Predicting alternate structure attainment and amyloidogenesis: a nonlinear signal analysis approach

Detecting transitions in protein dynamics using a recurrence quantification analysis based bootstrap method

Background

Proteins undergo conformational transitions over different time scales. These transitions are closely intertwined with the protein’s function. Numerous standard techniques such as principal component analysis are used to detect these transitions in molecular dynamics simulations. In this work, we add a new method that has the ability to detect transitions in dynamics based on the recurrences in the dynamical system. It combines bootstrapping and recurrence quantification analysis. We start from the assumption that a protein has a “baseline” recurrence structure over a given period of time. Any statistically significant deviation from this recurrence structure, as inferred from complexity measures provided by recurrence quantification analysis, is considered a transition in the dynamics of the protein.

Results

We apply this technique to a 132 ns long molecular dynamics simulation of the β-Lactamase Inhibitory Protein BLIP. We are able to detect conformational transitions in the nanosecond range in the recurrence dynamics of the BLIP protein during the simulation. The results compare favorably to those extracted using the principal component analysis technique.

Conclusions

The recurrence quantification analysis based bootstrap technique is able to detect transitions between different dynamics states for a protein over different time scales. It is not limited to linear dynamics regimes, and can be generalized to any time scale. It also has the potential to be used to cluster frames in molecular dynamics trajectories according to the nature of their recurrence dynamics. One shortcoming for this method is the need to have large enough time windows to insure good statistical quality for the recurrence complexity measures needed to detect the transitions.

Clues for divergent, polymorphic amyloidogenesis through dissection of amyloid forming steps of bovine carbonic anhydrase and its critical amyloid forming stretch

Certain amino acid stretches are considered 'critical' to trigger amyloidogenesis in a protein. Synthetic peptides corresponding to these stretches are often used as experimental mimics for studying the amyloidogenesis of their parent protein. Here we provide evidence that such simple extrapolation is misleading. We scrutinized each step of amyloid progression of full length bovine carbonic anhydrase (BCA) and compared it with the amyloidogenic process of its critical peptide stretch 201-227 (PepB). We found that under similar solution conditions amyloidogenesis of BCA followed surface-catalyzed secondary nucleation, whereas, that of PepB followed classical nucleation-dependent pathway. AFM images showed that while BCA formed short, thick and branched fibrils, PepB formed thin, long and unbranched fibrils. Structural information obtained by ATR-FTIR spectroscopy suggested parallel arrangement of intermolecular β-sheet in BCA amyloids in contrast to PepB amyloids which arranged into antiparallel β sheets. Amyloids formed by BCA were unable to seed the fibrillation of PepB and vice versa. Even the intermediates formed during lag phase revealed contrasting FTIR and far UV CD signature, hydrophobicity, morphology and cell cytotoxicity. Thus, we propose that sequences other than critical amyloidogenic stretches may significantly influence the initiation, polymerization and final fibrillar morphology of amyloid forming protein. The results have been discussed in light of primary sequence mediated amyloid polymorphism and its importance in the rational design of amyloid nanomaterials possessing desired physico-chemical properties.

Selective interception of gelsolin amyloidogenic stretch results in conformationally distinct aggregates with reduced toxicity

The pathogenesis of protein misfolding diseases is attributed to the cytotoxicity caused by amyloidogenic prefibrillar aggregates, rather than mature fibrils. The presence of one or more amyloidogenic stretches in different proteins has been proven critical for initiating fibril formation. In the present study, we show that two natural compounds, curcumin and emetine, bind tightly (Kd < 1.6 μM) to the core amyloidogenic stretch (182-192) of gelsolin (AGel). Binding happens in different structural orientations, distinctly modulating the amyloidogenic pathway of AGel. While AGel alone undergoes sigmoidal transition to thioflavin T (ThT)-responsive fibrillar aggregates with clear lag phase, the presence of curcumin or emetine abolishes the lag phase and produces starkly different, noncytotoxic end products. Atomic force microscopy revealed that while curcumin augments fibril formation, emetine arrests it at an intermediate aggregated stage with no fibrillar morphology. FTIR spectroscopy, dynamic light scattering, and ANS fluorescence experiments also suggest that these two species are distinct. Curcumin and emetine also differentially affect the preformed amyloids with the former thickening the fibrils and the latter releasing reclusive oligomers. MD simulations further provided mechanistic insights of differential interaction by the two compounds modulating amyloid formation. The results were also confirmed on the disease-associated amyloidogenic fragment of gelsolin (fAGel). Thus, our findings suggest that targeting amyloidogenic stretches in proteins could be useful in designing novel molecules against protein misfolding diseases.

Formation of amyloid fibrils by bovine carbonic anhydrase

Amyloids are typically characterized by extensive aggregation of proteins where the participating polypeptides are involved in formation of intermolecular cross beta-sheet structures. Alternate structure attainment and amyloid formation has been hypothesized to be a generic property of a polypeptide, the propensities of which vary widely depending on the polypeptide involved and the physicochemical conditions it encounters. Many proteins that exist in the normal form in-vivo have been shown to form amyloid when incubated in partially denaturing conditions. The protein bovine carbonic anhydrase II (BCA II) when incubated in mildly denaturing conditions showed that the partially unfolded conformers assemble together and form ordered amyloid aggregates. The properties of these aggregates were tested using the traditional Congo-Red (CR) and Thioflavin-T (ThT) assays along with fluorescence microscopy, transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. The aggregates were found to possess most of the characteristics ascribed to amyloid fibers. Thus, we report here that the single-domain globular protein, BCA II, is capable of forming amyloid fibrils. The primary sequence of BCA II was also analyzed using recurrence quantification analysis in order to suggest the probable residues responsible for amyloid formation.