant from 2 to 4 weeks after surgery. The treatment group showed a greater number of lymphatic vessels at the surgery site than the control group. The treatment group also showed more FITC coverage area at the surgery site. Conclusion: EW-7197 treatment ameliorates acquired lymphedema in a mouse tail model by increasing lymphangiogenesis and interstitial flow.

Mouse tail models of secondary lymphedema: fibrosis gradually worsens and is irreversible

Although the mouse tail model of secondary lymphedema has been widely used in research, our knowledge regarding some of the characteristic changes in this model is lacking. Therefore, in the current study, we aimed to identify pathologic changes after surgery. Tail lymphedema was created in C57BL/6J mice by disconnecting both superficial and deep lymphatic vessels. The surgery resulted in chronic edema formation with the proliferation of subcutaneous adipose tissue, deposition of fibrotic tissue, and gradual increase in CD4⁺ T lymphocyte infiltration. Furthermore, dramatic expansion and an increased number of lymphatic vessels were observed postoperatively. Lymphatic reflux was established at least 8 weeks after surgery, as evidenced by staining of the scar from the surgical excision. In addition, tissue fibrosis was irreversible, although CD4⁺ T cell infiltration, tail swelling, and subcutaneous adipose hyperplasia were alleviated over time. We also show that necrosis could be effectively avoided by paying attention to several details in the modeling process. As animal models play a key role in exploring the pathophysiology of disease, our findings provide strong support for the study of lymphedema. The irreversibility of fibrosis suggests the importance of treating lymphedema by preventing fibrosis development.