Enhanced aerobic granulation by inoculating dewatered activated sludge under short settling time in a sequencing batch reactor

Enhancing Wastewater Treatment with Aerobic Granular Sludge: Impacts of Tetracycline Pressure on Microbial Dynamics and Structural Stability

This study evaluated the efficiency of aerobic granular sludge (AGS) technology in treating wastewater contaminated with tetracycline (TC), a common antibiotic. AGS was cultivated under a TC pressure gradient ranging from 5 mg/L to 15 mg/L and compared with conventional wastewater conditions. The results demonstrated that AGS achieved high removal efficiencies and exhibited robust sedimentation performance, with significant differences in average particle sizes observed under both conditions (618.6 μm in TC conditions vs. 456.4 μm in conventional conditions). Importantly, exposure to TC was found to alter the composition and production of extracellular polymeric substances (EPSs), thereby enhancing the structural integrity and functional stability of the AGS. Additionally, the selective pressure of TC induced shifts in the microbial community composition; Rhodanobacter played a crucial role in EPS production and biological aggregation, enhancing the structural integrity and metabolic stability of AGS, while Candida tropicalis demonstrated remarkable resilience and efficiency in nutrient removal under stressful environmental conditions. These findings underscore the potential of AGS technology as a promising solution for advancing wastewater treatment methods, thus contributing to environmental protection and sustainability amid growing concerns over antibiotic contamination.

Bibliometric analysis of research trends in biogranulation technology for wastewater treatment

Inadequate management and treatment of wastewater pose significant threats, including environmental pollution, degradation of water quality, depletion of global water resources, and detrimental effects on human well-being. Biogranulation technology has gained increasing traction for treating both domestic and industrial wastewater, garnering interest from researchers and industrial stakeholders alike. However, the literature lacks comprehensive bibliometric analyses that examine and illuminate research hotspots and trends in this field. This study aims to elucidate the global research trajectory of scientific output in biogranulation technology from 1992 to 2022. Utilizing data from the Scopus database, we conducted an extensive analysis, employing VOSviewer and the R-studio package to visualize and map connections and collaborations among authors, countries, and keywords. Our analysis revealed a total of 1703 journal articles published in English. Notably, China emerged as the leading country, Jin Rencun as the foremost author, Bioresource Technology as the dominant journal, and Environmental Science as the prominent subject area, with the Harbin Institute of Technology leading in institutional contributions. The most prominent author keyword identified through VOSviewer analysis was "aerobic granular sludge," with "sequencing batch reactor" emerging as the dominant research term. Furthermore, our examination using R Studio highlighted "wastewater treatment" and "sewage" as notable research terms within the field. These findings underscore a diverse research landscape encompassing fundamental aspects of granule formation, reactor design, and practical applications. This study offers valuable insights into biogranulation potential for efficient wastewater treatment and environmental remediation, contributing to a sustainable and cleaner future.

The acceleration of aerobic sludge granulation by alternating organic loading rate: Performance and mechanism

As a highly promising treatment technology for wastewater, long start-up time is one of the bottlenecks hindering the widespread application of aerobic granular sludge (AGS). This study focused on exploring the possibility of alternating organic loading rate (OLR) in promoting AGS granulation. Under alternating OLR (3.6-14.4 kgCOD/m3·d), AGS granulation was significantly accelerated. The mean granule size under alternating load reached 234.6 μm at 17 d, while under constant OLR (7.2 kgCOD/m3·d), the mean granule size was only 179.2 μm. Moreover, the granule size maintained continuous growth even when the alternating OLR was changed to constant OLR. Alternating load significantly increased the content of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), especially proteins (PN) in tightly bound EPS (TB-EPS), which was likely the main reason for accelerating AGS granulation. Moreover, alternating load reduced the hydrophilicity of EPS and promoted the content of proteins secondary structures that favored aggregation in TB-EPS, which were also beneficial for granulation. Microbial community results showed that alternating load might promote the enrichment of EPS producing bacteria, such as Thauera, Brevundimonas and Shinella. Meanwhile, the content of enzymes that regulated amino acids metabolism also increased under alternating load, which might be related to the increase of PN in EPS. These results further demonstrated that alternating load promoted granulation through EPS.

Granule formation mechanism, key influencing factors, and resource recycling in aerobic granular sludge (AGS) wastewater treatment: A review

The high-efficiency and additionally economic benefits generated from aerobic granular sludge (AGS) wastewater treatment have led to its increasing popularity among academics and industrial players. The AGS process can recycle high value-added biomaterials including extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), sodium alginate-like external polymer (ALE), polyhydroxyfatty acid (PHA), and phosphorus (P), etc., which can serve various fields including agriculture, construction, and chemical while removing pollutants from wastewaters. The effects of various key operation parameters on formation and structural stability of AGS are comprehensively summarized. The degradable metabolism of typical pollutants and corresponding microbial diversity and succession in the AGS wastewater treatment system are also discussed, especially with a focus on emerging contaminants removal. In addition, recent attempts for potentially effective production of high value-added biomaterials from AGS are proposed, particularly concerning improving the yield, quality, and application of these biomaterials. This review aims to provide a reference for in-depth research on the AGS process, suggesting a new alternative for wastewater treatment recycling.

Enhancement of biogranules development using magnetized powder activated carbon

Biogranulation has emerged as a viable alternative biological wastewater treatment approach because of its strong biodegradability potential, toxicity tolerance, and biomass retention features. However, this process requires a long duration for biogranules formation to occur. In this study, magnetic powder activated carbon (MPAC) was used as support material in a sequencing batch reactor to enhance biogranules development for wastewater treatment. Two parallel SBRs (designated R1 and R2) were used, with R1 serving as a control without the presence of MPAC while R2 was operated with MPAC. The biodegradability capacity and biomass properties of MPAC biogranules were compared with a control system. The measured diameter of biogranules for R1 and R2 after 8 weeks of maturation were 2.2 mm and 3.4 mm, respectively. The integrity coefficient of the biogranules in R2 was higher (8.3%) than that of R1 (13.4%), indicating that the addition of MPAC improved the structure of the biogranules in R2. The components of extracellular polymeric substances were also higher in R2 than in R1. Scanning electronic microscopy was able to examine the morphological structures of the biogranules which showed there were irregular formations compacted together. However, there were more cavities situated in R1 biogranules (without MPAC) when compared to R2 biogranules (with MPAC). Dye removal reached 65% and 83% in R1 and R2 in the post-development stage. This study demonstrates that the addition of MPAC could shorten and improve biogranules formation. MPAC acted as the support media for microbial growth during the biogranulation developmental process.

Highly promoted phytoremediation with endophyte inoculation in multi-contaminated soil: plant biochemical and rhizosphere soil ecological functioning behavior

Rhizosphere soil ecological functioning behavior is of critical importance for regulating phytoremediation efficiency during microbial-assisted phytoremediation for multi-heavy metal-polluted soils. In this study, Trifolium repens L. and its endophyte Pseudomonas putida were used to investigate the ecological responses of the microbe-plant-soil system in Cd, Cr, and Pb co-contaminated soil. The results showed that endophyte Pseudomonas putida significantly increased plant biomass by 22.26-22.78% and phytoremediation efficiency by 29.73-64.01%. The increased phytoremediation efficiency may be related to the improvement of photosynthetic pigment content and antioxidant enzyme activities in leaves and the enhancement of rhizosphere soil ecological functioning. With endophyte application, soil nutrient content was significantly increased and heavy metal bioavailability was enhanced that residual fraction was reduced by 3.79-12.87%. Besides, the relative abundance of ecologically beneficial rhizobacteria such as Bacteriovorax and Arthrobacter was increased by 3.04-8.53% and 0.80-1.64%, respectively. Endophyte inoculation also significantly increased all the functional genes involved in cellular processes, genetic information processing, environmental information processing, and metabolism. This study indicated that the application of endophytes has a positive effect on the biochemical responses of Trifolium repens L. and could significantly improve rhizosphere ecological functioning in multi-heavy metal contamination, which provided clear strategies for regulating phytoremediation.

Aerobic granular sludge with filamentous bacteria immobilized by string carriers to treat simulated municipal wastewater in a continuous flow reactor

Aerobic granular sludge with filamentous bacteria (FAGS) has displayed many desirable properties. However, the selective pressure based on settling speed cannot effectively separate FAGS from water in sequencing batch reactor (SBR), which limits FAGS development. In this study, a new selection pressure was created by adding string carriers. Strings were used as crystal nuclei to form immobilized FAGS to achieve rapid separation from water. The immobilization of FAGS was achieved in both SBR and continuous flow reactor (CFR). The immobilization and long-term operation of FAGS in CFR were explored. NH₄⁺ and COD removal efficiency remained above 90 % and 85 %, respectively. Sphaerotilus, denitrifying microorganisms and EPS-secreting microorganisms were the main microorganisms in the immobilized FAGS. The selection pressure provided by the strings, the operating characteristics of the CFR, and the properties of Sphaerotilus may play key role in the immobilization of FAGS.

A Review of the Role of Extracellular Polymeric Substances (EPS) in Wastewater Treatment Systems

A review of the characterization and functions of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) of microbial aggregates in biological wastewater treatment systems is presented in this paper. EPS represent the complex high-molecular-weight mixture of polymers excreted by microorganisms generated from cell lysis as well as adsorbed inorganic and organic matter from wastewater. EPS exhibit a three-dimensional, gel-like, highly hydrated matrix that facilitates microbial attachment, embedding, and immobilization. EPS play multiple roles in containments removal, and the main components of EPS crucially influence the properties of microbial aggregates, such as adsorption ability, stability, and formation capacity. Moreover, EPS are important to sludge bioflocculation, settleability, and dewatering properties and could be used as carbon and energy sources in wastewater treatment. However, due to the complex structure of EPS, related knowledge is incomplete, and further research is necessary to understand fully the precise roles in biological treatment processes.

Optimization of Microalgae–Bacteria Consortium in the Treatment of Paper Pulp Wastewater

The microalgae–bacteria consortium is a promising and sustainable alternative for industrial wastewater treatment, since it may allow good removal of organic matter and nutrients, as well as the possibility of producing products with added value from the algae biomass. This research investigated the best bacterial and microalgae inoculation ratio for system start-up and evaluation of removing organic matter (as chemical oxygen demand (COD)), ammoniacal nitrogen (NH4+–N), nitrite nitrogen (NO2−–N), nitrate nitrogen (NO3−–N), phosphate phosphorus (PO43−–P) and biomass formation parameters in six photobioreactors with a total volume of 1000 mL. Reactors were operated for 14 days with the following ratios of pulp mill biomass aerobic (BA) and Scenedesmus sp. microalgae (MA): 0:1 (PBR1), 1:0 (PBR2), 1:1 (PBR3), 3:1 (PBR4), 5:1 (PBR5), and 1:3 (PBR6). Results show that COD removal was observed in just two days of operation in PBR4, PBR5, and PBR6, whereas for the other reactors (with a lower rate of initial inoculation) it took five days. The PBR5 and PBR6 performed better in terms of NH4+–N removal, with 86.81% and 77.11%, respectively, which can be attributed to assimilation by microalgae and nitrification by bacteria. PBR6, with the highest concentration of microalgae, had the higher PO43−–P removal (86%), showing the advantage of algae in consortium with bacteria for phosphorus uptake. PBR4 and PBR5, with the highest BA, led to a better biomass production and sedimentability on the second day of operation, with flocculation efficiencies values over 90%. Regarding the formation of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), protein production was substantially higher in PBR4 and PBR5, with more BA, with average concentrations of 49.90 mg/L and 49.05 mg/L, respectively. The presence of cyanobacteria and Chlorophyceae was identified in all reactors except PBR1 (only MA), which may indicate a good formation and structuring of the microalgae–bacteria consortium. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analysis revealed that filamentous microalgae were employed as a foundation for the fixation of bacteria and other algae colonies.

Emerging biological wastewater treatment using microalgal-bacterial granules: A review

Aiming at deepening the understanding of the formation and evolution of emerging microalgal-bacterial granule (MBG)-based wastewater treatment systems, the recent advances regarding the formation processes, transfer phenomena, innovative bioreactors development and wastewater treatment performance of MBG-based systems are comprehensively reviewed in this work. Particularly, the successful establishments of MBG-based systems with various inocula are summarized. Besides, as the indispensable factors for biochemical reactions in MBGs, the light and substrates (organic matters, inorganic nutrients, etc) need to undergo complicated and multi-scale transfer processes before being assimilated by microorganisms within MBGs. Therefore, the involved transfer phenomena and mechanisms in MBG-based bioreactors are critically discussed. Subsequently, some recent advances of MBG-based bioreactors, the application of MBG-based systems in treating various synthetic and real wastewater, and the future development directions are discussed. In short, this review helps in promoting the development of MBG-based systems by presenting current research status and future perspectives.

Enhanced aerobic granulation for treating low-strength wastewater in an anaerobic-aerobic-anoxic sequencing batch reactor by selecting slow-growing organisms and adding carriers

The aerobic granular sludge (AGS) process is a promising technology for wastewater treatment. However, a long start-up period for granulation and instability during long-term operation still hinder the application of AGS technology, especially for low-strength wastewater. To solve these two problems, this study tested a novel strategy involving the selection of slow-growing organisms and the addition of carriers in an anaerobic-aerobic-anoxic sequencing batch reactor (AN/O/AX_SBR). Three identical AN/O/AX_SBRs (R_Ctrl, R_CCM, and R_GAC), fed with low-strength wastewater, were operated for 120 days. R_Ctrl had no carriers, R_CCM contained cell culture microcarriers (CCM), and R_GAC contained granular activated carbon (GAC). Mature AGS was achieved within 80 days in all reactors. The carriers could reduce the maturation period of AGS by approximately 10 days (76, 66, and 69 days in R_Ctrl, R_CCM, and R_GAC, respectively) and improve the physical strength of the AGS. AGS showed a strong structure without excessive proliferation of filamentous bacteria, full-grown size (900-1100 μm), and good settleability (SVI₅ was 15.4-19.4 mL/g). Microbiological analysis showed that AN/O/AX_SBRs can provide a metabolic selective pressure to select slow-growing organisms such as nitrifying bacteria (norank_f__NS9_marine_group, Ellin6067, and Nitrospira), glycogen and phosphorus accumulating organisms (GAOs: Candidatus_Competibacter and Defluviicoccus; PAOs: Candidatus_Accumulibacter and Flavobacterium). All reactors showed good performance for simultaneous nitrification, endogenous denitrification, and phosphorus removal. The removal efficiencies of total nitrogen and total phosphorous were above 70% and 80%, respectively. The cycle test showed intermediate PAO-GAO metabolism prevailed in the system, and endogenous denitrification was primarily carried out by denitrifying GAOs.

Reproducibility of Aerobic Granules in Treating Low-Strength and Low-C/N-Ratio Wastewater and Associated Microbial Community Structure

Long-term stability of the aerobic granular sludge system is essentially based on the microbial community structure of the biomass. In this study, the physicochemical and microbial characteristics of sludge and wastewater treatment performance were investigated regarding formation, maturation, and long-term maintenance of granules in two parallel sequencing batch reactors (SBR), R1 and R2, under identical conditions. The aim was to explore the linkage between microbial community structure of the aerobic granules, their long-term stability, as well as the reproducibility of granulation and long-term stability. The two reactors were operated with a COD concentration of 400 mg/L and a chemical oxygen demand to nitrogen (COD/N) ratio of 4:1 under anoxic–oxic conditions. It was found that although SVI30, sludge size, and distributions in R1 and R2 were different, aerobic granules were formed, and they maintained long-term stability in both reactors for 320 days, implying that a certain level of randomness of granulation does not affect the long-term stability and performance for COD and N removal. In addition, a significant reduction in the richness and diversity of microbial production was observed after the sludge was converted from inoculum or flocs to granules, but this did not negatively affect the performance of wastewater treatment. Among the predominant microbial species in aerobic granules, Zoogloea was identified as the most important bacteria present during the whole operation with the highest abundance, while Thauera was the important genus in the formation and maturation of the aerobic granules, but it cannot be maintained long-term due to the low food-to-microorganisms ratio (F/M) in the system. In addition, some species from Ohtaekwangia, Chryseobacterium, Taibaiella, and Tahibacter were found to proliferate strongly during long-term maintenance of aerobic granules. They may play an important role in the long-term stability of aerobic granules. These results demonstrate the reproducibility of granulation, the small influence of granulation on long-term stability, and the robustness of aerobic granulation for the removal of COD and N. Overall, our study contributes significantly to the understanding of microbial community structure for the long-term stability of aerobic granular sludge in the treatment of low-COD and low-COD/N-ratio wastewater in practice.

Interaction and removal of oxytetracycline with aerobic granular sludge

Aerobic granular sludge as a promising technology showed great resistance to adverse conditions. However, the interaction between oxytetracycline (OTC) and granular sludge was not studied sufficiently. This study therefore investigated OTC-tolerance ability of incomplete and complete granulation sludge from aspects of simultaneous nutrients removal, sludge characteristics, microbial activity, community changes, and vice versa OTC removal performance. Incomplete granulation sludge showed better denitrification performance and resistance. Whereas, denitrification and phosphorus removal of complete granulation sludge suffered a permanent collapse under 5 mg/L OTC. OTC could be removed by rapid adsorption and slow biodegradation via granular sludge. The EPS, especially TB-PS, played a significant role during the operational period subjected to OTC. The major genera of Lysobacter and Candidatus_Competibacter laid the biological basis for stability and functionality of granules, which acted as the putative contributors for resisting and removing OTC. This study showed that incomplete-granulated sludge qualified more promising application prospect.

Effect of operational strategies on the rapid start-up of nitrogen removal aerobic granular system with dewatered sludge as inoculant

In both sequencing batch reactors with dewatering sludge as inoculant, the strategies by step-feeding (R1) or step-feeding combined with low aeration (R2) were performed under alternating anoxic/aerobic condition to discover superior methods launching nitrogen removal aerobic granule system. Interestingly, two reactors accomplished granulation at day 0, two days later, possessed prominent settling performance (SVI < 45 ml/g. MLSS) and denitrifying ability (TIN > 80%). Thereinto, R2 had lower crushing rate, larger granules, higher biomass and better pollutant removal performance owing to low aeration and more filamentous bacteria on AGS surface. Moreover, effluent NH₄⁺-N was used as indicator of excess filaments due to its quick response for the filaments. After effluent NH₄⁺-N exceeded 5 mg/L, causative filaments Sphaerotilus were effectively inhibited and eliminated by enhancing pH value to 8.0 ± 0.2. As a result, this study provides a new insight into rapid start-up nitrogen removal granule system by promoting and limiting filaments in proper period.

Aerobic granular sludge shows enhanced resistances to the long-term toxicity of Cu(II)

Cu(II) is one of the most widely-existed heavy metal ions in industrial effluents. A high concentration of Cu(II) leads to strong toxic effects on microorganisms and sludge for treating industrial wastewater which often contains aromatic pollutants. Granular sludge has different characteristics compared with floc sludge, and it may exhibit unique responses to the high concentration of Cu(II). Therefore, in this study, the variations of sludge properties and pollutant removal were investigated in the aerobic granular sludge (AGS) system with 0, 5, and 10 mg L^-1 of Cu(II). The results suggested that both levels of Cu(II) promoted protein secretion and bounded with extracellular polymeric substances; thus, led to more compact granules with better settleability. Cu(II) had limited impacts on the overall organic degradation and denitrification efficiency, while it exerted significant negative effect on nitrification. The average NH₄⁺-N concentration reached 1.4 ± 0.5, 6.7 ± 3.1, and 8.4 ± 1.5 mg L^-1 in the effluent when the influent contained 0, 5, and 10 mg L^-1 of Cu(II), respectively. The microbial community succession showed that no reduction was observed for the total relative abundance of main groups involved in organic removal such as Pseudoxanthomonas, Acidovorax, Acinetobacter, and Thauera. However, the growth of some functional groups such as Saccharibacteria for nitrification was inhibited by the toxic effect of Cu(II). These findings suggested that AGS could resist to the long-term toxic effects of Cu(II) by multiple rationales.

Impact of additive application on the establishment of fast and stable aerobic granulation

Aerobic granular sludge (AGS) is a microbial biofilm self-aggregation, which is effective for nutrient and pollutant removal, through the development of dense microbial layers bound together with extracellular polymeric substances (EPSs). However, long start-up times and granule disintegration are still challenges ahead. An array of external additives, including ion chelating agents, sludge-based enhancers, and magnetic influence have been tested to overcome these barriers. The application of such additives may promote enhanced EPS production, neutralization of charges on the bacterial surface, acts as a core-induced agent, or as a bridge to connect EPSs and cell surfaces. Although additives may improve the granule formation without reducing treatment efficiencies, there are still environmental concerns due to the fate and toxicity of discharged excess sludge. This mini-review identifies an array of external additives and their mechanisms to improve granulation properties, and proposes discussion about the technical and economic viability of these additives. KEY POINTS: • Additives reduce granulation time and repair granule disintegration. • Biopolymer-based additives fulfill technical and environmental requirements. • Sludge-based additives are cheap and in line with the resource recovery concept. • The need for environmental-friendly additives for aerobic granular sludge process. • External additives affect granular biomass size distribution.