Dynamics of pH-dependent self-association and membrane binding of a dicarboxylic porphyrin: a study with small unilamellar vesicles

Ring-Fused meso-Tetraarylchlorins as Auspicious PDT Sensitizers: Synthesis, Structural Characterization, Photophysics, and Biological Evaluation

Novel 4,5,6,7-tetrahydropyrazolo[1,5-a]pyridine-fused meso-tetraarylchlorins, with different degrees of hydrophilicity (with methyl ester, hydroxymethyl, and carboxylic acid moieties), have been synthesized and their photophysical characterization as well as in vitro photocytotoxicity assessment against human melanoma and esophageal and bladder carcinomas was carried out. An integrated analysis of the photosensitizers’ performance, considering the singlet oxygen generation data, cell internalization, and intracellular localization, allowed to establish relevant structure-photoactivity relationships and the rationalization of the observed photocytotoxicity. In the diacid and monoalcohol series, chlorins derived from meso-tetraphenylporphyrin proved to be the most efficient photodynamic therapy agents, showing IC50 values of 68 and 344 nM against A375 cells, respectively. These compounds were less active against OE19 and HT1376 cells, the diacid chlorin with IC50 values still in the nano-molar range, whereas the monohydroxymethyl-chlorin showed significantly higher IC50 values. The lead di(hydroxymethyl)-substituted meso-tetraphenylchlorin confirmed its remarkable photoactivity with IC50 values below 75 nM against the studied cancer cell lines. Subcellular accumulation of this chlorin in the mitochondria, endoplasmic reticulum, and plasma membrane was demonstrated.

Lipid Unsaturation Properties Govern the Sensitivity of Membranes to Photoinduced Oxidative Stress

Unsaturated lipid oxidation is a fundamental process involved in different aspects of cellular bioenergetics; dysregulation of lipid oxidation is often associated with cell aging and death. To study how lipid oxidation affects membrane biophysics, we used a chlorin photosensitizer to oxidize vesicles of various lipid compositions and degrees of unsaturation in a controlled manner. We observed different shape transitions that can be interpreted as an increase in the area of the targeted membrane followed by a decrease. These area modifications induced by the chemical modification of the membrane upon oxidation were followed in situ by Raman tweezers microspectroscopy. We found that the membrane area increase corresponds to the lipids' peroxidation and is initiated by the delocalization of the targeted double bonds in the tails of the lipids. The subsequent decrease of membrane area can be explained by the formation of cleaved secondary products. As a result of these area changes, we observe vesicle permeabilization after a time lag that is characterized in relation with the level of unsaturation. The evolution of photosensitized vesicle radius was measured and yields an estimation of the mechanical changes of the membrane over oxidation time. The membrane is both weakened and permeabilized by the oxidation. Interestingly, the effect of unsaturation level on the dynamics of vesicles undergoing photooxidation is not trivial and thus carefully discussed. Our findings shed light on the fundamental dynamic mechanisms underlying the oxidation of lipid membranes and highlight the role of unsaturations on their physical and chemical properties.

New insights about the self-aggregation of benzoporphyrin derivatives: A theoretical and experimental investigation

The self-aggregation process and its overcoming remain a barrier for the employment of many molecules as photosensitizers (PS) in photodynamic therapy (PDT). The B-ring isomer co-produced during the synthesis of the Verteporfin[Formula: see text] (A-ring) is an example. Although both isomers possess similar in vitro/in vivo efficiency, the strong and not well-understood self-aggregation process of the B-ring derivative impairs its clinical use. This paper reports the use of theoretical calculus and its correlation with experimental analysis to find the main differences between the A and B-ring isomers. For that purpose, micelles of Pluronic[Formula: see text] P-123 and Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate were chosen as simple membrane models and possible drug delivery system, as in the case of P-123. At physiological pH, the main reason for the high self-aggregation tendency is associated with the higher (22%) molecular volume of the B ring, which increases the van der Waals interactions. However, at mildly acidic conditions, the B ring possesses a shallow dihedral angle between the methyl ester group and the tetrapyrrolic macrocycle that favors the approach of units in the aggregate. These discrepancies directly affect the binding and stability of the isomers in the micelles. However, P-123 micelles were able to readily incorporate and monomerize/stabilize both PS over long periods. NOESY experiments confirmed a deep location of both PS inside P-123 micelles, which justifies their efficiency in preventing the self-aggregation process. These findings may substantiate new studies involving the marginalized B-ring isomers and encourage new development in formulations for their use in PDT.

Self-assembling properties of porphyrinic photosensitizers and their effect on membrane interactions probed by NMR spectroscopy

Aggregation and membrane penetration of porphyrinic photosensitizers play crucial roles for their efficacy in photodynamic therapy. The current study was aimed at comparing the aggregation behavior of selected photosensitizers and correlating it with membrane affinity. Self-assembling properties of 15 amphiphilic free-base chlorin and porphyrin derivatives bearing carboxylate substituents were studied in phosphate buffered saline (PBS) by (1)H NMR spectroscopy, making use of ring current induced aggregation shifts. All compounds exhibited aggregation in PBS to a different degree with dimers or oligomers showing slow aggregate growth over time. Aggregate structures were proposed on the basis of temperature dependent chemical shift changes. All chlorin compounds revealed similar aggregation maps with their hydrophobic sides overlapping and their carboxylate groups protruding toward the exterior. In contrast, for the porphyrin compounds, the carboxylate groups were located in overlapping regions. Membrane interactions were probed using 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC) bilayer vesicles and 1,2-dihexanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DHPC) micelles as models. The chlorin derivatives had higher membrane affinity and were all monomerized by DHPC micelles as opposed to the porphyrin compounds. The observed differences were attributed to the different aggregate structures proposed for the chlorin and porphyrin derivatives. Free accessibility of the carboxylate groups seemed to promote initial surface interaction with phospholipid bilayers and micelles.

Diffusion of chlorin-p6 across phosphatidyl choline liposome bilayer probed by second harmonic generation

We have investigated the diffusion of the photosensitizer Chlorin-p(6) (Cp(6)) across a egg lecithin lipid bilayer at different pH by the Second Harmonic Generation (SHG) method. Cp(6) has three ionizable carboxylic acid groups, and consequently, neutral and several ionic forms of Cp(6) are expected to be present in the pH range 3-8. The absorption spectra of Cp(6) get considerably modified in the presence of liposomes as the pH is decreased indicating that the drug liposome binding is pH dependent. The first pK(a) of interconversion (D-C) has been identified at pH ~7.0 by fluorescence measurement in an earlier work. In this work, the second pK(a) of interconversion (C-B) has been identified at pH ~4.8 by the hyper-Rayleigh scattering method. At acidic pH (3, 4, and 5), where species A, B, and C are dominant, the addition of liposomes to a Cp(6) solution generates an instantaneous rise (less than 1 s) in the second harmonic (SH) signal followed by decays whose time constants ranged from ten to hundreds of seconds. The instantaneous rise is attributed to the adsorption of Cp(6) to the outer lipid bilayer, and the decay is attributed to the diffusion of the neutral and charged (A and B) species of the drug. The observed fast and slow time constants for diffusion in the pH range 3-5 are attributed to the neutral (A) and ionic form (B) of Cp(6), respectively. At pH 6, the intensity of the generated SH signals on the addition of liposome reduced, and at physiological pH, it was too weak to be detected. These results are consistent with previous studies that show that the interaction between Cp(6) and egg-PC liposomes is pH dependent. At lower pH due to the presence of the hydrophobic species (A and B) of Cp(6), its interaction with liposomes is strong, and at higher pH, the abundance of the negatively charged hydrophilic species (C and D) decreases the interaction with the like charged liposomes. We have also studied the effect of increasing the bilayer rigidity by decreasing the temperature of the medium or by incorporating 50 mol % cholesterol in the lipid bilayer and observed that lowering of temperature has more profound effect on the diffusion rates. The characteristics of the SH signal changed significantly when liposomes incorporating 50 mol % cholesterol were used at a low (3 °C) temperature. Under these conditions, the SH signal consisted of an instantaneous (<1s) followed by a slower rise (10-90s), and then, it decayed on a much longer time scale. This slow rise of the SH signal at pH 3 and 4 may be attributed to the temperature dependent adsorption of the anionic species (B) of Cp(6) with the liposomes. Further investigations are required in order to understand clearly the pH dependent diffusion of this drug across lipid bilayers.

Protonation and deprotonation of nitrogens in tetrapyrazino-porphyrazine macrocycles

Acid-base properties of zinc phthalocyanine (Pc) and zinc and metal-free tetrapyrazinoporphyrazine (TPPz) macrocycles with eight peripheral tert-butylsulfanyl or diethylamino substituents are investigated in this work by means of UV-vis spectroscopy. The Pc and TPPz are protonated on the azomethine nitrogens in acidic media. The monoprotonated form was found using trifluoroacetic acid and lower amounts of H 2 SO 4. The higher concentrations of sulfuric acid lead to the appearance of the diprotonated form, and possibly also the triprotonated form in the case of Pc. It was found that the pyrazine nitrogens in the TPPz macrocycle undergo protonation at approx. 20-30% of sulfuric acid in THF solution. TPPz with diethylamino peripheral substituents are protonated preferably on these peripheral tertiary amines. Metal-free TPPz can readily lose the hydrogens on central nitrogens in strong basic media (e.g. tetrabutylammonium hydroxide) to directly form a dianion, with no presence of important or detectable amounts of the monoanion species. A different form of deprotonated macrocycle was observed in pyridine suggesting the formation of only a proton transfer complex, not a true ionic form. The acidity of the central nitrogens is dependent on the strength of the electron-donating effect of peripheral substituents. TPPz with tert-butylsulfanyl substituents is a stronger acid than the one with diethylamino substituents.

Binding and acid-base properties of novel photosensitizing drugs in micellar and liposome solutions

The binding and acid-base equilibria of the two novel mesoporphyrin derivatives, PB07 and PB109 (quino[4,4a,5,6-efg]- annulated 7-demethyl-8-deethylmesoporphyrin and 2'-cyano-8'-formyl-N'-methyl-1',1a',5a',6'-tetrahydroacrido [4,5,5a,6-bcd]- annulated 2,3-dihydromesoporphyrin, resp.), which are promising agents for photodynamic therapy (PDT), were studied in aqueous solutions of different surfactants (Triton X-100 (TX-100), dodecyl maltoside (DDM), cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB), lithium dodecyl sulfate (LDS)) and phosphatidyl choline (PC) liposomes. In all cases, the porphyrins are solubilized at neutral/alkaline pH in monomeric form and remain micelle/liposome-bound independently of their ionization state. The dissociation constants of the solubilized porphyrins are found to be influenced by the charge of the surface groups of the carrier. The protonation of pyrrole/quinoline nitrogens of the studied porphyrins is facilitated in the following order: LDS ≫TX-100 (DDM, PC liposomes) > CTAB. The dissociation constants of PB 07 carboxylic groups are similar in neutral/cationic micellar and liposome solutions and are significantly decreased for LDS-bound pigment. The results provide necessary information for the optimization of delivery systems for PB 07 and PB 109 when applied as sensitizers in PDT.

Synthetic porphyrins bearing β-propionate chains as photosensitizers for photodynamic therapy

Porphyrins with different numbers of β-propionate chains mimicking natural porphyrins were prepared via the 2+2 MacDonald type approach. Photodynamic activity against WiDr colon adenocarcinoma cells showed that activity is related to the number of β-propionate chains, with the derivatives with two carboxylic groups showing higher activity.

pH-dependent distribution of chlorin e6 derivatives across phospholipid bilayers probed by NMR spectroscopy

The pH-dependent membrane adsorption and distribution of three chlorin derivatives, chlorin e6 (CE), rhodin G7 (RG), and monoaspartyl-chlorin e6 (MACE), in the physiological pH range (pH 6-8) were probed by NMR spectroscopy. Unilamellar vesicles consisting of dioleoyl-phosphatidyl-choline (DOPC) were used as membrane models. The chlorin derivatives were characterized with respect to their aggregation behavior, the pK(a) values of individual carboxylate groups, the extent of membrane adsorption, and their flip-flop rates across the bilayer membrane for pH 6-8. External membrane adsorption was found to be lower for RG than for CE and MACE. Both electrostatic interactions and the extent of aggregation seemed to be the main determinants of membrane adsorption. Rate constants for chlorin transfer across the membrane were found to correlate strongly with the pH of the surrounding medium, in particular, for CE and RG. In acidic solution, CE and RG transfer across the membrane was strongly accelerated, and in basic solution, all compounds were retained, mostly in the outer monolayer. In contrast, MACE flip-flop across the membrane remained very low even at pH 6. The protonation of ionizable groups is suggested to be a major determinant of chlorin transfer rates across the bilayer. pK(a) values of CE and RG were found to be between 6 and 8, and two of the carboxylate groups in MACE had pK(a) values below 6. For CE and RG, the kinetic profiles at acidic pH indicated that the initial fast membrane distribution was followed by secondary steps that are discussed in this article.

Time-dependent interactions of the two porphyrinic compounds chlorin e6 and mono-L-aspartyl-chlorin e6 with phospholipid vesicles probed by NMR spectroscopy

The distribution processes of chlorin e6 (CE) and monoaspartyl-chlorin e6 (MACE) between the outer and inner phospholipid monolayers of 1,2-dioleoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DOPC) vesicles were monitored by 1H NMR spectroscopy through analysis of chemical shifts and line widths of the DOPC vesicle resonances. Chlorin adsorption to the outer vesicle monolayer induced changes in the DOPC 1H NMR spectrum. Most pronounced was a split of the N-methyl choline resonance, allowing for separate analysis of inner and outer vesicle layers. Transbilayer distribution of the chlorin compounds was indicated by time-dependent characteristic spectral changes of the DOPC resonances. Kinetic parameters for the flip-flop processes, that is, half-lives and rate constants, were obtained from the experimental data points. In comparison to CE, MACE transbilayer movement was significantly reduced, with MACE remaining more or less attached to the outer membrane layer. The distribution coefficients for CE and MACE between the vesicular and aqueous phase were determined. Both CE and MACE exhibited a high affinity for the vesicular phase. For CE, a positive correlation was found between transfer rate and increasing molar ratio CE/DOPC. Enhanced membrane rigidity induced by increasing amounts of cholesterol into the model membrane was accompanied by a decrease of CE flip-flop rates across the membrane. The present study shows that the movement of porphyrins across membranes can efficiently be investigated by 1H NMR spectroscopy and that small changes in porphyrin structure can have large effects on membrane kinetics.

Cellular uptake and subcellular distribution of chlorin e6 as functions of pH and interactions with membranes and lipoproteins

The uptake and more importantly the subcellular distribution of photosensitizers are major determinants of their efficacy. In this paper, the cellular internalization of chlorin e6 (Ce6), a photosensitizer bearing three carboxylic chains, is considered with emphasize on pH effects. Small unilamellar vesicles are used as models to investigate the dynamics of interactions of Ce6 with membranes. The entrance and exit steps from the outer lipid hemileaflet are very fast (~ms). A slow transfer of Ce6 through the membrane was observed only for thin bilayers made of dimyristoleoyl-phosphatidylcholine. Ce6 did not permeate through bilayers consisting of longer phospholipids more representative of biological membranes. These results along with previous data on the interactions of Ce6 with low-density lipoproteins (LDL) are correlated with cellular studies. After 15 min incubation of HS68 human fibroblasts with Ce6, fluorescence microscopy revealed labeling of the plasma membrane and cytosolic vesicles different from lysosomes. When vectorized by LDL, Ce6 was mainly localized in lysosomes but absent from the plasma membrane. Internalization of LDL bound photosensitizer via ApoB/E receptor mediated pathway was demonstrated by overexpression experiments. A pH decrease from 7.4 to 6.9 did not affect the intracellular distribution of Ce6, but significantly increased its overall cellular uptake.

Structural and physico-chemical determinants of the interactions of macrocyclic photosensitizers with cells

New therapies have been developed using reactive oxygen species produced by light-activation of photosensitizers (PS). Since the lifetime of these species is extremely short and their diffusion in space is limited, the photo-induced reactions primarily affect the cell organelles labeled by the PS. In addition to the development of molecules with the best optical and photosensitizing properties, considerable research has been done to understand the physico-chemical parameters governing their subcellular localization. In this review, we examine these parameters to establish the structure/efficacy relationships, which allow specific targeting of PS. We examine the effect of subcellular localization on the cellular response to photosensitization processes. We discuss the determinants of subcellular localization, including the hydrophobic/hydrophilic balance, the specific charge effects and the dynamics of PS' transfer through membranes. Specific targeting can also be achieved with molecular structures able to recognize cellular or intracellular receptors, and this is also dealt with in this paper.

The pH-dependent distribution of the photosensitizer chlorin e6 among plasma proteins and membranes: a physico-chemical approach

Decrease in interstitial pH of the tumor stroma and over-expression of low density lipoprotein (LDL) receptors by several types of neoplastic cells have been suggested to be important determinants of selective retention of photosensitizers by proliferative tissues. The interactions of chlorin e6 (Ce6), a photosensitizer bearing three carboxylic groups, with plasma proteins and DOPC unilamellar vesicles are investigated by fluorescence spectroscopy. The binding constant to liposomes, with reference to the DOPC concentration, is 6 x 10(3) M(-1) at pH 7.4. Binding of Ce6 to LDL involves about ten high affinity sites close to the apoprotein and some solubilization in the lipid compartment. The overall association constant is 5.7 x 10(7) M(-1) at pH 7.4. Human serum albumin (HSA) is the major carrier (association constant 1.8 x 10(8) M(-1) at pH 7.4). Whereas the affinity of Ce6 for LDL and liposomes increases at lower pH, it decreases for albumin. Between pH 7.4 and 6.5, the relative affinities of Ce6 for LDL versus HSA, and for membranes versus HSA, are multiplied by 4.6 and 3.5, respectively. These effects are likely driven by the ionization equilibria of the photosensitizer carboxylic chains. Then, the cellular uptake of chlorin e6 may be facilitated by its pH-mediated redistribution within the tumor stroma.

Proton NMR detection of porphyrins and cytochrome C in small unilamellar vesicles: role of the dissociation kinetic constant

The molecular tumbling of small unilamellar vesicles is not fast enough to enable the detection of (1)H NMR signals of molecules associated with phospholipids. We show that relatively fast kinetic exchange of the interacting molecules is able to induce a strong decrease of the residual homonuclear dipolar coupling, allowing the acquisition of sharp signals. At low molecule/lipids molecular ratio, this can be lead to signal broadening due to exchange at intermediate rates on the NMR chemical timescale. However, proton resonances can be easily detected when sufficient lipids are added to prevent the occurrence of any free compounds in solution. This is demonstrated, using lipid signal suppression, in the case of paramagnetic porphyrin derivatives as well as diamagnetic hematoporphyrin. Since several peptides and proteins are expected to be associated with lipids having relatively fast dynamics, this study addresses, as a first example, the interaction of cytochrome c.

The Influence of Aggregation of Porphyrins on the Efficiency of Photogeneration of Hydrogen Peroxide in Aqueous Solution

The pH-dependence of the ability of coproporphyrin (CP) and uroporphyrin (UP) to photogenerate hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) in aqueous solution was investigated, with special attention to the structure-activity relationship related to the aggregation of the porphyrins. It was found that the efficiency was strongly dependent on the aggregation of CP and UP mediated by changes in the pH of the solution, and a dimeric form had a weak ability to produce H2O2, while a highly aggregated form had a good ability. The increased efficiency of the highly aggregated porphyrin to produce H2O2 was further demonstrated using a different type of aggregate formed by the electrostatic interaction of cationic tetrakis-5,10,15,20-(N-methyl-4-pyridyl)porphin (TMPyP) with anionic tetrakis-5,10,15,20-(4-sulfonatophenyl)porphin (TSPP). The present results demonstrated the importance of the state of aggregation of porphyrin to photogenerate H2O2, and the results may help to develop a new type of medicine for photodynamic therapy.

Dynamics of interactions of photosensitizers with lipoproteins and membrane-models: correlation with cellular incorporation and subcellular distribution

The incorporation and subcellular localization of photosensitizers are critical determinants of their efficiency. Here, we correlate these properties with the interactions of photosensitizers with membrane-models and low density lipoproteins (LDL) in acellular systems. Focus was given on dynamics aspects. Two amphiphilic photosensitizers, deuteroporphyrin (DP) and aluminum phthalocyanine sulfonated on two adjacent isoindole units (AlPcS2a) were selected. The phthalocyanine was bound to LDL with an overall association constant around 5 x 10(7)M(-1). Biphasic association kinetics was indicative of two types of sites. The release of the phthalocyanine into the bulk aqueous medium occurred within less than a second. A similar behavior was found previously for deuteroporphyrin although its affinity was somewhat higher (5.5 x 10(8)M(-1)). Both compounds were previously characterized by high affinity for membrane-models and quick exchange with the bulk solution. However, they strongly differed by their rate of transfer through the lipid bilayer, in the range of seconds for the porphyrin, several hours for the phthalocyanine. In the case of the porphyrin, fluorescence microscopy on human fibroblasts showed diffuse labeling with no significant modification of the distribution upon vectorization by LDL. In contrast, the phthalocyanine was localized in intracellular vesicles. Vectorization by LDL favored lysosomal localization although little effect was found on the overall uptake as shown by extraction experiments. The role of lipoproteins in the cellular localization of photosensitizers is significantly more important for photosensitizers not freely diffusing through bilayers. The dynamics of the interactions of photosensitizers with membranes appears as an important determinant of their subcellular localization.

Biosynthesis and alternate targeting of the lysosomal cysteine protease cathepsin L

Upregulation of cathepsin L expression, whether during development or cell transformation, or mediated by ectopic expression from a plasmid, alters the targeting of the protease and thus its physiological function. Upregulated procathepsin L is targeted to small dense core vesicles and to the dense cores of multivesicular bodies, as well as to lysosomes and to the plasma membrane for selective secretion. The multivesicular vesicles resemble secretory lysosomes characterized in specialized cell types in that they are endosomes that stably store an upregulated protein and they possess the tetraspanin CD63. Morphologically the multivesicular endosomes also resemble late endosomes, but they store procathepsin L, not the active protease, and they are not the major site for LAMP-1 accumulation. Distinction between the lysosomal proenzyme and active protease thus identifies two populations of multivesicular endosomes in fibroblasts, one a storage compartment and one an enzymatically active compartment. A distinctive targeting pathway using aggregation is utilized to enrich the storage endosomes with a particular lysosomal protease that can potentially activate and be secreted.