Insight into adaptive remodeling of the rotor ring complex of the bacterial flagellar motor

Structural basis of directional switching by the bacterial flagellum

The bacterial flagellum is a macromolecular protein complex that harvests energy from uni-directional ion flow across the inner membrane to power bacterial swimming via rotation of the flagellar filament. Rotation is bi-directional, with binding of a cytoplasmic chemotactic response regulator controlling reversal, though the structural and mechanistic bases for rotational switching are not well understood. Here we present cryoelectron microscopy structures of intact Salmonella flagellar basal bodies (3.2-5.5 Å), including the cytoplasmic C-ring complexes required for power transmission, in both counter-clockwise and clockwise rotational conformations. These reveal 180° movements of both the N- and C-terminal domains of the FliG protein, which, when combined with a high-resolution cryoelectron microscopy structure of the MotA5B2 stator, show that the stator shifts from the outside to the inside of the C-ring. This enables rotational switching and reveals how uni-directional ion flow across the inner membrane is used to accomplish bi-directional rotation of the flagellum.

The swimming defect caused by the absence of the transcriptional regulator LdtR in Sinorhizobium meliloti is restored by mutations in the motility genes motA and motS

The flagellar motor is a powerful macromolecular machine used to propel bacteria through various environments. We determined that flagellar motility of the alpha-proteobacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti is nearly abolished in the absence of the transcriptional regulator LdtR, known to influence peptidoglycan remodeling and stress response. LdtR does not regulate motility gene transcription. Remarkably, the motility defects of the ΔldtR mutant can be restored by secondary mutations in the motility gene motA or a previously uncharacterized gene in the flagellar regulon, which we named motS. MotS is not essential for S. meliloti motility and may serve an accessory role in flagellar motor function. Structural modeling predicts that MotS comprised an N-terminal transmembrane segment, a long-disordered region, and a conserved β-sandwich domain. The C terminus of MotS is localized in the periplasm. Genetics based substitution of MotA with MotAG12S also restored the ΔldtR motility defect. The MotAG12S variant protein features a local polarity shift at the periphery of the MotAB stator units. We propose that MotS may be required for optimal alignment of stators in wild-type flagellar motors but becomes detrimental in cells with altered peptidoglycan. Similarly, the polarity shift in stator units composed of MotB/MotAG12S might stabilize its interaction with altered peptidoglycan.

Structure, Assembly, and Function of Flagella Responsible for Bacterial Locomotion

Many motile bacteria use flagella for locomotion under a variety of environmental conditions. Because bacterial flagella are under the control of sensory signal transduction pathways, each cell is able to autonomously control its flagellum-driven locomotion and move to an environment favorable for survival. The flagellum of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium is a supramolecular assembly consisting of at least three distinct functional parts: a basal body that acts as a bidirectional rotary motor together with multiple force generators, each of which serves as a transmembrane proton channel to couple the proton flow through the channel with torque generation; a filament that functions as a helical propeller that produces propulsion; and a hook that works as a universal joint that transmits the torque produced by the rotary motor to the helical propeller. At the base of the flagellum is a type III secretion system that transports flagellar structural subunits from the cytoplasm to the distal end of the growing flagellar structure, where assembly takes place. In recent years, high-resolution cryo-electron microscopy (cryoEM) image analysis has revealed the overall structure of the flagellum, and this structural information has made it possible to discuss flagellar assembly and function at the atomic level. In this article, we describe what is known about the structure, assembly, and function of Salmonella flagella.

FliL and its paralog MotF have distinct roles in the stator activity of the Sinorhizobium meliloti flagellar motor

The bacterial flagellum is a complex macromolecular machine that drives bacteria through diverse fluid environments. Although many components of the flagellar motor are conserved across species, the roles of FliL are numerous and species‐specific. Here, we have characterized an additional player required for flagellar motor function in Sinorhizobium meliloti, MotF, which we have identified as a FliL paralog. We performed a comparative analysis of MotF and FliL, identified interaction partners through bacterial two‐hybrid and pull‐down assays, and investigated their roles in motility and motor rotation. Both proteins form homooligomers, and interact with each other, and with the stator proteins MotA and MotB. The ∆motF mutant exhibits normal flagellation but its swimming behavior and flagellar motor activity are severely impaired and erratic. In contrast, the ∆fliL mutant is mostly aflagellate and nonmotile. Amino acid substitutions in cytoplasmic regions of MotA or disruption of the proton channel plug of MotB partially restored motor activity to the ∆motF but not the ∆fliL mutant. Altogether, our findings indicate that both, MotF and FliL, are essential for flagellar motor torque generation in S. meliloti. FliL may serve as a scaffold for stator integration into the motor, and MotF is required for proton channel modulation.

Achievements in bacterial flagellar research with focus on Vibrio species

In 1980's, the most genes involved in the bacterial flagellar function and formation had been isolated though many of their functions or roles were not clarified. Bacterial flagella are the primary locomotive organ and are not necessary for growing in vitro but are probably essential for living in natural condition and are involved in the pathogenicity. In vitro, the flagella-deficient strains can grow at rates similar to wild-type strains. More than 50 genes are responsible for flagellar function, and the flagellum is constructed by more than 20 structural proteins. The maintenance cost of flagellum is high as several genes are required for its development. The fact that it evolved as a motor organ even with such the high cost shows that the motility is indispensable to survive under the harsh environment of Earth. In this review, we focus on flagella-related research conducted by the authors for about 40 years and flagellar research focused on Vibrio spp. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

A slight bending of an α-helix in FliM creates a counterclockwise-locked structure of the flagellar motor in Vibrio

Many bacteria swim by rotating flagella. The chemotaxis system controls the direction of flagellar rotation. Vibrio alginolyticus, which has a single polar flagellum, swims smoothly by rotating the flagellar motor counterclockwise (CCW) in response to attractants. In response to repellents, the motor frequently switches its rotational direction between CCW and clockwise (CW). We isolated a mutant strain that swims with a CW-locked rotation of the flagellum, which pulls rather than pushes the cell. This CW phenotype arises from a R49P substitution in FliM, which is the component in the C-ring of the motor that binds the chemotaxis signaling protein, phosphorylated CheY. However, this phenotype is independent of CheY, indicating that the mutation produces a CW conformation of the C-ring in the absence of CheY. The crystal structure of FliM with the R49P substitution showed a conformational change in the N-terminal α-helix of the middle domain of FliM (FliMM). This helix should mediates FliM-FliM interaction. The structural models of wild-type and mutant C-ring showed that the relatively small conformational change in FliMM induces a drastic rearrangement of the conformation of the FliMM domain that generates a CW conformation of the C-ring.

Architecture and Assembly of the Bacterial Flagellar Motor Complex

One of the central systems responsible for bacterial motility is the flagellum. The bacterial flagellum is a macromolecular protein complex that is more than five times the cell length. Flagella-driven motility is coordinated via a chemosensory signal transduction pathway, and so bacterial cells sense changes in the environment and migrate towards more desirable locations. The flagellum of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium is composed of a bi-directional rotary motor, a universal joint and a helical propeller. The flagellar motor, which structurally resembles an artificial motor, is embedded within the cell envelop and spins at several hundred revolutions per second. In contrast to an artificial motor, the energy utilized for high-speed flagellar motor rotation is the inward-directed proton flow through a transmembrane proton channel of the stator unit of the flagellar motor. The flagellar motor realizes efficient chemotaxis while performing high-speed movement by an ingenious directional switching mechanism of the motor rotation. To build the universal joint and helical propeller structures outside the cell body, the flagellar motor contains its own protein transporter called a type III protein export apparatus. In this chapter we summarize the structure and assembly of the Salmonella flagellar motor complex.

[Flagellar related genes and functions in Vibrio]

Bacteria can move or swim by flagella. On the other hand, the motile ability is not necessary to live at all. In laboratory, the flagella-deficient strains can grow just like the wild-type strains. The flagellum is assembled from more than 20 structural proteins and there are more than 50 genes including the structural genes to regulate or support the flagellar formation. The cost to construct the flagellum is so expensive. The fact that it evolved as a motor organ means even at such the large cost shows that the flagellum is essential for survival in natural condition. In this review, we would like to focus on the flagella-related researches conducted by the authors and the flagellar research on Vibrio spp.

Robustness in an Ultrasensitive Motor

In Escherichia coli, the chemotaxis response regulator CheY-P binds to FliM, a component of the switch complex at the base of the bacterial flagellar motor, to modulate the direction of motor rotation. The bacterial flagellar motor is ultrasensitive to the concentration of unbound CheY-P in the cytoplasm. CheY-P binds to FliM molecules both in the cytoplasm and on the motor. As the concentration of FliM unavoidably varies from cell to cell, leading to a variation of unbound CheY-P concentration in the cytoplasm, this raises the question whether the flagellar motor is robust against this variation, that is, whether the rotational bias of the motor is more or less constant as the concentration of FliM varies. Here, we showed that the motor is robust against variations of the concentration of FliM. We identified adaptive remodeling of the motor as the mechanism for this robustness. As the level of FliM molecules changes, resulting in different amounts of the unbound CheY-P molecules, the motor adaptively changes the composition of its switch complex to compensate for this effect.IMPORTANCE The bacterial flagellar motor is an ultrasensitive motor. Its output, the probability of the motor turning clockwise, depends sensitively on the occupancy of the protein FliM (a component on the switch complex of the motor) by the input CheY-P molecules. With a limited cellular pool of CheY-P molecules, cell-to-cell variation of the FliM level would lead to large unwanted variation of the motor output if not compensated. Here, we showed that the motor output is robust against the variation of FliM level and identified the adaptive remodeling of the motor switch complex as the mechanism for this robustness.

A Mechanism of Modulating the Direction of Flagellar Rotation in Bacteria by Fumarate and Fumarate Reductase

Fumarate, an electron acceptor in anaerobic respiration of Escherichia coli, has an additional function of assisting the flagellar motor to shift from counterclockwise to clockwise rotation, with a consequent modulation of the bacterial swimming behavior. Fumarate transmits its effect to the motor via the fumarate reductase complex (FrdABCD), shown to bind to FliG-one of the motor's switch proteins. How binding of the FrdABCD respiratory enzyme to FliG enhances clockwise rotation and how fumarate is involved in this activity have remained puzzling. Here we show that the FrdA subunit in the presence of fumarate is sufficient for binding to FliG and for clockwise enhancement. We further demonstrate by in vitro binding assays and super-resolution microscopy in vivo that the mechanism by which fumarate-occupied FrdA enhances clockwise rotation involves its preferential binding to the clockwise state of FliG (FliG_cw). Continuum electrostatics combined with docking analysis and conformational sampling endorsed the experimental conclusions and suggested that the FrdA-FliG_cw interaction is driven by the positive electrostatic potential generated by FrdA and the negatively charged areas of FliG. They further demonstrated that fumarate changes FrdA's conformation to one that can bind to FliG_cw. These findings also show that the reason for the failure of the succinate dehydrogenase flavoprotein SdhA (an almost-identical analog of FrdA shown to bind to FliG equally well) to enhance clockwise rotation is that it has no binding preference for FliG_cw. We suggest that this mechanism is physiologically important as it can modulate the magnitude of ΔG⁰ between the clockwise and counterclockwise states of the motor to tune the motor to the growth conditions of the bacteria.

Directional Switching Mechanism of the Bacterial Flagellar Motor

Bacteria sense temporal changes in extracellular stimuli via sensory signal transducers and move by rotating flagella towards into a favorable environment for their survival. Each flagellum is a supramolecular motility machine consisting of a bi-directional rotary motor, a universal joint and a helical propeller. The signal transducers transmit environmental signals to the flagellar motor through a cytoplasmic chemotactic signaling pathway. The flagellar motor is composed of a rotor and multiple stator units, each of which acts as a transmembrane proton channel to conduct protons and exert force on the rotor. FliG, FliM and FliN form the C ring on the cytoplasmic face of the basal body MS ring made of the transmembrane protein FliF and act as the rotor. The C ring also serves as a switching device that enables the motor to spin in both counterclockwise (CCW) and clockwise (CW) directions. The phosphorylated form of the chemotactic signaling protein CheY binds to FliM and FliN to induce conformational changes of the C ring responsible for switching the direction of flagellar motor rotation from CCW to CW. In this mini-review, we will describe current understanding of the switching mechanism of the bacterial flagellar motor.

Flagella-Driven Motility of Bacteria

The bacterial flagellum is a helical filamentous organelle responsible for motility. In bacterial species possessing flagella at the cell exterior, the long helical flagellar filament acts as a molecular screw to generate thrust. Meanwhile, the flagella of spirochetes reside within the periplasmic space and not only act as a cytoskeleton to determine the helicity of the cell body, but also rotate or undulate the helical cell body for propulsion. Despite structural diversity of the flagella among bacterial species, flagellated bacteria share a common rotary nanomachine, namely the flagellar motor, which is located at the base of the filament. The flagellar motor is composed of a rotor ring complex and multiple transmembrane stator units and converts the ion flux through an ion channel of each stator unit into the mechanical work required for motor rotation. Intracellular chemotactic signaling pathways regulate the direction of flagella-driven motility in response to changes in the environments, allowing bacteria to migrate towards more desirable environments for their survival. Recent experimental and theoretical studies have been deepening our understanding of the molecular mechanisms of the flagellar motor. In this review article, we describe the current understanding of the structure and dynamics of the bacterial flagellum.

Novel Insights into Conformational Rearrangements of the Bacterial Flagellar Switch Complex

The flagellar motor can spin in both counterclockwise (CCW) and clockwise (CW) directions. The flagellar motor consists of a rotor and multiple stator units, which act as a proton channel. The rotor is composed of the transmembrane MS ring made of FliF and the cytoplasmic C ring consisting of FliG, FliM, and FliN. The C ring is directly involved in rotation and directional switching. The Salmonella FliF-FliG deletion fusion motor missing 56 residues from the C terminus of FliF and 94 residues from the N terminus of FliG keeps a domain responsible for the interaction with the stator intact, but its motor function is reduced significantly. Here, we report the structure and function of the FliF-FliG deletion fusion motor. The FliF-FliG deletion fusion not only resulted in a strong CW switch bias but also affected rotor-stator interactions coupled with proton translocation through the proton channel of the stator unit. The energy coupling efficiency of the deletion fusion motor was the same as that of the wild-type motor. Extragenic suppressor mutations in FliG, FliM, or FliN not only relieved the strong CW switch bias but also increased the motor speed at low load. The FliF-FliG deletion fusion made intersubunit interactions between C ring proteins tighter compared to the wild-type motor, whereas the suppressor mutations affect such tighter intersubunit interactions. We propose that a change of intersubunit interactions between the C ring proteins may be required for high-speed motor rotation as well as direction switching.IMPORTANCE The bacterial flagellar motor is a bidirectional rotary motor for motility and chemotaxis, which often plays an important role in infection. The motor is a large transmembrane protein complex composed of a rotor and multiple stator units, which also act as a proton channel. Motor torque is generated through their cyclic association and dissociation coupled with proton translocation through the proton channel. A large cytoplasmic ring of the motor, called C ring, is responsible for rotation and switching by interacting with the stator, but the mechanism remains unknown. By analyzing the structure and function of the wild-type motor and a mutant motor missing part of the C ring connecting itself with the transmembrane rotor ring while keeping a stator-interacting domain for bidirectional torque generation intact, we found interesting clues to the change in the C ring conformation for the switching and rotation involving loose and tight intersubunit interactions.

Molecular Organization and Assembly of the Export Apparatus of Flagellar Type III Secretion Systems

The bacterial flagellum is a supramolecular motility machine consisting of the basal body, the hook, and the filament. For construction of the flagellum beyond the cellular membranes, a type III protein export apparatus uses ATP and proton-motive force (PMF) across the cytoplasmic membrane as the energy sources to transport flagellar component proteins from the cytoplasm to the distal end of the growing flagellar structure. The protein export apparatus consists of a PMF-driven transmembrane export gate complex and a cytoplasmic ATPase complex. In addition, the basal body C ring acts as a sorting platform for the cytoplasmic ATPase complex that efficiently brings export substrates and type III export chaperone-substrate complexes from the cytoplasm to the export gate complex. In this book chapter, we will summarize our current understanding of molecular organization and assembly of the flagellar type III protein export apparatus.

Rotational direction of flagellar motor from the conformation of FliG middle domain in marine Vibrio

FliG, which is composed of three distinctive domains, N-terminal (N), middle (M), and C-terminal (C), is an essential rotor component that generates torque and determines rotational direction. To determine the role of FliG in determining flagellar rotational direction, we prepared rotational biased mutants of fliG in Vibrio alginolyticus. The E144D mutant, whose residue is belonging to the EHPQR-motif in FliG_M, exhibited an increased number of switching events. This phenotype generated a response similar to the phenol-repellent response in chemotaxis. To clarify the effect of E144D mutation on the rotational switching, we combined the mutation with other che mutations (G214S, G215A and A282T) in FliG. Two of the double mutants suppressed the rotational biased phenotype. To gain structural insight into the mutations, we performed molecular dynamic simulations of the FliG_MC domain, based on the crystal structure of Thermotoga maritima FliG and nuclear magnetic resonance analysis. Furthermore, we examined the swimming behavior of the fliG mutants lacking CheY. The results suggested that the conformation of FliG in E144D mutant was similar to that in the wild type. However, that of G214S and G215A caused a steric hindrance in FliG. The conformational change in FliG_M triggered by binding CheY may lead to a rapid change of direction and may occur in both directional states.

Effect of a clockwise-locked deletion in FliG on the FliG ring structure of the bacterial flagellar motor

FliG is a rotor protein of the bacterial flagellar motor. FliG consists of FliG_N , FliG_M and FliG_C domains. Intermolecular FliG_M -FliG_C interactions promote FliG ring formation on the cytoplasmic face of the MS ring. A conformational change in Helix_MC connecting FliG_M and FliG_C is responsible for the switching between the counterclockwise (CCW) and clockwise (CW) rotational states of the FliG ring. However, it remains unknown how it occurs. Here, we carried out in vivo disulfide cross-linking experiments to see the effect of a CW-locked deletion (∆PAA) in FliG on the FliG ring structure in Salmonella enterica. Higher-order oligomers were observed in the membrane fraction of the fliG(∆PAA + G166C/G194C) strain upon oxidation with iodine in a way similar to FliG(G166C/G194C), indicating that the PAA deletion does not inhibit domain-swap polymerization of FliG. FliG(∆PAA + E174C) formed a cross-linked homodimer whereas FliG(E174C) did not, indicating that Glu174 in Helix_MC of one FliG protomer is located much closer to that of its neighboring subunit in the CW motor than in the CCW motor. We will discuss possible helical rearrangements of Helix_MC that induce a structural remodeling of the FliG ring upon flagellar motor switching.