The functional expression and motile properties of recombinant outer arm dynein from Tetrahymena

Wave-like oscillations of clamped microtubules driven by collective dynein transport

Microtubules (MTs) are observed to move and buckle driven by ATP-dependent molecular motors in both mitotic and interphasic eukaryotic cells as well as in specialized structures such as flagella and cilia with a stereotypical geometry. In previous work, clamped MTs driven by a few kinesin motors were seen to buckle and occasionally flap in what was referred to as flagella-like motion. Theoretical models of active-filament dynamics and a following force have predicted that, with sufficient force and binding-unbinding, such clamped filaments should spontaneously undergo periodic buckling oscillations. However, a systematic experimental test of the theory and reconciliation to a model was lacking. Here, we have engineered a minimal system of MTs clamped at their plus ends and transported by a sheet of dynein motors that demonstrate the emergence of spontaneous traveling-wave oscillations along single filaments. The frequencies of tip oscillations are in the millihertz range and are statistically indistinguishable in the onset and recovery phases. We develop a 2D computational model of clamped MTs binding and unbinding stochastically to motors in a "gliding-assay" geometry. The simulated MTs oscillate with a frequency comparable to experiment. The model predicts the effect of MT length and motor density on qualitative transitions between distinct phases of flapping, regular oscillations, and looping. We develop an effective "order parameter" based on the relative deflection along the filament and orthogonal to it. The transitions predicted in simulations are validated by experimental data. These results demonstrate a role for geometry, MT buckling, and collective molecular motor activity in the emergence of oscillatory dynamics.

Structure and Mechanics of Dynein Motors

Dyneins make up a family of AAA+ motors that move toward the minus end of microtubules. Cytoplasmic dynein is responsible for transporting intracellular cargos in interphase cells and mediating spindle assembly and chromosome positioning during cell division. Other dynein isoforms transport cargos in cilia and power ciliary beating. Dyneins were the least studied of the cytoskeletal motors due to challenges in the reconstitution of active dynein complexes in vitro and the scarcity of high-resolution methods for in-depth structural and biophysical characterization of these motors. These challenges have been recently addressed, and there have been major advances in our understanding of the activation, mechanism, and regulation of dyneins. This review synthesizes the results of structural and biophysical studies for each class of dynein motors. We highlight several outstanding questions about the regulation of bidirectional transport along microtubules and the mechanisms that sustain self-coordinated oscillations within motile cilia.

Development of an expression system in Tetrahymena inner arm dyneins and motile properties of the single-headed subspecies (Dyh8p and Dyh12p)

Diverse inner arm dyneins cooperate with outer arm dyneins to produce ciliary beating. This study demonstrates an expression system for inner arm dyneins in Tetrahymena. The motor domain of inner arm dynein (Dyh8p or Dyh12p) was fused with the tail of outer arm dynein (Dyh3p) and expressed in viable DYH3-knockout (vKO-DYH3) cells. The chimeric dyneins were observed in the oral apparatus and cilia on the cell bodies, and did not change the swimming speed of vKO-DYH3 cells. In a gliding assay, the motor domains of Dyh8p and Dyh12p moved toward the minus ends of microtubules at 0.8 and 0.3 μm/s, respectively. The gliding velocities of Dyh8p and Dyh12p were decreased in 5 mM ATP but not increased in 0.1 or 0.5 mM ADP. This expression system will be useful for molecular studies on diverse inner arm dyneins.

Functional characterization of lethal P-loop mutations in Tetrahymena outer arm dynein (Dyh3p)

Mutational analyses of axonemal dyneins are useful for elucidating the molecular mechanism of ciliary motility. This study demonstrates a mutation system for characterizing lethal P-loop mutations in Tetrahymena outer arm dynein (Dyh3p). The viable DYH3-knockout (vKO-DYH3) cells isolated in this study enabled the examination of lethal mutations in P-loops 1 and 2. The P1 mutant dynein localized in the oral apparatus and the proximal region of the cilia, and the P2 mutant dynein localized only in the oral apparatus. Both results are different from the localization of wild-type Dyh3p. In addition, a co-precipitation assay showed that the P1 and P2 mutant dyneins did not dissociate from microtubules in ATP plus vanadate or in no-ATP conditions, in contrast to wild-type Dyh3p. This mutation system is useful for further molecular studies of axonemal dyneins and ciliary motility.

Establishment of a mutation system in Tetrahymena outer arm dynein and P-loop functions of the alpha heavy chain (Dyh3p)

Axonemal dyneins are large AAA+ type motor proteins that exhibit unique motor properties during ciliary beating. This study established a mutation system for Tetrahymena outer arm dynein and characterized four nucleotide-binding loops (P-loops; P1-P4) in the alpha heavy chain (Dyh3p). Macronuclear transformation of the mutant DYH3 genes in DYH3-knockout (KO-DYH3) cells enabled P-loop mutations that abolish the ability of nucleotide binding to be stably maintained in the polyploid genome. This mutation system revealed that the P3 and P4 mutant dyneins rescued lethality in macronuclear KO-DYH3 cells and exhibited normal ciliary localization. Intriguingly, however, an in vitro motility assay showed that the P3 mutation abolished the motor activity of Dyh3p, whereas the P4 mutation did not affect the gliding velocity or gliding index of Dyh3p. In contrast, no P1 or P2 mutant cells were isolated from the KO-DYH3 cells, which suggests that nucleotide binding at the P1 and P2 sites is required for the intracellular function of Dyh3p. This mutation system will be useful for further molecular studies of diverse axonemal dyneins and ciliary motility.

Motor domain-based motility system and motile properties of alpha heavy chain in Tetrahymena outer arm dynein

Axonemal dynein plays an essential role in ciliary motility, and impaired ciliary motility causes human diseases such as primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD). The motor domain of axonemal dynein powers ciliary motility and its function is regulated by several accessary proteins bound to the tail region. Therefore, to understand the essential properties of dynein motility, examining the motile properties of the motor domain without the tail is necessary. In this study, the functional motor domain of the alpha heavy chain in Tetrahymena outer arm dynein was purified, and its motile properties were examined using an in vitro motility system. The purified protein caused microtubules to glide at a velocity of 5.0μm/s with their minus-end trailing, and motility was inhibited in an ATP concentration-dependent manner, which is in contrast with kinesin1. This method could be applicable to other axonemal dyneins and will enable further molecular studies on diverse axonemal dyneins and ciliary motility.

Identification of biotin carboxyl carrier protein in Tetrahymena and its application in in vitro motility systems of outer arm dynein

Axonemal dynein plays a central role in ciliary beating. Recently, a functional expression system of axonemal dynein was established in the ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena. This study identifies biotin carboxyl carrier protein (BCCP) in Tetrahymena and demonstrates its application in in vitro motility systems of outer arm dynein.