Synergistic SHAPE/Single-Molecule Deconvolution of RNA Conformation under Physiological Conditions

On the Problem of Reconstructing a Mixture of RNA Structures

A growing number of RNA sequences are now known to exist in some distribution with two or more different stable structures. Recent algorithms attempt to reconstruct such mixtures using the list of nucleotides in a sequence in conjunction with auxiliary experimental footprinting data. In this paper, we demonstrate some challenges which remain in addressing this problem; in particular we consider the difficulty of reconstructing a mixture of two RNA structures across a spectrum of different relative abundances. Although progress has been made in identifying the stable structures present, it remains nontrivial to predict the relative abundance of each within the experimentally sampled mixture. Because the ratio of structures present can change depending on experimental conditions, it is the footprinting data-and not the sequence-which must encode information on changes in the relative abundance. Here, we use simulated experimental data to demonstrate that there exist RNA sequences and relative abundance combinations which cannot be recovered by current methods. We then prove that this is not a single exception, but rather part of the rule. In particular, we show, using a Nussinov-Jacobson model, that recovering the relative abundances is difficult for a large proportion of RNA structure pairs. Lastly, we use information theory to establish a framework for quantifying how useful auxiliary data is in predicting the relative abundance of a structure. Together, these results demonstrate that aspects of the problem of reconstructing a mixture of RNA structures from experimental data remain open.

Challenges and approaches to predicting RNA with multiple functional structures

The revolution in sequencing technology demands new tools to interpret the genetic code. As in vivo transcriptome-wide chemical probing techniques advance, new challenges emerge in the RNA folding problem. The emphasis on one sequence folding into a single minimum free energy structure is fading as a new focus develops on generating RNA structural ensembles and identifying functional structural features in ensembles. This review describes an efficient combinatorially complete method and three free energy minimization approaches to predicting RNA structures with more than one functional fold, as well as two methods for analysis of a thermodynamics-based Boltzmann ensemble of structures. The review then highlights two examples of viral RNA 3'-UTR regions that fold into more than one conformation and have been characterized by single molecule fluorescence energy resonance transfer or NMR spectroscopy. These examples highlight the different approaches and challenges in predicting structure and function from sequence for RNA with multiple biological roles and folds. More well-defined examples and new metrics for measuring differences in RNA structures will guide future improvements in prediction of RNA structure and function from sequence.