Peptide adsorption to lipid bilayers: slow processes revealed by linear dichroism spectroscopy

Linear dichroism and linearly polarised luminescence spectra of oriented samples collected on a new integrated instrument

Linearly polarised luminescence (LPL) has a wide range of potential applications giving optical and geometric parameters for oriented lumiphores. In this work we present the first wavelength scanned LPL spectra. Analytes are either oriented on stretched polyethylene films or in flow. Applications of the wavelength-dependence of g-factors are illustrated.

Spectroscopic and Microscopic Approaches for Investigating the Dynamic Interactions of Anti-microbial Peptides With Membranes and Cells

The emergence of microbes resistant to conventional antibiotics is a burgeoning threat to humanity with significant impacts on the health of people and on the health system itself. Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) hold promise as potential future alternatives to conventional drugs because they form an integral part of the defense systems of other species in the animal, plant, and fungal kingdoms. To aid the design of the next generation of AMPs optimized for human use, we must first understand the mechanism of action of existing AMPs with their targets, ideally in the context of the complex landscape of the living (microbial) cell. Advances in lasers, optics, detectors, fluid dynamics and various probes has enabled the experimentalist to measure the kinetics of molecule–membrane, molecule–molecule, and molecule–cell interactions with increasing spatial and temporal resolution. The purpose of this review is to highlight studies into these dynamic interactions with a view to improving our understanding of AMP mechanisms.

Flow Linear Dichroism of Protein-Membrane Systems

Linear dichroism (LD) is the differential absorbance of light polarized parallel and perpendicular to an orientation direction. Any oriented sample will show a signal in its electronic as well as vibrational transitions. Model membrane small unilamellar vesicles or liposomes provide an oriented system when they are subject to shear flow in a Couette or other type of flow cell. Anything, including peptides and proteins, that is bound to the liposome also gives an LD signal whereas unbound analytes are invisible. Flow LD is the ideal technique for determining the orientation of different chromophores with respect to the membrane normal. To illustrate the power of the method, data for diphenyl hexatriene, fluorene, antimicrobial peptides (aurein 2.5 and gramicidin), are considered as well as another common chromophore, fluorene, often used to increase the hydrophobicity and hence membrane binding of peptides. How LD can be used both for geometry, structure analysis and probing kinetic processes is considered. Kinetic analysis usually involves identifying binding (appearance of an LD signal), insertion (sign change), often followed by loss of signal, if the inserted protein or peptide disrupts the membrane .

Spectroscopy of model-membrane liposome-protein systems: complementarity of linear dichroism, circular dichroism, fluorescence and SERS

A range of membrane models have been developed to study components of cellular systems. Lipid vesicles or liposomes are one such artificial membrane model which mimics many properties of the biological system: they are lipid bilayers composed of one or more lipids to which other molecules can associate. Liposomes are thus ideal to study the roles of cellular lipids and their interactions with other membrane components to understand a wide range of cellular processes including membrane disruption, membrane transport and catalytic activity. Although liposomes are much simpler than cellular membranes, they are still challenging to study and a variety of complementary techniques are needed. In this review article, we consider several currently used analytical methods for spectroscopic measurements of unilamellar liposomes and their interaction with proteins and peptides. Among the variety of spectroscopic techniques seeing increasing application, we have chosen to discuss: fluorescence based techniques such as FRET (fluorescence resonance energy transfer) and FRAP (fluorescence recovery after photobleaching), that are used to identify localisation and dynamics of molecules in the membrane; circular dichroism (CD) and linear dichroism (LD) for conformational and orientation changes of proteins on membrane binding; and SERS (Surface Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy) as a rapidly developing ultrasensitive technique for site-selective molecular characterisation. The review contains brief theoretical basics of the listed techniques and recent examples of their successful applications for membrane studies.

Kinetics of interaction between antimicrobial peptide nisin and Langmuir monolayers of DPPC and DPPG molecules

We have studied the kinetics of the interaction between antimicrobial peptide nisin and Langmuir monolayers of phospholipids DPPC and DPPG at the air-water interface using the surface manometry technique. The charge on the nisin and the lipid molecules is controlled by varying the pH of the subphase, and the interactions between them are studied by measuring the surface pressure of the lipid monolayer as a function of time after injecting the nisin in the subphase. A model based on the diffusion of particles under the influence of a constant force is developed to obtain an analytical expression for surface pressure as a function of time. The expression was found to fit well with the experimental data. The average hydrodynamic radius and the translational diffusion constant of the nisin molecules are calculated from the fit parameters for the different subphase pH solutions.

Membrane negative curvature induced by a hybrid peptide from pediocin PA-1 and plantaricin 149 as revealed by atomistic molecular dynamics simulations

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are cationic peptides that kill bacteria with a broad spectrum of action, low toxicity to mammalian cells and exceptionally low rates of bacterial resistance. These features have led to considerable efforts in developing AMPs as an alternative antibacterial therapy. In vitro studies have shown that AMPs interfere with membrane bilayer integrity via several possible mechanisms, which are not entirely understood. We have performed the synthesis, membrane lysis measurements, and biophysical characterization of a novel hybrid peptide. These measurements show that PA-Pln149 does not form nanopores, but instead promotes membrane rupture. It causes fast rupture of the bacterial model membrane (POPG-rich) at concentrations 100-fold lower than that required for the disruption of mammalian model membranes (POPC-rich). Atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were performed for single and multiple copies of PA-Pln149 in the presence of mixed and pure POPC/POPG bilayers to investigate the concentration-dependent membrane disruption by the hybrid peptide. These simulations reproduced the experimental trend and provided a potential mechanism of action for PA-Pln149. It shows that the PA-Pln149 does not form nanopores, but instead promotes membrane destabilization through peptide aggregation and induction of membrane negative curvature with the collapse of the lamellar arrangement. The sequence of events depicted for PA-Pln149 may offer insights into the mechanism of action of AMPs previously shown to induce negative deformation of membrane curvature and often associated with peptide translocation via non-bilayer intermediate structures.

The association of defensin HNP-2 with negatively charged membranes: A combined fluorescence and linear dichroism study

The association of defensin HNP-2 with negatively charged membranes has been studied using a new approach that combines fluorescence and linear dichroism (LD) spectroscopies with simulated LD spectra in order to characterise the binding kinetics and bound configurations of the peptide. Binding to membranes composed of mixtures of diacylglycerophosphocholines (PC) with either diacylglycerophosphoglycerol (PG) or diacylglycerophosphoserine (PS) was conducted at lipid:peptide ratios that yielded binding, but not membrane fusion. HNP-2 association with membranes under these conditions was a 2 stage-process, with both stages exhibiting first order kinetics. The fast initial step, with a half-life of < 1 min, was followed by a slower step with a half-life of > 3 min. Conversion between the states was estimated to have an enthalpy of activation of approximately 10 kJ mol(-1) and an entropy of activation of -0.2 kJ K mol(-1). LD spectra corresponding to each of the membrane bound states were generated by non-linear regression using a standard kinetic model. These spectra are interpreted in comparison with spectra calculated using the program Dichrocalc and reveal that the peptide associates with membranes in a small number of stable configurations. All of these configurations have a significant proportion of β-sheet structure residing in the plane of the membrane. Two configurations support structures previously proposed for defensins in membranes.

Long-time-scale interaction dynamics between a model antimicrobial peptide and giant unilamellar vesicles

The interaction dynamics between a lytic peptide and a biomembrane was studied using time-lapse fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy. The model membrane was 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphochloine giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs), and the peptide was the K14 derivative of melittin, to which the polarity-sensitive fluorescent probe AlexaFluor 430 was grafted. The interaction of the peptide with the GUVs resulted in a progressive quenching of the fluorescence lifetime over a period of minutes. From previous photophysics characterization of the peptide, we were able to deconvolve the contribution of three distinct peptide states to the lifetime trajectory and use this data to develop a kinetics model for the interaction process. It was found that the peptide-membrane interaction was well described by a two-step mechanism: peptide monomer adsorption followed by membrane surface migration, assembly, and insertion to form membrane pores. There was an equilibrium exchange between pore and surface monomers at all lipid/peptide (L/P) concentration ratios, suggesting that the fully inserted phase was reached, even at low peptide concentrations. In contrast to previous studies, there was no evidence of critical behavior; irrespective of L/P ratio, lytic pores were the dominant peptide state at equilibrium and were formed even at very low peptide concentrations. We suggest that this behavior is seen in GUVs because their low curvature means low Laplace pressure. Membrane elasticity is therefore relatively ineffective at damping the thermal fluctuations of lipid molecules that lead to random molecular-level lipid protrusions and membrane undulations. The transient local membrane deformations that result from these thermal fluctuations create the conditions necessary for facile peptide insertion.

Combined mass and structural kinetic analysis of multistate antimicrobial peptide-membrane interactions

Kinetic analysis of peptide-membrane interactions generally involves a curve fitting process with no information about what the different curves may physically correspond to. Given the multistep process of peptide-membrane interactions, a computational method that utilizes physical parameters that relate to both peptide binding and membrane structure would provide new insight into this complex process. In this study, kinetic models accounting for two-state and three-state mechanisms were fitted to our previously reported simultaneous real-time measurements of mass and birefringence during the binding and dissociation of the peptide HPA3 (Hirst, D.; Lee, T.-H.; Swann, M.; Unabia, S.; Park, Y.; Hahm, K.-S.; Aguilar, M. Eur. Biophys. J. 2011, 40, 503-514); significantly, the mass and birefringence are constrained by the same set of kinetic constants, allowing the unification of peptide binding patterns with membrane structure changes. For the saturated phospholipid dimyristoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DMPC) the two-state model was sufficient to account for the observed changes in mass and birefringence, whereas for the unsaturated phospholipid 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) the two-state model was found to be inadequate and a three-state model gave a significantly better fit. The third state of interaction for POPC was found to disrupt the bilayer much more than the previous two states. We propose a hypothesis for the mechanism of membrane permeabilization based on the results featuring a loosely bound first state, a tightly bound second state, and a highly membrane-disrupting third state. The results demonstrate the importance of the difference in membrane fluidity between the gel phase DMPC and the liquid crystal phase POPC for peptide-membrane interactions and establish the combination of DPI and kinetic modeling as a powerful tool for revealing features of peptide-membrane interaction mechanisms, including intermediate states between initial binding and full membrane disruption.

Slow insertion kinetics during interaction of a model antimicrobial peptide with unilamellar phospholipid vesicles

The mechanism of interaction between a model antimicrobial peptide and phospholipid unilamellar vesicle membranes was studied using fluorescence spectroscopy, fluorescence lifetime measurements, and light scattering. The peptide, a mellitin mutant, was labeled at position K14 with the polarity-sensitive probe AlexaFluor 430. The kinetics of the interaction of this derivative with various concentrations of 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) vesicles was examined. Our work unveiled two novel aspects of peptide-lipid interactions. First, the AB plot or phasor analysis of the fluorescence lifetime studies revealed at least three different peptide states, the population of which depended on the lipid to peptide (L:P) concentration ratio. Second, complex fluorescence kinetics were observed over extended time-scales from 30 s to 2 h. The extended kinetics was only observed at particular lipid concentrations (L:P ratios 20:1 and 10:1) and not at others (30, 40, 50 and 100:1 L:P ratio). Analysis of the complex kinetics revealed several intermediates. We assign these to distinct states of the peptide formed during helix insertion into the vesicle membrane that are intermediate to lytic pore formation.

On the origin of multiphasic kinetics in peptide binding to phospholipid vesicles

We critically examined a series of exact kinetic models for their ability to describe binding of a typical α-helical amphipathic peptide to lipid bilayers. Binding of the model peptide lysette-26 was measured through fluorescence resonance energy transfer from a Trp residue on the peptide to a fluorescently labeled acceptor lipid included in vesicles composed of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine. Experimental data was collected varying peptide and lipid concentrations over an order of magnitude. The kinetic models were fit to all the experimental data simultaneously. Of the four models examined, the simplest one that is sufficient to correctly describe the experimental data includes two coupled equilibria, one between peptide monomers in solution and bound to the lipid membrane, and a second one between lipid-bound peptides that oligomerize to form dimers. We found that individual kinetic binding curves are insufficient to distinguish among kinetic models of peptide binding to lipid bilayers but that a number of models can be excluded based on inspection of a simple set of experiments.

Is DNA a worm-like chain in Couette flow? In search of persistence length, a critical review

Persistence length is the foremost measure of DNA flexibility. Its origins lie in polymer theory which was adapted for DNA following the determination of BDNA structure in 1953. There is no single definition of persistence length used, and the links between published definitions are based on assumptions which may, or may not be, clearly stated. DNA flexibility is affected by local ionic strength, solvent environment, bound ligands and intrinsic sequence-dependent flexibility. This article is a review of persistence length providing a mathematical treatment of the relationships between four definitions of persistence length, including: correlation, Kuhn length, bending, and curvature. Persistence length has been measured using various microscopy, force extension and solution methods such as linear dichroism and transient electric birefringence. For each experimental method a model of DNA is required to interpret the data. The importance of understanding the underlying models, along with the assumptions required by each definition to determine a value of persistence length, is highlighted for linear dichroism data, where it transpires that no model is currently available for long DNA or medium to high shear rate experiments.