Effect of interfragmentary gap on the mechanical behavior of mandibular angle fracture with three fixation designs: A finite element analysis

Biomechanical effects of different miniplate use on bone and miniplate systems in multiple mandible fracture: A finite element study

PURPOSE

The aim of this study is to evaluate the biomechanical efficiency of different miniplates in the treatment of multiple mandibula fractures.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

Mandible, miniplates, and screws were modeled using the Solid Works v2015 (Dassault Systèmes, France) program, Subsequently two fracture lines were created on the right parasymphysis and angulus mandible. Models were divided into two main groups according to the plates used in the anterior fracture line: group A, 2 piece 4-hole-bar-I plate, and group B, ellipse plate. Each group was divided into five subgroups according to the plates used in the posterior fracture line (I, X, G, 3D, E) and 10 study models were created in total. Under three different biting forces (anterior, right, left), maximum von-Mises stresses seen on miniplates/screws, and Pmax/Pmin stresses seen in the cortically/cancellous bone were analyzed using the Ansys 16.2 software (ANSYS, Inc., USA). Data was visualized using a color distribution scale and interpreted.

RESULTS

The highest von-Mises stress, seen in plates, was found in the I plate (353.82 MPa) at the angulus region of model A1. The highest Pmax and Pmin stresses, revealed in cortical bone, were found respectively in model A1 (181.63 MPa) and model B2 (115.01 MPa). The ideal results on plates were seen in models B3 and B5, in which E plates were used in the parasymphysis and G/E plates were used in the angulus region.

CONCLUSION

Grid and ellipse plates provide successful results and plate geometry is more critical than number in terms of stress distribution.

Biomechanical evaluation of various rigid internal fixation modalities for condylar-base-associated multiple mandibular fractures: A finite element analysis

Condylar-base-associated multiple mandibular fractures are more prevalent than single ones. Direct trauma to mandibular symphysis, body or angle are prone to induce indirect condylar fracture. However, little is known about the effects of various rigid internal fixation modalities in condylar base for relevant multiple mandibular fractures, especially when we are confused in the selection of operative approach. Within the finite element analysis, straight-titanium-plate implanting positions in condylar base contained posterolateral zone (I), anterolateral zone (II), and intermediate zone (III). Von Mises stress (SS) in devices and bone and mandibular displacement (DT) were solved, while maximum values (SSmax and DTmax) were documented. For rigid internal fixation in condylar-base-and-symphysis fractures, I + II modality exhibited least SSmax in screws and cortical bone and least DTmax, I + III modality exhibited least SSmax in plates. For rigid internal fixation in condylar-base-and-contralateral-body fractures, I + III modality exhibited least SSmax in screws and cortical bone, I + II modality exhibited least SSmax in plates and least DTmax. For rigid internal fixation in condylar-base-and-contralateral-angle fractures, I + III modality exhibited least DTmax. The findings suggest that either I + II or I + III modality is a valid guaranty for rigid internal fixation of condylar base fractures concomitant with symphysis, contralateral body or angle fractures.

A Proof of Concept: Optimized Jawbone-Reduction Model for Mandibular Fracture Surgery

Previous research on computer-assisted jawbone reduction for mandibular fracture surgery has only focused on the relationship between fractured sections disregarding proper dental occlusion with the maxilla. To overcome malocclusion caused by overlooking dental articulation, this study aims to provide a model for jawbone reduction based on dental occlusion. After dental landmarks and fracture sectional features are extracted, the maxilla and two mandible segments are aligned first using the extracted dental landmarks. A swarm-based optimization is subsequently performed by simultaneously observing the fracture section fitting and the dental occlusion condition. The proposed method was evaluated using jawbone data of 12 subjects with simulated and real mandibular fractures. Results showed that the optimized model achieved both accurate jawbone reduction and desired dental occlusion, which may not be possible by existing methods.

The role of stiffness-matching in avoiding stress shielding-induced bone loss and stress concentration-induced skeletal reconstruction device failure

It is well documented that overly stiff skeletal replacement and fixation devices may fail and require revision surgery. Recent attempts to better support healing and sustain healed bone have looked at stiffness-matching of these devices to the desired role of limiting the stress on fractured or engrafted bone to compressive loads and, after the reconstructed bone has healed, to ensure that reconstructive medical devices (implants) interrupt the normal loading pattern as little as possible. The mechanical performance of these devices can be optimized by adjusting their location, integration/fastening, material(s), geometry (external and internal), and surface properties. This review highlights recent research that focuses on the optimal design of skeletal reconstruction devices to perform during and after healing as the mechanical regime changes. Previous studies have considered auxetic materials, homogeneous or gradient (i.e., adaptive) porosity, surface modification to enhance device/bone integration, and choosing the device's attachment location to ensure good osseointegration and resilient load transduction. By combining some or all of these factors, device designers work hard to avoid problems brought about by unsustainable stress shielding or stress concentrations as a means of creating sustainable stress-strain relationships that best repair and sustain a surgically reconstructed skeletal site. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Although standard-of-care skeletal reconstruction devices will usually allow normal healing and improved comfort for the patient during normal activities, there may be significant disadvantages during long-term use. Stress shielding and stress concentration are amongst the most common causes of failure of a metallic device. This review highlights recent developments in devices for skeletal reconstruction that match the stiffness, while not interrupting the normal loading pattern of a healthy bone, and help to combat stress shielding and stress concentration. This review summarises various approaches to achieve stiffness-matching: application of materials with modulus close to that of the bone; adaptation of geometry with pre-defined mechanical properties; and/or surface modification that ensures good integration and proper load transfer to the bone.

Development and validation of a digital twin of the human lower jaw under impact loading by using non-linear finite element analyses

Mandibular fractures are one of the most frequently observed injuries within craniofacial region mostly due to tumor-related problems and traumatic events, often related to non-linear effects like impact loading. Therefore, a validated digital twin of the mandible is required to develop the best possible patient-specific treatment. However, there is a need to obtain a fully compatible numerical model that can reflect the patients' characteristics, be available and accessible quickly, require an acceptable level of modeling efforts and knowledge to provide accurate, robust and fast results at the same time under highly non-linear effects. In this study, a validated simulation methodology is suggested to develop a digital twin of mandible, capable of predicting the non-linear response of the biomechanical system under impact loading, which then can be utilized to design treatment strategies even for multiple fractures of the mandibular system. Using Computed Tomography data containing cranial (skull) images of a patient, a 3-dimensional mandibular model, which consists cortical and cancellous bones, disks and fossa is obtained with high accuracy that is compatible with anatomical boundaries. A Finite Element Model (FEM) of the biomechanical system is then developed for a three-level validation procedure including (A) modal analysis, (B) dynamic loading and (C) impact loading. For the modal analysis stage: Free-free vibration modes and frequencies of the system are validated against cadaver test results. For the dynamic loading stage: Two different regions of the mandible are loaded, and maximum stress levels of the system are validated against finite element analyses (FEA) results, where the first loading condition (i) transfers a 2000 N force acting on the symphysis region and, the second loading condition (ii) transfers a 2000 N force acting on the left body region. In both cases, equivalent muscle forces dependent on time are applied. For the impact loading stage: Thirteen different human mandibular models with various tooth deficiencies are used under the effects of traumatic impact forces that are generated by using an impact hammer with different initial velocities to transfer the impulse and momentum, where contact forces and fracture patterns are validated against cadaver tests. Five different anatomical regions are selected as the impact site. The results of the analyzes (modal, dynamic and impact) performed to validate the digital twin model are compared with the similar FEA and cadaver test results published in the literature and the results are found to be compatible. It has been evaluated that the digital twin model and numerical models are quite realistic and perform well in terms of predicting the biomechanical behavior of the mandible. The three-level validation methodology that is suggested in this research by utilizing non-linear FEA has provided a reliable road map to develop a digital twin of a biomechanical system with enough confidence that it can be utilized for similar structures to offer patient-specific treatments and can help develop custom or tailor-made implants or prosthesis for best compliance with the patient even considering the most catastrophic effects of impact related trauma.

Macaca mulatta is a good model for human mandibular fixation research

Biomechanical and clinical studies have yet to converge on the optimal fixation technique for angle fractures, one of the most common and controversial fractures in terms of fixation approach. Prior pre-clinical studies have used a variety of animal models and shown abnormal strain environments exacerbated by less rigid (single-plate) Champy fixation and chewing on the side opposite the fracture (contralateral chewing). However, morphological differences between species warrant further investigation to ensure that these findings are translational. Here we present the first study to use realistically loaded finite-element models to compare the biomechanical behaviour of human and macaque mandibles pre- and post-fracture and fixation. Our results reveal only small differences in deformation and strain regimes between human and macaque mandibles. In the human model, more rigid biplanar fixation better approximated physiologically healthy global bone strains and moments around the mandible, and also resulted in less interfragmentary strain than less rigid Champy fixation. Contralateral chewing exacerbated deviations in strain, moments and interfragmentary strain, especially under Champy fixation. Our pre- and post-fracture fixation findings are congruent with those from macaques, confirming that rhesus macaques are excellent animal models for biomedical research into mandibular fixation. Furthermore, these findings strengthen the case for rigid biplanar fixation over less rigid one-plate fixation in the treatment of isolated mandibular angle fractures.

3D-printed porous condylar prosthesis for temporomandibular joint replacement: Design and biomechanical analysis

BACKGROUND

Customized prosthetic joint replacements have crucial applications in severe temporomandibular joint problems, and the combined use of porous titanium scaffold is a potential method to rehabilitate the patients.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to develop a design method to obtain a titanium alloy porous condylar prosthesis with good function and esthetic outcomes for mandibular reconstruction.

METHODS

A 3D virtual mandibular model was created from CBCT data. A condylar defect model was subsequently created by virtual condylectomy on the initial mandibular model. The segmented condylar defect model was reconstructed by either solid or porous condyle with a fixation plate. The porous condyle was created by a density-driven modeling scheme with an inhomogeneous tetrahedral lattice structure. The porous condyle, supporting fixation plate, and screw locations were topologically optimized. Biomechanical behaviors of porous and solid condylar prostheses made of Ti-6Al-4V alloy were compared. Finite element analysis (FEA) was used to evaluate maximum stress distribution on both prostheses and the remaining mandibular ramus.

RESULTS

The FEA results showed levels of maximum stresses were 6.6%, 36.4% and 47.8% less for the porous model compared to the solid model for LCI, LRM, and LBM loading conditions. Compared to the solid prosthesis, the porous prosthesis had a weight reduction of 57.7% and the volume of porosity of the porous condyle was 65% after the topological optimization process.

CONCLUSIONS

A custom-made porous condylar prosthesis with fixation plate was designed in this study. The 3D printed Ti-6Al-4V porous condylar prosthesis had reduced weight and effective modulus of elasticity close to that of cortical bone. The.

[Three-dimensional finite element analysis of traumatic mechanism of mandibular symphyseal fracture combined with bilateral intracapsular condylar fractures]

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the biomechanical mechanism of mandibular symphyseal fracture combined with bilateral intracapsular condylar fractures using finite element analysis (FEA).

METHODS

Maxillofacial CT scans and temporomandibular joint (TMJ) MRI were performed on a young male with normal mandible, no wisdom teeth and no history of TMJ diseases. The three-dimensional finite element model of mandible was established by Mimics and ANSYS based on the CT and MRI data. The stress distributions of mandible with different angles of traumatic loads applied on the symphyseal region were analyzed. Besides, two models with or without disc, two working conditions in occlusal or non-occlusal status were established, respectively, and the differences of stress distribution between them were compared.

RESULTS

A three-dimensional finite element model of mandible including TMJ was established successfully with the geometry and mechanical properties to reproduce a normal mandibular structure. Following a blow to the mandibular symphysis with different angles, stress concentration areas were mainly located at condyle, anterior border of ramus and symphyseal region under all conditions. The maximum equivalent stress always appeared on condylar articular surface. As the angle between the external force and the horizontal plane gradually increased from 0° to 60°, the stress on the mandible gradually concentrated to symphysis and bilateral condyle. However, when the angle between the external force and the horizontal plane exceeded 60°, the stress tended to disperse to other parts of the mandible. Compared with the condition without simulating the disc, the stress distribution of articular surface and condylar neck decreased significantly when the disc was present. Compared with non-occlusal status, the stress on the mandible in occlusal status mainly distributed on the occlusal surface, and no stress concentration was found in other parts of the mandible.

CONCLUSION

When the direction of external force is 60° from the horizontal plane, the stress distribution mainly concentrates on symphyseal region and bilateral condylar surface, which explains the occurrence of symphyseal fracture and intracapsular condylar fracture. The stress distribution of condyle (including articular surface and condylar neck) decreases significantly in the presence of arti-cular disc and in stable occlusal status when mandibular symphysis is under traumatic force.

Finite element analysis of different titanium miniplates: Evaluation of three-dimensional designs applied on condylar neck fractures

INTRODUCTION

The fixation of condylar neck fractures is raising difficulties and for this reason, many plate designs have been developed. The current study compares the performance of four miniplates used in the condylar neck.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A virtual condylar neck fracture in a mandible obtained from a CT scan was fixed with four miniplates (two straight miniplates, lambda, strut, and trapezoidal). Using finite element analysis, we examined the fragments' displacements and stress distribution in the titanium material and bone. The models were analyzed under two loading conditions: a reduced bite force of 135 N and a force of 500 N.

RESULTS

No risk of material failure was observed. For a load of 135 N, all four plates offer an adequate fixation. For 500 N of applied loading, the lambda and strut plates showed the best rigidity and lowest bone strains. The two parallel plates showed the lowest rigidity and the trapezoidal plate the highest bone strains around all screws.

DISCUSSION

These findings imply that three-dimensional miniplates (lambda, strut) perform better when higher loads are applied. On the other hand, the trapezoidal plate has an increased risk of screw loosening and the two straight plates higher mobility of the fragments.

Finite Element Analysis of Two- and Three-Dimensional Fixation in Treating Mandibular Symphyseal Fracture Combined With Bilateral Condylar Intracapsular Fractures

ABSTRACT

The aim of this study was to compare through finite element analysis two- and three-dimensional (2D and 3D) fixation in the treatment of mandibular symphyseal fracture combined with bilateral condylar intracapsular fractures. The authors created 2 fixation models for the above fracture, and analyzed the stress and displacement in the mandible and fixation materials under 3 loading conditions. The von Mises stress of the mandible and plates peaked during lateral occlusion, and was lowest during central occlusion. In all conditions, stresses in the fixation materials did not exceed the yield stress of titanium. The inferior border of the symphyseal fracture segments showed opposing displacements, and the mandible tended to widen in the 2D fixation model. However, the fracture displacement did not exceed 150 μm for either fixation method. The results suggested that after well reduction and fixation of condylar intracapsular fractures, either 2D or 3D fixation for symphyseal fracture can provide adequately strong fixation. Compared with 2D fixation, 3D fixation has more advantages in controlling the mandibular width and preventing the fixation materials from enduring excessive stress.

Experimental validation of finite element simulation of a new custom-designed fixation plate to treat mandibular angle fracture

BACKGROUND

The objective of the study was to validate biomechanical characteristics of a 3D-printed, novel-designated fixation plate for treating mandibular angle fracture, and compare it with two commonly used fixation plates by finite element (FE) simulations and experimental testing.

METHODS

A 3D virtual mandible was created from a patient's CT images as the master model. A custom-designed plate and two commonly used fixation plates were reconstructed onto the master model for FE simulations. Modeling of angle fracture, simulation of muscles of mastication, and defining of boundary conditions were integrated into the theoretical model. Strain levels during different loading conditions were analyzed using a finite element method (FEM). For mechanical test design, samples of the virtual mandible with angle fracture and the custom-designed fixation plates were printed using selective laser sintering (SLS) and selective laser melting (SLM) printing methods. Experimental data were collected from a testing platform with attached strain gauges to the mandible and the plates at different 10 locations during mechanical tests. Simulation of muscle forces and temporomandibular joint conditions were built into the physical models to improve the accuracy of clinical conditions. The experimental vs the theoretical data collected at the 10 locations were compared, and the correlation coefficient was calculated.

RESULTS

The results show that use of the novel-designated fixation plate has significant mechanical advantages compared to the two commonly used fixation plates. The results of measured strains at each location show a very high correlation between the physical model and the virtual mandible of their biomechanical behaviors under simulated occlusal loading conditions when treating angle fracture of the mandible.

CONCLUSIONS

Based on the results from our study, we validate the accuracy of our computational model which allows us to use it for future clinical applications under more sophisticated biomechanical simulations and testing.

Ti-15Mo Alloy Decreases the Stress Concentration in Mandibular Angle Fracture Internal Fixation Hardware

Objectives

Comparison of the mechanical stability of 2.0 plates made of commercially pure titanium (cpTi) and a titanium-molybdenum (Ti-15Mo) alloy and two methods of internal fixation employed mandibular angle fractures, using 3D finite element analysis.

Materials and Methods

Four groups were evaluated. For the cpTi: group Eng 1P, one 4-hole plate and 4 screws 6 mm long, in the tension zone of the mandible; group Eng 2P, two 4-hole plates, one in the tension zone of the mandible and the other in the compression zone, both were fixed with 8 screws 6 mm long. The same groups were created for the Ti-15Mo alloy. A 100 N compressive load was applied to the occlusal surface of the mandibular first molar on the plated side.

Results

When considering the von Mises equivalent stress (σ _vM) values for the comparison between both groups with one plate, a decrease of 10.5% in the plate and a decrease of 29.0% in the screws for the Ti-15Mo group was observed. Comparing the same groups with two plates, a decrease of 28.5% in the screws was shown for the Ti-15Mo alloy group. No significant differences were observed when considering maximum and minimum principal stresses (σ _max, σ _min), and maximum principal strain (ε _max) to the mandibular bone. The Ti-15Mo alloy plates substantially decreased the stress concentration in the screws for both internal fixation techniques and in the plate for the Ti-15Mo 1 plate group.

Conclusion

From a clinical standpoint, the use of Ti-Mo alloy with reduced stiffness will decrease the stress shielding between the hardware and bone, influencing the outcome of the treatment.

Biomechanical Analysis of Various Reconstructive Methods for the Mandibular Body and Ramus Defect Using a Free Vascularized Fibula Flap

Several different methods exist for reconstructing the mandibular body and ramus defect with the use of a free vascularized fibula flap, but none have adequately addressed the long-term mechanical stability and osseointegration. The aim of this study is to compare the biomechanics of different surgical methods and to investigate the best approach for reconstructing the mandibular body and ramus defect. Five finite element models based on different reconstructive methods were simulated. Stress, strain, and displacement of connective bone sections were calculated for five models and compared. The models were printed using a 3D printer, and stiffness was measured using an electromechanical universal testing machine. The postoperative follow-up cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) was taken at different time points to analyze bone mineral density of connective bone sections. The results showed that the “double up” (DU) model was the most efficient for reconstructing a mandibular body and ramus defect by comparing the mechanical distribution of three sections under vertical and inclined loading conditions of 100 N. The stiffness detection showed that stiffness in the DU and “double down” (DD) models was higher compared with the “single up” (SU), “single down” (SD), and “distraction osteogenesis” (DO) models. We used the DU model for the surgery, and postoperative follow-up CBCT showed that bone mineral density of each fibular connective section increased gradually with time, plateauing at 12 weeks. We conclude that a free vascularized fibula flap of the DU type was the best approach for the reconstruction of the mandibular body and ramus defect. Preoperative finite element analysis and stiffness testing were shown to be very useful for maxillofacial reconstruction.

Analysis of biomechanical behavior of 3D printed mandibular graft with porous scaffold structure designed by topological optimization

BACKGROUND

Our long-term goal is to design and manufacture a customized graft with porous scaffold structure for repairing large mandibular defects using topological optimization and 3D printing technology. The purpose of this study is to characterize the mechanical behavior of 3D printed anisotropic scaffolds as bone analogs by fused deposition modeling (FDM).

METHODS

Cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) images were used to reconstruct a 3D mandible and finite element models. A virtual sectioned-block of the mandible was used as the control group and the trabecular portion of the block was modified by topological optimization methods as experimental groups. FDM (FDM) printed samples at 0, 45 and 90 degrees with Poly-lactic acid (PLA) material under a three-point bending test. Finite element analysis was also used to validate the data obtained from the physical model tests.

RESULTS

The ultimate load, yield load, failure deflection, yield deflection, stress, strain distribution, and porosity of scaffold structures were compared. The results show that the topological optimized graft had the best mechanical properties.

CONCLUSIONS

The results from mechanical tests on physical models and numerical simulations from this study show a great potential for topological optimization and 3D printing technology to be served in design and rapidly manufacturing of artificial porous grafts.

Assessment of the long bone inter-fragmentary gap size in ultrasound strain elastograms

The inter-fragmentary gap size (IFGS) is a critical factor affecting the propensity of bone healing. In this paper, we present a study to analyze ultrasound strain elastographic numerical features in samples with distinct IFGS using both simulations and experiments. Six fractured rabbit hind leg samples in total were used in this study with controlled IFGS of 1 mm, 5 mm and 1 cm. For the simulation, computed tomography (CT) scans of all six samples were used to create solid models. Finite element analysis (FEA) and subsequent elastography simulations were performed on the 3D models to produce tensorial strain field data. Features of bony fragment separation were defined on different strain components and computed for strains segmented at varying thresholds to evaluate their performance in estimating the IFGS. A threshold for each strain component was then determined, based on which extra 3D features of interest were defined and extracted from the segmented strain data. Then, all 3D features were compared statistically among the three nominal groups. Additional simulations and experiments of axial shear strain elastography (ASSE) on the median coronal plane of the same samples were also performed. Our results indicate that coronal plane axial shear (CPAS) strain elastography produces a separation feature which is statistically correlated with the IFGS, and that our elastography simulation module is effective in predicting the CPAS elastographic strain behavior for different IFGS.

Biomechanical behavior of mandibles reconstructed with fibular grafts at different vertical positions using finite element method

BACKGROUND

For large mandibular defects, surgical reconstruction using microvascular fibular grafts has advantages over other alternatives in terms of blood supply and good quality of grafted bone. However, the fibular segment is usually lower in height than that of the original mandible, meaning that the vertical positioning of the fibular graft is variable, with different biomechanical consequences on the reconstructed mandible.

OBJECTIVES

To use finite element method (FEM) to evaluate stress distribution and displacement of a reconstructed mandible versus an intact mandible under occlusal loads.

METHODS

A three-dimensional intact edentulous mandibular bone (Model I) and a reconstructed mandible bone with fibular graft were created from CBCT images. Calculation models were generated with fibular bone graft extracted from the reconstructed mandible of identical length placed into a mimicked defect area on the right-hand side of the mandible at three different vertical positions: superior (Model II), intermediate (Model III), and inferior (Model IV). Forces were applied at lower left first molar region and lower left central incisor area. Von Mises stresses and mandibular displacement were calculated as outcome measurements during loadings.

RESULTS

Maximum stress and strain within the reconstructed mandible were identified at the posterior border of the graft and the contralateral condyle. Maximum displacement occurred near the interface of fibular graft and anterior segment of the mandible. Stress distribution in the graft under functional loads is much higher than that in the residual mandibular segments from Models II to IV. The combined average maximum stress from anterior and posterior loads is 10.66 times higher in the mandible with inferiorly positioned graft (Model IV), 8.72 times for superior graft (Model II), and 3.68 times for intermediate graft (Model III) than that in the control group (Model I). The worst displacement result during functional loadings was in the group with fibular graft located at the inferior border of the mandible.

CONCLUSIONS

The position of fibular graft placed in the surgical resection site has significant effects on the mechanical behavior of the reconstructed mandible. The fibular graft aligned with the inferior border of the mandible, the most common site designated location by clinicians, has the worst effects on the stress distribution and displacement to the mandibular under functional loads. The fibular graft placed at the intermediate location has the best biomechanics and provides favorable condition for subsequent prosthetic reconstruction.

A customized fixation plate with novel structure designed by topological optimization for mandibular angle fracture based on finite element analysis

Background

The purpose of this study was to design a customized fixation plate for mandibular angle fracture using topological optimization based on the biomechanical properties of the two conventional fixation systems, and compare the results of stress, strain and displacement distributions calculated by finite element analysis (FEA).

Methods

A three-dimensional (3D) virtual mandible was reconstructed from CT images with a mimic angle fracture and a 1 mm gap between two bone segments, and then a FEA model, including volume mesh with inhomogeneous bone material properties, three loading conditions and constraints (muscles and condyles), was created to design a customized plate using topological optimization method, then the shape of the plate was referenced from the stress concentrated area on an initial part created from thickened bone surface for optimal calculation, and then the plate was formulated as “V” pattern according to dimensions of standard mini-plate finally. To compare the biomechanical behavior of the “V” plate and other conventional mini-plates for angle fracture fixation, two conventional fixation systems were used: type A, one standard mini-plate, and type B, two standard mini-plates, and the stress, strain and displacement distributions within the three fixation systems were compared and discussed.

Results

The stress, strain and displacement distributions to the angle fractured mandible with three different fixation modalities were collected, respectively, and the maximum stress for each model emerged at the mandibular ramus or screw holes. Under the same loading conditions, the maximum stress on the customized fixation system decreased 74.3, 75.6 and 70.6% compared to type A, and 34.9, 34.1, and 39.6% compared to type B. All maximum von Mises stresses of mandible were well below the allowable stress of human bone, as well as maximum principal strain. And the displacement diagram of bony segments indicated the effect of treatment with different fixation systems.

Conclusions

The customized fixation system with topological optimized structure has good biomechanical behavior for mandibular angle fracture because the stress, strain and displacement within the plate could be reduced significantly comparing to conventional “one mini-plate” or “two mini-plates” systems. The design methodology for customized fixation system could be used for other fractures in mandible or other bones to acquire better mechanical behavior of the system and improve stable environment for bone healing. And together with SLM, the customized plate with optimal structure could be designed and fabricated rapidly to satisfy the urgent time requirements for treatment.

A comparative study between traditional fixation with miniplates and modified lag screws for the treatment of mandibular fractures

OBJECTIVES

The objective of this study is to investigate two internal fixation surgical techniques for mandibular fractures in order to compare modified lag screw techniques with standard miniplates.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This is an observational prospective study. Three hundred eighteen patients were operated on for mandibular fractures. The patients were divided into two groups according to the type of surgical technique used: modified lag screws (155 patients) and traditional miniplates (163 patients). Analyses were made of sociodemographic and preoperative variables, the parameters related to the fracture type and postoperative data.

RESULTS

There were no differences between the two groups regarding their sociodemographic characteristics. The modified lag screws were primarily used with double fractures, while conventional miniplates were more often used with simple fractures. The number of complications was higher with the miniplate technique. The unfavorable fractures had an OR of 5.75 due to postoperative complications; double fractures had an OR of 8.87 and simple fractures an OR of 19.53, which, in both cases, were lower with conventional miniplates than with modified lag screws.

CONCLUSION

Modified lag screws provide a rigid fixation system that is as secure as miniplates, but with greater compression between the fragments, less postsurgical gap, faster ossification, and fewer postoperative complications.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The modified screw technique is a safe tool that does not require any specific osteosynthesis materials not found in a basic traumatology kit and has a lower cost, due to the reduced amount of material used.