Speckle filtering of ultrasonic images using a modified non local-based algorithm

An application of deep dual convolutional neural network for enhanced medical image denoising

This work investigates the medical image denoising (MID) application of the dual denoising network (DudeNet) model for chest X-ray (CXR). The DudeNet model comprises four components: a feature extraction block with a sparse mechanism, an enhancement block, a compression block, and a reconstruction block. The developed model uses residual learning to boost denoising performance and batch normalization to accelerate the training process. The name proposed for this model is dual convolutional medical image-enhanced denoising network (DCMIEDNet). The peak signal-to-noise ratio (PSNR) and structure similarity index measurement (SSIM) are used to assess the MID performance for five different additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN) levels of σ = 15, 25, 40, 50, and 60 in CXR images. Presented investigations revealed that the PSNR and SSIM offered by DCMIEDNet are better than several popular state-of-the-art models such as block matching and 3D filtering, denoising convolutional neural network, and feature-guided denoising convolutional neural network. In addition, it is also superior to the recently reported MID models like deep convolutional neural network with residual learning, real-valued medical image denoising network, and complex-valued medical image denoising network. Therefore, based on the presented experiments, it is concluded that applying the DudeNet methodology for DCMIEDNet promises to be quite helpful for physicians.

Bayesian Framework-Based Adaptive Hybrid Filtering for Speckle Noise Reduction in Ultrasound Images Via Lion Plus FireFly Algorithm

The existence of speckle noise in ultrasound (US) image processing distorts the image quality and also hinders the development of systematic approaches for US images. Numerous de-speckling schemes were established to date that concern speckle reduction; however, the models suffer from demerits like computational time, computational complexity, etc., that are to be rectified as soon as possible. This compulsion takes to the introduction of a new de-speckling model via an adaptive hybrid filter model that includes four filters like guided filter (GF), speckle-reducing bilateral filter (SRBF), rotation invariant bilateral nonlocal means filter (RIBNLM), and median filter (MF) respectively. Moreover, the novelty goes under the selection of optimal filter coefficients that make the process effective. Bayesian-based neural network is used to predict the appropriate filter coefficients, where the training library is constructed with the optimal coefficients. Along with this, the selection of optimal filter coefficients is done under the defined objective function using a new hybrid algorithm termed as Randomized FireFly (FF) update in Lion Algorithm (RFU-LA) that hybrids the concept of both LA and FF, respectively. Finally, the performance of the proposed de-speckling model is compared over that of other conventional models with respect to different performance measures. Accordingly, from the analysis, the mean MAPE of the proposed method are 39.13% and 49.28% higher than those of the wavelet filtering and hybrid filtering schemes for a noise variance of 0.1.

Restoration and enhancement of breast ultrasound images using extended complex diffusion based unsharp masking

Ultrasound is a well-known imaging modality for the interpretation of breast cancer. It is playing very important role for breast cancer detection that are missed by mammograms. The image acquisition is usually affected by the presence of noise, artifacts, and distortion. To overcome such type of issues, there is a need of image restoration and enhancement to improve the quality of image. This paper proposes a single framework for denoising and enhancement of ultrasound images, where a smoothing filter is replaced with an extended complex diffusion-based filter in an unsharp masking technique. The performance evaluation of the proposed method is tested on real ultrasound breast cancer images database and synthetic ultrasound image. The performance evaluation comprises qualitative and quantitative evaluation along with comparative analysis of pre-existing and proposed method. The quantitative evaluation metrics are mean squared error, peak-signal-to-noise ratio, correlation parameter, normalized absolute error, universal quality index, similarity structure index, edge preservation index, a measure of enhancement, a measure of enhancement by entropy, and second derivative like measurement. The result specifies that the proposed method is better suited approach for the removal of speckle noise which follows Rayleigh distribution, restoration of information, enhancement of abnormalities, and proper edge preservation.

Learning Medical Image Denoising with Deep Dynamic Residual Attention Network

Image denoising performs a prominent role in medical image analysis. In many cases, it can drastically accelerate the diagnostic process by enhancing the perceptual quality of noisy image samples. However, despite the extensive practicability of medical image denoising, the existing denoising methods illustrate deficiencies in addressing the diverse range of noise appears in the multidisciplinary medical images. This study alleviates such challenging denoising task by learning residual noise from a substantial extent of data samples. Additionally, the proposed method accelerates the learning process by introducing a novel deep network, where the network architecture exploits the feature correlation known as the attention mechanism and combines it with spatially refine residual features. The experimental results illustrate that the proposed method can outperform the existing works by a substantial margin in both quantitative and qualitative comparisons. Also, the proposed method can handle real-world image noise and can improve the performance of different medical image analysis tasks without producing any visually disturbing artefacts.

An Ultrasound Image Enhancement Method Using Neutrosophic Similarity Score

Ultrasound images, having low contrast and noise, adversely impact in the detection of abnormalities. In view of this, an enhancement method is proposed in this work to reduce noise and improve contrast of ultrasound images. The proposed method is based on scaling with neutrosophic similarity score (NSS), where an image is represented in the neutrosophic domain through three membership subsets T, I, and F denoting the degree of truth, indeterminacy, and falseness, respectively. The NSS measures the belonging degree of pixel to the texture using multi-criteria that is based on intensity, local mean intensity and edge detection. Then, NSS is utilized to extract the enhanced coefficient and this enhanced coefficient is applied to scale the input image. This scaling reflects contrast improvement and denoising effect on ultrasound images. The performance of proposed enhancement method is evaluated on clinical ultrasound images, using both subjective and objective image quality measures. In subjective evaluation, with proposed method, overall best score of 4.3 was obtained and that was 44% higher than the score of original images. These results were also supported by objective measures. The results demonstrated that the proposed method outperformed the other methods in terms of mean brightness preservation, edge preservation, structural similarity, and human perception-based image quality assessment. Thus, the proposed method can be used in computer-aided diagnosis systems and to visually assist radiologists in their interactive-decision-making task.

Improved non-local self-similarity measures for effective speckle noise reduction in ultrasound images

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

In the observed medical ultrasound image, there is always some speckle noise which suppress the details of images and impairs the value of ultrasonography in diagnosis. This work present a novel despeckling method which effectively exploit non-local self-similarity for restoration of corrupted ultrasound images. The proposed approach consist of three stages. First, an improved optimized Bayesian non-local means (OBNLM) filter in which pixel patch is represented by a new vector form is used to get an preliminary estimation of noise-free image. Then, a new index called redundancy index of each pixel patch is calculated for determining which areas in image have low redundancy. Finally, another new vector form is used to represent pixel patch in areas with low redundancy obtained in second stage to recalculate filtered output, and the recalculated output is superimposed on preliminary estimation to generate final result of proposed method.

METHODS

The performance of proposed approach is evaluated on simulated and real ultrasound images. The experiments conducted on various test image illustrate that our proposed algorithm outperforms the various classic denoising algorithms included block matching 3-D (BM3D) and optimized Bayesian non-local means filter.

RESULTS

The objective evaluations and subjective visual inspection of denoised simulated and real ultrasound images demonstrate that the proposed algorithm can achieve superior performance than previously developed methods for speckle noise suppression.

CONCLUSIONS

The combined use of two new representations improve denoising and edge preserving capability of proposed filter apparently. The success of proposed algorithm would help in building the lay foundation for inventing the despeckling algorithms that can make fuller use of information in images.

Speckle Suppression of Ultrasonography Using Maximum Likelihood Estimation and Weighted Nuclear Norm Minimization

Speckle noise corrupts medical ultrasound images and suppression of speckle noise is valuable for image interpretation. This paper presents a new method for speckle suppression named the maximum likelihood based weighted nuclear norm minimization (MLWNNM) filtering by integrating the maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) with the weighted nuclear norm minimization (WNNM). The MLE is first used to get an initially filtered image with reduced Rayleigh distributed noise, and then the WNNM is applied to further improve the denoising effect by preserving and enhancing tissue details. Simulation work shows that when the noise variance is as high as 0.14, the MLWNNM improves the Pratt's figure of merit, peak signal to noise ratio, and mean structural similarity by 123.51%, 0.84%, and 6.13%, respectively, in contrast to the best values of other six methods. Experimental results on clinical ultrasound images suggest that the MLWNNM outperforms other six methods in noise reduction and detail preservation.

Nonlocal total variation based on symmetric Kullback-Leibler divergence for the ultrasound image despeckling

Background

Ultrasound imaging is safer than other imaging modalities, because it is noninvasive and nonradiative. Speckle noise degrades the quality of ultrasound images and has negative effects on visual perception and diagnostic operations.

Methods

In this paper, a nonlocal total variation (NLTV) method for ultrasonic speckle reduction is proposed. A spatiogram similarity measurement is introduced for the similarity calculation between image patches. It is based on symmetric Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence and signal-dependent speckle model for log-compressed ultrasound images. Each patch is regarded as a spatiogram, and the spatial distribution of each bin of the spatiogram is regarded as a weighted Gamma distribution. The similarity between the corresponding bins of the two spatiograms is computed by the symmetric KL divergence. The Split-Bregman fast algorithm is then used to solve the adapted NLTV object function. Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) test is performed on synthetic noisy images and real ultrasound images.

Results

We validate our method on synthetic noisy images and clinical ultrasound images. Three measures are adopted for the quantitative evaluation of the despeckling performance: the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), structural similarity index (SSIM), and natural image quality evaluator (NIQE). For synthetic noisy images, when the noise level increases, the proposed algorithm achieves slightly higher SNRS than that of the other two algorithms, and the SSIMS yielded by the proposed algorithm is obviously higher than that of the other two algorithms. For liver, IVUS and 3DUS images, the NIQE values are 8.25, 6.42 and 9.01, all of which are higher than that of the other two algorithms.

Conclusions

The results of the experiments over synthetic and real ultrasound images demonstrate that the proposed method outperforms current state-of-the-art despeckling methods with respect to speckle reduction and tissue texture preservation.

A hybrid algorithm for speckle noise reduction of ultrasound images

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Medical images are contaminated by multiplicative speckle noise which significantly reduce the contrast of ultrasound images and creates a negative effect on various image interpretation tasks. In this paper, we proposed a hybrid denoising approach which collaborate the both local and nonlocal information in an efficient manner. The proposed hybrid algorithm consist of three stages in which at first stage the use of local statistics in the form of guided filter is used to reduce the effect of speckle noise initially. Then, an improved speckle reducing bilateral filter (SRBF) is developed to further reduce the speckle noise from the medical images. Finally, to reconstruct the diffused edges we have used the efficient post-processing technique which jointly considered the advantages of both bilateral and nonlocal mean (NLM) filter for the attenuation of speckle noise efficiently.

METHODS

The performance of proposed hybrid algorithm is evaluated on synthetic, simulated and real ultrasound images. The experiments conducted on various test images demonstrate that our proposed hybrid approach outperforms the various traditional speckle reduction approaches included recently proposed NLM and optimized Bayesian-based NLM.

RESULTS

The results of various quantitative, qualitative measures and by visual inspection of denoise synthetic and real ultrasound images demonstrate that the proposed hybrid algorithm have strong denoising capability and able to preserve the fine image details such as edge of a lesion better than previously developed methods for speckle noise reduction.

CONCLUSIONS

The denoising and edge preserving capability of hybrid algorithm is far better than existing traditional and recently proposed speckle reduction (SR) filters. The success of proposed algorithm would help in building the lay foundation for inventing the hybrid algorithms for denoising of ultrasound images.

Rayleigh-maximum-likelihood bilateral filter for ultrasound image enhancement

Background

Ultrasound imaging plays an important role in computer diagnosis since it is non-invasive and cost-effective. However, ultrasound images are inevitably contaminated by noise and speckle during acquisition. Noise and speckle directly impact the physician to interpret the images and decrease the accuracy in clinical diagnosis. Denoising method is an important component to enhance the quality of ultrasound images; however, several limitations discourage the results because current denoising methods can remove noise while ignoring the statistical characteristics of speckle and thus undermining the effectiveness of despeckling, or vice versa. In addition, most existing algorithms do not identify noise, speckle or edge before removing noise or speckle, and thus they reduce noise and speckle while blurring edge details. Therefore, it is a challenging issue for the traditional methods to effectively remove noise and speckle in ultrasound images while preserving edge details.

Methods

To overcome the above-mentioned limitations, a novel method, called Rayleigh-maximum-likelihood switching bilateral filter (RSBF) is proposed to enhance ultrasound images by two steps: noise, speckle and edge detection followed by filtering. Firstly, a sorted quadrant median vector scheme is utilized to calculate the reference median in a filtering window in comparison with the central pixel to classify the target pixel as noise, speckle or noise-free. Subsequently, the noise is removed by a bilateral filter and the speckle is suppressed by a Rayleigh-maximum-likelihood filter while the noise-free pixels are kept unchanged. To quantitatively evaluate the performance of the proposed method, synthetic ultrasound images contaminated by speckle are simulated by using the speckle model that is subjected to Rayleigh distribution. Thereafter, the corrupted synthetic images are generated by the original image multiplied with the Rayleigh distributed speckle of various signal to noise ratio (SNR) levels and added with Gaussian distributed noise. Meanwhile clinical breast ultrasound images are used to visually evaluate the effectiveness of the method. To examine the performance, comparison tests between the proposed RSBF and six state-of-the-art methods for ultrasound speckle removal are performed on simulated ultrasound images with various noise and speckle levels.

Results

The results of the proposed RSBF are satisfying since the Gaussian noise and the Rayleigh speckle are greatly suppressed. The proposed method can improve the SNRs of the enhanced images to nearly 15 and 13 dB compared with images corrupted by speckle as well as images contaminated by speckle and noise under various SNR levels, respectively. The RSBF is effective in enhancing edge while smoothing the speckle and noise in clinical ultrasound images. In the comparison experiments, the proposed method demonstrates its superiority in accuracy and robustness for denoising and edge preserving under various levels of noise and speckle in terms of visual quality as well as numeric metrics, such as peak signal to noise ratio, SNR and root mean squared error.

Conclusions

The experimental results show that the proposed method is effective for removing the speckle and the background noise in ultrasound images. The main reason is that it performs a “detect and replace” two-step mechanism. The advantages of the proposed RBSF lie in two aspects. Firstly, each central pixel is classified as noise, speckle or noise-free texture according to the absolute difference between the target pixel and the reference median. Subsequently, the Rayleigh-maximum-likelihood filter and the bilateral filter are switched to eliminate speckle and noise, respectively, while the noise-free pixels are unaltered. Therefore, it is implemented with better accuracy and robustness than the traditional methods. Generally, these traits declare that the proposed RSBF would have significant clinical application.

Improvement of displacement estimation of breast tissue in ultrasound elastography using the monogenic signal

BACKGROUND

In breast ultrasound elastography, tissues displacements estimation is obtained through a technique that follows the evolution of tissues under stress. However, during the acquisition of B-mode images, tissue displacements are often contaminated with multiplicative noise caused by changes in the speckle pattern in the tissue. Thus, the application of monogenic signal technique on the B-mode image in order to estimate displacement tissue, result in a presence of amplified noise in the deformation tissue image, which severely obscures the useful information. In this paper, we propose a new method based on the monogenic features, that is to improve the old monogenic signal (OMS) technique by improving the filtering step, so that the use of an effective denoising technique is enough to ensure a good estimation of displacement tissue. Our proposed method is based on the use of a robust filtering technique combined with the monogenic model.

METHODS

Two models of phantom elasticity are used in our test validation sold by CIRS company. In-vivo testing was also performed on the sets of clinical B-mode images to 20 patients including malignant breast tumors. Shrinkage wavelets has been used to eliminate the noise according to the threshold, then a guided filter is introduced to completely filter the image, the monogenic model is used after excerpting the image feature and estimating analytically the displacement tissue.

RESULTS

Accurate and excellent displacement estimation for breast tissue was observed in proposed method results. By adapting our proposed approach to breast B-mode images, we have shown that it demonstrated a higher performance for displacement estimation; it gives better values in term of standard deviation, higher contrast to noise ratio, greater peak signal-to-noise ratio, excellent structural similarity and much faster speed than OMS and B-spline techniques. The results of the proposed model are encouraging, allowing quick and reliable estimations.

CONCLUSION

Although the proposed approach is used in ultrasound domains, it has never been used in the estimation of the breast tissue displacement. In this context, our proposed approach could be a powerful diagnostic tool to be used in breast displacement estimation in ultrasound elastography.

Nonlocal Total-Variation-Based Speckle Filtering for Ultrasound Images

Ultrasound is one of the most important medical imaging modalities for its real-time and portable imaging advantages. However, the contrast resolution and important details are degraded by the speckle in ultrasound images. Many speckle filtering methods have been developed, but they are suffered from several limitations, difficult to reach a balance between speckle reduction and edge preservation. In this paper, an adaptation of the nonlocal total variation (NLTV) filter is proposed for speckle reduction in ultrasound images. The speckle is modeled via a signal-dependent noise distribution for the log-compressed ultrasound images. Instead of the Euclidian distance, the statistical Pearson distance is introduced in this study for the similarity calculation between image patches via the Bayesian framework. And the Split-Bregman fast algorithm is used to solve the adapted NLTV despeckling functional. Experimental results on synthetic and clinical ultrasound images and comparisons with some classical and recent algorithms are used to demonstrate its improvements in both speckle noise reduction and tissue boundary preservation for ultrasound images.

Speckle filtering of medical ultrasonic images using wavelet and guided filter

Speckle noise is an inherent yet ineffectual residual artifact in medical ultrasound images, which significantly degrades quality and restricts accuracy in automatic diagnostic techniques. Speckle reduction is therefore an important step prior to the analysis and processing of the ultrasound images. A new de-noising method based on an improved wavelet filter and guided filter is proposed in this paper. According to the characteristics of medical ultrasound images in the wavelet domain, an improved threshold function based on the universal wavelet threshold function is developed. The wavelet coefficients of speckle noise and noise-free signal are modeled as Rayleigh distribution and generalized Gaussian distribution respectively. The Bayesian maximum a posteriori estimation is applied to obtain a new wavelet shrinkage algorithm. The coefficients of the low frequency sub-band in the wavelet domain are filtered by guided filter. The filtered image is then obtained by using the inverse wavelet transformation. Experiments with the comparison of the other seven de-speckling filters are conducted. The results show that the proposed method not only has a strong de-speckling ability, but also keeps the image details, such as the edge of a lesion.

Comparing noisy patches for image denoising: a double noise similarity model

This paper presents a concept of noise similarity (NS), which can be used to refine the comparison of noisy patch and enhance the denoising power of the nonlocal means (NLM) filter. The fact behind this concept is that the similarity of noisy patch should depend on not only the underlying signal (noise free patches), but also the noise. Based on the concept of noise similarity, we derived a double NS (DNS) model, which converts the denoising problem into the problem of reducing two kinds of noise: one is the superimposed additive noise; the other is the deviation error, defined as another kind of noise denoting the difference between similar pixels on their true intensities. The former corresponds to noise suppression, while the latter corresponds to the restoration of image details. To evaluate the effectiveness of the DNS model, we proposed an iterative version of the NLM filter, where the two noise similarities can work collaboratively in the framework of maximum a posterior. Finally, the experimental results demonstrate that the proposed approach can provide competitive performance when compared with other state-of-the-art NLM filters.

Automatic classification of intracardiac tumor and thrombi in echocardiography based on sparse representation

Identification of intracardiac masses in echocardiograms is one important task in cardiac disease diagnosis. To improve diagnosis accuracy, a novel fully automatic classification method based on the sparse representation is proposed to distinguish intracardiac tumor and thrombi in echocardiography. First, a region of interest is cropped to define the mass area. Then, a unique globally denoising method is employed to remove the speckle and preserve the anatomical structure. Subsequently, the contour of the mass and its connected atrial wall are described by the K-singular value decomposition and a modified active contour model. Finally, the motion, the boundary as well as the texture features are processed by a sparse representation classifier to distinguish two masses. Ninety-seven clinical echocardiogram sequences are collected to assess the effectiveness. Compared with other state-of-the-art classifiers, our proposed method demonstrates the best performance by achieving an accuracy of 96.91%, a sensitivity of 100%, and a specificity of 93.02%. It explicates that our method is capable of classifying intracardiac tumors and thrombi in echocardiography, potentially to assist the cardiologists in the clinical practice.

GPU-based block-wise nonlocal means denoising for 3D ultrasound images

Speckle suppression plays an important role in improving ultrasound (US) image quality. While lots of algorithms have been proposed for 2D US image denoising with remarkable filtering quality, there is relatively less work done on 3D ultrasound speckle suppression, where the whole volume data rather than just one frame needs to be considered. Then, the most crucial problem with 3D US denoising is that the computational complexity increases tremendously. The nonlocal means (NLM) provides an effective method for speckle suppression in US images. In this paper, a programmable graphic-processor-unit- (GPU-) based fast NLM filter is proposed for 3D ultrasound speckle reduction. A Gamma distribution noise model, which is able to reliably capture image statistics for Log-compressed ultrasound images, was used for the 3D block-wise NLM filter on basis of Bayesian framework. The most significant aspect of our method was the adopting of powerful data-parallel computing capability of GPU to improve the overall efficiency. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed method can enormously accelerate the algorithm.