Diverse mechanisms of PARP inhibitor resistance in ovarian cancer

The journey from bench to bedside-it takes a science village

I was fortunate enough to start my career at what was the dawn of modern-day molecular biology and to apply it to an important health problem. While my early work focused on fundamental science, the desire to understand human disease better and to find practical applications for research discoveries resulted, over the following decades, in creating a stream of translational research directed specifically toward epithelial cancers. This could only have been possible through multiple collaborations. This type of team science would eventually become a hallmark of my career. With the development of higher throughput molecular techniques, the pace of research and discovery has quickened, and the concept of personalized medicine based on genomics is now coming to fruition. I hope my legacy will not just reflect my published works, but will also include the impact I have had on the development of the next generation of scientists and clinician scientists who inspired me with their dedication, knowledge, and enthusiasm.

RAD51D Secondary Mutation-Mediated Resistance to PARP-Inhibitor-Based Therapy in HGSOC

Ovarian cancer is the leading cause of gynecologic cancer-related death, and PARP inhibitors (PARPis) are becoming a promising treatment option, as demonstrated by recent clinical trials. After PARPi exposure, somatic reversion mutations in the homologous recombination genes may be a mechanism of PARPi resistance in ovarian carcinoma. We present an ovarian cancer case of a 61-year-old woman, who underwent routine tumor reduction surgery followed by platinum and PARPis. She demonstrated a good response to PARPis for 15 months before recurrence and secondary tumor reduction surgery. However, post-surgery platinum and PARPi treatment only kept the disease stable for 5 months. A potential molecular mechanism for PARPi resistance was investigated using next-generation sequencing, immunohistochemical (IHC) staining, and other functional assays. A germline RAD51D loss-of-function mutation was found in the reported case (LRG_516t1:c.270_271dup p1:p.(Lys91fs*13)). Subsequently, a secondary mutation (LRG_516t1:c.271_282 del) was identified in the same locus of the germline duplication in the post-progression biopsies and ctDNA. The IHC staining supported low expression of RAD51D in the initial tumor tissue, but the expression was restored after the correction of the open reading frame by the secondary mutation. The in vitro results supported that the loss-of-function mutation of RAD51D was the basis for the initial response to the platinum and PARPi therapy, while the newly acquired reversion mutation could be attributed to the observed PARPi resistance. An acquired mutation can reverse a loss-of-function change in RAD51D and can result in PARPi resistance in a hereditary ovarian cancer patient. Liquid biopsy could be considered for longitudinal monitoring in ovarian patients under PARPi-based therapy, which can identify acquired resistant mutations earlier and facilitate precision management.

Inhibition of nicotinamide dinucleotide salvage pathway counters acquired and intrinsic poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitor resistance in high-grade serous ovarian cancer

Epithelial ovarian cancer is the most lethal gynecological malignancy, owing notably to its high rate of therapy-resistant recurrence in spite of good initial response to chemotherapy. Although poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitors (PARPi) have shown promise for ovarian cancer treatment, extended therapy usually leads to acquired PARPi resistance. Here we explored a novel therapeutic option to counter this phenomenon, combining PARPi and inhibitors of nicotinamide phosphoribosyltransferase (NAMPT). Cell-based models of acquired PARPi resistance were created through an in vitro selection procedure. Using resistant cells, xenograft tumors were grown in immunodeficient mice, while organoid models were generated from primary patient tumor samples. Intrinsically PARPi-resistant cell lines were also selected for analysis. Our results show that treatment with NAMPT inhibitors effectively sensitized all in vitro models to PARPi. Adding nicotinamide mononucleotide, the resulting NAMPT metabolite, abrogated the therapy-induced cell growth inhibition, demonstrating the specificity of the synergy. Treatment with olaparib (PARPi) and daporinad (NAMPT inhibitor) depleted intracellular NAD+ , induced double-strand DNA breaks, and promoted apoptosis as monitored by caspase-3 cleavage. The two drugs were also synergistic in mouse xenograft models and clinically relevant patient-derived organoids. Therefore, in the context of PARPi resistance, NAMPT inhibition could offer a promising new option for ovarian cancer patients.

Improving PARP inhibitor efficacy in high-grade serous ovarian carcinoma: A focus on the immune system

High-grade serous ovarian carcinoma (HGSOC) is a genomically unstable malignancy responsible for over 70% of all deaths due to ovarian cancer. With roughly 50% of all HGSOC harboring defects in the homologous recombination (HR) DNA repair pathway (e.g., BRCA1/2 mutations), the introduction of poly ADP-ribose polymerase inhibitors (PARPi) has dramatically improved outcomes for women with HR defective HGSOC. By blocking the repair of single-stranded DNA damage in cancer cells already lacking high-fidelity HR pathways, PARPi causes the accumulation of double-stranded DNA breaks, leading to cell death. Thus, this synthetic lethality results in PARPi selectively targeting cancer cells, resulting in impressive efficacy. Despite this, resistance to PARPi commonly develops through diverse mechanisms, such as the acquisition of secondary BRCA1/2 mutations. Perhaps less well documented is that PARPi can impact both the tumour microenvironment and the immune response, through upregulation of the stimulator of interferon genes (STING) pathway, upregulation of immune checkpoints such as PD-L1, and by stimulating the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines. Whilst targeted immunotherapies have not yet found their place in the clinic for HGSOC, the evidence above, as well as ongoing studies exploring the synergistic effects of PARPi with immune agents, including immune checkpoint inhibitors, suggests potential for targeting the immune response in HGSOC. Additionally, combining PARPi with epigenetic-modulating drugs may improve PARPi efficacy, by inducing a BRCA-defective phenotype to sensitise resistant cancer cells to PARPi. Finally, invigorating an immune response during PARPi therapy may engage anti-cancer immune responses that potentiate efficacy and mitigate the development of PARPi resistance. Here, we will review the emerging PARPi literature with a focus on PARPi effects on the immune response in HGSOC, as well as the potential of epigenetic combination therapies. We highlight the potential of transforming HGSOC from a lethal to a chronic disease and increasing the likelihood of cure.

Research progress on the association between environmental pollutants and the resistance mechanism of PARP inhibitors in ovarian cancer

The occurrence and progression of ovarian cancer are closely related to genetics and environmental pollutants. Poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) inhibitors have been a major breakthrough in the history of ovarian cancer treatment. PARP is an enzyme responsible for post-translational modification of proteins and repair of single-stranded DNA damage. PARP inhibitors can selectively inhibit PARP function, resulting in a synthetic lethal effect on tumor cells defective in homologous recombination repair. However, with large-scale application, drug resistance also inevitably appears. For PARP inhibitors, the diversity and complexity of drug resistance mechanisms have always been difficult problems in clinical treatment. Herein, we mainly summarized the research progress of DNA damage repair and drug resistance mechanisms related to PARP inhibitors and the impact of environmental pollutants on DNA damage repair to aid the development prospects and highlight urgent problems to be solved.

PARP Inhibitors for Ovarian Cancer: Current Indications, Future Combinations, and Novel Assets in Development to Target DNA Damage Repair

PARP inhibitors (PARPIs) have revolutionized the treatment of epithelial ovarian cancer, first for BRCA-associated cancer, and, recently, for all epithelial cancers of serous or high-grade endometrioid subtypes in the front line. Although there is hope that PARPIs will help prevent recurrences when used following frontline maintenance, cancer will still recur in most women, and the need for active combination strategies as well as continued development of novel assets, either as monotherapy or in combination, will be urgently needed. This review article discusses the current indications for PARPIs in both frontline and recurrent settings, current research in combination approaches, and finally, ongoing research on novel methods to target DNA damage response in an effort to exploit the common susceptibility to DNA damage repair in epithelial ovarian cancer and improve outcomes for patients.

CRISPR-cas9 genome editing delivery systems for targeted cancer therapy

The prokaryotic CRISPR-Cas systems could be applied as revolutionized genome editing tool in live cells of various species to modify, visualize and identify definite sequences of DNA and RNA. CRISPR-Cas could edit the genome by homology-directed repair and non-homologous end joining mechanisms. Furthermore, DNA-targeting modification by CRISPR-Cas methodology provides opportunity for diagnosis, therapy and the genetic disorders investigation. Here, we summarized delivery systems employed for CRISPR-Cas9 for genome editing. Then preclinical studies of the CRISPR-Cas9-based therapeutics will be discussed considering the associated challenges and developments in its translation to clinic for cancer therapy.

The RNA polymerase I transcription inhibitor CX-5461 cooperates with topoisomerase 1 inhibition by enhancing the DNA damage response in homologous recombination-proficient high-grade serous ovarian cancer

Background

Intrinsic and acquired drug resistance represent fundamental barriers to the cure of high-grade serous ovarian carcinoma (HGSC), the most common histological subtype accounting for the majority of ovarian cancer deaths. Defects in homologous recombination (HR) DNA repair are key determinants of sensitivity to chemotherapy and poly-ADP ribose polymerase inhibitors. Restoration of HR is a common mechanism of acquired resistance that results in patient mortality, highlighting the need to identify new therapies targeting HR-proficient disease. We have shown promise for CX-5461, a cancer therapeutic in early phase clinical trials, in treating HR-deficient HGSC.

Methods

Herein, we screen the whole protein-coding genome to identify potential targets whose depletion cooperates with CX-5461 in HR-proficient HGSC.

Results

We demonstrate robust proliferation inhibition in cells depleted of DNA topoisomerase 1 (TOP1). Combining the clinically used TOP1 inhibitor topotecan with CX-5461 potentiates a G2/M cell cycle checkpoint arrest in multiple HR-proficient HGSC cell lines. The combination enhances a nucleolar DNA damage response and global replication stress without increasing DNA strand breakage, significantly reducing clonogenic survival and tumour growth in vivo.

Conclusions

Our findings highlight the possibility of exploiting TOP1 inhibition to be combined with CX-5461 as a non-genotoxic approach in targeting HR-proficient HGSC.

Human La Protein: An RNA-Binding Protein Involved in Ovarian Cancer Development and Multidrug Resistance

Multidrug resistance is the main cause of chemotherapy failure and death in patients with advanced ovarian cancer. Drug resistance is a problem that must be solved to improve the survival rate of patients with advanced ovarian cancer. The RNA-binding protein La and the La-related protein family are highly expressed in various malignant tumors, including ovarian cancer. This article reviews the mechanisms of La protein in tumorigenesis, development, and drug resistance. High La protein expression in tumor cells promotes tumor proliferation, invasion, and migration; disrupts cell cycle; and inhibits tumor cell apoptosis caused by chemotherapeutic drugs through various pathways, resulting in chemotherapy resistance in ovarian cancer. Further study of the role of La protein in ovarian cancer multidrug resistance may be conducive to the development of human La protein-specific inhibitors that suppress ovarian cancer drug resistance.

lncRNA DUXAP8 Facilitates Multiple Malignant Phenotypes and Resistance to PARP Inhibitor in HCC via Upregulating FOXM1

In this study, we examined the clinical significance and molecular mechanisms of a long non-coding RNA (lncRNA), double homeobox A pseudogene 8 (DUXAP8) in hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). DUXAP8 expression was compared using quantitative real-time PCR in HCC versus adjacent tissues and in HCC cell lines versus normal hepatic epithelial cells. The correlations between DUXAP8 level and clinicopathological features were analyzed. Assays including MTT, colony-forming analysis, Transwell assay, western blot, xenograft formation, experimental metastasis, luciferase assay, RNA pull-down, and RNA immunoprecipitation were used to examine DUXAP8-induced malignant phenotypes, its regulation on forkhead box protein M1 (FOXM1), and the importance of FOXM1 in mediating DUXAP8 phenotypes. Our results showed that DUXAP8 was significantly upregulated in HCC tissues or cell lines associated with tumors of advanced grades, tumors that were positive for lymph node metastasis, and patients with poor overall survival. DUAXP8 was essential in maintaining multiple malignant phenotypes (including resistance to olaparib) both in vitro and in vivo. Mechanistically, DUXAP8 upregulated FOXM1 expression by sponging miR-485-5p and interacting with the RNA-binding protein Fused in Sarcoma (FUS). Functionally, FOXM1 essentially mediated the oncogenic phenotypes of DUXAP8. Collectively, DUXAP8 acts through two distinct mechanisms to upregulate FOXM1 and becomes a pleotropic oncogenic lncRNA in HCC.

PARP Inhibitor Resistance Mechanisms and Implications for Post-Progression Combination Therapies

The use of PARP inhibitors (PARPi) is growing widely as FDA approvals have shifted its use from the recurrence setting to the frontline setting. In parallel, the population developing PARPi resistance is increasing. Here we review the role of PARP, DNA damage repair, and synthetic lethality. We discuss mechanisms of resistance to PARP inhibition and how this informs on novel combinations to re-sensitize cancer cells to PARPi.

Challenges and Opportunities in Cancer Drug Resistance

There has been huge progress in the discovery of targeted cancer therapies in recent years. However, even for the most successful and impactful cancer drugs which have been approved, both innate and acquired mechanisms of resistance are commonplace. These emerging mechanisms of resistance have been studied intensively, which has enabled drug discovery scientists to learn how it may be possible to overcome such resistance in subsequent generations of treatments. In some cases, novel drug candidates have been able to supersede previously approved agents; in other cases they have been used sequentially or in combinations with existing treatments. This review summarizes the current field in terms of the challenges and opportunities that cancer resistance presents to drug discovery scientists, with a focus on small molecule therapeutics. As part of this review, common themes and approaches have been identified which have been utilized to successfully target emerging mechanisms of resistance. This includes the increase in target potency and selectivity, alternative chemical scaffolds, change of mechanism of action (covalents, PROTACs), increases in blood-brain barrier permeability (BBBP), and the targeting of allosteric pockets. Finally, wider approaches are covered such as monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), bispecific antibodies, antibody drug conjugates (ADCs), and combination therapies.

The dynamic landscape of BRCA1 reversion mutations from indel to SNV in a patient with ovarian cancer treated with PARP-inhibitors and immunotherapy

Background

Reversion mutations of somatic BRCA mutations are an important source of resistance within ovarian cancer. Furthermore, these reversion mutations are known to change over the course of treatment. Better understanding of the mechanisms leading to reversion mutations and the role of serial ctDNA collection in detecting changes to overall landscape of resistance mutations over time is needed to guide treatment in the metastatic setting.

Methods

Here we study a case of metastatic ovarian cancer undergoing multiple lines of treatment with collection of three serial ctDNA samples. These samples were analyzed by Guardant Health next generation sequencing to detect somatic alterations and their associated mutant allele frequency (MAF) as % cfDNA.

Results

Analysis of our initial ctDNA collection, taken during PARP-inhibitor therapy, revealed a nonsense BRCA-1 mutation (c. 2563C > T p. Q855∗), consistent with the BRCA 1 somatic mutation detected on tumor tissue analysis. Initial analysis also revealed a reversion mutation (c.2535_2576del) resulting in an in-frame deletion of the somatic BRCA-1 alteration. The second collection, taken while still on PARP-inhibitor therapy, re-demonstrated this indel reversion mutation along with a second indel reversion mutation (c.2546_2587del), again resulting in an in-frame deletion of the somatic BRCA-1 mutation. The final ctDNA, collected upon initiation of immunotherapy, revealed 4 novel SNV reversion mutations (c.2564A > C, c.2564A > T, c.2565G > T, and c.2565G > C). These SNV reversion mutations result in missense amino acid changes rather than insertions or deletions within the BRCA-1 somatic mutation. The previous indel reversion mutations were no longer detected.

Conclusions

This study illustrates the role of serial ctDNA analyses in the detection of resistance mutations and the dynamic nature of reversion mutations with multiple lines of treatment. While other studies have described both indels and SNVs that occur in tandem, a change in the types of reversion mutations detected across changing therapies has never before been described. Further studies regarding the unique selective pressures arising from use of multiple types of therapy is needed to fully explain this phenomenon.

Physiological and Pathological Roles of RAD52 at DNA Replication Forks

Understanding basic molecular mechanisms underlying the biology of cancer cells is of outmost importance for identification of novel therapeutic targets and biomarkers for patient stratification and better therapy selection. One of these mechanisms, the response to replication stress, fuels cancer genomic instability. It is also an Achille’s heel of cancer. Thus, identification of pathways used by the cancer cells to respond to replication-stress may assist in the identification of new biomarkers and discovery of new therapeutic targets. Alternative mechanisms that act at perturbed DNA replication forks and involve fork degradation by nucleases emerged as crucial for sensitivity of cancer cells to chemotherapeutics agents inducing replication stress. Despite its important role in homologous recombination and recombinational repair of DNA double strand breaks in lower eukaryotes, RAD52 protein has been considered dispensable in human cells and the full range of its cellular functions remained unclear. Very recently, however, human RAD52 emerged as an important player in multiple aspects of replication fork metabolism under physiological and pathological conditions. In this review, we describe recent advances on RAD52’s key functions at stalled or collapsed DNA replication forks, in particular, the unexpected role of RAD52 as a gatekeeper, which prevents unscheduled processing of DNA. Last, we will discuss how these functions can be exploited using specific inhibitors in targeted therapy or for an informed therapy selection.