Crystal structure and DNA-binding property of the ATPase domain of bacterial mismatch repair endonuclease MutL from Aquifex aeolicus

Identification of a Catalytic Lysine Residue Conserved Among GHKL ATPases: MutL, GyrB, and MORC

DNA mismatch repair endonuclease MutL is a member of GHKL ATPase superfamily. Mutations of MutL homologs are causative of a hereditary cancer, Lynch syndrome. We characterized MutL homologs from human and a hyperthermophile, Aquifex aeolicus, (aqMutL) to reveal the catalytic mechanism for the ATPase activity. Although involvement of a basic residue had not been conceived in the catalytic mechanism, analysis of the pH dependence of the aqMutL ATPase activity revealed that the reaction is catalyzed by a residue with an alkaline pKa. Analyses of mutant aqMutLs showed that Lys79 is the catalytic residue, and the corresponding residues were confirmed to be critical for activities of human MutL homologs, on the basis of which a catalytic mechanism for MutL ATPase is proposed. These and other results described here would contribute to evaluating the pathogenicity of Lynch syndrome-associated missense mutations. Furthermore, it was confirmed that the catalytic lysine residue is conserved among DNA gyrases and microrchidia ATPases, other members of GHKL ATPases, indicating that the catalytic mechanism proposed here is applicable to these members of the superfamily.

An extensive ion-pair/hydrogen-bond network contributes to the thermostability of the MutL ATPase domain from Aquifex aeolicus

Proteins from hyperthermophiles often contain a large number of ionic interactions. Close examination of the previously determined crystal structure of the ATPase domain of MutL from a hyperthermophile, Aquifex aeolicus, revealed that the domain contains a continuous ion-pair/hydrogen-bond network consisting of 11 charged amino acid residues on a β-sheet. Mutations were introduced to disrupt the network, showing that the more extensively the network was disrupted, the greater the thermostability of the protein was decreased. Based on urea denaturation analysis, a thermodynamic parameter, energy for the conformational stability, was evaluated, which indicated that amino acid residues in the network contributed additively to the protein stability. A continuous network rather than a cluster of isolated interactions would pay less entropic penalty upon fixing the side chains to make the same number of ion pairs/hydrogen bonds, which might contribute more favorably to the structural formation of thermostable proteins.

Insights into DNA cleavage by MutL homologs from analysis of conserved motifs in eukaryotic Mlh1

MutL family proteins contain an N-terminal ATPase domain (NTD), an unstructured interdomain linker, and a C-terminal domain (CTD), which mediates constitutive dimerization between subunits and often contains an endonuclease active site. Most MutL homologs direct strand-specific DNA mismatch repair by cleaving the error-containing daughter DNA strand. The strand cleavage reaction is poorly understood; however, the structure of the endonuclease active site is consistent with a two- or three-metal ion cleavage mechanism. A motif required for this endonuclease activity is present in the unstructured linker of Mlh1 and is conserved in all eukaryotic Mlh1 proteins, except those from metamonads, which also lack the almost absolutely conserved Mlh1 C-terminal phenylalanine-glutamate-arginine-cysteine (FERC) sequence. We hypothesize that the cysteine in the FERC sequence is autoinhibitory, as it sequesters the active site. We further hypothesize that the evolutionary co-occurrence of the conserved linker motif with the FERC sequence indicates a functional interaction, possibly by linker motif-mediated displacement of the inhibitory cysteine. This role is consistent with available data for interactions between the linker motif with DNA and the CTDs in the vicinity of the active site.

Responses of DNA Mismatch Repair Proteins to a Stable G-Quadruplex Embedded into a DNA Duplex Structure

DNA mismatch repair (MMR) plays a crucial role in the maintenance of genomic stability. The main MMR protein, MutS, was recently shown to recognize the G-quadruplex (G4) DNA structures, which, along with regulatory functions, have a negative impact on genome integrity. Here, we studied the effect of G4 on the DNA-binding activity of MutS from Rhodobacter sphaeroides (methyl-independent MMR) in comparison with MutS from Escherichia coli (methyl-directed MMR) and evaluated the influence of a G4 on the functioning of other proteins involved in the initial steps of MMR. For this purpose, a new DNA construct was designed containing a biologically relevant intramolecular stable G4 structure flanked by double-stranded regions with the set of DNA sites required for MMR initiation. The secondary structure of this model was examined using NMR spectroscopy, chemical probing, fluorescent indicators, circular dichroism, and UV spectroscopy. The results unambiguously showed that the d(GGGT)₄ motif, when embedded in a double-stranded context, adopts a G4 structure of a parallel topology. Despite strong binding affinities of MutS and MutL for a G4, the latter is not recognized by E. coli MMR as a signal for repair, but does not prevent MMR processing when a G4 and G/T mismatch are in close proximity.

A Lynch syndrome-associated mutation at a Bergerat ATP-binding fold destabilizes the structure of the DNA mismatch repair endonuclease MutL

In humans, mutations in genes encoding homologs of the DNA mismatch repair endonuclease MutL cause a hereditary cancer that is known as Lynch syndrome. Here, we determined the crystal structures of the N-terminal domain (NTD) of MutL from the thermophilic eubacterium Aquifex aeolicus (aqMutL) complexed with ATP analogs at 1.69-1.73 Å. The structures revealed significant structural similarities to those of a human MutL homolog, postmeiotic segregation increased 2 (PMS2). We introduced five Lynch syndrome-associated mutations clinically found in human PMS2 into the aqMutL NTD and investigated the protein stability, ATPase activity, and DNA-binding ability of these protein variants. Among the mutations studied, the most unexpected results were obtained for the residue Ser34. Ser34 (Ser46 in PMS2) is located at a previously identified Bergerat ATP-binding fold. We found that the S34I aqMutL NTD retains ATPase and DNA-binding activities. Interestingly, CD spectrometry and trypsin-limited proteolysis indicated the disruption of a secondary structure element of the S34I NTD, destabilizing the overall structure of the aqMutL NTD. In agreement with this, the recombinant human PMS2 S46I NTD was easily digested in the host Escherichia coli cells. Moreover, other mutations resulted in reduced DNA-binding or ATPase activity. In summary, using the thermostable aqMutL protein as a model molecule, we have experimentally determined the effects of the mutations on MutL endonuclease; we discuss the pathological effects of the corresponding mutations in human PMS2.

Probing the DNA-binding center of the MutL protein from the Escherichia coli mismatch repair system via crosslinking and Förster resonance energy transfer

As no crystal structure of full-size MutL bound to DNA has been obtained up to date, in the present work we used crosslinking and Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) assays for probing the putative DNA-binding center of MutL from Escherichia coli. Several single-cysteine MutL variants (scMutL) were used for site-specific crosslinking or fluorophore modification. The crosslinking efficiency between scMutL proteins and mismatched DNA modified with thiol-reactive probes correlated with the distances from the Cys residues to the DNA calculated from a model of MutS-MutL-DNA complex. FRET-based investigation of DNA binding with different scMutL variants clearly showed that the highest signals were detected for the variants MutL(T218C) and MutL(A251C) indicating closeness of the positions 218 and 251 to DNA in the MutL-DNA complex. Indeed, the Cys218 and Cys251 of scMutL were crosslinked to the reactive DNA with the highest yield demonstrating their proximity to DNA in the MutL-DNA complex. The presence of MutS increased the yield of conjugate formation between the MutL variants and the modified DNA due to tighter MutL-DNA interactions caused by MutS binding to MutL.

A novel heterozygous large deletion of MSH6 gene in a Chinese family with Lynch syndrome

Lynch syndrome (LS) is a common cancer syndrome that is inherited in an autosomal dominant manner. Its pathogenesis is thought to be closely related to germline mutations of mismatch repair (MMR) genes such as the MLH1, MSH2, PMS2 and MSH6 genes. This study identifies a Chinese family with LS clinically diagnosed according to the Amsterdam II criteria. In these patients, immuno-histochemical staining showed negative MSH6 expressions but positive MLH1, MSH2, and PMS2 expressions. In order to further explore the molecular biology of this LS family, we used targeted next-generation sequencing (NGS) and Multiplex ligation dependent probe amplification (MLPA) to identify the mutation and verify the authenticity of the mutation in 15 family members. For NGS, two panels have been used, one is of MLH1, MSH2, PMS2 and MSH6 genes, the other one is of 139 cancer genetic susceptibility genes. And for the large deletions/duplications can also be identified by NGS panel, an adjusted data analysis strategy of NGS has been used. As a result, we identified a novel heterozygous large deletion in MSH6 gene that was found to be co-segregated among affected family members. This deletion results in the loss of a 3246 bp-sized fragment in MSH6 gene exons 5-9 which represents the coding regions of the MSH6 ATPase domain. This novel mutation has yet to be documented in the International Society for Gastrointestinal Hereditary Tumours (InSiGHT) database. This mutation resulted in MSH6 protein losing gene mismatch repair function, and further caused the microsatellite instable. We speculate that this mutation may significantly impact MMR function through impaired ATP domain function. Theoretically, this proband would likely benefit from PD-1 immune check-point blockade therapy, but conversely, we observed that tumors appeared to rapidly progress after 4 sessions of anti-PD-1 treatment. Further studies to validate the effectiveness of anti-PD-1 treatments in carriers of this mutation are necessary.

The GIY-YIG endonuclease domain of Arabidopsis MutS homolog 1 specifically binds to branched DNA structures

In plant organelle genomes, homeologous recombination between heteroallelic positions of repetitive sequences is increased by dysfunction of the gene encoding MutS homolog 1 (MSH1), a plant organelle-specific homolog of bacterial mismatch-binding protein MutS1. The C-terminal region of plant MSH1 contains the GIY-YIG endonuclease motif. The biochemical characteristics of plant MSH1 have not been investigated; accordingly, the molecular mechanism by which plant MSH1 suppresses homeologous recombination is unknown. Here, we characterized the recombinant GIY-YIG domain of Arabidopsis thaliana MSH1, showing that the domain possesses branched DNA-specific DNA-binding activity. Interestingly, the domain exhibited no endonuclease activity, suggesting that the mismatch-binding domain is required for DNA incision. Based on these results, we propose a possible mechanism for MSH1-dependent suppression of homeologous recombination.

Archaeal MutS5 tightly binds to Holliday junction similarly to eukaryotic MutSγ

Archaeal DNA recombination mechanism and the related proteins are similar to those in eukaryotes. However, no functional homolog of eukaryotic MutSγ, which recognizes Holliday junction to promote homologous recombination, has been identified in archaea. Hence, the whole molecular mechanism of archaeal homologous recombination has not yet been revealed. In this study, to identify the archaeal functional homolog of MutSγ, we focused on a functionally uncharacterized MutS homolog, MutS5, from a hyperthermophilic archaeon Pyrococcus horikoshii (phMutS5). Archaeal MutS5 has a Walker ATPase motif-containing amino acid sequence that shows similarity to the ATPase domain of MutSγ. It is known that the ATPase domain of MutS homologs is also a dimerization domain. Chemical cross-linking revealed that purified phMutS5 has an ability to dimerize in solution. phMutS5 bound to Holliday junction with a higher affinity than to other branched and linear DNAs, which resembles the DNA-binding specificities of MutSγ and bacterial MutS2, a Holliday junction-resolving MutS homolog. However, phMutS5 has no nuclease activity against branched DNA unlike MutS2. The ATPase activity of phMutS5 was significantly stimulated by the presence of Holliday junction similarly to MutSγ. Furthermore, site-directed mutagenesis revealed that the ATPase activity is dependent on the Walker ATPase motif of the protein. These results suggest that archaeal MutS5 should stabilize the Holliday junction and play a role in homologous recombination, which is analogous to the function of eukaryotic MutSγ.