Distraction osteogenesis in the irradiated rabbit mandible

A Histomorphometric Analysis of Radiation Damage in an Isogenic Murine Model of Distraction Osteogenesis

PURPOSE

The devastation radiation therapy (XRT) causes to endogenous tissue in patients with head and neck cancer can be a prohibitive obstacle in reconstruction of the mandible, demanding a better understanding of XRT-induced damage and options for reconstruction. This study investigated the cellular damage caused by radiation in an isogenic murine model of mandibular distraction osteogenesis (DO). The authors posited that radiation would result in fewer osteocytes, with increased empty lacunae and immature osteoid.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty Lewis rats were randomly assigned to a DO group (n = 10) or a XRT/DO group (n = 10). These groups underwent an osteotomy and mandibular DO across a 5.1-mm gap. XRT was administered to the XRT/DO group at a fractionated human equivalent dose of 35 Gy before surgery. Animals were sacrificed on postoperative day 40 and mandibles were harvested and sectioned for histologic analysis.

RESULTS

Bone that underwent radiation showed a significantly decreased osteocyte count and complementary increase in empty lacunae compared with non-XRT bone (P = .019 and P = .000). In addition, XRT bone exhibited increased immature osteoid and decreased mature woven bone compared with nonradiated bone (P = .001 and P = .003, respectively). Furthermore, analysis of the ratio of immature osteoid to woven bone volume exhibited a significant increase in the XRT bone, further showing the devastating damage from XRT (P = .001).

CONCLUSION

These results clearly show the cellular diminution that occurs as a result of radiation. This foundational study provides the groundwork on which to investigate cellular therapies in an immuno-privileged model of mandibular DO.

Does a change in bone mineral density occur in the mandible of Göttingen minipigs after irradiation in correlation with radiation dose and implant surgery?

PURPOSE

To date, studies have not agreed on the effects of irradiation on bone mineral density. The aim of our study was to investigate the changes in mandibular bone mineral density after irradiation at various doses with and without surgery.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We implemented a descriptive animal experiment. The sample included 16 female Göttingen Minipigs, randomly assigned to 4 groups and irradiated with equivalent doses of 0, 25, 50, and 70 Gy to the mandibular region. At 3 months after irradiation, the mandibular left premolars and molars were removed, and dental implants were placed. Computed tomography scans were taken before and 6 months after irradiation. The measured bone density was related to a bone phantom to calculate the bone mineral density quotient (BMDQ). The outcome variable was the BMDQ. Other study variables were the radiation dose and surgery. Descriptive and univariate analyses were computed, and significance was set at P ≤ .05.

RESULTS

In the left hemimandible, compared with the control group, a significant decrease in BMDQ was observed: 0.01 at 0 Gy, -0.01 at 25 Gy, -0.06 at 50 Gy, and -0.11 at 70 Gy (P = .023). The right hemimandible compared with the control group also showed a significant decrease in BMDQ: -0.02 at 0 Gy, -0.08 at 25 Gy, -0.09 at 50 Gy, and -0.11 at 70 Gy (P = .007).

CONCLUSIONS

The present study used a large animal model to simulate the tissue reactions induced by various radiation doses in the mandible. We found a significant decrease in the BMDQ after irradiation, but no significant correlation could be found between the irradiation dose and a decrease in the BMDQ.

Comparing calvarial transport distraction with and without radiation and fat grafting

The purpose of this study is to: a) assess transport distraction to reconstruct cranial defects in radiated and non-radiated fields b) examine adipose grafting's effect on the bony regenerate and overlying wound, and c) elucidate sources of bone formation during transport distraction osteogenesis. Twenty-three male New Zealand white rabbits (3 months; 3.5 kg) were used, 10 non-irradiated and 13 irradiated (17 treatment, 6 control) with a one-time fraction of 35 Gy. A 16 × 16 mm defect was abutted by a 10 × 16 mm transport disc 5 weeks after irradiation, and 11 animals were fat grafted at the distraction site. Latency (1 day), distraction (1.5 mm/day), and consolidation (4 weeks) followed. Fluorochromes were injected subcutaneously and microCT, fluorescence, and histology assessed. In distracted animals without fat grafting, bone density measured 701.87 mgHA/ccm and 2271.95 mgHA/ccm in irradiated and non-irradiated animals. In distracted animals with fat grafting, bone density measured 703.23 mgHA/ccm and 2254.27 mgHA/ccm in irradiated and non-irradiated animals. Fluorescence revealed ossification emanating from the dura, periosteum, and transport segment with decreased formation in irradiated animals. Transport distraction is possible for cranial reconstruction in irradiated fields but short-term osseous fill is significantly diminished. Adipose grafting enhances wound healing in previously irradiated fields but does not enhance ossification.

Distraction osteogenesis following low-dose hyperfractionated irradiation in the rat mandible

PURPOSE

The investigators hypothesized that low-dose hyperfractionated radiation would impair mandibular distraction osteogenesis (DO) in a murine mandibular model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Male Sprague-Dawley rats underwent fractionated radiation (30 Gy) of the left mandible. After a 2-week recovery period, an external frame distractor was applied and gradual distraction of the mandible was performed. Tissue was harvested after a 28-day consolidation period. Gross, radiologic, and histologic evaluations were undertaken. Control animals underwent surgery for an identical time frame without preoperative radiation.

RESULTS

Animals subjected to preoperative radiation (n = 10) showed suboptimal bone formation, including bone atrophy, incomplete bridging of the distraction gap, and gross bony defects or nonunion, compared with controls (n = 10). Although physical lengthening was achieved, irradiation consistently led to a detrimental effect on the normal process of DO.

CONCLUSION

This set of experiments establishes a valuable rodent model to evaluate the effects of radiation on DO and may help to formulate strategies to optimize DO before it is widely applied in oncologic reconstruction.

The rabbit as experimental model for research in implant dentistry and related tissue regeneration

The use of rabbits for experimental research has a long historical tradition. The aim of this review consists in outlining the use of the rabbit for research in implant dentistry and related tissue regeneration. Rabbits appear as a first-hand choice for fundamental implant design studies because of their size, easy handling, short life span, and economical aspects in purchasing and sustaining. In the following, the various anatomical sites in the rabbit will be summarized to provide an overview of current possibilities and limitations of this model for bone research in oral implantology.

The effects of high dose and highly fractionated radiation on distraction osteogenesis in the murine mandible

The ability of irradiated tissue to support bony growth remains poorly defined, although there are anecdotal cases reported showing mixed results for the use of mandibular distraction osteogenesis after radiation for head and neck cancer. Many of these reports lack objective measures that would allow adequate analysis of outcomes or efficacy. The purpose of this experiment was to utilize a rat model of mandibular distraction osteogenesis after high dose and highly fractionated radiation therapy and to evaluate and quantify distracted bone formation under these conditions. Male Sprague–Dawley rats underwent 12 fractions of external beam radiation (48 Gray) of the left mandible. Following a two week recovery period, an external frame distractor was applied and gradual distraction of the mandible was performed. Tissue was harvested after a twenty-eight day consolidation period. Gross, radiologic and histological evaluations were undertaken. Those animals subjected to pre-operative radiation showed severe attenuation of bone formation including bone atrophy, incomplete bridging of the distraction gap, and gross bony defects or non-union. Although physical lengthening was achieved, the irradiated bone consistently demonstrated marked damaging effects on the normal process of distraction osteogenesis. This murine model has provided reliable evidence of the injurious effects of high dose radiation on bone repair and regeneration in distraction osteogenesis utilizing accurate and reproducible metrics. These results can now be used to assist in the development of therapies directed at mitigating the adverse consequences of radiation on the regeneration of bone and to optimize distraction osteogenesis so it can be successfully applied to post-oncologic reconstruction.

Distraction osteogenesis in the dog mandible under 60-Gy irradiation

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to explore the probability of distraction osteogenesis (DO) in the irradiated dog mandible after 60-Gy irradiation.

STUDY DESIGN

Fourteen Chinese dogs were randomly divided into 2 groups. Twelve dogs received a preoperative unilateral irradiation from (60)Co (group R) in the mandible with a total dose of 24.8 Gy in four 6.2-Gy fractions (biologically equivalent to 60 Gy/25 fractions). The other 2 dogs without irradiation served as the control (group C). Bilateral corticotomies were made 6 months after completion of irradiation. Bone distraction was activated at a rate of 0.5 mm twice daily for 10 days after a 1-week latency period, followed by a consolidation phase of 8 weeks. The inferior alveolar nerve (IAN) underwent electrophysiologic analysis. Dog mandibles were subsequently subjected to histologic and radiographic analysis.

RESULTS

All the animals had successful distractions. After 8 weeks of consolidation, no difference was found between the percentage area of new bone in both groups. New bone was more mature and organized in group C than in group R. The action potential of IAN showed corresponding alternation during the irradiation and distraction process.

CONCLUSIONS

Based on this study it seems that DO may be feasible in dog mandible under 60-Gy irradiation. Further research is indicated.

Quantitative histomorphometric assessment of regenerate cellularity and bone quality in mandibular distraction osteogenesis after radiation therapy

BACKGROUND

The use of mandibular distraction osteogenesis (MDO) for tissue replacement after oncologic resection in head and neck cancer could have immense therapeutic ramifications. We have previously demonstrated significantly decreased mechanical and microdensitomeric metrics of our MDO regenerate after 36-Gy radiation. Quantitative histomorphometry, a third metric, would permit objective investigation of the effects of radiation on tissue and cellular composition. Our hypothesis is that radiation-induced cellular depletion and diminution in function impair optimal bone regeneration.

METHODS

Five rats received radiation to the left mandible; 5 received none. All animals underwent surgical placement of external fixators, creation of mandibular osteotomies, distraction to a 5.1-mm gap width, and consolidation. Point counting and color thresholding were performed.

RESULTS

There was a significant increase in empty lacunae and a corresponding diminution in osteocytes after radiation. Whereas the volume fraction of mineralized, mature bone was not different, that of nonmineralized, immature osteoid was significantly increased in the radiated group compared with that in the nonradiated group.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings confirm our prior 2 metrics. Actually, all 3 diverse metrics--microdensitometry, biomechanical analysis, and histomorphometry--corroborate our hypothesis of cellular depletion and diminution of function as the potential mechanism of radiation-induced attenuation in the distracted regenerate. Furthermore, our findings of tissue and cellular changes in the irradiated regenerate elucidate the pathophysiology of decreased bone quality when amalgamated with our previous results. Therapeutic agents may now be introduced, and their effects on the irradiated regenerate critically measured, so that MDO may be used as a viable reconstructive option in patients with head and neck cancer.

Alteration in volumetric bone mineralization density gradation patterns in mandibular distraction osteogenesis following radiation therapy

BACKGROUND

The use of mandibular distraction osteogenesis for tissue replacement after oncologic resection or for deformations secondary to radiotherapy could have immense therapeutic ramifications. Radiotherapy, however, drastically impairs bone healing, potentially precluding the use of mandibular distraction osteogenesis as a durable reconstructive option. The authors have previously demonstrated significantly decreased mechanical and histologic metrics of the mandibular distraction osteogenesis regenerate after 36 Gy. The authors' goal is to now investigate the effect of these same radiation dosages on bone densitometrics using micro-computed tomographic scanning.

METHODS

Six Sprague-Dawley rats received 36-Gy fractionated radiotherapy sessions to the left mandible; six received none. All animals had external fixators placed, creation of osteotomies, distraction, and consolidation. Mandibles were scanned with micro-computed tomographic scanning. Volumetric density and microdensitometric measurements were analyzed.

RESULTS

There was a significant difference in volumetric bone mineralization patterns in irradiated animals. Bone volume fraction and bone mineral density, however, demonstrated no significant differences.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors discovered a significant increase of low mineralized, immature bone and a significant decrease of highly mineralized, mature bone in the irradiated regenerate. These findings corroborate the authors' hypothesis that radiation induces a diminution in cell function, impairing optimal bone regeneration. Overall densitometrics, however, were unchanged according to micro-computed tomographic measurements, despite documented significant changes in biomechanical and histologic metrics. An optimal radiation dose must now be sought that demonstrates a higher degree of reproducible degradation, but not irreversible destruction, in all three outcomes. Such an approach will allow formulation of therapeutic interventions designed to enhance mandibular distraction osteogenesis so that it may be used as a viable reconstructive option.

Character of distracted bone in irradiated canine mandibles and electrophysiological changes in the inferior alveolar nerve

Our aim was to explore the character of distracted bone in irradiated canine mandibles and the electrophysiological changes in the irradiated inferior alveolar nerve (IAN). Twelve Chinese dogs were studied, 10 of which were given unilateral irradiation of (60)Co in the mandible with a total dose of 22.8Gy in four 5.7Gy fractions (biologically equivalent to 50Gy/25 fractions) (experimental group). The other two dogs were not irradiated and served as controls. All had a bilateral corticotomy 3 months after irradiation. After a 1-week latency period distraction of the mandible was activated at a rate of 0.5mm twice daily for 10 days, followed by a consolidation phase of 8 weeks. New bone was assessed by radiographic, histological, and single-photon electron computed tomographic (SPECT) analysis. The IAN was analysed electrophysiologically. One dog in the experimental group was excluded from the study with anaesthetic problems. After 8 weeks of consolidation there was no difference between the percentage area of new bone in the two groups. New bone was more mature and organised in the control group than in the experimental group. SPECT analysis showed that there was active osteogenic activity in dogs in the experimental group. The action potential of the IAN showed corresponding changes during the irradiation and distraction processes. We conclude that distraction osteogenesis is feasible in previously irradiated canine mandibles and IAN.

Reconstruction of a Severe Maxillofacial Deformity After Tumorectomy and Irradiation Using Distraction Osteogenesis and LeFort I Osteotomy Before Vascularized Bone Graft

We present the successful reconstruction of a large mandibular defect with a severe maxillofacial deformity after malignant tumor resection and irradiation. The patient was a 16-year-old boy with a defect in the left mandible, which extended from the mandibular body to the condylar process and hypoplasia of the maxillozygomatic complex on the left side as a result of ablation and radiotherapy of a grown rhabdomyosarcoma in the left infratemporal fossa at the age of 10. We planned a two-stage reconstruction because of his wide mandibular defect and hypoplasia. LeFort I type osteotomy to correct the maxillary declination was combined with mandibular lengthening to decrease the width of the defect in the first stage. New bone formation was confirmed at the distraction site 4 months after surgery, and the second stage was performed. A free latissimus dorsi myocutaneous flap with a vascularized scapula and rib was transferred to reconstruct the ramus of the mandible, zygomatic arch, and soft tissues. This procedure resulted in satisfactory results. In conclusion, the combination of distraction osteogenesis and microsurgical bone transplantation facilitated the straightforward reconstruction of a three-dimensional deformity with huge bony defects. We think that this combined surgical procedure will become a favorable option in the treatment of severe maxillomandibular deformities with bone defects.