Size-dependent elastic/inelastic behavior of enamel over millimeter and nanometer length scales

Mechanical insights into jawbone characteristics under chronic kidney disease: A comprehensive nanoindentation approach

The mechanical properties of the jawbone play a critical role in determining the successful integration of dental prostheses. Chronic kidney disease (CKD) has been identified to abnormally accelerate bone turnover rates. However, the impact of CKD on the mechanical characteristics of the jawbone has not been extensively studied. This study sought to evaluate the time-dependent viscoelastic behaviors of rat jawbones, particularly in the scenarios both with and without CKD. We hypothesized that CKD might compromise the bone's innate toughening mechanisms, potentially owing to the time-dependent viscoelasticity of the bone matrix proteins. The maxillary and mandibular bones of Wistar rats were subjected to nanoindentation and Raman micro-spectroscopy. Load-hold-displacement curves from the cortical regions were obtained via nanoindentation and were mathematically characterized using a suitable viscoelastic constitutive model. Raman micro-spectroscopy was employed to identify nuanced vibrational changes in local molecular structures induced by CKD. The time course of indenter penetration onto cortical bones during the holding stage (creep behavior) can be mathematically represented by a series arrangement of the Kelvin-Voigt bodies. This configuration dictates the overall viscoelastic response observed during nanoindentation tests. The CKD model exhibited a reduced extent of viscoelastic contributions, especially during the initial ramp loading phase in both the maxillary and mandibular cortical bones. The generalized Kelvin-Voigt model comprises 2 K-Voigt elements that signify an immediate short retardation time (τ1) and a subsequent prolonged retardation time (τ2), respectively. Notably, the mandibular CKD model led to an increase in the delayed τ2 alongside an increase in non-enzymatic collagen cross-linking. These suggest that, over time, CKD diminishes the bone's capability for supplementary energy absorption and dimensional recovery, thus heightening their susceptibility to fractures.

Chronic kidney disease compromises structural and mechanical properties of maxillary cortical bone in a rat model

PURPOSE

This study aimed to investigate the effects of chronic kidney disease (CKD) on the structural and mechanical properties of the maxillary and mandibular cortical bone.

METHODS

The maxillary and mandibular cortical bones from CKD model rats were used in this study. CKD-induced histological, structural, and micro-mechanical alterations were assessed using histological analyses, micro-computed tomography (CT), bone mineral density (BMD) measurements, and nanoindentation tests.

RESULTS

Histological analyses indicated that CKD caused an increase in the number of osteoclasts and a decrease in the number of osteocytes in the maxilla. Micro-CT analysis revealed that CKD induced a void volume/cortical volume (%) increase, which was more remarkable in the maxilla than in the mandible. CKD also significantly decreased the BMD in the maxilla. In the nanoindentation stress-strain curve, the elastic-plastic transition point and loss modulus were lower in the CKD group than that in the control group in the maxilla, suggesting that CKD increased micro fragility of the maxillary bone.

CONCLUSIONS

CKD affected bone turnover in the maxillary cortical bone. Furthermore, the maxillary histological and structural properties were compromised, and micro-mechanical properties, including the elastic-plastic transition point and loss modulus, were altered by CKD.

Deciphering load attenuation mechanisms of the dentin-enamel junction: Insights from a viscoelastic constitutive model

A considerable material discontinuity between the enamel and dentin might jeopardize the tooth's mechanical durability over time without the attenuation of the dentin-enamel junction (DEJ). However, the critical loading transmission mechanism at the DEJ remains understudied. This study aimed to define the extent and effective width of the DEJ, along with its mechanical competence. The presence of DEJ interphase layer was identified using a motif analysis based on the ion beam-transmission electron microscopy coupled with nanoindentation modulus mapping. For each region, nanoindentation load-displacement curves were recorded and mathematically analyzed using an appropriate viscoelastic constitutive model. The time-course of indenter penetration (creep) behavior of the tooth tissues can be mathematically approximated by the Kelvin-Voigt model in series, which determined the visco-contribution to the overall mechanical responses. Therefore, the elastic-plastic contribution can be distinguished from the overall mechanical responses of the tooth after subtracting the visco-contributions. During the loading period, the enamel behavior was dominated by elastic-plastic responses, while both the dentin and DEJ showed pronounced viscoelastic responses. The instantaneous modulus of the DEJ, which was measured by eliminating viscoelastic behavior from the raw load-displacement curve, was almost double that of the dentin. The DEJ was stiffer than the dentin, but it exhibited large viscoelastic motion even at the initial loading stage. This study revealed that the load attenuation competence of the DEJ, which involves extra energy expenditure, is mainly associated with its viscoelasticity. The mathematical analysis proposed here, performed on the nanoindentation creep behavior, could potentially augment the existing knowledge on hard-tissue biomechanics. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: In this study, we undertake a rigorous mechanical characterization of the dentin-enamel junction (DEJ) using an advanced nanoindentation technique coupled with a pertinent viscoelastic constitutive model. Our approach unveils the substantial viscoelastic contribution of the DEJ during the initial indentation loading phase and offers an elaborate delineation of the DEJ interphase layer through sophisticated image analysis. These insights significantly augment our understanding of tooth durability. Importantly, our innovative mathematical analysis of creep behavior introduces a novel approach with profound implications for future research in the expansive field of hard-tissue biomechanics. The pioneering methodologies and findings presented in this work hold substantial potential to invigorate progress in biomaterials research and fuel further explorations into the functionality of biological tissues.

A Remineralizing and Antibacterial Coating for Arresting Caries

Dental caries is a dynamic disease induced by the unbalance between demineralization of dental hard tissues caused by biofilm and remineralization of them; however, although various effective remineralization methods have been well documented, it is a challenge to reestablish the balance by enhancing remineralization alone while ignoring the antibacterial therapy. Therefore, the integration of remineralizing and antibacterial technologies offers a promising strategy to halt natural caries progression in clinical practice. Here, the conception of interrupting dental caries (IDC) was proposed based on the development of dual-functional coating with remineralizing and antibacterial properties. In this study, bovine serum albumin (BSA) loaded octenidine (OCT) successfully to form a BSA-OCT composite. Subsequently, through fast amyloid-like aggregation, the phase-transited BSA-OCT (PTB-OCT) coating can be covered on teeth, resin composite, or sealant surfaces in 30 min by a simple smearing process. The PTB-OCT coating showed satisfactory effects in promoting the remineralization of demineralized enamel and dentin in vitro. Moreover, this coating also exerted significant acid-resistance stability and anti-biofilm properties. Equally importantly, this coating exhibited promising abilities in reducing the microleakage between the tooth and resin composite in vitro and preventing primary and secondary caries in vivo. In conclusion, this novel dual-functional PTB-OCT coating could reestablish the balance between demineralization and remineralization in the process of caries, thereby potentially preventing or arresting caries.

Fatigue and wear of human tooth enamel: A review

Human tooth enamel must withstand the cyclic contact forces, wear, and corrosion processes involved with typical oral functions. Furthermore, unlike other human tissues, dental enamel does not have a significant capacity for healing or self-repair and thus the longevity of natural teeth in the oral environment depends to a large degree on the fatigue and wear properties of enamel. The purpose of this review is to provide an overview of our understanding of the fatigue and wear mechanisms of human enamel and how they relate to in vivo observations of tooth damage in the complex oral environment. A key finding of this review is that fatigue and wear processes are closely related. For example, the presence of abrasive wear particles significantly lowers the forces needed to initiate contact fatigue cracking while subsurface fatigue crack propagation drives key delamination wear mechanisms during attrition or attrition-corrosion of enamel. Furthermore, this review seeks to bring a materials science and mechanical engineering perspective to fatigue and wear phenomena. In this regard, we see developing a mechanistic description of fatigue and wear, and understanding the interconnectivity of the processes, as essential for successfully modelling enamel fatigue and wear damage and developing strategies and treatments to improve the longevity of our natural teeth. Furthermore, we anticipate that this review will stimulate ideas for extending the lifetime of the natural tooth structure and will help highlight where our understanding is too limited and where additional research into fatigue and wear of human tooth enamel is warranted.

Special architecture and anti-wear strategies for giant panda tooth enamel: Based on wear simulation findings

Giant pandas are the flagship species in world conservation. Due to bamboo being the primary food source for giant pandas, dental wear is common owing to the extreme toughness of the bamboo fiber. Even though research on tooth enamel wear in humans and domestic animals is well-established, research on tooth enamel wear in giant pandas is scarce. The purpose of this study is to evaluate tooth enamel wear resistance in giant pandas to provide a basis for a better understanding of their evolutionary process. From microscopic and macroscopic perspectives, the abrasion resistance of dental enamel in giant pandas is compared with that of herbivorous cattle and carnivorous dogs in this study. This involves the use of micro-scratch and frictional wear tests. The results show that the boundary between the enamel prism and the enamel prism stroma is well-defined in panda and canine teeth, while bovine tooth enamel appears denser. Under constant load, the tribological properties of giant panda enamel are similar to those of canines and significantly different from those of bovines. Test results show that the depth of micro scratches in giant panda and canine enamel was greater than in cattle, with greater elastic recovery occurring in dogs. Scratch morphology indicates that the enamel substantive damage critical value is greater in pandas than in both dogs and cattle. The analysis suggests that giant panda enamel consists of a neatly arranged special structure that may disperse extrusion stress and absorb impact energy through a series of inelastic deformation mechanisms to cope with the wear caused by eating bamboo. In this study, the excellent wear resistance of giant panda's tooth enamel is verified by wear tests. A possible theoretical explanation of how the special structure of giant panda tooth enamel may improve its wear resistance is provided. This provides a direction for subsequent theoretical and experimental studies on giant panda tooth enamel and its biomaterials.

Structure-function relationships in dog dentin

Investigations into teeth mechanical properties provide insight into physiological functions and pathological changes. This study sought to 1) quantify the spatial distribution of elastic modulus, hardness and the microstructural features of dog dentin and to 2) investigate quantitative relationships between the mechanical properties and the complex microstructure of dog dentin. Maxillary canine teeth of 10 mature dogs were sectioned in the transverse and vertical planes, then tested using nanoindentation and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Microstructural features (dentin area fraction and dentinal tubule density) and mechanical properties (elastic modulus and hardness) were quantified. Results demonstrated significant anisotropy and spatial variation in elastic modulus, hardness, dentin area fraction and tubule density. These spatial variations adhered to a consistent distribution pattern; hardness, elastic modulus and dentin area fraction generally decreased from superficial to deep dentin and from crown tip to base; tubule density generally increased from superficial to deep dentin. Poor to moderate correlations between microstructural features and mechanical properties (R² = 0.032-0.466) were determined. The results of this study suggest that the other constituents may contribute to the mechanical behavior of mammalian dentin. Our results also present several remaining opportunities for further investigation into the roles of organic components (e.g., collagen) and mineral content on dentin mechanical behavior.

Comparison of modern light-curing hybrid resin-based composites to the tooth structure: Static and dynamic mechanical parameters

The study aims to compare the way modern resin-based composites (RBCs) respond to mechanical stress related to the tooth structure they are designed to replace. Eight representative light-cured RBCs, including ormocers, giomers, RBCs with nano and agglomerated nanoparticles, prepolymerized, or compact fillers, were selected. Flexural strength, FS and modulus/E, were measured in a three-point bending test. A fractographic analysis determined the origin of fracture. The quasi-static (indentation hardness/H_IT , indentation modulus/E_IT ) and viscoelastic (storage modulus/E', loss modulus/E″, loss factor/tan δ) behavior was assessed by a depth-sensing indentation test equipped with a dynamic-mechanical analysis module. One and multiple-way analysis of variance (ANOVA), Tukey honestly significant difference (HSD) post-hoc tests (α = 0.05), and Weibull statistics were applied. Parameter material exhibited the highest effect on E (p < .001, η_P ²  = .857), followed by FS (η_P ²  = .729), and the strain (η_P ²  = .553). Highest material reliability was identified in the RBCs with nano and agglomerated nanoparticles. The most frequent type of failure originated from volume (81.3%), followed by edge (10.6%), and corner (8.1%) flaws. Enamel evidenced three times higher H_IT , E_IT , and E' values as RBCs and dentin, and the smallest deviation from ideal elasticity. Ormocers exhibited the highest damping capacity, followed by the RBCs with prepolymerized fillers. Damping capacity and static mechanical properties are mutually exclusive. Analyzed RBCs and the tooth structure are better adapted to the relevant frequency for chewing than for higher frequencies. RBCs are comparable to dentin in terms of their mechanical performance, but apart from the damping behavior, they are far inferior to enamel. Damping ability of analyzed material could be exploited for correlation with the clinical behavior.

Study on fracture behavior of molars based on three-dimensional high-precision computerized tomography scanning and numerical simulation

A series of three-dimensional (3D) numerical simulations are conducted to investigate the gradual failure process of molars in this study. The real morphology and internal mesoscopic structure of a whole tooth are implemented into the numerical simulations through computerized tomography scanning, digital image processing, and 3D matrix mapping. The failure process of the whole tooth subject to compressions including crack initiation, crack propagation, and final failure pattern is reproduced using 3D realistic failure process analysis (RFPA3D) method. It is concluded that a series of microcracks are gradually initiated, nucleated, and subsequently interconnect to form macroscopic cracks when the teeth are under over-compressions. The propagation of the macroscopic cracks results in the formation of fracture surfaces and penetrating cracks, which are essential signs and manifestations of the tooth failure. Moreover, the simulations reveal that, the material heterogeneity is a critical factor that affects the mechanical properties and fracture modes of the teeth, which vary from crown fractures to crown-root fractures and root fractures depending on different homogeneity indices.

Black Drum Fish Teeth: Built for Crushing Mollusk Shells

With an exclusive diet of hard-shelled mollusks, the black drum fish (Pogonias cromis) exhibits one of the highest bite forces among extant animals. Here we present a systematic microstructural, chemical, crystallographic, and mechanical analysis of the black drum teeth to understand the structural basis for achieving the molluscivorous requirements. At the material level, the outermost enameloid shows higher modulus (E_r = 126.9 ± 16.3 GPa, H = 5.0 ± 1.4 GPa) than other reported fish teeth, which is attributed to the stiffening effect of Zn and F doping in apatite crystals and the preferential co-alignment of crystallographic c-axes and enameloid rods along the biting direction. The high fracture toughness (K_c = 1.12 MPa⋅m^1/2) of the outer enameloid also promotes local yielding instead of fracture during crushing contact with mollusk shells. At the individual-tooth scale, the molar-like teeth, high density of dentin tubules, enlarged pulp chamber, and specialized dentin-bone connection, all contribute to the functional requirements, including confinement of contact compressive stress in the stiff enameloid, enhanced energy absorption in the compliant dentin, and controlled failure of tooth-bone composite under excessive loads. These results show that the multi-scale structures of black drum teeth are adapted to feed on hard-shelled mollusks. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: The black drum fish feeds on hard-shelled mollusks, which requires strong, tough, and wear-resistant teeth. This study presents a comprehensive multiscale material and mechanical analysis of the black drum teeth in achieving such remarkable biological function. At microscale, the fluoride- and zinc-doped apatite crystallites in the outer enameloid region are aligned perpendicular to the chewing surface, representing one of the stiffest biomineralized materials found in nature. In the inner enameloid region, the apatite crystals are arranged into intertwisted rods with crystallographic misorientation for increased crack resistance and toughness. At the macroscale, the molariform geometry, the two-layer design based on the outer enameloid and inner dentin, enlarged pulp chamber and the underlying strong bony toothplate work synergistically to contribute to the teeth's crushing resistance.

Microstructural and mechanical recovery of bone in ovariectomized rats: The effects of menaquinone-7

The loss of bone quantity and quality in postmenopausal female patients can be a problem for dental treatment. A sufficient intake of nutrients such as calcium, magnesium, and vitamins D and K is likely correlated with the mechanical properties of bone. In particular, vitamin K2, also called menaquinone (MK), inhibits bone loss in postmenopausal women. Here we demonstrate the microstructural and mechanical properties of bone recovery in ovariectomized (OVX) rats during MK-7 administration. Bilateral ovariectomy and a sham operation were performed on 14-week-old female SPF Wistar rats. MK-4 and -7 were orally administered at 30 mg/kg daily for 12 weeks. The femur was used for the 3-point bending test and microstructural analysis of the cancellous bone by micro-CT, and the mandibular cortical bone for the evaluation of mechanical properties on a nanoscale. Micro-computed tomography revealed irregular trabecular architecture, hollow marrow cavities, and sparse trabecular bone in the femurs of the OVX group. Trabecular bone structure analysis showed that the MK-7 group had greater bone volume per tissue volume (BV/TV) and a higher trabecular number than the OVX group. The bulk-scale 3-point bending test did not allow the mechanical properties between OVX and OVX/MK7 groups to be discerned, yet at the smallest level, the elastic-plastic transition point of the nanoindentation stress-strain curve of the mandibular cortical bone was higher in the MK-7 group than in the OVX group. These findings suggest that MK-7 enables bone microstructural and mechanical recovery in the OVX model.

High-resolution mechanical mapping of the adhesive-dentin interface: The effect of co-monomers in 10-methacryloyloxydecyl dihydrogen phosphate

The presence of 10-methacryloyloxydecyl dihydrogen phosphate (MDP) at the adhesive-dentin interface enables ionic binding to calcium salts, which results in rigid nano-layering within the submicron scale resin-dentin interdiffusion zone. MDP has been used with additional co-monomers, such as hydroxyethyl methacrylate (HEMA) and/or 4-methacryloyloxyethyl-trimellitic acid (4-MET), mainly to enhance the chemical bonding properties. However, the use of co-monomers may compromise the rigidity of the adhesive-dentin interface. In this study, we use high-resolution mechanical mapping across the interface to discern the in situ mechanical properties of each target region at the nanoscale. Visualization by modulus mapping demonstrated that HEMA increases the diffusion properties of MDP into dentin structures. However, the rigidity of the adhesive-dentin interface indicated by the storage modulus was markedly lower in MDP containing HEMA than in MDP containing 4-MET. Dynamic indentation testing revealed that the bonding layer was more deformable in the presence of HEMA. Moreover, the presence of MDP in the bonding layer might also increase the deformability because the polymerization linearity allows a large degree of viscoelasticity. These factors also diminish the rigidity of the adhesive-dentin interface. Within the limitations of this study, our findings demonstrated that 4-MET is a better co-monomer than HEMA in MDP-based dental adhesives. Modulus mapping and nanoindentation are introduced as new tests for the adhesive-dentin interface to address queries about the effectiveness of dental adhesives.

X-ray diffraction and in situ pressurization of dentine apatite reveals nanocrystal modulus stiffening upon carbonate removal

Bone-like materials comprise carbonated-hydroxyapatite nanocrystals (c-Ap) embedding a fibrillar collagen matrix. The mineral particles stiffen the nanocomposite by tight attachment to the protein fibrils creating a high strength and toughness material. The nanometer dimensions of c-Ap crystals make it very challenging to measure their mechanical properties. Mineral in bony tissues such as dentine contains 2~6 wt.% carbonate with possibly different elastic properties as compared with crystalline hydroxyapatite. Here we determine strain in biogenic apatite nanocrystals by directly measuring atomic deformation in pig dentine before and after removing carbonate. Transmission electron microscopy revealed the platy 3D morphology while atom probe tomography revealed carbon inside the calcium rich domains. High-energy X-ray diffraction in combination with in situ hydrostatic pressurization quantified reversible c-Ap deformations. Crystal strains differed between annealed and ashed (decarbonated) samples, following 1 or 10 h heating at 250 °C or 550 °C respectively. Measured bulk moduli (K) and a-/c-lattice deformation ratios (η) were used to generate synthetic K_syn and η_syn identifying the most likely elastic constants C₃₃ and C₁₃ for c-Ap. These were then used to calculate the nanoparticle elastic moduli. For ashed samples, we find an average E₁₁=107 GPa and E₃₃ =128 GPa corresponding to ~5% and ~17% stiffening of the a-/c-axes of the nanocrystals as compared with the biogenic nanocrystals in annealed samples. Ashed samples exhibit ~10% lower Poisson's ratios as compared with the 0.25~0.36 range of carbonated apatite. Carbonate in c-Ap may therefore serve for tuning local deformability within bony tissues. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Carbonated apatite nanoparticles, typical for bony tissues, stiffen the network of collagen fibrils. However, it is not known if the biogenic apatite mechanical (elastic) properties differ from those of geologic mineral counterparts. Indeed the tiny dimensions and variable carbonate composition may have strong effects on deformation resistance. The present study provides experimental measurements of the elastic constants which we use to estimate Young's moduli and Poisson's ratio values. Comparison between ashed and annealed dentine samples quantifies the properties of both carbonated and decarbonated apatite nanocrystals. The results reveal fundamental attributes of bony mineral and showcase the additive advantages of combining X-ray diffraction with in situ hydrostatic compression, backed by atom probe and transmission electron microscopy tomography.

Nanoscale effects of beverages on enamel surface of human teeth: An atomic force microscopy study

Dental erosion has become a prevalence disease and attracted increasing attention worldwide. In this research, we quantitatively evaluate the mechanical and morphological changes in the very early stages of softening and weakening of human enamel surfaces induced by soft drinks using atomic force microscopy (AFM). With an increase of the immersion time in soft drinks, we found a significant increase of surface roughness (R_q) of the enamel surface. The prismatic structure of enamel was clearly observed after a 1-h immersion in Coca-Cola®, which shows its strong erosion effect. According to the elastic modulus mapping images obtained by AFM, a considerable decrease of elastic modulus (E) of enamel surface has been found as the enamel surface structures are etched away by soft drinks. A high surface roughness of enamel will result in a high chance of cavities due to easier bacterial adhesion on rougher surface, while a drastic deterioration of the mechanical properties of the enamel will weaken its protection property. Our findings show the serious influence of acidic drinks on enamel surface at the very beginning stage of etching process, which is quite meaningful for people to prevent dental erosion and keep dental health.

Characterization of Enamel and Dentine about a White Spot Lesion: Mechanical Properties, Mineral Density, Microstructure and Molecular Composition

The study focuses on in vitro tracing of some fundamental changes that emerge in teeth at the initial stage of caries development using multiple approaches. The research was conducted on a mostly sound maxillary molar tooth but with a clearly visible natural proximal white spot lesion (WSL). Values of mineral density, reduced Young's modulus, indentation hardness and creep as well as the molecular composition and surface microstructure of the WSL and bordering dentine area were studied. The results obtained were compared to those of sound enamel and dentine on the same tooth. A decrease of mechanical properties and mineral density both for the WSL and bordering dentine was detected in comparison to the sound counterparts, as well as increase of creep for the enamel WSL. Differences in molecular composition and surface microstructure (including the indenter impressions) were found and described. WSL induces a serious change in the state of not only the visually affected enamel but also surrounding visually intact enamel and dentine in its vicinity. The results provide the basis for future studies of efficacy of minimal invasive treatments of caries.

Nature's design solutions in dental enamel: Uniting high strength and extreme damage resistance

The most important demand of today's high-performance materials is to unite high strength with extreme fracture toughness. The combination of withstanding large forces (strength) and resistance to fracture (toughness), especially preventing catastrophic material failure by cracking, is of utmost importance when it comes to structural applications of these materials. However, these two properties are commonly found to be mutually exclusive: strong materials are brittle and tough materials are soft. In dental enamel, nature has combined both properties with outstanding success - despite a limited number of available constituents. Made up of brittle mineral crystals arranged in a sophisticated hierarchical microstructure, enamel exhibits high stiffness and excellent toughness. Different species exhibit a variety of structural adaptations on varying scales in their dental enamel which optimise not only fracture toughness, but also hardness and abrasion behaviour. Nature's materials still outperform their synthetic counterparts due to these complex structure-property relationships that are not yet fully understood. By analysing structure variations and the underlying mechanical mechanisms systematically, design principles which are the key for the development of advanced synthetic materials uniting high strength and toughness can be formulated. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Dental enamel is a hard protective tissue that combines high strength with an exceptional resistance to catastrophic fracture, properties that in classical materials are commonly found to be mutually exclusive. The biological material is able to outperform its synthetic counterparts due to a sophisticated hierarchical microstructure. Between different species, microstructural adaptations can vary significantly. In this contribution, the different types of dental enamel present in different species are reviewed and connections between microstructure and (mechanical) properties are drawn. By consolidating available information for various species and reviewing it from a materials science point of view, design principles for the development of advanced biomimetic materials uniting high strength and toughness can be formulated.

Optimized biological tools: ultrastructure of rodent and bat teeth compared to human teeth

Enamel, the outer layer of the teeth of vertebrates, is the hardest tissue in their body. In general, enamel is highly mineralized and has a special ultrastructure that directs the mechanical properties of teeth and thereby their biological functions. However, there are differences between the enamel ultrastructures of different species. The authors compare the teeth of the Eurasian beaver Castor fiber, the African mole rat Fukomys kafuensis and the common pipistrelle bat Pipistrellus pipistrellus by high-resolution analytical methods, including scanning electron microscopy, quantitative wavelength-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy and X-ray powder diffraction. The enamel of all animals consists of long, thin and differently oriented calcium phosphate crystallites (length > 1 µm; thickness about 50 nm). On the outer surface of the beaver tooth, a thin layer of brown iron oxide was found. The diameter of the dentin tubuli was between 1 and 3 µm for all species – that is, comparable to that for human teeth.

Research of the role of microstructure in the wear mechanism of canine and bovine enamel

The relationship between the microstructure and tribological behavior of mammalian tooth enamel has not been fully understood. In this paper, the microstructure, mechanical properties, and tribological behavior of canine (carnivore) and bovine (herbivore) enamel are studied using scanning electronic microscopy and nano-indentation/scratch technique, aiming to reveal the contribution of enamel microstructure to its mechanical and tribological properties. Canine enamel has a microstructure of hard keyhole-like rods embedded in soft inter-rod enamel, and its surface exhibits high resistance against both micro-crack initiation and crack-induced delamination during friction and wear process. Bovine enamel with the microstructure consisting of the hydroxyapatite (HAP) nano-fibers in decussation has higher surface hardness and better capabilities of resisting wear and encumbering crack propagation, as compared to canine enamel. In sum, the soft inter-rod enamel in the canine enamel contributes to high load tolerance and then protects enamel surface from brittle damage, while the staggered arrangement of HAP nano-fibers benefits hard bovine enamel in crack propagation resistance and then help resist wear and fatigue. The findings suggest that there exists a self-adaptation in enamel microstructure and tribological performance of mammals with their feeding habits, which will promote and assist the bionic design of high-performance materials.

Polarization induced contrast X-ray fluorescence at submicrometer resolution reveals nanometer apatite crystal orientations across entire tooth sections

For biomedical research, successful imaging of calcified microstructures often relies on absorption differences between features, or on employing dies with selective affinity to areas of interest. When texture is concerned, e.g. for crystal orientation studies, polarization induced contrast is of particular interest. This requires sufficient interaction of the incoming radiation with the volume of interest in the sample to produce orientation-based contrast. Here we demonstrate polarization induced contrast at the calcium K-edge using submicron sized monochromatic synchrotron X-ray beams. We exploit the orientation dependent subtle absorption differences of hydroxyl-apatite crystals in teeth, with respect to the polarization field of the beam. Interaction occurs with the fully mineralized samples, such that differences in density do not contribute to the contrast. Our results show how polarization induced contrast X-ray fluorescence mapping at specific energies of the calcium K-edge reveals the micrometer and submicrometer crystal arrangements in human tooth tissues. This facilitates combining both high spatial resolution and large fields of view, achieved in relatively short acquisition times in reflection geometry. In enamel we observe the varying crystal orientations of the micron sized prisms exposed on our prepared surface. We easily reproduce crystal orientation maps, typically observed in polished thin sections. We even reveal maps of submicrometer mineralization fronts in spherulites in intertubular dentine. This Ca K-edge polarization sensitive method (XRF-PIC) does not require thin samples for transmission nor extensive sample preparation. It can be used on both fresh, moist samples as well as fossilized samples where the information of interests lies in the crystal orientations and where the crystalline domains extend several micrometers beneath the exposed surface.

Hydration-induced nano- to micro-scale self-recovery of the tooth enamel of the giant panda

The tooth enamel of vertebrates comprises a hyper-mineralized bioceramic, but is distinguished by an exceptional durability to resist impact and wear throughout the lifetime of organisms; however, enamels exhibit a low resistance to the initiation of large-scale cracks comparable to that of geological minerals based on fracture mechanics. Here we reveal that the tooth enamel, specifically from the giant panda, is capable of developing durability through counteracting the early stage of damage by partially recovering its innate geometry and structure at nano- to micro- length-scales autonomously. Such an attribute results essentially from the unique architecture of tooth enamel, specifically the vertical alignment of nano-scale mineral fibers and micro-scale prisms within a water-responsive organic-rich matrix, and can lead to a decrease in the dimension of indent damage in enamel introduced by indentation. Hydration plays an effective role in promoting the recovery process and improving the indentation fracture toughness of enamel (by ∼73%), at a minor cost of micro-hardness (by ∼5%), as compared to the dehydrated state. The nano-scale mechanisms that are responsible for the recovery deformation, specifically the reorientation and rearrangement of mineral fragments and the inter- and intra-prismatic sliding between constituents that are closely related to the viscoelasticity of organic matrix, are examined and analyzed with respect to the structure of tooth enamel. Our study sheds new light on the strategies underlying Nature's design of durable ceramics which could be translated into man-made systems in developing high-performance ceramic materials. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Tooth enamel plays a critical role in the function of teeth by providing a hard surface layer to resist wear/impact throughout the lifetime of organisms; however, such enamel exhibits a remarkably low resistance to the initiation of large-scale cracks, of hundreds of micrometers or more, comparable to that of geological minerals. Here we reveal that tooth enamel, specifically that of the giant panda, is capable of partially recovering its geometry and structure to counteract the early stages of damage at nano- to micro-scale dimensions autonomously. Such an attribute results essentially from the architecture of enamel but is markedly enhanced by hydration. Our work discerns a series of mechanisms that lead to the deformation and recovery of enamel and identifies a unique source of durability in the enamel to accomplish this function. The ingenious design of tooth enamel may inspire the development of new durable ceramic materials in man-made systems.

Nano-indentation of native phytoliths and dental tissues: implications for herbivore-plant combat and dental wear proxies

Tooth wear induced by abrasive particles is a key process affecting dental function and life expectancy in mammals. Abrasive particles may be plant endogenous opal phytoliths, exogene wind-blown quartz dust or rain borne mineral particles ingested by mammals. Nano-indentation hardness of abrasive particles and dental tissues is a significant yet not fully established parameter of this tribological system. We provide consistent nano-indentation hardness data for some of the major antagonists in the dental tribosystem (tooth enamel, tooth dentine and opaline phytoliths from silica controlled cultivation). All indentation data were gathered from native tissues under stable and controlled conditions and thus maximize comparability to natural systems. Here we show that native (hydrated) wild boar enamel exceeds any hardness measures known for dry herbivore tooth enamel by at least 3 GPa. The native tooth enamel is not necessarily softer then environmental quartz grit, although there is little overlap. The native hardness of the tooth enamel exceeds that of any silica phytolith hardness recently published. Further, we find that native reed phytoliths equal native suine dentine in hardness, but does not exceed native suine enamel. We also find that native suine enamel is significantly harder than dry enamel and dry phytoliths are harder than native phytoliths. Our data challenge the claim that the culprit of tooth wear may be the food we chew, but suggest instead that wear may relates more to exogenous than endogenous abrasives.

Evidence that metallic proxies are unsuitable for assessing the mechanics of microwear formation and a new theory of the meaning of microwear

Mammalian tooth wear research reveals contrasting patterns seemingly linked to diet: irregularly pitted enamel surfaces, possibly from consuming hard seeds, versus roughly aligned linearly grooved surfaces, associated with eating tough leaves. These patterns are important for assigning diet to fossils, including hominins. However, experiments establishing conditions necessary for such damage challenge this paradigm. Lucas et al. (Lucas et al. 2013 J. R. Soc. Interface10, 20120923. (doi:10.1098/rsif.2012.0923)) slid natural objects against enamel, concluding anything less hard than enamel would rub, not abrade, its surface (producing no immediate wear). This category includes all organic plant matter. Particles harder than enamel, with sufficiently angular surfaces, could abrade it immediately, prerequisites that silica/silicate particles alone possess. Xia et al. (Xia, Zheng, Huang, Tian, Chen, Zhou, Ungar, Qian. 2015 Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA112, 10 669-10 672. (doi:10.1073/pnas.1509491112)) countered with experiments using brass and aluminium balls. Their bulk hardness was lower than enamel, but the latter was abraded. We examined the ball exteriors to address this discrepancy. The aluminium was surfaced by a thin rough oxide layer harder than enamel. Brass surfaces were smoother, but work hardening during manufacture gave them comparable or higher hardness than enamel. We conclude that Xia et al.'s results are actually predicted by the mechanical model of Lucas et al. To explain wear patterns, we present a new model of textural formation, based on particle properties and presence/absence of silica(tes).

A COMPUTATIONAL STRATEGY TO EXAMINE THE PROFILE EFFECTS OF MICROPRISM REGIONS ON THE OVERALL ANISOTROPY OF HUMAN ENAMELS

In this study, our attention is mainly on elaborating a computational strategy to effectively predict the influence of prism profiles on the overall anisotropic property of human enamels (HEs). At first, two distinct schemes are developed separately with the aid of the polynomial fitting technique and the general power functions to mathematically describe the practical irregular and simplified regular profiles of enamel prisms. Hereafter, two parametric piecewise formulas, which facilitate the definition of anisotropic material properties of finite elements at different locations and make the numerical simulation of HE microstructures consisting of irregularly shaped prisms feasible, are presented to describe the orientation of hydroxyapatite (HAP) crystallites embedded in microprisms. The effective anisotropic moduli over a representative unit cell (RUC) under the periodic displacement constraint is concisely introduced according to the micromechanics, and a computational strategy is established to calculate these moduli numerically. Finally, the evaluations in the open literature are employed to demonstrate the validity of the elaborated computational strategy, and more investigations are conducted and yield the conclusions such that the material property of the inter-prism regions as well as the prism shapes plays a crucial role in determining the overall anisotropy of HEs.

Evidence that metallic proxies are unsuitable for assessing the mechanics of microwear formation and a new theory of the meaning of microwear

Mammalian tooth wear research reveals contrasting patterns seemingly linked to diet: irregularly pitted enamel surfaces, possibly from consuming hard seeds, versus roughly aligned linearly grooved surfaces, associated with eating tough leaves. These patterns are important for assigning diet to fossils, including hominins. However, experiments establishing conditions necessary for such damage challenge this paradigm. Lucas et al. (Lucas et al. 2013 J. R. Soc. Interface10, 20120923. (doi:10.1098/rsif.2012.0923)) slid natural objects against enamel, concluding anything less hard than enamel would rub, not abrade, its surface (producing no immediate wear). This category includes all organic plant matter. Particles harder than enamel, with sufficiently angular surfaces, could abrade it immediately, prerequisites that silica/silicate particles alone possess. Xia et al. (Xia, Zheng, Huang, Tian, Chen, Zhou, Ungar, Qian. 2015 Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA112, 10 669-10 672. (doi:10.1073/pnas.1509491112)) countered with experiments using brass and aluminium balls. Their bulk hardness was lower than enamel, but the latter was abraded. We examined the ball exteriors to address this discrepancy. The aluminium was surfaced by a thin rough oxide layer harder than enamel. Brass surfaces were smoother, but work hardening during manufacture gave them comparable or higher hardness than enamel. We conclude that Xia et al.'s results are actually predicted by the mechanical model of Lucas et al. To explain wear patterns, we present a new model of textural formation, based on particle properties and presence/absence of silica(tes).

Durability of adhesive bonds to tooth structure involving the DEJ

The importance of the Dentin Enamel Junction (DEJ) to the durability of adhesive bonds to tooth structure is unclear. In fact, no investigation has been reported on contributions of the DEJ to the fatigue resistance of the bonded interface. In this study, the durability of adhesive bonds to tooth structure involving the DEJ was quantified and compared to that of adhesive bonds to enamel only, not including the DEJ. Two different configurations of enamel bonding were considered, including when tensile stress is focused on the outer enamel (occlusal configuration) or the inner decussated enamel (decussated configuration). The resistance to failure for all bonded interfaces was assessed under both static and cyclic loading to failure. Results showed that the durability of the bonded interfaces was primarily a function of their resistance to crack initiation and growth. The bonded interface strength involving the DEJ was significantly (p ≤ 0.05) greater than that of bonds to enamel only with occlusal configuration, under both static and cyclic loading. While the fatigue strength of bonds involving the DEJ was approximately 20% greater than that for enamel bonds with occlusal configuration (7.7MPa) it was lower than that of enamel with the decussated configuration. The DEJ deterred cracks from extending readily into the dentin but it did not prevent fatigue failure. These results suggest that the durability of bonds to enamel are most dependent on the enamel rod decussation and that the DEJ plays a minor role.

Enhanced protective role in materials with gradient structural orientations: Lessons from Nature

Living organisms are adept at resisting contact deformation and damage by assembling protective surfaces with spatially varied mechanical properties, i.e., by creating functionally graded materials. Such gradients, together with multiple length-scale hierarchical structures, represent the two prime characteristics of many biological materials to be translated into engineering design. Here, we examine one design motif from a variety of biological tissues and materials where site-specific mechanical properties are generated for enhanced protection by adopting gradients in structural orientation over multiple length-scales, without manipulation of composition or microstructural dimension. Quantitative correlations are established between the structural orientations and local mechanical properties, such as stiffness, strength and fracture resistance; based on such gradients, the underlying mechanisms for the enhanced protective role of these materials are clarified. Theoretical analysis is presented and corroborated through numerical simulations of the indentation behavior of composites with distinct orientations. The design strategy of such bioinspired gradients is outlined in terms of the geometry of constituents. This study may offer a feasible approach towards generating functionally graded mechanical properties in synthetic materials for improved contact damage resistance.

STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

Living organisms are adept at resisting contact damage by assembling protective surfaces with spatially varied mechanical properties, i.e., by creating functionally-graded materials. Such gradients, together with multiple length-scale hierarchical structures, represent the prime characteristics of many biological materials. Here, we examine one design motif from a variety of biological tissues where site-specific mechanical properties are generated for enhanced protection by adopting gradients in structural orientation at multiple length-scales, without changes in composition or microstructural dimension. The design strategy of such bioinspired gradients is outlined in terms of the geometry of constituents. This study may offer a feasible approach towards generating functionally-graded mechanical properties in synthetic materials for improved damage resistance.

Mechanical properties of human enamel under compression: On the feature of calculations

The paper is aimed at determination of the causes of shape effect in human tooth enamel under compression and correction of the relevant mechanical characteristics. For this purpose, six groups of samples with different ratios of the compression surface diagonal to the sample height, which consisted of 10 cuboid samples in each, were prepared from the backside of human enamel. The lateral deformation of a sample was calculated at the maximum compressive stress for correction of the mechanical characteristics. It is shown that the ratio between the lateral and axial deformations decreases with an increase in the ratio of the compression surface diagonal to the sample height. This is caused by the friction between the compression plates and the working surfaces of the enamel sample when the lateral deformation is suppressed. In addition, the slope of enamel sample by about 15° occurred during compression due to the inclination of rigid and low deformable enamel rods. The corrections of the elastic modulus and the compression strength taking into account the lateral deformation and the sample slope are carried out. The mechanical properties of enamel samples with the 2.1 aspect ratio are closer to the intrinsic properties of human enamel samples. The elastic modulus and the compression strength of human enamel under compression are 5.64 GPa and 363 MPa, respectively. The lateral deformation (~10%) may be considered as the critical parameter that indicates the strength of human enamel.

On the importance of aging to the crack growth resistance of human enamel

With improvements in oral health and an overall increase in quality of life, the percentage of fully or largely dentate seniors is increasing. Understanding the effects of aging on the mechanical properties of teeth is essential to the maintenance of lifelong oral health. In this investigation the effects of aging on the fracture toughness of human enamel were evaluated from incremental crack growth experiments performed on tissue of donor teeth representing "young" (17 ⩽ age ⩽ 25) and "old" (age ⩾ 55) age groups. Results showed that the old enamel exhibited significantly lower resistance to fracture than that of the young tissue in two orthogonal directions of crack growth. For crack growth transverse to the enamel rods, the fracture toughness of the old enamel (0.37 ± 0.15 MPa m(0.5)) was nearly 70% lower than that of tissue from the young teeth (1.23 ± 0.20 MPa m(0.5)). Based on results from a mechanistic analysis of crack growth, the reduction in fracture resistance is attributed to a decrease in the degree of extrinsic toughening. The practice of restorative dentistry should account for these changes in tooth tissues in the treatment of senior patients.

STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

The mechanical behavior of enamel has been studied for over 3 decades. Due to the limited volume of tissue available for evaluation, past work has been largely based on indentation methods. In this investigation we have evaluated the resistance to fracture of human enamel using a conventional fracture mechanics approach and incremental crack growth. We compared the fracture resistance of cuspal enamel obtained from the teeth of representative "young" and "old" donor groups. Our results show that there is a substantial reduction in the resistance to fracture with age, that it is anisotropic, and that the degradation is more severe than that which occurs to dentin. As such, we feel this work is a significant contribution to the field.

Viscoplastic response of tooth enamel under cyclic microindentation

Cyclic microindentations were performed on the occlusal surface and axial section of tooth enamel, using the Berkovich indenter. Under the action of a cyclic indentation load, the indenter continuously penetrated into the tooth enamel and reached a quasi-steady state at which the penetration depth per cycle was a constant. At the quasi-steady state, both the amplitude of the indentation depth and the penetration depth per cycle for the cyclic indentation of the axial section are larger than those for the indentation of the occlusal section under the same loading condition. The energy dissipation per cycle consists of two contributions; one is the plastic energy dissipated per cycle due to the propagation of the plastic zone underneath the indentation and the other is the energy dissipation due to the viscous flow during the cyclic indentation. Both the penetration depth and the plastic energy dissipated per cycle at the quasi-steady state are independent of the maximum applied load and increase with increasing the amplitude of the cyclic indentation load.

Nanoscratch testing for the assessment of enamel demineralization under conditions simulating wine erosion

BACKGROUND

Erosive tooth wear and dentinal hypersensitivity are common problems affecting professional wine tasters. By using nanoscratch testing, the aim of this in vitro study was to assess enamel softening under conditions simulating 10 one-minute episodes of wine erosion.

METHODS

Ten enamel specimens were bathed in artificial saliva for 2 hours before being eroded for 10 episodes, with each episode comprising one minute of wine erosion followed by one minute of remineralization in artificial saliva. Nanoscratches were placed with a spherical tip (20 μm radius) in a nanoindenter under a load of 100 mN at baseline (stage 1), after a one-erosion episode (stage 2) and after 10-erosion episodes (stage 3).

RESULTS

There were significant effects of erosion stages on both scratch depth (p<0.001) and surface roughness (p<0.001). Post hoc tests showed significant differences in both scratch depths and surface roughness between stages 1 and 3 (p<0.001), and between stages 2 and 3 (p<0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Enamel softening occurs at an early stage of wine tasting, emphasizing the need to implement early preventive strategies in professional wine tasters. Further research elucidating the fundamental mechanisms involved in early stages of erosion has the potential to lead to development of more effective preventive strategies.

The role of organic proteins on the crack growth resistance of human enamel

With only 1% protein by weight, tooth enamel is the most highly mineralized tissue in mammals. The focus of this study was to evaluate contributions of the proteins on the fracture resistance of this unique structural material. Sections of enamel were obtained from the cusps of human molars and the crack growth resistance was quantified using a conventional fracture mechanics approach with complementary finite element analysis. In selected specimens the proteins were extracted using a potassium hydroxide treatment. Removal of the proteins resulted in approximately 40% decrease in the fracture toughness with respect to the fully proteinized control. The loss of organic content was most detrimental to the extrinsic toughening mechanisms, causing over 80% reduction in their contribution to the total energy to fracture. This degradation occurred by embrittlement of the unbroken bridging ligaments and consequent reduction in the crack closure stress. Although the organic content of tooth enamel is very small, it is essential to crack growth toughening by facilitating the formation of unbroken ligaments and in fortifying their potency. Replicating functions of the organic content will be critical to the successful development of bio-inspired materials that are designed for fracture resistance.

Uniaxial compressive behavior of micro-pillars of dental enamel characterized in multiple directions

In this work, the compressive elastic modulus and failure strength values of bovine enamel at the first hierarchical level formed by hydroxyapatite (HA) nanofibers and organic matter are identified in longitudinal, transverse and oblique direction with the uniaxial micro-compression method. The elastic modulus values (∼70 GPa) measured here are within the range of results reported in the literature but these values were found surprisingly uniform in all orientations as opposed to the previous nanoindentation findings revealing anisotropic elastic properties in enamel. Failure strengths were recorded up to ∼1.7 GPa and different failure modes (such as shear, microbuckling, fiber fracture) governed by the orientation of the HA nanofibers were visualized. Structural irregularities leading to mineral contacts between the nanofibers are postulated as the main reason for the high compressive strength and direction-independent elastic behavior on enamels first hierarchical level.

Mapping residual organics and carbonate at grain boundaries and the amorphous interphase in mouse incisor enamel

Dental enamel has evolved to resist the most grueling conditions of mechanical stress, fatigue, and wear. Adding insult to injury, it is exposed to the frequently corrosive environment of the oral cavity. While its hierarchical structure is unrivaled in its mechanical resilience, heterogeneity in the distribution of magnesium ions and the presence of Mg-substituted amorphous calcium phosphate (Mg-ACP) as an intergranular phase have recently been shown to increase the susceptibility of mouse enamel to acid attack. Herein we investigate the distribution of two important constituents of enamel, residual organic matter and inorganic carbonate. We find that organics, carbonate, and possibly water show distinct distribution patterns in the mouse enamel crystallites, at simple grain boundaries, and in the amorphous interphase at multiple grain boundaries. This has implications for the resistance to acid corrosion, mechanical properties, and the mechanism by which enamel crystals grow during amelogenesis.

Damage modeling of small-scale experiments on dental enamel with hierarchical microstructure

Dental enamel is a highly anisotropic and heterogeneous material, which exhibits an optimal reliability with respect to the various loads occurring over years. In this work, enamel's microstructure of parallel aligned rods of mineral fibers is modeled and mechanical properties are evaluated in terms of strength and toughness with the help of a multiscale modeling method. The established model is validated by comparing it with the stress-strain curves identified by microcantilever beam experiments extracted from these rods. Moreover, in order to gain further insight in the damage-tolerant behavior of enamel, the size of crystallites below which the structure becomes insensitive to flaws is studied by a microstructural finite element model. The assumption regarding the fiber strength is verified by a numerical study leading to accordance of fiber size and flaw tolerance size, and the debonding strength is estimated by optimizing the failure behavior of the microstructure on the hierarchical level above the individual fibers. Based on these well-grounded properties, the material behavior is predicted well by homogenization of a representative unit cell including damage, taking imperfections (like microcracks in the present case) into account.

On the mechanical properties of tooth enamel under spherical indentation

The mechanical properties of tooth enamel generally exhibit large variations, which reflect its structural and material complexity. Some key properties were evaluated under localized contact, simulating actual functioning conditions. Prominent cusps of extracted human molar teeth were polished down ~0.7 mm below the cusp tip and indented by tungsten carbide balls. The internal damage was assessed after unloading from longitudinal or transverse sections. The ultimate tensile stress (UTS) was determined using a novel bilayer specimen. The damage is characterized by penny-like radial cracks driven by hoop stresses and cylindrical cracks driven along protein-rich interrod materials by shear stresses. Shallow cone cracks typical of homogeneous materials which may cause rapid tooth wear under repeat contact are thus avoided. The mean stress vs. indentation strain curve is highly nonlinear, attributable to plastic shearing of protein between and within enamel rods. This curve is also affected by damage, especially radial cracks, the onset of which depends on ball radius. Several material properties were extracted from the tests, including shear strain at the onset of ring cracks γ(F) (=0.14), UTS (=119 MPa), toughness K(C) (=0.94 MPa m(1/2)), a crack propagation law and a constitutive response determined by trial and error with the aid of a finite-element analysis. These quantities, which are only slightly sensitive to anatomical location within the enamel region tested, facilitate a quantitative assessment of crown failure. Causes for variations in published UTS and K(C) values are discussed.