An oligomeric equilibrium intermediate as the precursory nucleus of globular and fibrillar supramacromolecular assemblies in a PDZ domain

A calorimetric and structural analysis of cooperativity in the thermal unfolding of the PDZ tandem of human Syntenin-1

Syntenin-1 is a multidomain protein containing a central tandem of two PDZ domains flanked by two unnamed domains. Previous structural and biophysical studies show that the two PDZ domains are functional both isolated and in tandem, occurring a gain in their respective binding affinities when joined through its natural short linker. To get insight into the molecular and energetic reasons of such a gain, here, the first thermodynamic characterization of the conformational equilibrium of Syntenin-1 is presented, with special focus on its PDZ domains. These studies include the thermal unfolding of the whole protein, the PDZ-tandem construct and the two isolated PDZ domains using circular dichroism, differential scanning fluorimetry and differential scanning calorimetry. The isolated PDZ domains show low stability (ΔG < 10 kJ·mol-1) and poor cooperativity compared to the PDZ-tandem, which shows higher stability (20-30 kJ·mol-1) and a fully cooperative behaviour, with energetics similar to that previously described for archetypical PDZ domains. The high-resolution structures suggest that this remarkable increase in cooperativity is associated to strong, water-mediated, interactions at the interface between the PDZ domains, associated to nine conserved hydration regions. The low Tm value (45 °C), the anomalously high unfolding enthalpy (>400 kJ·mol-1), and native heat capacity values (above 40 kJ·K-1·mol-1), indicate that these interfacial buried waters play a relevant role in Syntenin-1 folding energetics.

Reverse Engineering Analysis of the High-Temperature Reversible Oligomerization and Amyloidogenicity of PSD95-PDZ3

PSD95-PDZ3, the third PDZ domain of the post-synaptic density-95 protein (MW 11 kDa), undergoes a peculiar three-state thermal denaturation (N ↔ In ↔ D) and is amyloidogenic. PSD95-PDZ3 in the intermediate state (I) is reversibly oligomerized (RO: Reversible oligomerization). We previously reported a point mutation (F340A) that inhibits both ROs and amyloidogenesis and constructed the PDZ3-F340A variant. Here, we “reverse engineered” PDZ3-F340A for inducing high-temperature RO and amyloidogenesis. We produced three variants (R309L, E310L, and N326L), where we individually mutated hydrophilic residues exposed at the surface of the monomeric PDZ3-F340A but buried in the tetrameric crystal structure to a hydrophobic leucine. Differential scanning calorimetry indicated that two of the designed variants (PDZ3-F340A/R309L and E310L) denatured according to the two-state model. On the other hand, PDZ3-F340A/N326L denatured according to a three-state model and produced high-temperature ROs. The secondary structures of PDZ3-F340A/N326L and PDZ3-wt in the RO state were unfolded according to circular dichroism and differential scanning calorimetry. Furthermore, PDZ3-F340A/N326L was amyloidogenic as assessed by Thioflavin T fluorescence. Altogether, these results demonstrate that a single amino acid mutation can trigger the formation of high-temperature RO and concurrent amyloidogenesis.

Blocking PSD95-PDZ3's amyloidogenesis through point mutations that inhibit high-temperature reversible oligomerization (RO)

The third PDZ domain of postsynaptic density protein 95 (PSD95-PDZ3; 11 kDa, 103 residues) has a propensity to form amyloid fibrils at high temperatures. At neutral pH, wild type PDZ3 is natively folded, but it exhibits a peculiar three-state thermal unfolding with a reversible oligomerization (RO) equilibrium at high temperatures, which is uncharacteristic in the unfolding of small globular protein as PDZ3 is. Here, we examined RO's role in PDZ3's amyloidogenesis at high-temperature using two variants (F340A and L342A) that suppress the high-temperature RO and five single-alanine-mutated variants, where we mutated surface-exposed hydrophobic residues to alanine. Circular Dichroism (CD), Analytical Ultracentrifuge (AUC), and other spectroscopic measurements confirmed the retention of the native structure at ambient temperature. Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) was used to assess the presence or absence of the high-temperature RO, and the amyloidogenicity of the variants was measured by Thioflavin T (ThT) fluorescence and Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM). By comparing the fraction of RO and the ThT signal, we found that mutations that suppressed the high-temperature RO strongly inhibited amyloidogenesis. On the other hand, all variants forming RO also formed amyloids under the same conditions as the wild type PDZ3.

A Thermodynamic Analysis of the Binding Specificity between Four Human PDZ Domains and Eight Host, Viral and Designed Ligands

PDZ domains are binding modules mostly involved in cell signaling and cell–cell junctions. These domains are able to recognize a wide variety of natural targets and, among the PDZ partners, viruses have been discovered to interact with their host via a PDZ domain. With such an array of relevant and diverse interactions, PDZ binding specificity has been thoroughly studied and a traditional classification has grouped PDZ domains in three major specificity classes. In this work, we have selected four human PDZ domains covering the three canonical specificity-class binding mode and a set of their corresponding binders, including host/natural, viral and designed PDZ motifs. Through calorimetric techniques, we have covered the entire cross interactions between the selected PDZ domains and partners. The results indicate a rather basic specificity in each PDZ domain, with two of the domains that bind their cognate and some non-cognate ligands and the two other domains that basically bind their cognate partners. On the other hand, the host partners mostly bind their corresponding PDZ domain and, interestingly, the viral ligands are able to bind most of the studied PDZ domains, even those not previously described. Some viruses may have evolved to use of the ability of the PDZ fold to bind multiple targets, with resulting affinities for the virus–host interactions that are, in some cases, higher than for host–host interactions.

Sensing the allosteric force

Allosteric regulation is an innate control in most metabolic and signalling cascades that enables living organisms to adapt to the changing environment by tuning the affinity and regulating the activity of target proteins. For a microscopic understanding of this process, a protein system has been designed in such a way that allosteric communication between the binding and allosteric site can be observed in both directions. To that end, an azobenzene-derived photoswitch has been linked to the α3-helix of the PDZ3 domain, arguably the smallest allosteric protein with a clearly identifiable binding and allosteric site. Photo-induced trans-to-cis isomerisation of the photoswitch increases the binding affinity of a small peptide ligand to the protein up to 120-fold, depending on temperature. At the same time, ligand binding speeds up the thermal cis-to-trans back-isomerisation rate of the photoswitch. Based on the energetics of the four states of the system (cis vs trans and ligand-bound vs free), the concept of an allosteric force is introduced, which can be used to drive chemical reactions.

Thermodynamic Analysis of Point Mutations Inhibiting High-Temperature Reversible Oligomerization of PDZ3

Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) indicated that PDZ3 undergoes a peculiar thermal denaturation, exhibiting two endothermic peaks because of the formation of reversible oligomers at high temperature (N↔I₆↔D). This contrasts sharply with the standard two-state denaturation model observed for small, globular proteins. We performed an alanine scanning analysis by individually mutating three hydrophobic residues at the crystallographic oligomeric interface (Phe340, Leu342, and Ile389) and one away from the interface (Leu349, as a control). DSC analysis indicated that PDZ3-F340A and PDZ3-L342A exhibited a single endothermic peak. Furthermore, PDZ3-L342A underwent a perfect two-state denaturation, as evidenced by the single endothermic peak and confirmed by detailed DSC analysis, including global fitting of data measured at different protein concentrations. Reversible oligomerization (RO) at high temperatures by small globular proteins is a rare event. Furthermore, our present study showing that a point mutation, L342A, designed based on the crystal structure inhibited RO is surprising because RO occurs at a high-temperature. Future studies will determine how and why mutations designed using crystal structures determined at ambient temperatures influence the formation of RO at high temperatures, and whether high-temperature ROs are related to the propensity of proteins to aggregate or precipitate at lower temperatures, which would provide a novel and unique way of controlling protein solubility and aggregation.

The Conformational Plasticity Vista of PDZ Domains

The PDZ domain (PSD95-Discs large-ZO1) is a widespread modular domain present in the living organisms. A prevalent function in the PDZ family is to serve as scaffolding and adaptor proteins connecting multiple partners in signaling pathways. An explanation of the flexible functionality in this domain family, based just on a static perspective of the structure-activity relationship, might fall short. More dynamic and conformational aspects in the protein fold can be the reasons for such functionality. Folding studies indeed showed an ample and malleable folding landscape for PDZ domains where multiple intermediate states were experimentally detected. Allosteric phenomena that resemble energetic coupling between residues have also been found in PDZ domains. Additionally, several PDZ domains are modulated by post-translational modifications, which introduce conformational switches that affect binding. Altogether, the ability to connect diverse partners might arise from the intrinsic plasticity of the PDZ fold.

Conformational changes in the third PDZ domain of the neuronal postsynaptic density protein 95

PDZ domains are protein–protein recognition modules that interact with other proteins through short sequences at the carboxyl terminus. These domains are structurally characterized by a conserved fold composed of six β-strands and two α-helices. The third PDZ domain of the neuronal postsynaptic density protein 95 has an additional α-helix (α3), the role of which is not well known. In previous structures, a succinimide was identified in the β2–β3 loop instead of Asp332. The presence of this modified residue results in conformational changes in α3. In this work, crystallographic structures of the following have been solved: a truncated form of the third PDZ domain of the neuronal postsynaptic density protein 95 from which α3 has been removed, D332P and D332G variants of the protein, and a new crystal form of this domain showing the binding of Asp332 to the carboxylate-binding site of a symmetry-related molecule. Crystals of the wild type and variants were obtained in different space groups, which reflects the conformational plasticity of the domain. Indeed, the overall analysis of these structures suggests that the conformation of the β2–β3 loop is correlated with the fold acquired by α3. The alternate conformation of the β2–β3 loop affects the electrostatics of the carboxylate-binding site and might modulate the binding of different PDZ-binding motifs.

Denaturants Alter the Flux through Multiple Pathways in the Folding of PDZ Domain

Although we understand many aspects of how small proteins (number of residues less than about hundred) fold, it is a major challenge to quantitatively describe how large proteins self-assemble. To partially overcome this challenge, we performed simulations using the self-organized polymer model with side chains (SOP-SC) in guanidinium chloride (GdmCl), using the molecular transfer model (MTM), to describe the folding of the 110-residue PDZ3 domain. The simulations reproduce the folding thermodynamics accurately including the melting temperature (T_m), the stability of the folded state with respect to the unfolded state. We show that the calculated dependence of ln k_obs (k_obs is the relaxation rate) has the characteristic chevron shape. The slopes of the chevron plots are in good agreement with experiments. We show that PDZ3 folds by four major pathways populating two metastable intermediates, in accord with the kinetic partitioning mechanism. The structure of one of the intermediates, populated after polypeptide chain collapse, is structurally similar to an equilibrium intermediate. Surprisingly, the connectivities between the intermediates and hence, the fluxes through the pathways depend on the concentration of GdmCl. The results are used to predict possible outcomes for unfolding of PDZ domain subject to mechanical forces. Our study demonstrates that, irrespective of the size or topology, simulations based on MTM and SOP-SC offer a theoretical framework for describing the folding of proteins, mimicking precisely the conditions used in experiments.

Common features in the unfolding and misfolding of PDZ domains and beyond: the modulatory effect of domain swapping and extra-elements

PDZ domains are protein-protein interaction modules sharing the same structural arrangement. To discern whether they display common features in their unfolding/misfolding behaviour we have analyzed in this work the unfolding thermodynamics, together with the misfolding kinetics, of the PDZ fold using three archetypical examples: the second and third PDZ domains of the PSD95 protein and the Erbin PDZ domain. Results showed that all domains passed through a common intermediate, which populated upon unfolding, and that this in turn drove the misfolding towards worm-like fibrillar structures. Thus, the unfolding/misfolding behaviour appears to be shared within these domains. We have also analyzed how this landscape can be modified upon the inclusion of extra-elements, as it is in the nNOS PDZ domain, or the organization of swapped species, as happens in the second PDZ domain of the ZO2 protein. Although the intermediates still formed upon thermal unfolding, the misfolding was prevented to varying degrees.

The impact of extra-domain structures and post-translational modifications in the folding/misfolding behaviour of the third PDZ domain of MAGUK neuronal protein PSD-95

The modulation of binding affinities and specificities by post-translational modifications located out from the binding pocket of the third PDZ domain of PSD-95 (PDZ3) has been reported recently. It is achieved through an intra-domain electrostatic network involving some charged residues in the β2–β3 loop (were a succinimide modification occurs), the α3 helix (an extra-structural element that links the PDZ3 domain with the following SH3 domain in PSD-95, and contains the phosphorylation target Tyr397), and the ligand peptide. Here, we have investigated the main structural and thermodynamic aspects that these structural elements and their related post-translational modifications display in the folding/misfolding pathway of PDZ3 by means of site-directed mutagenesis combined with calorimetry and spectroscopy. We have found that, although all the assayed mutations generate proteins more prone to aggregation than the wild-type PDZ3, those directly affecting the α3 helix, like the E401R substitution or the truncation of the whole α3 helix, increase the population of the DSC-detected intermediate state and the misfolding kinetics, by organizing the supramacromolecular structures at the expense of the two β-sheets present in the PDZ3 fold. However, those mutations affecting the β2–β3 loop, included into the prone-to-aggregation region composed by a single β-sheet comprising β2 to β4 chains, stabilize the trimeric intermediate previously shown in the wild-type PDZ3 and slow-down aggregation, also making it partly reversible. These results strongly suggest that the α3 helix protects to some extent the PDZ3 domain core from misfolding. This might well constitute the first example where an extra-element, intended to link the PDZ3 domain to the following SH3 in PSD-95 and in other members of the MAGUK family, not only regulates the binding abilities of this domain but it also protects PDZ3 from misfolding and aggregation. The influence of the post-translational modifications in this regulatory mechanism is also discussed.

Post-translational modifications modulate ligand recognition by the third PDZ domain of the MAGUK protein PSD-95

The relative promiscuity of hub proteins such as postsynaptic density protein-95 (PSD-95) can be achieved by alternative splicing, allosteric regulation, and post-translational modifications, the latter of which is the most efficient method of accelerating cellular responses to environmental changes in vivo. Here, a mutational approach was used to determine the impact of phosphorylation and succinimidation post-translational modifications on the binding affinity of the postsynaptic density protein-95/discs large/zonula occludens-1 (PDZ3) domain of PSD-95. Molecular dynamics simulations revealed that the binding affinity of this domain is influenced by an interplay between salt-bridges linking the α3 helix, the β2–β3 loop and the positively charged Lys residues in its high-affinity hexapeptide ligand KKETAV. The α3 helix is an extra structural element that is not present in other PDZ domains, which links PDZ3 with the following SH3 domain in the PSD-95 protein. This regulatory mechanism was confirmed experimentally via thermodynamic and NMR chemical shift perturbation analyses, discarding intra-domain long-range effects. Taken together, the results presented here reveal the molecular basis of the regulatory role of the α3 extra-element and the effects of post-translational modifications of PDZ3 on its binding affinity, both energetically and dynamically.

A thermodynamic study of the third PDZ domain of MAGUK neuronal protein PSD-95 reveals a complex three-state folding behavior

The relevance of the C-terminal α helix of the PDZ3 domain of PSD95 in its unfolding process has been explored by achieving the thermodynamic characterization of a construct where the sequence of the nine residues corresponding to such motif has been deleted. Calorimetric traces at neutral pH require the application of a three-state model displaying three different equilibrium processes in which the intermediate state self-associates upon heating, being stable and populated in a wide temperature range. Temperature scans followed by circular dichroism, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and dynamic light scattering support the presence of such oligomeric-partially folded species. This study reveals that the deletion of the α3-helix sequence results in a more complex description of the domain unfolding.

The interconversion between a flexible β-sheet and a fibril β-arrangement constitutes the main conformational event during misfolding of PSD95-PDZ3 domain

The temperature-induced misfolding pathway of PDZ3, the third PDZ domain of the PSD95 neuronal protein, is populated by a trimeric β-sheet-rich intermediate state that leads to a stepwise and reversible formation of supramacromolecular structures. Using FTIR, we have found that misfolding of this pathway is not due to different ensembles of a variety of precursors, but comes mainly from the interconversion of a flexible β-sheet of the domain to wormlike fibrils. The appearance of the wormlike fibril FTIR component is also accompanied by a slight decrease of the band that corresponds to loops in the native state, whereas the rest of the regular elements of secondary structure are fairly well maintained upon misfolding. Transmission electron microscope micrographs have confirmed the presence of wormlike fibrils upon heating at 60°C, where the trimeric intermediate is maximally populated. Toxicity assays in the human neuroblastoma cell line SH-SY5Y show that cytotoxicity increases as the aggregation pathway proceeds. NMR analysis of chemical shifts as a function of temperature has revealed, as one of the main conformational aspects of such an interconversion at the residue level, that the β-sheet arrangement around strand β3 promotes the change that drives misfolding of the PDZ3 domain.

Application and use of differential scanning calorimetry in studies of thermal fluctuation associated with amyloid fibril formation

The aggregation of proteins into amyloid fibrils is a topic that has attracted great interest because the process is associated with the pathology of numerous human diseases. Despite considerable progress in the elucidation of the structure of amyloid fibrils and the kinetic mechanism of their formation, knowledge on the thermodynamic aspects underlying the formation and stability of amyloid fibrils is limited. In this review, we summarize recent calorimetric studies of amyloid fibril formation, with the goal of obtaining a better understanding of the causal factors that thermally induce proteins to aggregate into amyloid fibrils. Calorimetric data show that differential scanning calorimetry is a useful technique to study the causative factors that thermally trigger the conversion to the amyloid structure and highlight the physics related to the thermal fluctuation of proteins during this conversion.

Equilibrium unfolding of the PDZ domain of β2-syntrophin

β2-syntrophin, a dystrophin-associated protein, plays a pivotal role in insulin secretion by pancreatic β-cells. It contains a PDZ domain (β2S-PDZ) that, in complex with protein-tyrosine phosphatase ICA512, anchors the dense insulin granules to actin filaments. The phosphorylation state of β2-syntrophin allosterically regulates the affinity of β2S-PDZ for ICA512, and the disruption of the complex triggers the mobilization of the insulin granule stores. Here, we investigate the thermal unfolding of β2S-PDZ at different pH and urea concentrations. Our results indicate that, unlike other PDZ domains, β2S-PDZ is marginally stable. Thermal denaturation experiments show broad transitions and cold denaturation, and a two-state model fit reveals a significant unfolded fraction under physiological conditions. Furthermore, T(m) and T(max) denaturant-dependent shifts and noncoincidence of melting curves monitored at different wavelengths suggest that two-state and three-state models fail to explain the equilibrium data properly and are in better agreement with a downhill scenario. Its higher stability at pH >9 and the results of molecular dynamics simulations indicate that this behavior of β2S-PDZ might be related to its charge distribution. All together, our results suggest a link between the conformational plasticity of the native ensemble of this PDZ domain and the regulation of insulin secretion.

Thermodynamic impact of embedded water molecules in the unfolding of human CD2BP2-GYF domain

GYF domains are small polyproline-recognition modules adopting a structural arrangement consisting of a single α-helix packed against a small β-sheet. Although most families of proline-rich recognition modules have been extensively characterized in terms of function, structure, or conformational flexibility, little is known about GYF domain functionality and folding. We have undertaken the thermodynamic characterization of the unfolding of CD2BP2-GYF domain by combining differential scanning calorimetry and circular dichroism under different pH conditions. The experimental data can be well-described in terms of a two-state equilibrium, although an unusually high heat capacity of the native state reflects a considerable conformational flexibility and dynamics of CD2BP2-GYF domain. In addition, the normalized thermodynamic parameters of unfolding (enthalpy, entropy and heat capacity) are roughly a factor of two greater than expected. In contrast, stability curves reveal an ordinary unfolding behavior of CD2BP2-GYF domain in terms of Gibbs energies, incurring thus unusually strong enthalpy-entropy compensation. This phenomenon, previously described as "thermodynamic homeostasis", has been associated in different examples to the contribution of occluded water (solvent) molecules into the protein structure. By means of CASTp server, we have found seven cavities/pockets scattered throughout of the CD2BP2-GYF structure, each able to harbor at least one water molecule. This structural feature provides rationalization for the atypical enthalpy values observed for CD2BP2-GYF because each water molecule is able to organize an extra amount of hydrogen bonds in the native state. In addition, these bound waters increase the vibrational entropy of the protein, which could also be responsible for an increase in protein flexibility and may thus fully explain the homeostatic behavior experimentally observed.

A comparative analysis of the folding and misfolding pathways of the third PDZ domain of PSD95 investigated under different pH conditions

Equilibrium unfolding at neutral pH of the third PDZ domain of PSD95 is well described by the presence of a partly unfolded intermediate that presents association phenomena. After some days' incubation annular and fibrillar structures form from the oligomers. At pH values below 3, however, differential scanning calorimetry shows that PDZ3 seems to unfold under a two-state scheme. Kinetic measurements followed by dynamic light scattering, ThT and ANS fluorescence reveal that the misfolding pathway still exists despite the absence of any populated intermediates and shows an irreversible assembling of the supramacromolecular structures as well as an appreciable lag-phase, contrary to what is found in similar experiments at neutral pH. Moreover, as shown by transmission-electron-microscopy images, the annular structures seen at neutral pH completely disappear from incubated solutions. According to the structural information, this titration behavior appears to be the consequence of a conformational equilibrium that depends on the protonation of some Glu residues located at the C-terminal α3 helix and at the hairpin formed by strands β2 and β3. Our calculations suggest that the enthalpic contribution of these interactions may well be as much as 40kJ·mol(-1). The possible regulatory role of this equilibrium upon PDZ3 functionality and amyloid formation is briefly discussed.