Correlation between ToBI test and in vivo titration for diphtheria and tetanus

An ELISA system for tetanus toxoid potency tests: An alternative to lethal challenge

For a long time, a widely used method for tetanus toxoid (Ttd) potency has been the challenge test, in which animals are immunized and then challenged with tetanus toxin in lethal or non-lethal way. In the context of animal welfare, an alternative is desired because the method causes unsustainable distress to animals. We aimed to replace the system for describing test results, in which scores are assigned to symptoms exhibited by challenged animals, with scores assigned to antibody ELISA titers in immunized mouse sera. The potency values and confidence intervals calculated by the absorbance score system were equivalent to those calculated by the symptom score system. We also attempted to utilize the raw ELISA absorbance instead of the assigned absorbance score and obtained similar results. ELISA may serve as an alternative to the lethal challenge for Ttd potency tests, not only in Japan but also in other countries in which mouse challenge tests are employed.

Tetanus antitoxin potency assessment by surface plasmon resonance and ToBI test

Potency testing of tetanus antitoxin must be performed in vivo, in a very painful, stressful and prone to high variability assay. It is, therefore, mandatory to find alternatives to this kind of potency assessment. Immunochemical tests as ELISA or ToBI test are already available but usually results in a poor correlation to the in vivo protection. Considering research and development of mono and oligoclonal antibodies against tetanus and the improvement of equine polyclonal antitoxin production and control, we developed an alternative instrumental test for tetanus antitoxin by using surface plasmon resonance. Tetanus antitoxin from hyperimmune equine sera (16 batches) were tested and the results indicated excellent concordance and correlation to the in vivo test (Lin's ρ = 0.9). This innovative approach should now be improved in order to extend it to oligoclonal and monoclonal human antibodies aiming to replace mice for the potency assessment of tetanus antitoxin especially during research and development steps.