Intensity correlation-based calibration of FRET

Improved estimation of the ratio of detection efficiencies of excited acceptors and donors for FRET measurements

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is a radiationless interaction between a donor and an acceptor whose distance dependence makes it a sensitive tool for studying the oligomerization and the structure of proteins. When FRET is determined by measuring the sensitized emission of the acceptor, a parameter characterizing the ratio of detection efficiencies of an excited acceptor versus an excited donor is invariably involved in the formalism. For FRET measurements involving fluorescent antibodies or other external labels, this parameter, designated by α, is usually determined by comparing the intensity of a known number of donors and acceptors in two independent samples leading to a large statistical variability if the sample size is small. Here, we present a method that improves precision by applying microbeads with a calibrated number of antibody binding sites and a donor-acceptor mixture in which donors and acceptors are present in a certain, experimentally determined ratio. A formalism is developed for determining α and the superior reproducibility of the proposed method compared to the conventional approach is demonstrated. Since the novel methodology does not require sophisticated calibration samples or special instrumentation, it can be widely applied for the quantification of FRET experiments in biological research.

Advanced FRET normalization allows quantitative analysis of protein interactions including stoichiometries and relative affinities in living cells

FRET (Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer) measurements are commonly applied to proof protein-protein interactions. However, standard methods of live cell FRET microscopy and signal normalization only allow a principle assessment of mutual binding and are unable to deduce quantitative information of the interaction. We present an evaluation and normalization procedure for 3-filter FRET measurements, which reflects the process of complex formation by plotting FRET-saturation curves. The advantage of this approach relative to traditional signal normalizations is demonstrated by mathematical simulations. Thereby, we also identify the contribution of critical parameters such as the total amount of donor and acceptor molecules and their molar ratio. When combined with a fitting procedure, this normalization facilitates the extraction of key properties of protein complexes such as the interaction stoichiometry or the apparent affinity of the binding partners. Finally, the feasibility of our method is verified by investigating three exemplary protein complexes. Altogether, our approach offers a novel method for a quantitative analysis of protein interactions by 3-filter FRET microscopy, as well as flow cytometry. To facilitate the application of this method, we created macros and routines for the programs ImageJ, R and MS-Excel, which we make publicly available.

Understanding FRET as a research tool for cellular studies

Communication of molecular species through dynamic association and/or dissociation at various cellular sites governs biological functions. Understanding these physiological processes require delineation of molecular events occurring at the level of individual complexes in a living cell. Among the few non-invasive approaches with nanometer resolution are methods based on Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET). FRET is effective at a distance of 1-10 nm which is equivalent to the size of macromolecules, thus providing an unprecedented level of detail on molecular interactions. The emergence of fluorescent proteins and SNAP- and CLIP- tag proteins provided FRET with the capability to monitor changes in a molecular complex in real-time making it possible to establish the functional significance of the studied molecules in a native environment. Now, FRET is widely used in biological sciences, including the field of proteomics, signal transduction, diagnostics and drug development to address questions almost unimaginable with biochemical methods and conventional microscopies. However, the underlying physics of FRET often scares biologists. Therefore, in this review, our goal is to introduce FRET to non-physicists in a lucid manner. We will also discuss our contributions to various FRET methodologies based on microscopy and flow cytometry, while describing its application for determining the molecular heterogeneity of the plasma membrane in various cell types.

Single-laser polarization FRET (polFRET) on the cell surface

A new method for the simultaneous detection of rotational mobility and proximity of cell surface receptors is presented based on cell-by-cell basis measurement of polarized fluorescence intensity components of the donor and acceptor of a FRET system. In addition to the FRET efficiency and the donor and acceptor concentrations, the method makes also possible the determination of the rotational characteristics and the associated fraction of the donors (FRET-fraction). The method is illustrated with flow cytometric and rFLIM measurements on donor-acceptor systems comprising fluorescently labeled whole antibodies and their Fab fragments against epitopes of the MHCI and MHCII cell surface receptors on human lymphoblast cells. Fluorescence anisotropy of donor and acceptor and FRET efficiency were measured for samples of different acceptor-to-donor concentration ratios. Acceptor anisotropy proved to be more sensitive than the donor anisotropy for sensing FRET. After determining the rotational constants of the donor-conjugated antibodies by measurements of FRET in the steady state, and by rFLIM as a reference, the associated fractions of the MHCI and MHCII molecules in their clusters were determined. Besides the flow cytometer and the wide-field rFLIM used in this study, the method can be applied also in other devices capable of dual-anisotropy detection.

Maximum likelihood estimation of FRET efficiency and its implications for distortions in pixelwise calculation of FRET in microscopy

Ratiometric determination of the efficiency of fluorescence or Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is one of the most widespread methods for the characterization of protein clustering and conformation. Low photon numbers, often present in pixel-by-pixel determination of FRET efficiency in digital microscopy, result in large uncertainties in the derived FRET parameter. Here, we propose a method based on maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) of FRET efficiency using photon counting detectors to overcome this limitation. Intensities measured in the donor, FRET, and acceptor channels were all assumed to follow Poisson statistics as a result of detector shot noise. The joint probability of photon numbers detected in the donor, FRET, and acceptor channels was derived using an equation describing the relationship between the three measured intensities. The FRET efficiency generating the measured photon numbers with the largest likelihood was determined iteratively providing a single FRET value for all pixels in the calculation. Since as few as 100 pixels are sufficient to provide a maximum likelihood estimate for FRET, biological variability in FRET values can be revealed by performing the analysis for regions of interests in an image. Since the algorithm provides the probability of a combination of donor, FRET, and acceptor intensities observed in each individual pixel given a certain FRET efficiency, outlier pixels with low probabilities could be excluded from the analysis. Simulations carried out with low photon numbers in the presence and absence of outlier pixels revealed that the proposed approach can reliably and reproducibly estimate FRET efficiency. In addition, systematic evaluation of the simulation results showed that the distribution of pixel-by-pixel FRET efficiencies is skewed, and the mean of these FRET values is a biased and unreliable estimate of the FRET efficiency. In the absence of outlier pixels, FRET calculated from summed donor, FRET, and acceptor intensities proved to be as reliable as MLE. We conclude that MLE of FRET outperforms calculations using summed and pixel-by-pixel intensities in biologically relevant situations involving low photon numbers and outlier pixels. © 2014 International Society for Advancement of Cytometry.