Understanding the etiology of the posteromedial tibial stress fracture

Advancing Exoskeleton Development: Validation of a Robotic Surrogate to Measure Tibial Strain

Bone stress injuries are prevalent among athletes and military recruits and can significantly compromise training schedules. The development of an ankle-foot orthosis to reduce tibial load and enable a faster return to activity will require new device testing methodologies capable of capturing the contribution of muscular force on tibial strain. Thus, an actuated robotic surrogate leg was developed to explore how tibial strain changes with different ankle-foot orthosis conditions. The purpose of this work was to assess the reliability, scalability, and behavior of the surrogate. A dual actuation system consisting of a Bowden cable and a vertical load applied to the femur via a material testing system, replicated the action-reaction of the Achilles-soleus complex. Maximum and minimum principal strain, maximum shear strain, and axial strain were measured by instrumented strain gauges at five locations on the tibia. Strains were highly repeatable across tests but did not consistently match in vivo data when scaled. However, the stiffness of the ankle-foot orthosis strut did not systematically affect tibial load, which is consistent with in vivo findings. Future work will involve improving the scalability of the results to match in vivo data and using the surrogate to inform exoskeletal designs for bone stress injuries.

Significance of tibial MRI findings of special forces recruits at the onset of their training

INTRODUCTION

MRI is commonly used to evaluate medial tibial stress syndrome (MTSS), based on grading assessments developed in civilian populations. When MTSS represents stress fracture, rest is required to allow for bone remodelling to occur. False positive evaluations can lead to unnecessary recruit attrition.

METHODS

Thirty randomly selected new recruits to a special forces training unit underwent MRI of their tibias using the T2-Dixon sequence at the onset of training. Evaluation was according to the Fredericson MTSS grading system. Prior to undergoing MRI, anthropomorphic measurements, a survey of sports history and an orthopaedic examination of subject tibias were performed. Orthopaedic follow-up was through 11 weeks of training.

RESULTS

Medial periosteal oedema without the presence of bone marrow oedema, corresponding to a grade 1 stress reaction, was present on MRI in 10 recruits (17 tibias). In only one case did the periosteal oedema include the posterior aspect of the medial cortex where medial tibial stress fractures usually occur. Tibial tenderness was present in seven tibias on examination done just prior to the MRI studies, but none were symptomatic and only one had periosteal oedema present on MRI, but without anatomical correlation between the site of the tenderness and the periosteal oedema. During subsequent training, five tibias in four recruits developed pain and tenderness. Two had periosteal oedema in their prior MRIs, but the location did not coincide anatomically with that of the tibial tenderness. The time from stopping sports before induction and the presence of periosteal oedema was not significant.

CONCLUSION

Periosteal oedema, one of the hallmarks used in MRI grading systems to evaluate MTSS, was found to have a 37.7% false positive rate for anatomically corresponding tibial tenderness at the time of the examination and during subsequent training, indicating the grading systems' low utility for the military.

Breed and loading history influence in vivo skeletal strain patterns in pre-pubertal female chickens

The influence of loading history on in vivo strains within a given specie remains poorly understood, and although in vivo strains have been measured at the hindlimb bones of various species, strains engendered during modes of activity other than locomotion are lacking, particularly in non-human species. For commercial egg-laying chickens specifically, there is an interest in understanding their bones' mechanical behaviour, particularly during youth, to develop early interventions to prevent the high incidence of osteoporosis in this population. We measured in vivo mechanical strains at the tibiotarsus midshaft during steady activities (ground, uphill, downhill locomotion) and non-steady activities (perching, jumping, aerial transition landing) in 48 pre-pubescent female (egg-laying) chickens from two breeds that were reared in three different housing systems, allowing varying amounts and types of physical activity. Mechanical strain patterns differed between breeds, and were dependent on the activity performed. Mechanical strains were also affected by rearing environment: chickens that were restricted from performing dynamic load bearing activity due to caged-housing generally exhibited higher mechanical strain levels during steady, but not non-steady activities, compared to chickens with prior dynamic load-bearing activity experience. Among chickens with prior experience of dynamic load bearing activity, those reared in housing systems that allowed more frequent physical activity did not exhibit lower mechanical strains. In all groups, the tibiotarsus was subjected to a loading environment consisting of a combination of axial compression, bending, and torsion, with torsion being the predominant source of strain. Aerial transition landing produced the highest strain levels with unusual strain patterns compared to other activities, suggesting it may produce the strongest anabolic response. These results exemplify how different breeds within a given specie adapt to maintain different patterns of mechanical strains, and how benefits of physical activity in terms of resistance to strain are activity-type dependent and do not necessarily increase with increased physical activity. These findings directly inform controlled loading experiments aimed at studying the bone mechanoresponse in young female chickens and can also be associated to measures of bone morphology and material properties to understand how these features influence bone mechanical properties in vivo.

In vivo strains at the middle and distal thirds of the tibia during exertional activities

There is a known variance in the incidence and anatomical site of tibial stress fractures among infantry recruits and athletes who train according to established uniform training programs. To better understand the biomechanical basis for this variance, we conducted in vivo axial strain measurements using instrumented bone staples affixed in the medial cortex, aligned along the long axis of the tibia at the level of the mid and distal third of the bone in four male subjects. Strain measurements were made during treadmill walking, treadmill running, drop jumps from a 45 cm height onto a force plate and serial vertical jumps on a force plate. Significance levels for the main effects of location, type of activity and their interaction were determined by quasi-parametric methodologies. Compared to walking, running and vertical jumping peak axial tensile strain (με) was 1.94 (p = 0.009) and 3.92 times (p < 0.001) higher, respectively. Peak axial compression strain (με) values were found to be greater at the distal third than at the mid tibia for walking, running and vertical jumping (PR = 1.95, p-value<0.001). Peak axial compression and tension strains varied significantly between the subjects (all with p < 0.001), after controlling for strain gauge location and activity type.

The study findings help explain the variance in the anatomical location of tibial stress fractures among participants doing the same uniform training and offers evidence of individual biomechanical susceptibility to tibial stress fracture. The study data can provide guidance when developing a generalized finite element model for mechanical tibial loading. For subject specific decisions, individualized musculoskeletal finite element models may be necessary.

•

In vivo strains were measured simultaneously at the middle and distal tibial thirds.

•

Compression and tension varied between subjects controlling for location and activity.

•

Compared to walking, running and jumping tension was 1.94 and 3.92 higher.

•

Compression strains were greater at the distal third than at the mid tibia.

•

The data can be used to develop a generalized FE model for mechanical tibial loading.

Bone Adaptation in Adult Women Is Related to Loading Dose: A 12-Month Randomized Controlled Trial

Although strong evidence exists that certain activities can increase bone density and structure in people, it is unclear what specific mechanical factors govern the response. This is important because understanding the effect of mechanical signals on bone could contribute to more effective osteoporosis prevention methods and efficient clinical trial design. The degree to which strain rate and magnitude govern bone adaptation in humans has never been prospectively tested. Here, we studied the effects of a voluntary upper extremity compressive loading task in healthy adult women during a 12-month prospective period. A total of 102 women age 21 to 40 years participated in one of two experiments: (i) low (n = 21) and high (n = 24) strain magnitude; or (ii) low (n = 21) and high (n = 20) strain rate. Control (n = 16) no intervention. Strains were assigned using subject-specific finite element models. Load cycles were recorded digitally. The primary outcome was change in ultradistal radius integral bone mineral content (iBMC), assessed with QCT. Interim time points and secondary outcomes were assessed with high resolution pQCT (HRpQCT) at the distal radius. Sixty-six participants completed the intervention, and interim data were analyzed for 77 participants. Likely related to improved compliance and higher received loading dose, both the low-strain rate and high-strain rate groups had significant 12-month increases to ultradistal iBMC (change in control: -1.3 ± 2.7%, low strain rate: 2.7 ± 2.1%, high strain rate: 3.4 ± 2.2%), total iBMC, and other measures. "Loading dose" was positively related to 12-month change in ultradistal iBMC, and interim changes to total BMD, cortical thickness, and inner trabecular BMD. Participants who gained the most bone completed, on average, 128 loading bouts of (mean strain) 575 με at 1878 με/s. We conclude that signals related to strain magnitude, rate, and number of loading bouts contribute to bone adaptation in healthy adult women, but only explain a small amount of variance in bone changes. © 2020 The Authors. Journal of Bone and Mineral Research published by American Society for Bone and Mineral Research.

Intra-medullary osteosclerosis of the tibia in children

BACKGROUND

Intra-medullary osteosclerosis of the tibia is a rare condition characterised by chronic pain due to diaphyseal hyperostosis with no detectable triggering factor. The main differential diagnoses are stress fracture and osteoid osteoma. Of the few cases reported to date, most were in adults. The objective of this study was to assess paediatric patients with intra-medullary osteosclerosis to determine whether the first visit provides sufficient information to establish the diagnosis and rule out both osteoid osteoma and stress fracture, whether a biopsy is required, and which treatment is optimal.

HYPOTHESIS

The diagnosis of intra-medullary osteosclerosis of the tibia can be made at the first visit.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Seven paediatric patients, 4 males and 3 females, with a mean age of 11 years, were included in this retrospective study. We evaluated the clinical features, findings from imaging studies (standard radiographs, computed tomography, magnetic resonance imaging, and bone scintigraphy), and treatment outcomes.

RESULTS

At the first visit, all patients had a painful swelling at the middle of the shin and imaging study evidence of antero-lateral tibial cortical thickening extending into the medullary cavity; in 5 patients, a linear lucency was visible. No other bone abnormalities were seen. Treatments included non-operative measures, pinning, and nailing. None of these treatments provided permanent bone healing or pain relief, although transitory freedom from pain with or without radiological bone healing was achieved.

DISCUSSION

Intra-medullary osteosclerosis of the tibia is rarely reported and therefore probably underdiagnosed. Distinctive characteristics of the cortical and endosteal thickening include location at the antero-lateral mid-diaphysis and, in some cases, the concomitant presence of a linear lucency that can provide the early diagnosis. The distinctive radiological features allow differentiation from a stress fracture. The management is challenging.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV, retrospective observational study.

Do running speed and shoe cushioning influence impact loading and tibial shock in basketball players?

Background

Tibial stress fracture (TSF) is a common injury in basketball players. This condition has been associated with high tibial shock and impact loading, which can be affected by running speed, footwear condition, and footstrike pattern. However, these relationships were established in runners but not in basketball players, with very little research done on impact loading and speed. Hence, this study compared tibial shock, impact loading, and foot strike pattern in basketball players running at different speeds with different shoe cushioning properties/performances.

Methods

Eighteen male collegiate basketball players performed straight running trials with different shoe cushioning (regular-, better-, and best-cushioning) and running speed conditions (3.0 m/s vs. 6.0 m/s) on a flat instrumented runway. Tri-axial accelerometer, force plate and motion capture system were used to determine tibial accelerations, vertical ground reaction forces and footstrike patterns in each condition, respectively. Comfort perception was indicated on a 150 mm Visual Analogue Scale. A 2 (speed) × 3 (footwear) repeated measures ANOVA was used to examine the main effects of shoe cushioning and running speeds.

Results

Greater tibial shock (P < 0.001; η² = 0.80) and impact loading (P < 0.001; η² = 0.73-0.87) were experienced at faster running speeds. Interestingly, shoes with regular-cushioning or best-cushioning resulted in greater tibial shock (P = 0.03; η² = 0.39) and impact loading (P = 0.03; η² = 0.38-0.68) than shoes with better-cushioning. Basketball players continued using a rearfoot strike during running, regardless of running speed and footwear cushioning conditions (P > 0.14; η² = 0.13).

Discussion

There may be an optimal band of shoe cushioning for better protection against TSF. These findings may provide insights to formulate rehabilitation protocols for basketball players who are recovering from TSF.

The role of adaptive bone formation in the etiology of stress fracture

Stress fractures are common injuries with load-bearing activities. Stress fractures have been reported in the scientific literature for over a century; however, the etiology continues to be investigated with important distinctions made between the contributions of the tissue-level processes of bone remodeling and modeling. In response to novel repetitive loading, increased bone remodeling may serve to replace fatigue-damaged bone while at the same time creating temporary porosity. Much attention has been given to the role of remodeling in the etiology of stress fracture; however, the role of bone modeling has received less attention. Modest increases in modeling, via bone formation on the periosteal surface of long bones in response to mechanical loading, greatly increases the fatigue resistance of bone. Thus, enhancing this adaptive bone formation is a promising target for stress fracture prevention, and a focus on adaptive bone formation may reveal novel risk factors for stress fracture.

Immediate effects of modified landing pattern on a probabilistic tibial stress fracture model in runners

BACKGROUND

Tibial stress fracture is a common injury in runners. This condition has been associated with increased impact loading. Since vertical loading rates are related to the landing pattern, many heelstrike runners attempt to modify their footfalls for a lower risk of tibial stress fracture. Such effect of modified landing pattern remains unknown. This study examined the immediate effects of landing pattern modification on the probability of tibial stress fracture.

METHODS

Fourteen experienced heelstrike runners ran on an instrumented treadmill and they were given augmented feedback for landing pattern switch. We measured their running kinematics and kinetics during different landing patterns. Ankle joint contact force and peak tibial strains were estimated using computational models. We used an established mathematical model to determine the effect of landing pattern on stress fracture probability.

FINDINGS

Heelstrike runners experienced greater impact loading immediately after landing pattern switch (P<0.004). There was an increase in the longitudinal ankle joint contact force when they landed with forefoot (P=0.003). However, there was no significant difference in both peak tibial strains and the risk of tibial stress fracture in runners with different landing patterns (P>0.986).

INTERPRETATION

Immediate transitioning of the landing pattern in heelstrike runners may not offer timely protection against tibial stress fracture, despite a reduction of impact loading. Long-term effects of landing pattern switch remains unknown.