Intra- and intersubunit changes accompanying thermal activation of the HtrA2(Omi) protease homotrimer

Inter-subunit crosstalk via PDZ synergistically governs allosteric activation of proapoptotic HtrA2

The mitochondrial serine protease High-temperature requirement A2 (HtrA2) is associated with various diseases including neurodegenerative disorders and cancer. Despite availability of structural details, the reports on HtrA2's mechanistic regulation that varies with the type of activation signals still remain non-concordant. To expound the role of regulatory PDZ (Postsynaptic density-95/Discs large/Zonula occludens-1) domains in multimodal activation of HtrA2, we generated heterotrimeric HtrA2 variants comprising different numbers of PDZs and/or active-site mutations. Sequential deletion of PDZs from the trimeric ensemble significantly affected its residual activity in a way that proffered a hypothesis advocating inter-molecular allosteric crosstalk via PDZs in HtrA2. Furthermore, structural and computational snapshots affirmed the role of PDZs in secondary structural element formation around the regulatory loops and coordinated reorganization of the N-terminal region. Therefore, apart from providing cues for devising structure-guided therapeutic strategies, this study establishes a physiologically relevant working model of complex allosteric regulation through a trans-mediated cooperatively shared energy landscape.

Role of conserved regulatory loop residues in allosteric propagation of serine protease HtrA2

High temperature requirement protease A2 (HtrA2) is a mitochondrial serine protease that demonstrates multifaceted roles including protein quality control and proapoptotic properties in humans, making it a potential therapeutic target. Current literature suggests involvement of flexible regulatory loops in governing the allosteric propagation within the trimeric HtrA2 ensemble. Here, we have identified three important residues - R147, P148 (L3 loop) and F131 (LD loop) surrounding the catalytic-site that play crucial roles in stabilizing HtrA2 active conformation during its multimodal activation. Although mutagenesis of these residues does not affect the structural integrity, it renders the protease inactive by affecting the regulatory inter-subunit PDZ-protease crosstalk. This is further emphasized by the inactivity observed during N-terminal mediated activation of the HtrA2 loop mutants via BIR2 domain of the antiapoptotic protein XIAP. Overall, our results demonstrate the importance of L3 loop dynamics in mediating the inter-molecular allostery via R147-P148 residues. Understanding the on-off switch that regulates HtrA2 activation might help in designing HtrA2 modulators for therapeutic applications.

Unraveling the Dichotomy of Enigmatic Serine Protease HtrA2

Mitochondrial high-temperature requirement protease A2 (HtrA2) is an integral member of the HtrA family of serine proteases that are evolutionarily conserved from prokaryotes to humans. Involvement in manifold intricate cellular networks and diverse pathophysiological functions make HtrA2 the most enigmatic moonlighting protease amongst the human HtrAs. Despite perpetuating the oligomeric architecture and overall structural fold of its homologs that comprises serine protease and regulatory PDZ domains, subtle conformational alterations and dynamic enzymatic regulation through the distinct allosteric mode of action lead to its functional diversity. This mitochondrial protease upon maturation, exposes its one-of-a-kind N-terminal tetrapeptide (AVPS) motif that binds and subsequently cleaves Inhibitor of Apoptosis Proteins (IAPs) thus promoting cell death, and posing as an important molecule for therapeutic intervention. Interestingly, unlike its other human counterparts, HtrA2 has also been implicated in maintaining the mitochondrial integrity through a bi-functional chaperone-protease activity, the on-off switch of which is yet to be identified. Furthermore, its ability to activate a wide repertoire of substrates through both its N- and C-terminal regions presumably has calibrated its association with several cellular pathways and hence diseases including neurodegenerative disorders and cancer. Therefore, the exclusive structural attributes of HtrA2 that involve multimodal activation, intermolecular PDZ-protease crosstalk, and an allosterically-modulated trimeric active-site ensemble have enabled the protease to evolve across species and partake functions that are fine-tuned for maintaining cellular homeostasis and mitochondrial proteome quality control in humans. These unique features along with its multitasking potential make HtrA2 a promising therapeutic target both in cancer and neurodegeneration.

Cellular substrates and pro-apoptotic function of the human HtrA4 protease

The human HtrA4 protein, belonging to the HtrA family of proteases/chaperones, participates in oncogenesis and placentation, and plays a role in preeclampsia. As the knowledge concerning the biochemical features of this protein and its role at the molecular level is limited, in this work we characterized the HtrA4 molecule and searched for its cellular function. We found that recombinant HtrA4 composed of the protease and PDZ domains is a trimeric protein of intermediate thermal stability whose activity is considerably lower compared to other human HtrA proteases. By pull-down combined with mass spectrometry we identified a large array of potential HtrA4 partners. Using other experimental approaches, including immunoprecipitation, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and fluorescence microscopy we confirmed that HtrA4 formed complexes in vitro and in cellulo with proteins such as XIAP (inhibitor of apoptosis protein), caspases 7 and 9, β-tubulin, actin, TCP1α and S100A6. The recombinant HtrA4 degraded XIAP, the caspases, β-tubulin and actin but not TCP1α or S100A6. Together, these results suggest that HtrA4 may influence various cellular functions, including apoptosis. Furthermore, the panel of potential HtrA4 partners may serve as a basis for future studies of HtrA4 function.

The HtrA3 protease promotes drug-induced death of lung cancer cells by cleavage of the X-linked inhibitor of apoptosis protein (XIAP)

HtrA3 is a proapoptotic protease shown to promote drug-induced cytotoxicity in lung cancer cells and proposed to have an antitumor effect. However, at the molecular level, the role of HtrA3 in cell death induction is poorly understood. There are two HtrA3 isoforms, a long and a short one, termed HtrA3L and HtrA3S. By performing pull down assays, co-immunoprecipitation and ELISA, we showed that HtrA3 formed complexes with the X-linked inhibitor of apoptosis protein (XIAP). The recombinant HtrA3 variants ΔN-HtrA3L and -S, lacking the N-terminal regions that are not essential for protease activity, cleaved XIAP with a comparable efficiency, though ΔN-HtrA3S was more active in the presence of cellular extract, suggesting the existence of an activating factor. Immunofluorescence and proximity ligation assays indicated that HtrA3 partially co-localized with XIAP. Exogenous ΔN-HtrA3L/S promoted apoptotic death of lung cancer cells treated with etoposide and caused a significant decrease of cellular XIAP levels, in a way dependent on HtrA3 proteolytic activity. These results collectively indicate that both HtrA3 isoforms stimulate drug-induced apoptotic death of lung cancer cells via XIAP cleavage and thus help to understand the molecular mechanism of HtrA3 function in apoptosis and in cancer cell death caused by chemotherapy.

Properties of the HtrA Protease From Bacterium Helicobacter pylori Whose Activity Is Indispensable for Growth Under Stress Conditions

The protease high temperature requirement A from the gastric pathogen Helicobacter pylori (HtrA_Hp) belongs to the well conserved family of serine proteases. HtrA_Hp is an important secreted virulence factor involved in the disruption of tight and adherens junctions during infection. Very little is known about the function of HtrA_Hp in the H. pylori cell physiology due to the lack of htrA knockout strains. Here, using a newly constructed ΔhtrA mutant strain, we found that bacteria deprived of HtrA_Hp showed increased sensitivity to certain types of stress, including elevated temperature, pH and osmotic shock, as well as treatment with puromycin. These data indicate that HtrA_Hp plays a protective role in the H. pylori cell, presumably associated with maintenance of important periplasmic and outer membrane proteins. Purified HtrA_Hp was shown to be very tolerant to a wide range of temperature and pH values. Remarkably, the protein exhibited a very high thermal stability with the melting point (T_m) values of above 85°C. Moreover, HtrA_Hp showed the capability to regain its active structure following treatment under denaturing conditions. Taken together, our work demonstrates that HtrA_Hp is well adapted to operate under harsh conditions as an exported virulence factor, but also inside the bacterial cell as an important component of the protein quality control system in the stressed cellular envelope.

HtrA3 is a cellular partner of cytoskeleton proteins and TCP1α chaperonin

The human HtrA3 protease is involved in placentation, mitochondrial homeostasis, stimulation of apoptosis and proposed to be a tumor suppressor. Molecular mechanisms of the HtrA3 functions are poorly understood and knowledge concerning its cellular targets is very limited. There are two HtrA3 isoforms, the long (HtrA3L) and short (HtrA3S). Upon stress, their N-terminal domains are removed, resulting in the more active ΔN-HtrA3. By pull down and mass spectrometry techniques, we identified a panel of putative ΔN-HtrA3L/S substrates. We confirmed that ΔN-HtrA3L/S formed complexes with actin, β-tubulin, vimentin and TCP1α in vitro and in a cell and partially co-localized with the actin and vimentin filaments, microtubules and TCP1α in a cell. In vitro, both isoforms cleaved the cytoskeleton proteins, promoted tubulin polymerization and displayed chaperone-like activity, with ΔN-HtrA3S being more efficient in proteolysis and ΔN-HtrA3L - in polymerization. TCP1α, essential for the actin and tubulin folding, was directly bound by the ΔN-HtrA3L/S but not cleaved. These results indicate that actin, β-tubulin, vimentin, and TCP1α are HtrA3 cellular partners and suggest that HtrA3 may influence cytoskeleton dynamics. They also suggest different roles of the HtrA3 isoforms and a possibility that HtrA3 protease may also function as a co-chaperone.

SIGNIFICANCE

The HtrA3 protease stimulates apoptosis and is proposed to be a tumor suppressor and a therapeutic target, however little is known about its function at the molecular level and very few HtrA3 physiological substrates have been identified so far. Furthermore, HtrA3 is the only member of the HtrA family of proteins which, apart from the long isoform possessing the PD and PDZ domains (HtrA3L), has a short isoform (HtrA3S) lacking the PDZ domain. In this work we identified a large panel (about 150) of the tentative HtrA3L/S cellular partners which provides a good basis for further research concerning the HtrA3 function. We have shown that the cytoskeleton proteins actin, β-tubulin and vimentin, and the TCP1α chaperonin are cellular partners of both HtrA3 isoforms. Our findings indicate that HtrA3 may promote destabilization of the actin and vimentin cytoskeleton and suggest that it may influence the dynamics of the microtubule network, with the HtrA3S being more efficient in cytoskeleton protein cleavage and HtrA3L - in tubulin polymerization. Also, we have shown for the first time that HtrA3 has a chaperone-like, holdase activity in vitro - activity typical for co-chaperone proteins. The proposed HtrA3 influence on the cytoskeleton dynamics may be one of the ways in which HtrA3 promotes cell death and affects cancerogenesis. We believe that the results of this study provide a new insight into the role of HtrA3 in a cell and further confirm the notion that HtrA3 should be considered as a target of new anti-cancer therapies.

The crystal structure of Deg9 reveals a novel octameric-type HtrA protease

The high temperature requirement A (HtrA) proteases (also termed Deg proteases) play important roles in diverse organisms by regulating protein quality and quantity. One of the 16 Arabidopsis homologs, Deg9, is located in the nucleus where it modulates cytokinin- and light-mediated signalling via degrading the ARABIDOPSIS RESPONSE REGULATOR 4 (ARR4). To uncover the structural features underlying the proteolytic activity of Deg9, we determined its crystal structure. Unlike the well-established trimeric building block of HtrAs, Deg9 displays a novel octameric structure consisting of two tetrameric rings that have distinct conformations. Based on the structural architecture, we generated several mutant variants of Deg9, determined their structure and tested their proteolytic activity towards ARR4. The results of the structural and biochemical analyses allowed us to propose a model for a novel mechanism of substrate recognition and activity regulation of Deg9. In this model, protease activation of one tetramer is mediated by en-bloc reorientation of the protease domains to open an entrance for the substrate in the opposite (inactive) tetramer. This study provides the structural basis for understanding how the levels of nuclear signal components are regulated by a plant protease.

Biochemical properties of the HtrA homolog from bacterium Stenotrophomonas maltophilia

The HtrA proteins due to their proteolytic, and in many cases chaperone activity, efficiently counteract consequences of stressful conditions. In the environmental bacterium and nosocomial pathogen Stenotrophomonas maltophilia HtrA (HtrA_Sm) is induced as a part of adaptive response to host temperature (37°C). We examined the biochemical properties of HtrA_Sm and compared them with those of model HtrA_Ec from Escherichia coli. We found that HtrA_Sm is a protease and chaperone that operates over a wide range of pH and is highly active at temperatures between 35 and 37°C. The temperature-sensitive activity corresponded well with the lower thermal stability of the protein and weaker stability of the oligomer. Interestingly, the enzyme shows slightly different substrate cleavage specificity when compared to other bacterial HtrAs. A computational model of the three-dimensional structure of HtrA_Sm indicates differences in the S1 substrate specificity pocket and suggests weaker inter-trimer interactions when compared to HtrA_Ec. The observed features of HtrA_Sm suggest that this protein may play a protective role under stressful conditions acting both as a protease and a chaperone. The optimal temperatures for the protein activity may reflect the evolutionary adaptation of S. maltophilia to life in soil or aqueous environments, where the temperatures are usually much below 37°C.

Molecular motion regulates the activity of the Mitochondrial Serine Protease HtrA2

HtrA2 (high-temperature requirement 2) is a human mitochondrial protease that has a role in apoptosis and Parkinson's disease. The structure of HtrA2 with an intact catalytic triad was determined, revealing a conformational change in the active site loops, involving mainly the regulatory LD loop, which resulted in burial of the catalytic serine relative to the previously reported structure of the proteolytically inactive mutant. Mutations in the loops surrounding the active site that significantly restricted their mobility, reduced proteolytic activity both in vitro and in cells, suggesting that regulation of HtrA2 activity cannot be explained by a simple transition to an activated conformational state with enhanced active site accessibility. Manipulation of solvent viscosity highlighted an unusual bi-phasic behavior of the enzymatic activity, which together with MD calculations supports the importance of motion in the regulation of the activity of HtrA2. HtrA2 is an unusually thermostable enzyme (T_M=97.3 °C), a trait often associated with structural rigidity, not dynamic motion. We suggest that this thermostability functions to provide a stable scaffold for the observed loop motions, allowing them a relatively free conformational search within a rather restricted volume.

Selection of Effective HTRA3 Activators Using Combinatorial Chemistry

Herein, we report selection, synthesis, and enzymatic evaluation of a peptidomimetic library able to increase proteolytic activity of HtrA3 (high temperature requirement A) protease. Iterative deconvolution in solution of synthesized modified pentapeptides yielded two potent HtrA3 activators acting in the micromolar range (HCOO-CH₂O-C₆H₄-OCH₂-CO-Tyr-Asn-Phe-His-Asn-OH and HCOO-CH₂O-C₆H₄-OCH₂-CO-Tyr-Asn-Phe-His-Glu-OH). Both compounds increased proteolysis of an artificial HtrA3 substrate over 40-fold in a selective manner. On the basis of molecular modeling, the selected compounds bind strongly to the PDZ domain.

Structural insights into the activation mechanisms of human HtrA serine proteases

Human HtrA1-4 proteins belong to the HtrA family of evolutionarily conserved serine proteases and function as important modulators of many physiological processes, including maintenance of mitochondrial homeostasis, cell signaling and apoptosis. Disturbances in their action are linked to severe diseases, including oncogenesis and neurodegeneration. The HtrA1-4 proteins share structural and functional features of other members of the HtrA protein family, however there are several significant differences in structural architecture and mechanisms of action which makes each of them unique. Our goal is to present recent studies regarding human HtrAs. We focus on their physiological functions, structure and regulation, and describe current models of activation mechanisms. Knowledge of molecular basis of the human HtrAs' action is a subject of great interest; it is crucial for understanding their relevance in cellular physiology and pathogenesis as well as for using them as targets in future therapies of diseases such as neurodegenerative disorders and cancer.

Distinct 3D Architecture and Dynamics of the Human HtrA2(Omi) Protease and Its Mutated Variants

HtrA2(Omi) protease controls protein quality in mitochondria and plays a major role in apoptosis. Its HtrA2^S306A mutant (with the catalytic serine routinely disabled for an X-ray study to avoid self-degradation) is a homotrimer whose subunits contain the serine protease domain (PD) and the regulatory PDZ domain. In the inactive state, a tight interdomain interface limits penetration of both PDZ-activating ligands and PD substrates into their respective target sites. We successfully crystalized HtrA2^V226K/S306A, whose active counterpart HtrA2^V226K has had higher proteolytic activity, suggesting higher propensity to opening the PD-PDZ interface than that of the wild type HtrA2. Yet, the crystal structure revealed the HtrA2^V226K/S306A architecture typical of the inactive protein. To get a consistent interpretation of crystallographic data in the light of kinetic results, we employed molecular dynamics (MD). V325D inactivating mutant was used as a reference. Our simulations demonstrated that upon binding of a specific peptide ligand NH₂-GWTMFWV-COOH, the PDZ domains open more dynamically in the wild type protease compared to the V226K mutant, whereas the movement is not observed in the V325D mutant. The movement relies on a PDZ vs. PD rotation which opens the PD-PDZ interface in a lid-like (budding flower-like in trimer) fashion. The noncovalent hinges A and B are provided by two clusters of interfacing residues, harboring V325D and V226K in the C- and N-terminal PD barrels, respectively. The opening of the subunit interfaces progresses in a sequential manner during the 50 ns MD simulation. In the systems without the ligand only minor PDZ shifts relative to PD are observed, but the interface does not open. Further activation-associated events, e.g. PDZ-L3 positional swap seen in any active HtrA protein (vs. HtrA2), were not observed. In summary, this study provides hints on the mechanism of activation of wtHtrA2, the dynamics of the inactive HtrA2^V325D, but does not allow to explain an increased activity of HtrA2^V226K.