Enhanced sulfate reduction accompanied with electrically-conductive pili production in graphene oxide modified biocathodes

Enhanced denitrification by graphene oxide-modified cathode for the secondary effluent of wastewater treatment plants in three-dimensional biofilm electrode reactors

In this study, a novel three-dimensional biofilm electrode reactor (3D-BER) with a graphene oxide (GO)-modified cathode was developed to enhance the denitrification performance of secondary effluent from wastewater treatment plants (SEWTPs). The effects of different hydraulic retention times (HRTs) and currents on the 3D-BER were explored. The results indicated that at the optimal HRT of 4 h and current of 350 mA/m2, the 3D-BER with GO-modified cathode had a higher denitrification rate (2.40 ± 0.1 mg TN/L/h) and less accumulation of intermediate products, especially with 3.34% total nitrogen (TN) molar conversion to N2O. The GO-modified cathode offered a large biocompatible specific surface area and enhanced the conductivity, which favored microbial growth and increased electron transfer efficiency and extracellular enzyme activities. Moreover, the activity of nitrite reductase increased more than that of nitrate reductase to accelerate nitrite reduction, thus facilitating the denitrification process. The proposed 3D-BER provided an effective solution to elevate tertiary denitrification in the SEWTP.

Magnetite Alters the Metabolic Interaction between Methanogens and Sulfate-Reducing Bacteria

It is known that the presence of sulfate decreases the methane yield in the anaerobic digestion systems. Sulfate-reducing bacteria can convert sulfate to hydrogen sulfide competing with methanogens for substrates such as H2 and acetate. The present work aims to elucidate the microbial interactions in biogas production and assess the effectiveness of electron-conductive materials in restoring methane production after exposure to high sulfate concentrations. The addition of magnetite led to a higher methane content in the biogas and a sharp decrease in the level of hydrogen sulfide, indicating its beneficial effects. Furthermore, the rate of volatile fatty acid consumption increased, especially for butyrate, propionate, and acetate. Genome-centric metagenomics was performed to explore the main microbial interactions. The interaction between methanogens and sulfate-reducing bacteria was found to be both competitive and cooperative, depending on the methanogenic class. Microbial species assigned to the Methanosarcina genus increased in relative abundance after magnetite addition together with the butyrate oxidizing syntrophic partners, in particular belonging to the Syntrophomonas genus. Additionally, Ruminococcus sp. DTU98 and other species assigned to the Chloroflexi phylum were positively correlated to the presence of sulfate-reducing bacteria, suggesting DIET-based interactions. In conclusion, this study provides new insights into the application of magnetite to enhance the anaerobic digestion performance by removing hydrogen sulfide, fostering DIET-based syntrophic microbial interactions, and unraveling the intricate interplay of competitive and cooperative interactions between methanogens and sulfate-reducing bacteria, influenced by the specific methanogenic group.

Effect of different carbon sources on sulfate reduction and microbial community structure in bioelectrochemical systems

Microbial electrolysis cells (MECs) have rapidly developed into a promising technology to treat sulfate-rich wastewater that lacks electron donors. Hence, a better understanding of the effect on the microbial community structure caused by different sources in bioelectrochemical systems is required. This study sought to investigate the effect of different carbon sources (NaHCO₃, ethanol, and acetate were employed as sole carbon source respectively) on the performance of sulfate-reducing biocathodes. The sulfate reduction efficiency enhanced by the bioelectrochemical systems was 8.09 - 11.57% higher than that of open-circuit reference experiments. Furthermore, the optimum carbon source was ethanol with a maximum sulfate reduction rate of 170 mg L^-1 d^-1 in the bioelectrochemical systems. The different carbon sources induced significant differences in sulfate reduction efficiency as demonstrated by the application of a micro-electrical field. Microbial community structure and network analysis revealed that all three kinds of carbon source systems enriched large proportions of sulfate-reducing bacteria and electroactive bacteria but were significantly distinct in composition. The dominant sulfate-reducing bacteria that use NaHCO₃ and acetate as carbon sources were Desulfobacter and Desulfobulbus, whereas those that use ethanol as carbon source were Desulfomicrobium and Desulfovibrio. Our results suggest that ethanol is a more suitable carbon source for sulfate reduction in bioelectrochemical systems.

Roles of Fe-C amendment on sulfate-containing pharmaceutical wastewater anaerobic treatment: Microbial community and sulfur metabolism

The effects of multiple two-phase anaerobic treatment involving acidification coupling Fe-C on sulfate-containing chemical synthesis-based pharmaceutical wastewater treatment were investigated. Fe-C was added as a filler with 25% vol. to acidogenic reactors for semi-continuous operation. The results suggested that Fe-C amendment promoted sulfate removal efficiency by 47.5% and shortened the reaction time by 50% in the acidogenic phase. With mitigation of sulfate inhibition, SCOD removal efficiency and methane production were further increased by 24.6% and 398% compared to direct raw wastewater anaerobic digestion, respectively, in methanogenic phase. The results of sulfate removal kinetics confirmed a 150% increase of removal rate in acidogenic phase. However, the apparent kinetic microbial sulfate removal constant without Fe-C amendment was maintained at approximately 0.06 h^-1. The Fe-C amendment not only increased the relative abundance of Methanothrix and Desulfovibrio for sulfate reduction but also enriched unclassified_p__Chloroflexi and unclassified_c__Deltaproteobacteria for acidification. Metagenomic results indicated that Fe-C enhanced dissimilatory sulfate reduction and PAPS synthesis of assimilatory step. The hydrogen sulfide production through the 3-mercaptopyruvate to pyruvate pathways was also enhanced. Butyrate-oxidizing genes were increased synchronously to convert butyrate to acetate.

Removal of Arsenate From Groundwater by Cathode of Bioelectrochemical System Through Microbial Electrosorption, Reduction, and Sulfuration

Arsenate [As(V)] is a toxic metalloid and has been observed at high concentrations in groundwater globally. In this study, a bioelectrochemical system (BES) was used to efficiently remove As(V) from groundwater, and the mechanisms involved were systematically investigated. Our results showed that As(V) can be efficiently removed in the BES cathode chamber. When a constant cell current of 30 mA (I_cell, volume current density = 66.7 A/m³) was applied, 90 ± 3% of total As was removed at neutral pH (7.20–7.50). However, when I_cell was absent, the total As in the effluent, mainly As(V), had increased approximately 2–3 times of the As(V) in influent. In the abiotic control reactor, under the same condition, no significant total As or As(V) removal was observed. These results suggest that As(V) removal was mainly ascribed to microbial electrosorption of As(V) in sludge. Moreover, part of As(V) was bioelectrochemically reduced to As(III), and sulfate was also reduced to sulfides [S(–II)] in sludge. The XANES results revealed that the produced As(III) reacted with S(–II) to form As₂S₃, and the residual As(III) was microbially electroadsorbed in sludge. This BES-based technology requires no organic or chemical additive and has a high As(V) removal efficiency, making it an environment-friendly technique for the remediation of As-contaminated groundwater.

Energetics, electron uptake mechanisms and limitations of electroautotrophs growing on biocathodes - A review

Electroautotrophs are microorganisms that can take the electrons needed for energy generation, CO₂ fixation and other metabolic reactions from a polarized electrode. They have been the focus of intense research for its application in wastewater treatment, bioelectrosynthetic processes and hydrogen generation. As a general trend, current densities produced by the electron uptake of these microorganisms are low, limiting their applicability at large scale. In this work, the electron uptake mechanisms that may operate in electroautotrophs are reviewed, aiming at finding possible causes for this low performance. Biomass yields, growth rates and electron uptake rates observed when these microorganisms use chemical electron donors are compared with those typically obtained with electrodes, to explore limitations and advantages inherent to the electroautotrophic metabolism. Also, the factors affecting biofilm development are analysed to show how interfacial interactions condition bacterial adhesion, biofilm growth and electrons uptake. Finally, possible strategies to overcome these limitations are described.

Interrelation between sulphur and conductive materials and its impact on ammonium and organic pollutants removal in electroactive wetlands

This investigation is the first of its kind to evaluate the interrelation of sulphate (SO₄^2-) with conductive materials as well as their individual and synergetic effects on the removal of ammonium and organic pollutants in electroactive wetlands, also known as constructed wetland (CW) - microbial fuel cell (MFC). The role of MFC components in CW was investigated to treat the sulphate containing wastewater under a long-term operation without any toxicity build-up in the system. A comparative study was also performed between CW-MFC and CW, where sulphate containing wastewater (S-replete) and without sulphate wastewater (S-deplete) was assessed. The S-replete showed high NH₄⁺ removal than the S-deplete, and the requesnce of removal was: CW-MFC-replete>CW-MFC-deplete>CW-replete>CW-deplete. The chemical oxygen demand (COD) removal was high in the case of CW-MFC-replete, and the sequence of removal was CW-MFC-replete>CW-MFC-deplete>CW-deplete>CW-replete. X-ray photon spectroscopic study indicates 0.84% sulphur accumulation in CW-MFC-replete and 2.49% in CW-replete, indicating high sulphur precipitation in CW without the MFC component. The high relative abundance of class Deltaproteobacteria (7.3%) in CW-MFC-replete along with increased microbial diversity (Shannon index=3.5) rationalise the symbiosis of sulphate reducing/oxidising microbes and its impact on the treatment performance and electrochemical activity.

Effect of applied voltage on membrane fouling in the amplifying anaerobic electrochemical membrane bioreactor for long-term operation

A novel and amplifying anaerobic electrochemical membrane bioreactor (AnEMBR, R2) was constructed and operated for a long time (204 days) with synthetic glucose solution having an average chemical oxygen demand (COD) of 315 mg L⁻¹, at different applied voltages and room temperatures. More than twice sodium bicarbonate was added for maintaining a pH of around 6.7 in the supernatant of the reactor R2, close to that of a control reactor called anaerobic membrane bioreactor (AnMBR, R1), after 138 days. And the transmembrane pressure (TMP) for the R2 system was only 0.534 bar at the end of operation and 0.615 bar for the R1 system. Although the electrostatic repulsion force contributed to pushing away the pollutants (proteins, polysaccharose and inorganic salt deposits, and so on), more microorganisms adsorbed and accumulated on the membrane surface after the whole operation, which might result in a rapid increase in membrane filtration resistance in the long-term operation. There were much more exoelectrogenic bacteria, mainly Betaproteobacteria, Deltaproteobacteria and Grammaproteobacteria, on the cathode and the dominant methanogen Methanothrix content on the cathode was three times higher than the AnMBR. The study provides an important theoretical foundation for the application of AnEMBR technology in the treatment of low organic strength wastewater.

A novel and amplifying anaerobic electrochemical membrane bioreactor was constructed and operated for a long time (204 days) with synthetic glucose solution having an average chemical oxygen demand (COD) of 315 mg L⁻¹, at different applied voltages and room temperatures.

Recent progress of graphene based nanomaterials in bioelectrochemical systems

The application of graphene (Gr) to microbial fuel cells (MFCs) and microbial electrolysis cell (MECs) is considered a very promising approach in terms of enhancing their performance. The superior Gr properties of high electrical and thermal conductivities, along with: superior specific surface area, high electron mobility, and mechanical strength, are the key features that endorse this. Factors impeding the advancement of a microbial fuel cell into commercialization involve primarily the cost of their components, and their production on a small scale. Gr with such outstanding characteristics can help mitigate these challenges, when used as electrode material. The application of Gr as an anode material improves the efficiency of electron transfer and bacterial attachment. When used as a cathode material, it supports the oxygen reduction reaction. This investigation, presents a thorough analysis of the feasibility of Gr as an electrode material in both MFC and MEC applications - based on experimental results from the investigation. Current technological advancements in the implementation of Gr in MFC and MEC are also highlighted in this review. To summarise, the investigation exposes critical issues impeding the advancement of microbial fuel cells, and proposes possible solutions to mitigate these challenges.

Producing electrical energy in microbial fuel cells based on sulphate reduction: a review

Combination of the treatment of effluents with high organic loads and the production of electricity is the driving forces stimulating the development of microbial fuel cells (MFC). The increase in electricity production in MFCs requires not only the optimization of the operational parameters but also the inhibition of the metabolic pathways, which compete with electricity production, such as methanogenesis. The presence of both sulphate and sulphide ions in conventional anaerobic reactors hampers the growth of methanogenic archaea and justifies the use of sulphate and therefore sulphate-reducing bacteria (SRB) in the anodic half-cell of MFC. Most importantly, the literature on the subject reveals that SRB are able to directly transfer electrons to solid electrodes, enabling the production of electrical energy. This technology is versatile because it associates the removal of both sulphate and the chemical oxygen demand (COD) with the production of electricity. Therefore, the current work revises the main aspects related to the inoculation of MFC with SRB focusing on (i) the microbial interactions in the anodic chamber, (ii) the electron transfer pathways to the solid anode, and also (iii) the sulphate and COD removal yields along with the electricity production efficiencies.

Enhanced electron transfer on microbial electrosynthesis biocathode by polypyrrole-coated acetogens

Extracellular electron transfer (EET) is a significant pathway to transport electrons between bacteria and electrode in microbial electrosynthesis systems (MESs). To enhance EET in the MES, a high-conductivity polymer, polypyrrole (PPy), was coated on the surface of mixed culture acetogens in situ and the PPy-coated bacteria were inoculated on the cathode of MES. The charge transfer resistance of PPy-coated biocathode was 33%-70% of that with PPy-uncoated. Acetate production rate and Faradic efficiency in PPy-coated biocathodes increased by 3 to 6 times. After 960 h operation, Acetobacterium, Desulfovibrio, and Acinetobacter dominate the community on the coated and uncoated biocathode. Quinone loop and NADH dehydrogenase to ubiquinone were involved in electron transfer pathway of biocathode and stimulated by PPy coating. Low-level expression of C-type cytochromes on biocathode indicated its less important role in inward EET. The study provided useful information for applications of high-conductivity chemicals in microbial electrosynthesis.

Advances in heavy metal removal by sulfate-reducing bacteria

Industrial development has led to generation of large volumes of wastewater containing heavy metals, which need to be removed before the wastewater is released into the environment. Chemical and electrochemical methods are traditionally applied to treat this type of wastewater. These conventional methods have several shortcomings, such as secondary pollution and cost. Bioprocesses are gradually gaining popularity because of their high selectivities, low costs, and reduced environmental pollution. Removal of heavy metals by sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB) is an economical and effective alternative to conventional methods. The limitations of and advances in SRB activity have not been comprehensively reviewed. In this paper, recent advances from laboratory studies in heavy metal removal by SRB were reported. Firstly, the mechanism of heavy metal removal by SRB is introduced. Then, the factors affecting microbial activity and metal removal efficiency are elucidated and discussed in detail. In addition, recent advances in selection of an electron donor, enhancement of SRB activity, and improvement of SRB tolerance to heavy metals are reviewed. Furthermore, key points for future studies of the SRB process are proposed.

Interaction of graphene-family nanomaterials with microbial communities in sequential batch reactors revealed by high-throughput sequencing

The accelerated development and application of graphene-family nanomaterials (GFNs) have increased their release to various environments and converged in wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). However, little is known about the interactions between GFNs and microbes in WWTPs. In this study, the interaction of graphene oxide (GO) or graphene (G) at different concentrations with microbial communities in sequential batch reactors was investigated. Transmission electron microscopy and Raman spectroscopy analyses showed that the structures of GFNs were obviously changed, which suggested GFNs could be degraded by some microbes. Significantly higher DNA concentration and lower cell number in high-concentration GO group were detected by DNA leakage test and qPCR analysis, which confirmed the microbial toxicity of GO. The chemical oxygen demand and ammonia nitrogen removals were significantly affected by G and GO with high concentrations. Further, high-throughput sequencing confirmed the composition and dynamic changes of microbial communities under GFNs exposure. Saccharibacteria genera incertae sedis (12.55-28.05%) and Nakamurella (20.45-29.30%) were the predominant genera at two stages, respectively. FAPROTAX suggested 12 functional groups with obvious changes related to the biogeochemical cycle of C, N and S. Molecular ecological network analysis showed that the networks were more complex in the presence of GFNs, and the increased negative interactions reflected more competition relationships in microbial communities. This study is the first to report the effect of GFNs on network of microbial communities, which provides in-depth insights into the complex and highlights concerns regarding the risk of GFNs to WWTPs.

Enhanced methane production by alleviating sulfide inhibition with a microbial electrolysis coupled anaerobic digestion reactor

Anaerobic digestion (AD) of organics is a challenging task under high-strength sulfate (SO₄^2-) conditions. The generation of toxic sulfides by SO₄^2--reducing bacteria (SRB) causes low methane (CH₄) production. This study investigated the feasibility of alleviating sulfide inhibition and enhancing CH₄ production by using an anaerobic reactor with built-in microbial electrolysis cell (MEC), namely ME-AD reactor. Compared to AD reactor, unionized H₂S in the ME-AD reactor was sufficiently converted into ionized HS^- due to the weak alkaline condition created via cathodic H₂ production, which relieved the toxicity of unionized H₂S to methanogenesis. Correspondingly, the CH₄ production in the ME-AD system was 1.56 times higher than that in the AD reactor with alkaline-pH control and 3.03 times higher than that in the AD reactors (no external voltage and no electrodes) without alkaline-pH control. MEC increased the amount of substrates available for CH₄-producing bacteria (MPB) to generate more CH₄. Microbial community analysis indicated that hydrogentrophic MPB (e.g. Methanosphaera) and acetotrophic MPB (e.g. Methanosaeta) participated in the two major pathways of CH₄ formation were successfully enriched in the cathode biofilm and suspended sludge of the ME-AD system. Economic revenue from increased CH₄ production totally covered the cost of input electricity. Integration of MEC with AD could be an attractive technology to alleviate sulfide inhibition and enhance CH₄ production from AD of organics under SO₄^2--rich condition.

Microbial interactions regulated by the dosage of ferroferric oxide in the co-metabolism of organic carbon and sulfate

Effects of ferroferric oxide (Fe₃O₄) and organic carbon on co-metabolism of sulfate and organic carbon were investigated. With Fe₃O₄, the degradation of acetate and sulfate was inhibited when fed with acetate, while the degradation of acetate and propionate produced from ethanol was promoted when fed with ethanol. The dominant sulfate reducing bacteria (SRB) of acetate-fed reactors were Desulfobacteraceae (complete oxidizing SRB, CO-SRB) and Desulfurmonas (incomplete oxidizing SRB, IO-SRB). IO-SRBs of Desulfobulbus and Desulfomicrobium were dominant in ethanol-fed reactors. CO-SRB had higher competitiveness than methanogens to utilize acetate, while IO-SRBs might cooperate with methanogens to produce methane when dosed with ethanol and Fe₃O₄. The dosage of Fe₃O₄ changed the dominant methanogen from Methanosarcina to Methanosaeta with acetate as the organic carbon, while increased the relative abundance of Methanosaeta with ethanol as the organic carbon.