Observation of multi-step conformation switching in β-amyloid peptide aggregation by fluorescence resonance energy transfer

Mechanisms and rates of nucleation of amyloid fibrils

The classical nucleation theory finds the rate of nucleation proportional to the monomer concentration raised to the power, which is the "critical nucleus size," n_c. The implicit assumption, that amyloids nucleate in the same way, has been recently challenged by an alternative two-step mechanism, when the soluble monomers first form a metastable aggregate (micelle) and then undergo conversion into the conformation rich in β-strands that are able to form a stable growing nucleus for the protofilament. Here we put together the elements of extensive knowledge about aggregation and nucleation kinetics, using a specific case of Aβ_1-42 amyloidogenic peptide for illustration, to find theoretical expressions for the effective rate of amyloid nucleation. We find that at low monomer concentrations in solution and also at low interaction energy between two peptide conformations in the micelle, the nucleation occurs via the classical route. At higher monomer concentrations, and a range of other interaction parameters between peptides, the two-step "aggregation-conversion" mechanism of nucleation takes over. In this regime, the effective rate of the process can be interpreted as a power of monomer concentration in a certain range of parameters; however, the exponent is determined by a complicated interplay of interaction parameters and is not related to the minimum size of the growing nucleus (which we find to be ∼7-8 for Aβ_1-42).

Ensemble and single-molecule detected time-resolved FRET methods in studies of protein conformations and dynamics

Most proteins are nanomachines that are selected to execute specific functions and therefore should have some degree of flexibility. The driving force that excites specific motions of domains and smaller chain elements is the thermal fluctuations of the solvent bath which are channeled to selected modes of motions by the structural constraints. Consequently characterization of the ensembles of conformers of proteins and their dynamics should be expressed in statistical terms, i.e., determination of probability distributions of the various conformers. This can be achieved by measurements of time-resolved dynamic non-radiative excitation energy transfer (trFRET) within ensembles of site specifically labeled protein molecules. Distributions of intramolecular segmental end-to-end distances and their fast fluctuations can be determined, and fast and slow conformational transitions within selected sections of the molecule can be monitored and analyzed. Both ensemble and single-molecule detection methods can be applied for data collection. In combination with synchronization methods, time-resolved FRET was also used for studies of fast conformational transitions, in particular the folding/unfolding transitions.

Ensemble FRET methods in studies of intrinsically disordered proteins

The main structural characteristic of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) or intrinsically disordered regions of globular proteins is that they exist as ensembles of multiple conformers which can continuously interconvert, and at times, form ensembles of a more restricted number of conformers. Characterization of the disordered state and transitions to partially or fully ordered states of such ensembles must be expressed in statistical terms, i.e., determination of probability distributions of the various conformers. This can be achieved by measurements of time-resolved dynamic non-radiative excitation energy transfer within ensembles of site-specifically labeled IDP molecules. Distributions of intramolecular segmental end-to-end distances and their fast fluctuations can be determined and fast and slow conformational transitions within selected sections of the molecule can be monitored and analyzed.

Single-molecule atomic force microscopy force spectroscopy study of Aβ-40 interactions

Misfolding and aggregation of amyloid β-40 (Aβ-40) peptide play key roles in the development of Alzheimer's disease (AD). However, very little is known about the molecular mechanisms underlying these molecular processes. We developed a novel experimental approach that can directly probe aggregation-prone states of proteins and their interactions. In this approach, the proteins are anchored to the surface of the atomic force microscopy substrate (mica) and the probe, and the interaction between anchored molecules is measured in the approach-retraction cycles. We used dynamic force spectroscopy (DFS) to measure the stability of transiently formed dimers. One of the major findings from DFS analysis of α-synuclein (α-Syn) is that dimeric complexes formed by misfolded α-Syn protein are very stable and dissociate over a range of seconds. This differs markedly from the dynamics of monomers, which occurs on a microsecond to nanosecond time scale. Here we applied the same approach to quantitatively characterize interactions of Aβ-40 peptides over a broad range of pH values. These studies showed that misfolded dimers are characterized by lifetimes in the range of seconds. This value depends on pH and varies between 2.7 s for pH 2.7 and 0.1 s for pH 7, indicating that the aggregation properties of Aβ-40 are modulated by the environmental conditions. The analysis of the contour lengths revealed the existence of various pathways for dimer dissociation, suggesting that dimers with different conformations are formed. These structural variations result in different aggregation pathways, leading to different types of oligomers and higher-order aggregates, including fibrils.

Nanoimaging for protein misfolding diseases

Misfolding and aggregation of proteins are widespread phenomena leading to the development of numerous neurodegenerative disorders such as Parkinson's, Alzheimer's, and Huntington's diseases. Each of these diseases is linked to structural misfolding and aggregation of a particular protein. The aggregated forms of the protein induce the development of a particular disease at all levels, leading to neuronal dysfunction and loss. Because protein refolding is frequently accompanied by transient association of partially folded intermediates, the propensity to aggregate is considered a general characteristic of the majority of proteins. X-ray crystallography, nuclear magnetic resonance, electron microscopy, and atomic force microscopy have provided important information on the structure of aggregates. However, fundamental questions, such as why the misfolded conformation of the protein is formed, and why this state is important for self-assembly, remain unanswered. Although it is well known that the same protein under pathological conditions can lead to the formation of aggregates with diverse biological consequences, the conditions leading to misfolding and the formation of the disease prone complexes are unclear, complicating any development of efficient prevention of the diseases. Misfolded states exist transiently, so answering these questions requires the use of novel approaches and methods. Progress has been made during the past few years, when recently developed ensemble methods and single-molecule biophysics techniques were applied to the problem of the protein misfolding. In this review, the impacts of these studies on the understanding of the mechanisms of the protein self-assembly into aggregates and on the development of treatments of the diseases are discussed.

Tracking spatial disorder in an optical ruler by time-resolved NSET

For biomolecular applications, potential interactions between newly developed dye molecules and the biomolecule of interest can dramatically influence the accuracy of optical ruler techniques. By utilizing nanometal surface energy transfer (NSET), an optical technique is developed that allows the nature of interactions between dyes and a biomolecule, namely DNA, to be directly assessed. To demonstrate the method, interactions between well-known molecular dyes based on carboxyfluorescein (FAM, noninteracting) and Cy5 (known intercalator) with DNA is probed. The results demonstrate that FAM exhibits no interactions with the DNA backbone and is adequately represented as a solvent exposed dye, while the commonly used near-IR dye Cy5 exhibits two discrete interactions that depend on the site of appendage and the length of the linker arm. The exact population and nature of Cy5 interaction with the DNA indicates a 37% ratio of intercalation for the internal C(6), a 42% ratio for an internal C(3) spacer length, and no evidence of interaction for terminal labeling. The results allow quantitative assignment of the site occupation of donors to be analyzed providing a powerful set of information for use of dyes in FRET based optical ruler technologies without the need of single molecule methods or the assumption of an averaged site occupation for the donor.

Detecting the inter-peptide arrangement and maturation process of transthyretin (105-115) amyloid fibril using a FRET pair with short Förster distance

Transthyretin (TTR) is an amyloidogenic protein involved in many mental diseases. The peptide derived from TTR (105-115) has been widely studied as a model peptide for understanding the mechanism of amyloid fibril formation. However, the detailed arrangement of this peptide in amyloid fibril is still unclear. We have studied the amyloid fibril formation process of TTR (105-115) by introducing a pair of FRET probes into the peptide with a dansyl group at the N-terminal and a tryptophan residue at the C-terminal. Our experiment demonstrated that the strands of TTR (105-115) in the same beta-sheet may be parallel and the mating sheets may be anti-parallel to each other in the amyloid fibril. The kinetics followed by FRET and EM indicated for a possible intermediate state and the distance between sheets became shorter when the intermediate amyloid fibril turns into a more matured form.

The conformations of the amyloid-beta (21-30) fragment can be described by three families in solution

Alzheimer's disease has been linked to the self-assembly of the amyloid-beta protein of 40 and 42 residues. Although monomers are in equilibrium with higher-order species ranging from dimers to heptamers, structural knowledge of the monomeric amyloid-beta (Abeta) peptides is an important issue. Recent experimental data have shown that the fragment (21-30) is protease-resistant within full-length Abeta peptides and displays two structural families in solution. Because the details of the Abeta(21-30) structures found using distinct force fields and protocols differ at various degrees from those of the NMR structures, we revisit the conformational space of this peptide using the activation-relaxation technique (ART nouveau) coupled with a coarse-grained force field (OPEP v.3.0). We find that although Abeta(21-30) does not have a secondary structure, it dominantly populates three structural families, with a loop spanning residues Val24-Lys28. The first two families, which differ in the nature of the electrostatic interactions, satisfy the five interproton rotating frame nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy (ROESY) distances and superpose well onto the NMR structures. The third family, which cannot be seen by ROESY NMR experiments, displays a more open structure. This numeric study complements the experimental results by providing a much more detailed description of the dominant structures. Moreover, it provides further evidence of the capability of ART OPEP in providing a reliable conformational picture of peptides in solution.

Role of aggregation conditions in structure, stability, and toxicity of intermediates in the Abeta fibril formation pathway

beta-amyloid peptide (Abeta) is one of the main protein components of senile plaques associated with Alzheimer's disease (AD). Abeta readily aggregates to forms fibrils and other aggregated species that have been shown to be toxic in a number of studies. In particular, soluble oligomeric forms are closely related to neurotoxicity. However, the relationship between neurotoxicity and the size of Abeta aggregates or oligomers is still under investigation. In this article, we show that different Abeta incubation conditions in vitro can affect the rate of Abeta fibril formation, the conformation and stability of intermediates in the aggregation pathway, and toxicity of aggregated species formed. When gently agitated, Abeta aggregates faster than Abeta prepared under quiescent conditions, forming fibrils. The morphology of fibrils formed at the end of aggregation with or without agitation, as observed in electron micrographs, is somewhat different. Interestingly, intermediates or oligomers formed during Abeta aggregation differ greatly under agitated and quiescent conditions. Unfolding studies in guanidine hydrochloride indicate that fibrils formed under quiescent conditions are more stable to unfolding in detergent than aggregation associated oligomers or Abeta fibrils formed with agitation. In addition, Abeta fibrils formed under quiescent conditions were less toxic to differentiated SH-SY5Y cells than the Abeta aggregation associated oligomers or fibrils formed with agitation. These results highlight differences between Abeta aggregation intermediates formed under different conditions and provide insight into the structure and stability of toxic Abeta oligomers.

Aggregating the amyloid Abeta(11-25) peptide into a four-stranded beta-sheet structure

We present a detailed analysis of the structural properties of one monomer of Abeta(11-25) as well as of the aggregation mechanisms for four chains of Abeta(11-25) using the activation-relaxation technique coupled with a generic energy potential. Starting from a random distribution of these four chains, we find that the system assembles rapidly into a random globular state that evolves into three- and four-stranded antiparallel beta-sheets. The aggregation process is considerably accelerated by the presence of preformed dimers. We also find that the reptation mechanism already identified in shorter peptides plays a significant role here in allowing the structure to reorganize without having to fully dissociate.

Equilibrium unfolding of the poly(glutamic acid)20 helix

The equilibrium structural ensemble of a 20-residue polyglutamic acid peptide (E(20)) was studied with FRET, circular dichroism, and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. A FRET donor, o-aminobenzamide, and acceptor, 3-nitrotyrosine, were introduced at the N- and C-termini, respectively. Circular dichroism, steady state FRET, and time-resolved FRET measurements were employed to characterize the fraction helix and end-to-end distance under different pH conditions: pH 4 (60% alpha-helix), pH 6 (0% alpha-helix), and pH 9 (0% alpha-helix). At pH 4, the end-to-end distance was measured at 24 A and determined to be considerably less than the 31 A predicted for an alpha-helix of the same length. At pH 6 and 9, the end-to-end distance was measured at > 31 and 39 A respectively, both which are determined to be considerably greater than the 27 A predicted for a freely jointed random coil of the same length. To better understand the physical forces underlying the unusual helix-coil transition in this peptide, three theoretical MD models of E(20) were constructed: (1) a pure alpha-helix, (2) an alpha-helix with equivalent attractive intramolecular contacts, and (3) a weak alpha-helix with termini-weighted intramolecular contacts ("sticky ends"). Using MD simulations, the bent helix structure calculated from Model 3 was found to be the closest in agreement with the experimental data.

Imaging amyloid β peptide oligomeric particles in solution

While all protein misfolding diseases are characterized by fibrous amyloid deposits, the favorable free energy and strongly cooperative nature of the self-assembly have complicated the development of therapeutic strategies aimed at preventing their formation. As structural models for the amyloid fibrils approach atomic resolution, increasing evidence suggests that early folding intermediates, rather than the final structure, are more strongly associated with the loss of neuronal function. For that reason we now demonstrate the use of cryo-etch high-resolution scanning electron microscopy (cryo-HRSEM) for the direct observation of pathway intermediates in amyloid assembly. A congener of the Abeta peptide of Alzheimer's disease, Abeta(13-21), samples a variety of time-dependent self-assembles in a manner similar to those seen for larger proteins. A morphological description of these intermediates is the first step towards their structural characterization and the definition of their role in both amyloid assembly and neurotoxicity.

Interaction of the fusogenic peptide B18 in its amyloid-state with lipid membranes studied by solid state NMR

The interaction of the fusogenic polypeptide segment "B18" from the fertilization protein binding with lipid membranes was investigated by solid state 2H and 31P NMR, and by differential scanning calorimetry. B18 is known to adopt different conformations depending on peptide concentration, ionic conditions, pH and lipid environment. Here, the peptide was studied in its beta-stranded amyloid conformation. According to 31P NMR, the lamellar morphology of the DMPC bilayer remains intact in the presence of B18. In going from low (1:90) to high (1:10) peptide/lipid ratios, an increasing effect on several different 2H-labeled lipid segments was observed, reflecting changes in phase behavior and local dynamics. The strongest influence of B18 was detected at the acyl-chains, while no significant effect on the lipid headgroup conformation was observed. This suggests an insertion of B18 in its fibrillar state into the membrane driven by hydrophobic interactions, rather than a peripheral binding mediated by electrostatics.