Molecular mechanistic insights into uncoupling of ion transport from ATP synthesis

Symmetry breaking and mismatch in the torsional mechanism of ATP synthesis by FOF1-ATP synthase: mathematical number theory proof and its chemical and biological implications

Can mathematical proofs be employed for the solution of fundamental molecular-level problems in biology? Recently, I mathematically tackled complex mechanistic problems arising during the synthesis of the universal biological currency, adenosine triphosphate (ATP) by the FOF1-ATP synthase, nature's smallest rotary molecular motor, using graph-theoretical and combinatorial approaches for the membrane-bound FO and water-soluble F1 domains of this fascinating molecule (see Nath in Theory Biosci 141:249‒260, 2022 and Theory Biosci 143:217‒227, 2024). In the third part of this trilogy, I investigate another critical aspect of the molecular mechanism-that of coupling between the FO and F1 domains of the ATP synthase mediated by the central γ-subunit of ∼ 1 nanometer diameter. According to Nath's torsional mechanism of energy transduction and ATP synthesis the γ-subunit twists during ATP synthesis and the release of stored torsional energy in the central γ-stalk causes conformational changes in the catalytic sites that lead to ATP synthesis, with 1 ATP molecule synthesized per discrete 120° rotation. The twisted γ-subunit breaks the symmetry of the molecule, and its residual torsional strain is shown to readily accommodate any symmetry mismatch existing between FO and F1. A mathematical number theory proof is developed to quantify the extent of symmetry mismatch at any angular position during rotation and derive the conditions for the regaining of symmetry at the end of a 360° rotation. The many chemical and biological implications of the mechanism and the mathematical proof are discussed in detail. Finally, suggestions for further mathematical development of the subject based on ideas from symmetry and group theory have been made. In sum, the answer to the question posed at the beginning of the Abstract is a resounding YES. There exists new, relatively unexplored territory at the interface of mathematics and molecular biology, especially at the level of molecular mechanism. It is hoped that more mathematicians and scientists interested in interdisciplinary work are encouraged to include in their research program approaches of this type-a mathematical proofs-inspired molecular biology-that have the power to lead to new vistas. Such molecular-scale mechanistic problems in biology have proved extraordinarily difficult to solve definitively using conventional experimental, theoretical, and computational approaches.

2-Site versus 3-site models of ATP hydrolysis by F1-ATPase: definitive mathematical proof using combinatorics and conservation equations

The F1-ATPase enzyme is the smallest-known molecular motor that rotates in 120° steps, driven by the hydrolysis of ATP. It is a multi-subunit enzyme that contains three catalytic sites. A central question is how the elementary chemical reactions that occur in the three sites are coupled to mechanical rotation. Various models and coupling schemes have been formulated in an attempt to answer this question. They can be classified as 2-site (bi-site) models, exemplified by Boyer's binding change mechanism first proposed 50 years ago, and 3-site (tri-site) models such as Nath's torsional mechanism, first postulated 25 years ago and embellished 1 year back. Experimental data collated using diverse approaches have conclusively shown that steady-state ATP hydrolysis by F1-ATPase occurs in tri-site mode. Hence older models have been continually modified to make them conform to the new facts. Here, we have developed a pure mathematical approach based on combinatorics and conservation laws to test if proposed models are 2-site or 3-site. Based on this novel combinatorial approach, we have proved that older and modified models are effectively bi‒site models in that catalysis and rotation in F1-ATPase occurs in these models with only two catalytic sites occupied by bound nucleotide. Hence these models contradict consensus experimental data. The recent 2023 model of ATP hydrolysis by F1-ATPase has been proved to be a true tri-site model based on our novel mathematical approach. Such pure mathematical proofs constitute an important step forward for ATP mechanism. However, in what must be considered an aspect with great scientific potential, the power of such mathematical proofs has not been fully exploited to solve molecular biological problems, in our opinion. We believe that the creative application of pure mathematical proofs (for another example see Nath in Theory Biosci 141:249-260, 2022) can help resolve with finality various longstanding molecular-level issues that arise as a matter of course in the analysis of fundamental biological problems. Such issues have proved extraordinarily difficult to resolve by standard experimental, theoretical, or computational approaches.

Proteomic analysis of the effects of Dictyophora polysaccharide on arsenic-induced hepatotoxicity in rats

Arsenic (As) is a highly toxic environmental toxicant and a known human carcinogen. Long-term exposure to As can cause liver injury. Dictyophora polysaccharide (DIP) is a biologically active natural compound found in the Dictyophora with excellent antioxidation, anti-inflammation, and immune protection properties. In this study, the Sprague-Dawley (SD) rat model of As toxicity was established using a feeding method, followed by DIP treatment in rats with As-induced liver injury. The molecular mechanisms of As toxicity to the rat liver and the protective effect of DIP were investigated by proteomic studies. The results showed that 172, 328 and 191 differentially expressed proteins (DEPs) were identified between the As-exposed rats versus control rats (As/Ctrl), DIP treated rats versus As-exposed rats (DIP+As/As), and DIP treated rats versus control rats (DIP+As /Ctrl), respectively. Among them, the expression of 90 DEPs in the As/Ctrl groups was reversed by DIP treatment. As exposure caused dysregulation of metabolic pathways, mitochondria, oxidative stress, and apoptosis-related proteins in the rat liver. However, DIP treatment changed or restored the levels of these proteins, which attenuated the damage to the livers of rats caused by As exposure. The results provide new insights into the mechanisms of liver injury induced by As exposure and the treatment of DIP in As poisoning.

Size matters in metabolic scaling: Critical role of the thermodynamic efficiency of ATP synthesis and its dependence on mitochondrial H+ leak across mammalian species

In this last article of the trilogy, the unified biothermokinetic theory of ATP synthesis developed in the previous two papers is applied to a major problem in comparative physiology, biochemistry, and ecology-that of metabolic scaling as a function of body mass across species. A clear distinction is made between intraspecific and interspecific relationships in energy metabolism, clearing up confusion that had existed from the very beginning since Kleiber first proposed his mouse-to-elephant rule almost a century ago. It is shown that the overall mass exponent of basal/standard metabolic rate in the allometric relationship [Formula: see text] is composed of two parts, one emerging from the relative intraspecific constancy of the slope (b), and the other (b') arising from the interspecific variation of the mass coefficient, a(M) with body size. Quantitative analysis is shown to reveal the hidden underlying relationship followed by the interspecific mass coefficient, a(M)=P0M0.10, and a universal value of P0=3.23 watts, W is derived from empirical data on mammals from mouse to cattle. The above relationship is shown to be understood only within an evolutionary biological context, and provides a physiological explanation for Cope's rule. The analysis also helps in fundamentally understanding how variability and a diversity of scaling exponents arises in allometric relations in biology and ecology. Next, a molecular-level understanding of the scaling of metabolism across mammalian species is shown to be obtained by consideration of the thermodynamic efficiency of ATP synthesis η, taking mitochondrial proton leak as a major determinant of basal metabolic rate in biosystems. An iterative solution is obtained by solving the mathematical equations of the biothermokinetic ATP theory, and the key thermodynamic parameters, e.g. the degree of coupling q, the operative P/O ratio, and the metabolic efficiency of ATP synthesis η are quantitatively evaluated for mammals from rat to cattle. Increases in η (by ∼15%) over a 2000-fold body size range from rat to cattle, primarily arising from an ∼3-fold decrease in the mitochondrial H+ leak rate are quantified by the unified ATP theory. Biochemical and mechanistic consequences for the interpretation of basal metabolism, and the various molecular implications arising are discussed in detail. The results are extended to maximum metabolic rate, and interpreted mathematically as a limiting case of the general ATP theory. The limitations of the analysis are pointed out. In sum, a comprehensive quantitative analysis based on the unified biothermokinetic theory of ATP synthesis is shown to solve a central problem in biology, physiology, and ecology on the scaling of energy metabolism with body size.

Thermodynamic analysis of energy coupling by determination of the Onsager phenomenological coefficients for a 3×3 system of coupled chemical reactions and transport in ATP synthesis and its mechanistic implications

The nonequilibrium coupled processes of oxidation and ATP synthesis in the fundamental process of oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) are of vital importance in biosystems. These coupled chemical reaction and transport bioenergetic processes using the OXPHOS pathway meet >90% of the ATP demand in aerobic systems. On the basis of experimentally determined thermodynamic OXPHOS flux-force relationships and biochemical data for the ternary system of oxidation, ion transport, and ATP synthesis, the Onsager phenomenological coefficients have been computed, including an estimate of error. A new biothermokinetic theory of energy coupling has been formulated and on its basis the thermodynamic parameters, such as the overall degree of coupling, q and the phenomenological stoichiometry, Z of the coupled system have been evaluated. The amount of ATP produced per oxygen consumed, i.e. the actual, operating P/O ratio in the biosystem, the thermodynamic efficiency of the coupled reactions, η, and the Gibbs free energy dissipation, Φ have been calculated and shown to be in agreement with experimental data. At the concentration gradients of ADP and ATP prevailing under state 3 physiological conditions of OXPHOS that yield Vmax rates of ATP synthesis, a maximum in Φ of ∼0.5J(hmgprotein)-1, corresponding to a thermodynamic efficiency of ∼60% for oxidation on succinate, has been obtained. Novel mechanistic insights arising from the above have been discussed. This is the first report of a 3 × 3 system of coupled chemical reactions with transport in a biological context in which the phenomenological coefficients have been evaluated from experimental data.

The Warburg Effect Reinterpreted 100 yr on: A First-Principles Stoichiometric Analysis and Interpretation from the Perspective of ATP Metabolism in Cancer Cells

The Warburg Effect is a longstanding enigma in cancer biology. Despite the passage of 100 yr since its discovery, and the accumulation of a vast body of research on the subject, no convincing biochemical explanation has been given for the original observations of aerobic glycolysis in cancer cell metabolism. Here, we have worked out a first-principles quantitative analysis of the problem from the principles of stoichiometry and available electron balance. The results have been interpreted using Nath's unified theory of energy coupling and adenosine triphosphate (ATP) synthesis, and the original data of Warburg and colleagues have been analyzed from this new perspective. Use of the biomass yield based on ATP per unit substrate consumed, [Formula: see text], or the Nath-Warburg number, NaWa has been shown to excellently model the original data on the Warburg Effect with very small standard deviation values, and without employing additional fitted or adjustable parameters. Based on the results of the quantitative analysis, a novel conservative mechanism of synthesis, utilization, and recycling of ATP and other key metabolites (eg, lactate) is proposed. The mechanism offers fresh insights into metabolic symbiosis and coupling within and/or among proliferating cells. The fundamental understanding gained using our approach should help in catalyzing the development of more efficient metabolism-targeting anticancer drugs.

Coupling and biological free-energy transduction processes as a bridge between physics and life: Molecular-level instantiation of Ervin Bauer's pioneering concepts in biological thermodynamics

The nonequilibrium coupled processes of oxidation and ATP synthesis in the biological process of oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) are fundamental to all life on our planet. These steady-state energy transduction processes ‒ coupled by proton and anion/counter-cation concentration gradients in the OXPHOS pathway ‒ generate ∼95 % of the ATP requirement of aerobic systems for cellular function. The rapid energy cycling and homeostasis of metabolites involved in this coupling are shown to be responsible for maintenance and regulation of stable nonequilibrium states, the latter first postulated in pioneering biothermodynamics work by Ervin Bauer between 1920 and 1935. How exactly does this occur? This is shown to be answered by molecular considerations arising from Nath's torsional mechanism of ATP synthesis and two-ion theory of energy coupling developed in 25 years of research work on the subject. A fresh analysis of the biological thermodynamics of coupling that goes beyond the previous work of Stucki and others and shows how the system functions at the molecular level has been carried out. Thermodynamic parameters, such as the overall degree of coupling, q of the coupled system are evaluated for the state 4 to state 3 transition in animal mitochondria with succinate as substrate. The actual or operative P to O ratio, the efficiency of the coupled reactions, η, and the Gibbs energy dissipation, Φ have been calculated and shown to be in good agreement with experimental data. Novel mechanistic insights arising from the above have been discussed. A fourth law/principle of thermodynamics is formulated for a sub-class of physical and biological systems. The critical importance of constraints and time-varying boundary conditions for function and regulation is discussed in detail. Dynamic internal structural changes essential for torsional energy storage within the γ-subunit in a single molecule of the FOF1-ATP synthase and its transduction have been highlighted. These results provide a molecular-level instantiation of Ervin Bauer's pioneering concepts in biological thermodynamics.

Phosphorus Chemistry at the Roots of Bioenergetics: Ligand Permutation as the Molecular Basis of the Mechanism of ATP Synthesis/Hydrolysis by FOF1-ATP Synthase

The integration of phosphorus chemistry with the mechanism of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis requires dynamical information during ATP turnover and catalysis. Oxygen exchange reactions occurring at β-catalytic sites of the FOF1-ATP synthase/F1-ATPase imprint a unique record of molecular events during the catalytic cycle of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis. They have been shown to provide valuable time-resolved information on enzyme catalysis during ATP synthesis and ATP hydrolysis. The present work conducts new experiments on oxygen exchange catalyzed by submitochondrial particles designed to (i) measure the relative rates of Pi-ATP, Pi-HOH, and ATP-HOH isotope exchanges; (ii) probe the effect of ADP removal on the extent of inhibition of the exchanges, and (iii) test their uncoupler sensitivity/resistance. The objectives have been realized based on new experiments on submitochondrial particles, which show that both the Pi-HOH and ATP-HOH exchanges occur at a considerably higher rate relative to the Pi-ATP exchange, an observation that cannot be explained by previous mechanisms. A unifying explanation of the kinetic data that rationalizes these observations is given. The experimental results in (ii) show that ADP removal does not inhibit the intermediate Pi-HOH exchange when ATP and submitochondrial particles are incubated, and that the nucleotide requirement of the intermediate Pi-HOH exchange is adequately met by ATP, but not by ADP. These results contradicts the central postulate in Boyer's binding change mechanism of reversible catalysis at a F1 catalytic site with Keq~1 that predicts an absolute requirement of ADP for the occurrence of the Pi-HOH exchange. The prominent intermediate Pi-HOH exchange occurring under hydrolytic conditions is shown to be best explained by Nath's torsional mechanism of energy transduction and ATP synthesis/hydrolysis, which postulates an essentially irreversible cleavage of ATP by mitochondria/particles, independent from a reversible formation of ATP from ADP and Pi. The explanation within the torsional mechanism is also shown to rationalize the relative insensitivity of the intermediate Pi-HOH exchange to uncouplers observed in the experiments in (iii) compared to the Pi-ATP and ATP-HOH exchanges. This is shown to lead to new concepts and perspectives based on ligand displacement/substitution and ligand permutation for the elucidation of the oxygen exchange reactions within the framework of fundamental phosphorus chemistry. Fast mechanisms that realize the rotation/twist, tilt, permutation and switch of ligands, as well as inversion at the γ-phosphorus synchronously and simultaneously and in a concerted manner, have been proposed, and their stereochemical consequences have been analyzed. These considerations take us beyond the binding change mechanism of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis in bioenergetics.

Elucidating Events within the Black Box of Enzyme Catalysis in Energy Metabolism: Insights into the Molecular Mechanism of ATP Hydrolysis by F1-ATPase

Oxygen exchange reactions occurring at β-catalytic sites of the FOF1-ATP synthase/F1-ATPase imprint a unique record of molecular events during the catalytic cycle of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis. This work presents a new theory of oxygen exchange and tests it on oxygen exchange data recorded on ATP hydrolysis by mitochondrial F1-ATPase (MF1). The apparent rate constant of oxygen exchange governing the intermediate Pi-HOH exchange accompanying ATP hydrolysis is determined by kinetic analysis over a ~50,000-fold range of substrate ATP concentration (0.1-5000 μM) and a corresponding ~200-fold range of reaction velocity (3.5-650 [moles of Pi/{moles of F1-ATPase}-1 s-1]). Isotopomer distributions of [18O]Pi species containing 0, 1, 2, and 3 labeled oxygen atoms predicted by the theory have been quantified and shown to be in perfect agreement with the experimental distributions over the entire range of medium ATP concentrations without employing adjustable parameters. A novel molecular mechanism of steady-state multisite ATP hydrolysis by the F1-ATPase has been proposed. Our results show that steady-state ATP hydrolysis by F1-ATPase occurs with all three sites occupied by Mg-nucleotide. The various implications arising from models of energy coupling in ATP synthesis/hydrolysis by the ATP synthase/F1-ATPase have been discussed. Current models of ATP hydrolysis by F1-ATPase, including those postulated from single-molecule data, are shown to be effectively bisite models that contradict the data. The trisite catalysis formulated by Nath's torsional mechanism of energy transduction and ATP synthesis/hydrolysis since its first appearance 25 years ago is shown to be in better accord with the experimental record. The total biochemical information on ATP hydrolysis is integrated into a consistent model by the torsional mechanism of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis and shown to elucidate the elementary chemical and mechanical events within the black box of enzyme catalysis in energy metabolism by F1-ATPase.

Beyond binding change: the molecular mechanism of ATP hydrolysis by F1-ATPase and its biochemical consequences

F1-ATPase is a universal multisubunit enzyme and the smallest-known motor that, fueled by the process of ATP hydrolysis, rotates in 120o steps. A central question is how the elementary chemical steps occurring in the three catalytic sites are coupled to the mechanical rotation. Here, we performed cold chase promotion experiments and measured the rates and extents of hydrolysis of preloaded bound ATP and promoter ATP bound in the catalytic sites. We found that rotation was caused by the electrostatic free energy change associated with the ATP cleavage reaction followed by Pi release. The combination of these two processes occurs sequentially in two different catalytic sites on the enzyme, thereby driving the two rotational sub-steps of the 120o rotation. The mechanistic implications of this finding are discussed based on the overall energy balance of the system. General principles of free energy transduction are formulated, and their important physical and biochemical consequences are analyzed. In particular, how exactly ATP performs useful external work in biomolecular systems is discussed. A molecular mechanism of steady-state, trisite ATP hydrolysis by F1-ATPase, consistent with physical laws and principles and the consolidated body of available biochemical information, is developed. Taken together with previous results, this mechanism essentially completes the coupling scheme. Discrete snapshots seen in high-resolution X-ray structures are assigned to specific intermediate stages in the 120o hydrolysis cycle, and reasons for the necessity of these conformations are readily understood. The major roles played by the "minor" subunits of ATP synthase in enabling physiological energy coupling and catalysis, first predicted by Nath's torsional mechanism of energy transduction and ATP synthesis 25 years ago, are now revealed with great clarity. The working of nine-stepped (bMF1, hMF1), six-stepped (TF1, EF1), and three-stepped (PdF1) F1 motors and of the α3β3γ subcomplex of F1 is explained by the same unified mechanism without invoking additional assumptions or postulating different mechanochemical coupling schemes. Some novel predictions of the unified theory on the mode of action of F1 inhibitors, such as sodium azide, of great pharmaceutical importance, and on more exotic artificial or hybrid/chimera F1 motors have been made and analyzed mathematically. The detailed ATP hydrolysis cycle for the enzyme as a whole is shown to provide a biochemical basis for a theory of "unisite" and steady-state multisite catalysis by F1-ATPase that had remained elusive for a very long time. The theory is supported by a probability-based calculation of enzyme species distributions and analysis of catalytic site occupancies by Mg-nucleotides and the activity of F1-ATPase. A new concept of energy coupling in ATP synthesis/hydrolysis based on fundamental ligand substitution chemistry has been advanced, which offers a deeper understanding, elucidates enzyme activation and catalysis in a better way, and provides a unified molecular explanation of elementary chemical events occurring at enzyme catalytic sites. As such, these developments take us beyond binding change mechanisms of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis proposed for oxidative phosphorylation and photophosphorylation in bioenergetics.

Nanotopography reveals metabolites that maintain the immunomodulatory phenotype of mesenchymal stromal cells

Mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) are multipotent progenitor cells that are of considerable clinical potential in transplantation and anti-inflammatory therapies due to their capacity for tissue repair and immunomodulation. However, MSCs rapidly differentiate once in culture, making their large-scale expansion for use in immunomodulatory therapies challenging. Although the differentiation mechanisms of MSCs have been extensively investigated using materials, little is known about how materials can influence paracrine activities of MSCs. Here, we show that nanotopography can control the immunomodulatory capacity of MSCs through decreased intracellular tension and increasing oxidative glycolysis. We use nanotopography to identify bioactive metabolites that modulate intracellular tension, growth and immunomodulatory phenotype of MSCs in standard culture and during larger scale cell manufacture. Our findings demonstrate an effective route to support large-scale expansion of functional MSCs for therapeutic purposes.

The Need for Consistency with Physical Laws and Logic in Choosing Between Competing Molecular Mechanisms in Biological Processes: A Case Study in Modeling ATP Synthesis

Traditionally, proposed molecular mechanisms of fundamental biological processes have been tested against experiment. However, owing to a plethora of reasons-difficulty in designing, carrying out, and interpreting key experiments, use of different experimental models and systems, conduct of studies under widely varying experimental conditions, fineness in distinctions between competing mechanisms, complexity of the scientific issues, and the resistance of some scientists to discoveries that are contrary to popularly held beliefs-this has not solved the problem despite decades of work in the field/s. The author would like to prescribe an alternative way: that of testing competing models/mechanisms for their adherence to scientific laws and principles, and checking for errors in logic. Such tests are fairly commonly carried out in the mathematics, physics, and engineering literature. Further, reported experimental measurements should not be smaller than minimum detectable values for the measurement technique employed and should truly reflect function of the actual system without inapplicable extrapolation. Progress in the biological fields would be greatly accelerated, and considerable scientific acrimony avoided by adopting this approach. Some examples from the fundamental field of ATP synthesis in oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) have been reviewed that also serve to illustrate the approach. The approach has never let the author down in his 35-yr-long experience on biological mechanisms. This change in thinking should lead to a considerable saving of both time and resources, help channel research efforts toward solution of the right problems, and hopefully provide new vistas to a younger generation of open-minded biological scientists.

Ckmt1 is Dispensable for Mitochondrial Bioenergetics Within White/Beige Adipose Tissue

Within brown adipose tissue (BAT), the brain isoform of creatine kinase (CKB) has been proposed to regulate the regeneration of ADP and phosphocreatine in a futile creatine cycle (FCC) that stimulates energy expenditure. However, the presence of FCC, and the specific creatine kinase isoforms regulating this theoretical model within white adipose tissue (WAT), remains to be fully elucidated. In the present study, creatine did not stimulate respiration in cultured adipocytes, isolated mitochondria or mouse permeabilized WAT. Additionally, while creatine kinase ubiquitous-type, mitochondrial (CKMT1) mRNA and protein were detected in human WAT, shRNA-mediated reductions in Ckmt1 did not decrease submaximal respiration in cultured adipocytes, and ablation of CKMT1 in mice did not alter energy expenditure, mitochondrial responses to pharmacological β3-adrenergic activation (CL 316, 243) or exacerbate the detrimental metabolic effects of consuming a high-fat diet. Taken together, these findings solidify CKMT1 as dispensable in the regulation of energy expenditure, and unlike in BAT, they do not support the presence of FCC within WAT.

Supercomplex supercomplexes: Raison d’etre and functional significance of supramolecular organization in oxidative phosphorylation

Following structural determination by recent advances in electron cryomicroscopy, it is now well established that the respiratory Complexes I–IV in oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) are organized into supercomplexes in the respirasome. Nonetheless, the reason for the existence of the OXPHOS supercomplexes and their functional role remains an enigma. Several hypotheses have been proposed for the existence of these supercomplex supercomplexes. A commonly-held view asserts that they enhance catalysis by substrate channeling. However, this – and other views – has been challenged based on structural and biophysical information. Hence, new ideas, concepts, and frameworks are needed. Here, a new model of energy transfer in OXPHOS is developed on the basis of biochemical data on the pure competitive inhibition of anionic substrates like succinate by the classical anionic uncouplers of OXPHOS (2,4-dinitrophenol, carbonyl cyanide 4-(trifluoromethoxy)phenylhydrazone, and dicoumarol), and pharmacological data on the unique site-selective, energy-linked inhibition of energy conservation pathways in mitochondria induced by the guanidine derivatives. It is further found that uncouplers themselves are site-specific and exhibit differential selectivity and efficacy in reversing the inhibition caused by the Site 1/Complex I or Site 2/Complexes II–III-selective guanidine derivatives. These results lead to new vistas and sufficient complexity in the network of energy conservation pathways in the mitochondrial respiratory chain that necessitate discrete points of interaction with two classes of guanidine derivatives and uncoupling agents and thereby separate and distinct energy transfer pathways between Site 1 and Site 2 and the intermediate that energizes adenosine triphosphate (ATP) synthesis by Complex V. Interpretation based on Mitchell’s single-ion chemiosmotic theory that postulates only a single energy pool is inadequate to rationalize the data and account for the required complexity. The above results and available information are shown to be explained by Nath’s two-ion theory of energy coupling and ATP synthesis, involving coupled movement of succinate anions and protons, along with the requirement postulated by the theory for maintenance of homeostasis and ion translocation across the energy-transducing membrane of both succinate monoanions and succinate dianions by Complexes I–V in the OXPHOS supercomplexes. The new model of energy transfer in mitochondria is mapped onto the solved structures of the supercomplexes and integrated into a consistent model with the three-dimensional electron microscope computer tomography visualization of the internal structure of the cristae membranes in mammalian mitochondria. The model also offers valuable insights into diseased states induced in type 2 diabetes and especially in Alzheimer’s and other neurodegenerative diseases that involve mitochondrial dysfunction.

Skeletal Muscle Uncoupling Proteins in Mice Models of Obesity

Obesity and accompanying type 2 diabetes are among major and increasing worldwide problems that occur fundamentally due to excessive energy intake during its expenditure. Endotherms continuously consume a certain amount of energy to maintain core body temperature via thermogenic processes, mainly in brown adipose tissue and skeletal muscle. Skeletal muscle glucose utilization and heat production are significant and directly linked to body glucose homeostasis at rest, and especially during physical activity. However, this glucose balance is impaired in diabetic and obese states in humans and mice, and manifests as glucose resistance and altered muscle cell metabolism. Uncoupling proteins have a significant role in converting electrochemical energy into thermal energy without ATP generation. Different homologs of uncoupling proteins were identified, and their roles were linked to antioxidative activity and boosting glucose and lipid metabolism. From this perspective, uncoupling proteins were studied in correlation to the pathogenesis of diabetes and obesity and their possible treatments. Mice were extensively used as model organisms to study the physiology and pathophysiology of energy homeostasis. However, we should be aware of interstrain differences in mice models of obesity regarding thermogenesis and insulin resistance in skeletal muscles. Therefore, in this review, we gathered up-to-date knowledge on skeletal muscle uncoupling proteins and their effect on insulin sensitivity in mouse models of obesity and diabetes.

Charge transfer across biomembranes: A solution to the conundrum of high desolvation free energy penalty in ion transport

Charge transfer across membranes is an important problem in a wide variety of fundamental physicochemical and biological processes. Since Mitchell's concept of the ion well advanced in 1968, several models of ion translocation across biomembranes, for instance through the membrane-bound FO portion of ATP synthase have been proposed. None of these models has considered the large desolvation free energy penalty of ~500 meV incurred in transferring a protonic charge from the aqueous phase into the membrane that hinders such charge transfer processes. The difficulty has been pointed out repeatedly. However, the problem of how the adverse ∆Gdesolvation barrier is overcome in order to enable rapid ion translocation in biomembranes has not been satisfactorily resolved. Hence the fact that the self-energy of the charges has been overlooked can be regarded as a main source of confusion in the field of bioenergetics. Further, in order to consider charges of a finite size (and not just point charges), the free energy of transferring the ions from water into a membrane phase of lower dielectric εm needs to be evaluated. Here a solution to the longstanding conundrum has been proposed by including the bound anion - the second ion in Nath's two-ion theory of energy coupling and ATP synthesis - in the free energy calculations. The mechanistic importance of the H+ - A- charge pair in causing rotation and ATP synthesis by ion-protein interactions is highlighted. The ∆G calculations have been performed by using the Kirkwood-Tanford-Warshel (KTW) theory that takes into account the self-energies of the ions. The results show that the adverse ∆Gdesolvation can be almost exactly compensated by the sum of the electrostatic free energy of the charge-charge interactions and the dipole solvation energy for long-range ion pairs. Results of free energy compensation using the KTW theory have been compared with experimental data on the ∆G of ion pairs and shown to be in reasonable agreement. A general thermodynamic cycle for coupled ion transfer has been constructed to further elucidate facilitated ion permeation between water and membrane phases. Molecular interpretations of the results and their implications for various mechanisms of energy transduction have been discussed. We firmly believe that use of electrostatic theories such as the KTW theory that properly include the desolvation free energy penalty arising from the self-energy of the relevant ions are crucial for quantifying charge transfer processes in bioenergetics. Finally, the clear-cut implication is that proton-only and single-ion theories of ATP synthesis, such as the chemiosmotic theory, are grossly inadequate to comprehend energy storage and transduction in biological processes.

Coupling mechanisms in ATP synthesis: Rejoinder to "Response to molecular-level understanding of biological energy coupling and transduction"

Recently, an exchange of views on key fundamental aspects of biological energy coupling and ATP synthesis in the vital process of oxidative phosphorylation appeared in the pages of this journal. The very difficult scientific problems are analyzed and clarified. Errors in the mathematical/thermodynamic equations of a previous analysis have been identified that invalidate previous assertions, and the correct equations are derived. The major differences between the two competing models - localized versus delocalized - for biological energy coupling and transduction are discussed from physical, chemical, and mathematical perspectives. The opposing views are summarized, so that the reader can assess for himself or herself the merits of the two coupling mechanisms. A fresh attempt has been made to go to the root of bioenergetics by calculating the desolvation free energy barrier, ∆G_desolvation for ion transport across biomembranes. Several constructive suggestions are made that have the power to resolve the basic contradictions and the areas of fundamental conflict, and reach a consensus by catalyzing the progress of future research in this interdisciplinary field.

Molecular-level understanding of biological energy coupling and transduction: Response to "Chemiosmotic misunderstandings"

In a recent paper entitled "Chemiosmotic misunderstandings", it is claimed that "enough shortcomings in Mitchell's chemiosmotic theory have not been found and that a novel paradigm that offers at least as much explanatory power as chemiosmosis is not ready." This view is refuted by a wealth of molecular-level experimental data and strong new theoretical and computational evidence. It is shown that the chemiosmotic theory was beset with a large number of major shortcomings ever since the time when it was first proposed in the 1960s. These multiple shortcomings and flaws of chemiosmosis were repeatedly pointed out in incisive critiques by biochemical authorities of the late 20th century. All the shortcomings and flaws have been shown to be rectified by a quantitative, unified molecular-level theory that leads to a deeper and far more accurate understanding of biological energy coupling and ATP synthesis. The new theory is shown to be consistent with pioneering X-ray and cryo-EM structures and validated by state-of-the-art single-molecule techniques. Several new biochemical experimental tests are proposed and constructive ways for providing a revitalizing conceptual background and theory for integration of the available experimental information are suggested.

Predicting Uncoupling Toxicity of Organic Acids Based on Their Molecular Structure Using a Biophysical Model

We present a purely mechanistic model to predict protonophoric uncoupling activity EC_w of organic acids. All required input information can be derived from their chemical structure. This makes it a convenient predictive model to gain valuable information on the toxicity of organic chemicals already at an early stage of development of new commercial chemicals (e.g., in agriculture or pharmaceutical industries). A critical component of the model is the consideration of the possible formation of heterodimers from the neutral and anionic monomer, and its permeation through the membrane. The model was tested against literature data measured in chromatophores, submitochondrial particles, isolated mitochondria, and intact green algae cells with good success. It was also possible to reproduce pH-dependencies in isolated mitochondria and intact cells. Besides the prediction of the EC_w, the mechanistic nature of the model allows researchers to draw direct conclusions on the impact of single input factors such as pH- and voltage-gradients across the membrane, the anionic and neutral membrane permeability, and the heterodimerization constant. These insights are of importance in drug design or chemical regulation.

From sunscreens to medicines: Can a dissipation hypothesis explain the beneficial aspects of many plant compounds?

Medicine has utilised plant‐based treatments for millennia, but precisely how they work is unclear. One approach is to use a thermodynamic viewpoint that life arose by dissipating geothermal and/or solar potential. Hence, the ability to dissipate energy to maintain homeostasis is a fundamental principle in all life, which can be viewed as an accretion system where layers of complexity have built upon core abiotic molecules. Many of these compounds are chromophoric and are now involved in multiple pathways. Plants have further evolved a plethora of chromophoric compounds that can not only act as sunscreens and redox modifiers, but also have now become integrated into a generalised stress adaptive system. This could be an extension of the dissipative process. In animals, many of these compounds are hormetic, modulating mitochondria and calcium signalling. They can also display anti‐pathogen effects. They could therefore modulate bioenergetics across all life due to the conserved electron transport chain and proton gradient. In this review paper, we focus on well‐described medicinal compounds, such as salicylic acid and cannabidiol and suggest, at least in animals, their activity reflects their evolved function in plants in relation to stress adaptation, which itself evolved to maintain dissipative homeostasis.

Do trifluralin and tebuthiuron impair isolated rat liver mitochondria?

Emerging contaminants, such as the herbicides trifluralin and tebuthiuron, comprise a class of compounds for which toxicological data are lacking, especially data regarding their harmful effects and biomarkers of exposure. Their potential damage to the environment and non-target organisms makes understanding their toxic mechanisms an urgent matter. Mitochondria, which exert an energy production function, play a vital role in maintaining many cellular activities and therefore are reliable predictors of substance toxicity. This study evaluates whether the herbicides trifluralin and tebuthiuron (at concentrations ranging from 1 to 100 μM) affect isolated rat liver mitochondria. The herbicides were analyzed according to their ability to interact with the mitochondrial membrane and induce swelling, lipoperoxidation, ROS formation, and NAD(P)H oxidation; dissipate the membrane potential; dysregulate calcium homeostasis; and alter ATP and GSH/GSSG levels. Tebuthiuron does not disrupt the mitochondrial biochemistry at any of the tested concentrations. In contrast, trifluralin can disturb the mitochondrial respiration, especially at the highest concentration, but it cannot induce oxidative stress. These results suggest that the aforementioned effects can occur as toxic mechanisms of trifluralin in non-target organisms, as well.

Consolidation of Nath's torsional mechanism of ATP synthesis and two-ion theory of energy coupling in oxidative phosphorylation and photophosphorylation

In a recent publication, Manoj raises criticisms against consensus views on the ATP synthase. The radical statements and assertions are shown to contradict a vast body of available knowledge that includes i) pioneering single-molecule biochemical and biophysical studies from the respected experimental groups of Kinosita, Yoshida, Noji, Börsch, Dunn, Gräber, Frasch, and Dimroth etc., ii) state-of-the-art X-ray and EM/cryo-EM structural information garnered over the decades by the expert groups of Leslie-Walker, Kühlbrandt, Mueller, Meier, Rubinstein, Sazanov, Duncan, and Pedersen on ATP synthase, iii) the pioneering energy-based computer simulations of Warshel, and iv) the novel theoretical and experimental works of Nath. Valid objections against Mitchell's chemiosmotic theory and Boyer's binding change mechanism put forth by Manoj have been addressed satisfactorily by Nath's torsional mechanism of ATP synthesis and two-ion theory of energy coupling and published 10 to 20 years ago, but these papers are not cited by him. This communication shows conclusively and in great detail that none of his objections apply to Nath's mechanism/theory. Nath's theory is further consolidated based on its previous predictive record, its consistency with biochemical evidence, its unified nature, its application to other related energy transductions and to disease, and finally its ability to guide the design of new experiments. Some constructive suggestions for high-resolution structural experiments that have the power to delve into the heart of the matter and throw unprecedented light on the nature of coupled ion translocation in the membrane-bound F_O portion of F₁F_O-ATP synthase are made.

Modern theory of energy coupling and ATP synthesis. Violation of Gauss's law by the chemiosmotic theory and validation of the two-ion theory

Adenosine triphosphate (ATP) is the universal biological energy fuel, or nature's gasoline. The vast quantities of ATP required for sustenance of living processes in cells are synthesized by oxidative phosphorylation and photosynthesis. The chemiosmotic theory of energy coupling was proposed by Mitchell more than 50 years ago but has a contentious history. Part of the accumulated body of experimental evidence supports Mitchell's theory, and part of the evidence conflicts with the theory. Although Mitchell's theory was strongly criticized by several prominent scientists, the controversy was never resolved. Certain theoretical arguments and electrostatic calculations were originally made to justify the central tenet of the chemiosmotic theory of electrogenic proton transfer and violation of electrical neutrality in bulk aqueous phases by creation of a delocalized field. However, these calculations have not been scientifically scrutinized previously. Here it is proved from first principles that the original physical arguments and calculations made in support of steady state electrogenic ion transfer and chemiosmosis violate Gauss's law. Nath's two-ion theory of energy coupling in which the field is local, and ion translocation is dynamically electrogenic but overall electroneutral is shown to satisfactorily resolve the difficulties. Characterization of length scales in mitochondrial systems is shown to impose strong constraints on possible mechanisms of energy transduction. Some biological implications for energy coupling, transduction and ATP synthesis arising as a result of the above analysis are discussed. Examples of several other biological processes where the new theory is useful such as apoptosis, muscle contraction, the joint multisite regulation of oxidative phosphorylation and the Krebs cycle, and hindered protein aggregation arising from ATP's hydrotropic properties are outlined.

Integration of demand and supply sides in the ATP energy economics of cells

The central aspects of the energy economics of living cells revolve around the synthesis and utilization of molecules of adenosine triphosphate (ATP). Current descriptions of cell metabolism and its regulation in most textbooks of biochemistry assume that enzymes and transporters behave in the same way in isolation and in a cell. Calculations of the mechanistic or maximal P/O ratios in oxidative phosphorylation by mammalian cells generally consider only the supply side of the problem without linking to ATP-demand processes. The purpose of this article is to calculate the mechanistic P/O ratio by integration of the supply and demand sides of ATP reactions. The mechanistic stoichiometry calculated from an integrated approach is compared with that obtained from the standard model that considers only ATP supply. After accounting for leaks, slips, and other losses, the actual or operative P/O calculated by the integrated method is found to be in good agreement with the experimental values of the P/O ratio determined in mitochondria for both succinate and NADH-linked respiratory substrates. The thermodynamic consequences of these results and the biological implications are discussed. An integrated model of oxidative phosphorylation that goes beyond the chemiosmotic theory is presented, and a solution to the longstanding fundamental problem of respiratory control is found.