Demonstration of technical feasibility and viability of whole eye transplantation in a rodent model

Risky first-in-human clinical trials on medically fragile persons: owning the moral cost

The purpose of a first-in-human (FIH) clinical trial is to gather information about how the drug or device affects and interacts with the human body: its safety, side effects, and (potential) dosage. As such, the primary goal of a FIH trial is not participant benefit but to gain knowledge of drug or device efficacy, i.e., baseline human safety knowledge. Some FIH clinical trials carry significant foreseeable risk to participants with little to no foreseeable participant benefit. Participation in such trials would be a bad deal for participants, and the research is considered justifiable because of the promise of significant potential social benefit. I argue that there is an ethical tension inherent in risky FIH research and that researchers should fairly compensate risky FIH trial participants. This does not make the risk-benefit outcome more favorable for participants; rather, it amounts to a collective reckoning with the ethical tension inherent in the research.

Combined Whole Eye and Face Transplant: Microsurgical Strategy and 1-Year Clinical Course

Importance

Catastrophic facial injury with globe loss remains a formidable clinical problem with no previous reports of reconstruction by whole eye or combined whole eye and facial transplant.

Objective

To develop a microsurgical strategy for combined whole eye and facial transplant and describe the clinical findings during the first year following transplant.

Design, Setting, and Participant

A 46-year-old man who sustained a high-voltage electrical injury with catastrophic tissue loss to his face and left globe underwent combined whole eye and face transplant using personalized surgical devices and a novel microsurgical strategy at a specialized center for vascularized composite allotransplantation.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Reperfusion and viability of the whole eye and facial allografts, retinal function, and incidence of acute rejection.

Results

The patient underwent a combined whole eye and face transplant from an immunologically compatible donor with primary optic nerve coaptation and conventional postoperative immunosuppression. Globe and retinal perfusion were maintained throughout the immediate postoperative period, evidenced by fluorescein angiography. Optical coherence tomography demonstrated atrophy of inner retinal layers and attenuation and disruption of the ellipsoid zone. Serial electroretinography confirmed retinal responses to light in the transplanted eye. Using structural and functional magnetic resonance imaging, the integrity of the transplanted visual pathways and potential occipital cortical response to light stimulation of the transplanted eye was demonstrated. At 1 year post transplant (postoperative day 366), there was no perception of light in the transplanted eye.

Conclusions and Relevance

This is the first report of whole eye transplant combined with facial transplant, demonstrating allograft survival including rejection-free graft survival and electroretinographic measurements indicating retinal response to light stimuli. These data highlight the potential for clinical allotransplantation for globe loss.

Whole-Eye Transplantation: How Far Are We From a Breakthrough?

PURPOSE

Traumatic facial injuries and resultant eye enucleation remain a devastating life-changing event for many. However, whole-eye transplantation (WET) has remained a distant goal until recently. This narrative review explores the existing literature on WET, assesses current hurdles to its success, and considers the ethical challenges to the expansion of WET programs globally.

METHOD

The authors identified pertinent keywords by conducting an initial literature exploration which were subsequently used to search scientific databases. In line with the narrative methodology employed in this article, specific inclusion and exclusion criteria were not explicitly defined. Nevertheless, the review focused exclusively on articles relating to ocular restoration and reconstructive surgery.

RESULTS

Though vision restoration remains elusive, burgeoning surgical techniques such as vascularized composite allotransplantation have opened the scope for surgeons to consider WET when planning facial transplants. Dr. Rodriguez and the New York University Langone team's success supports the recent advancements made in surgical innovation and the potential of CD34-positive stem cells as neuroprotective agents when injected at the optic nerve connection of the recipient. For WET to succeed, vascular and neural structures and the transplanted eye must be considered. Such requirements have been strengthened by the development of microsurgical techniques. In addition to addressing the technical feasibility of WET, it is crucial to deliberate on ethical considerations such as the lifelong implications associated with immunosuppression and, challenges related to the fair division of ocular tissue for WET versus keratoplasty.

CONCLUSION

WET amid significant facial trauma has great potential to restore the quality of life in patients, however, more research is required to demonstrate its long-term viability.

Whole-eye transplantation: Current challenges and future perspectives

Whole-eye transplantation emerges as a frontier in ophthalmology, promising a transformative approach to irreversible blindness. Despite advancements, formidable challenges persist. Preservation of donor eye viability post-enucleation necessitates meticulous surgical techniques to optimize retinal integrity and ganglion cell survival. Overcoming the inhibitory milieu of the central nervous system for successful optic nerve regeneration remains elusive, prompting the exploration of neurotrophic support and immunomodulatory interventions. Immunological tolerance, paramount for graft acceptance, confronts the distinctive immunogenicity of ocular tissues, driving research into targeted immunosuppression strategies. Ethical and legal considerations underscore the necessity for stringent standards and ethical frameworks. Interdisciplinary collaboration and ongoing research endeavors are imperative to navigate these complexities. Biomaterials, stem cell therapies, and precision immunomodulation represent promising avenues in this pursuit. Ultimately, the aim of this review is to critically assess the current landscape of whole-eye transplantation, elucidating the challenges and advancements while delineating future directions for research and clinical practice. Through concerted efforts, whole-eye transplantation stands to revolutionize ophthalmic care, offering hope for restored vision and enhanced quality of life for those afflicted with blindness.

First-in-Human Whole-Eye Transplantation: Ensuring an Ethical Approach to Surgical Innovation

As innovations in the field of vascular composite allotransplantation (VCA) progress, whole-eye transplantation (WET) is poised to transition from non-human mammalian models to living human recipients. Present treatment options for vision loss are generally considered suboptimal, and attendant concerns ranging from aesthetics and prosthesis maintenance to social stigma may be mitigated by WET. Potential benefits to WET recipients may also include partial vision restoration, psychosocial benefits related to identity and social integration, improvements in physical comfort and function, and reduced surgical risk associated with a biologic eye compared to a prosthesis. Perioperative and postoperative risks of WET are expected to be comparable to those of facial transplantation (FT), and may be similarly mitigated by immunosuppressive protocols, adequate psychosocial support, and a thorough selection process for both the recipient and donor. To minimize the risks associated with immunosuppressive medications, the first attempts in human recipients will likely be performed in conjunction with a FT. If first-in-human attempts at combined FT-WET prove successful and the biologic eye survives, this opens the door for further advancement in the field of vision restoration by means of a viable surgical option. This analysis integrates recent innovations in WET research with the existing discourse on the ethics of surgical innovation and offers preliminary guidance to VCA programs considering undertaking WET in human recipients.

Composite tissue xenopreservation: Preliminary results of staged VCA in rat to mouse model

BACKGROUND

The time between procurement and transplantation of composite tissues, especially regarding the limited donor pool, is a challenge effecting the outcomes of the transplantation. Current preservation techniques mainly include either cold preservation with a solution or machine perfusion using blood or certain oxygen-carrying solutions. However, none enables preservation beyond 24 h. Increasing this time to several days will provide better usage of the donor pool, safer transplantation of VCA with significant muscle content, and gives time to stabilize a patient before long surgical procedures. Herein, we described a novel strategy of xenopreservation (preservation via xenotransplantation) to preserve composite tissues for 7 days, followed by staged transplantation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We used two concordant species, female Sprague Dawley rats (n = 10) and female CF-1 mice (n = 10) in this study. Four of pair of animals are used for anatomical study. The groin flap of the rat was used as a xenograft and xenotransplanted to the neck area of the carrier mouse. Cyclosporine (CsA) was administered used as immunosuppressant. After 7 days of preservation on the mouse neck, xenotransplanted groin flap (called xenopreserved flap) was re-harvested, skin and vessels samples were collected for histopathological evaluation, and the xenopreserved flap was transplanted to the donor rat's opposite groin area. Anastomoses were performed between the flap's pedicle and the femoral vessels. Clinical observation regarding inflammation and tissue perfusion of the xenopreserved flap was monitored daily. Fifteen days after the second surgical procedure, the rats were euthanized, and skin and vessel samples were collected. Histologic evaluation, including inflammatory cell numbers, was performed. Wilcoxon test was used to compare the changes in inflammation severity and p < .05 was set for statistical significance.

RESULTS

All xenopreserved groin flaps except one survived. Mean lymphocyte count before the second operation (at the end of the xenopreservation procedure) was 20,22 ± 0.44 and reduced to 13,14 ± 0.47 at the end of 15 days, and the difference was statistically significant (p < .05).

CONCLUSION

This proof-of-concept study with preliminary results showed that xenotransplantation might be a novel strategy for preservation of VCA for a certain period of time. However, additional translational studies are needed to modulate the tissue changes following xenopreservation.

Retinal ganglion cell repopulation for vision restoration in optic neuropathy: a roadmap from the RReSTORe Consortium

Retinal ganglion cell (RGC) death in glaucoma and other optic neuropathies results in irreversible vision loss due to the mammalian central nervous system's limited regenerative capacity. RGC repopulation is a promising therapeutic approach to reverse vision loss from optic neuropathies if the newly introduced neurons can reestablish functional retinal and thalamic circuits. In theory, RGCs might be repopulated through the transplantation of stem cell-derived neurons or via the induction of endogenous transdifferentiation. The RGC Repopulation, Stem Cell Transplantation, and Optic Nerve Regeneration (RReSTORe) Consortium was established to address the challenges associated with the therapeutic repair of the visual pathway in optic neuropathy. In 2022, the RReSTORe Consortium initiated ongoing international collaborative discussions to advance the RGC repopulation field and has identified five critical areas of focus: (1) RGC development and differentiation, (2) Transplantation methods and models, (3) RGC survival, maturation, and host interactions, (4) Inner retinal wiring, and (5) Eye-to-brain connectivity. Here, we discuss the most pertinent questions and challenges that exist on the path to clinical translation and suggest experimental directions to propel this work going forward. Using these five subtopic discussion groups (SDGs) as a framework, we suggest multidisciplinary approaches to restore the diseased visual pathway by leveraging groundbreaking insights from developmental neuroscience, stem cell biology, molecular biology, optical imaging, animal models of optic neuropathy, immunology & immunotolerance, neuropathology & neuroprotection, materials science & biomedical engineering, and regenerative neuroscience. While significant hurdles remain, the RReSTORe Consortium's efforts provide a comprehensive roadmap for advancing the RGC repopulation field and hold potential for transformative progress in restoring vision in patients suffering from optic neuropathies.

Technical Feasibility of Whole-eye Vascular Composite Allotransplantation: A Systematic Review

There are over 43 million individuals in the world who are blind. As retinal ganglion cells are incapable of regeneration, treatment modalities for this condition are limited. Since first incepted in 1885, whole-eye transplantation (WET) has been proposed as the ultimate cure for blindness. As the field evolves, different aspects of the surgery have been individually explored, including allograft viability, retinal survival, and optic nerve regeneration. Due to the paucity in the WET literature, we aimed to systematically review proposed WET surgical techniques to assess surgical feasibility. Additionally, we hope to identify barriers to future clinical application and potential ethical concerns that could be raised with surgery.

Methods

We conducted a systematic review of PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, and Scopus from inception to June 10, 2022, to identify articles pertaining to WET. Data collection included model organisms studied, surgical techniques utilized, and postoperative functional outcomes.

Results

Our results yielded 33 articles, including 14 mammalian and 19 cold-blooded models. In studies performing microvascular anastomosis in mammals, 96% of allografts survived after surgery. With nervous coaptation, 82.9% of retinas had positive electroretinogram signals after surgery, indicating functional retinal cells after transplantation. Results on optic nerve function were inconclusive. Ocular-motor functionality was rarely addressed.

Conclusions

Regarding allograft survival, WET appears feasible with no complications to the recipient recorded in previous literature. Functional restoration is potentially achievable with a demonstrated positive retinal survival in live models. Nevertheless, the potential of optic nerve regeneration remains undetermined.

Novel vision restoration techniques: 3D bioprinting, gene and stem cell therapy, optogenetics, and the bionic eye

BACKGROUND

Vision restoration has been one of the most sought-after goals of ophthalmology because of its inception. Despite these problems being tackled from numerous different perspectives, a concrete solution has not yet been achieved. An optimal solution will have significant implications on the patient's quality of life, socioeconomic status, and mental health.

METHODS

This article will explore new and innovative approaches with one common aim-to restore functional vision for the visually impaired. These novel techniques include 3D bioprinting, stem cell therapy, gene therapy, implantable devices, and optogenetics.

RESULTS

While the techniques mentioned above show significant promise, they are currently in various stages of development ranging from clinical trials to commercial availability. Restoration of minimal vision in specific cases has already been achieved by the different methods but optimization of different parameters like biocompatibility, spatiotemporal resolution, and minimizing the costs are essential for widespread use.

CONCLUSION

The developments over the past decade have resulted in multiple milestones in each of the techniques with many solutions getting approved by the FDA. This article will compare these novel techniques and highlight the major advantages and drawbacks of each of them.

Immunological considerations and concerns as pertinent to whole eye transplantation

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The advent of clinical vascularized composite allotransplantation (VCA), offers hope for whole eye transplantation (WET) in patients with devastating vison loss that fails or defies current treatment options. Optic nerve regeneration and reintegration remain the overarching hurdles to WET. However, the realization of WET may indeed be limited by our lack of understanding of the singular immunological features of the eye as pertinent to graft survival and functional vision restoration in the setting of transplantation.

RECENT FINDINGS

Like other VCA, such as the hand or face, the eye includes multiple tissues with distinct embryonic lineage and differential antigenicity. The ultimate goal of vision restoration through WET requires optimal immune modulation of the graft for successful optic nerve regeneration. Our team is exploring barriers to our understanding of the immunology of the eye in the context of WET including the role of immune privilege and lymphatic drainage on rejection, as well as the effects ischemia, reperfusion injury and rejection on optic nerve regeneration.

SUMMARY

Elucidation of the unique immunological responses in the eye and adnexa after WET will provide foundational clues that will help inform therapies that prevent immune rejection without hindering optic nerve regeneration or reintegration.