Towards accurate estimation of cuffless and continuous blood pressure using multi-order derivative and multivariate photoplethysmogram features

A flexible multimodal pulse sensor for wearable continuous blood pressure monitoring

Monitoring of arterial blood pressure via cuffless pulse waveform measurement at the wrist has an important clinical value for the early diagnosis and prevention of cardiovascular disease. However, accurate measurement of the radial pulse waveform is challenging owing to its subtle, wideband, and preload-dependent variation characteristics. Evidence shows that uncertainties or variations of wearing pressure and skin temperature can cause artifact signals in wrist pulse measurements, thus degrading blood pressure estimate accuracy and hindering precise clinical diagnosis. Herein, we report a flexible multisensory pulse sensor utilizing natural piezo-thermic transduction of human skin in conjunction with thin-film thermistors for the accurately measuring radial artery pulse waves with high fidelity and good anti-artifact performance. The flexible pulse sensor achieved a wide pressure measuring range (228.2 kPa), low detection limit (4 Pa), good linearity (R2 = 0.999), low hysteresis (2.45%), fast response (88 ms), and good durability and stability, thereby enabling accurate pulse measurement with high fidelity. The pulse sensor also monolithically integrated the simultaneous detections of skin temperature and wearing pressure for resisting artifact effects in pulse measurements. Through the fusion of multiple features extracted from the pulse waveform, wearing pressure, skin temperature and user's personal physical characteristics using an efficient multilayer perceptron, blood pressure is accurately estimated and good generalizability is achieved.

Automatic identification of hypertension and assessment of its secondary effects using artificial intelligence: A systematic review (2013-2023)

Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques are increasingly used in computer-aided diagnostic tools in medicine. These techniques can also help to identify Hypertension (HTN) in its early stage, as it is a global health issue. Automated HTN detection uses socio-demographic, clinical data, and physiological signals. Additionally, signs of secondary HTN can also be identified using various imaging modalities. This systematic review examines related work on automated HTN detection. We identify datasets, techniques, and classifiers used to develop AI models from clinical data, physiological signals, and fused data (a combination of both). Image-based models for assessing secondary HTN are also reviewed. The majority of the studies have primarily utilized single-modality approaches, such as biological signals (e.g., electrocardiography, photoplethysmography), and medical imaging (e.g., magnetic resonance angiography, ultrasound). Surprisingly, only a small portion of the studies (22 out of 122) utilized a multi-modal fusion approach combining data from different sources. Even fewer investigated integrating clinical data, physiological signals, and medical imaging to understand the intricate relationships between these factors. Future research directions are discussed that could build better healthcare systems for early HTN detection through more integrated modeling of multi-modal data sources.

Blood Pressure Estimation Based on PPG and ECG Signals Using Knowledge Distillation

OBJECTIVE

Easy access bio-signals are useful for alleviating the shortcomings and difficulties associated with cuff-based and invasive blood pressure (BP) measurement techniques. This study proposes a deep learning model, trained using knowledge distillation, based on photoplethysmographic (PPG) and electrocardiogram (ECG) signals to estimate systolic and diastolic blood pressures.

METHODS

The estimation model comprises convolutional layers followed by one bidirectional recurrent layer and attention layers. The training approach involves knowledge distillation, where a smaller model (student model) is trained by leveraging information from a larger model (teacher model).

RESULTS

The proposed multistage model was evaluated on 1205 subjects from Medical Information Mart for Intensive Care (MIMIC) III database using the Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation (AAMI) and the standards of the British Hypertension Society (BHS). The results revealed that our model performance achieved grade A in estimating both systolic blood pressure (SBP) and diastolic blood pressure (DBP) and met the requirements of the AAMI standard. After training with knowledge distillation (KD), the model achieved a mean absolute error and standard deviation of 2.94 ± 5.61 mmHg for SBP and 2.02 ± 3.60 mmHg for DBP.

CONCLUSION

Our results demonstrate the benefits of the knowledge distillation training method in reducing the number of parameters and improving the predictive accuracy of the blood pressure regression model.

The Investigation of Bio-impedance Analysis at a Wrist Phantom with Two Pulsatile Arteries

PURPOSE

Bio-impedance analysis (BIA) has been widely investigated for hemodynamic monitoring. However, previous works rarely modelled two synchronously pulsatile arteries (representing the radial and ulnar arteries) in the wrist/forearm model. This work aims to clarify and quantify the influences of two pulsatile arteries on BIA.

METHODS

First, two blood-filled arteries were structured in a 3D wrist segment using the finite element method (FEM). Afterwards, an easy-to-produce two-arteries artificial wrist was fabricated with two components: gelatine-based surrounding tissue phantom and saline blood phantom. A syringe driver was utilised to constrict the arteries, and the impedance signals were measured using a Multi-frequency Impedance Analyser (MFIA).

RESULTS

Both simulation and experimental results demonstrated the non-negligible influences of the ulnar artery on the overall BIA, inducing unwanted resistance changes to the acquired signals from the radial artery. The phantom experiments revealed the summation of the individual resistance changes caused by a single pulsatile artery was approximately equal to the measured resistance change caused by two synchronously pulsatile arteries, confirming the measured impedance signal at the wrist contains the pulsatile information from both arteries.

CONCLUSION

This work is the first simulation and phantom investigation into two synchronously pulsatile arteries under BIA in the distal forearm, providing a better insight and understanding in the morphology of measured impedance signals. Future research can accordingly select either a small spacing 4-spot electrode configuration for a single artery sensing or a band electrode configuration for overall pulsatile arteries sensing. A more accurate estimation of blood volume change and pulse wave analysis (PWA) could help to develop cuffless blood pressure measurement (BPM).

Insights into vascular physiology from sleep photoplethysmography

STUDY OBJECTIVES

Photoplethysmography (PPG) in consumer sleep trackers is now widely available and used to assess heart rate variability (HRV) for sleep staging. However, PPG waveform changes during sleep can also inform about vascular elasticity in healthy persons who constitute a majority of users. To assess its potential value, we traced the evolution of PPG pulse waveform during sleep alongside measurements of HRV and blood pressure (BP).

METHODS

Seventy-eight healthy adults (50% male, median [IQR range] age: 29.5 [23.0, 43.8]) underwent overnight polysomnography (PSG) with fingertip PPG, ambulatory blood pressure monitoring, and electrocardiography (ECG). Selected PPG features that reflect arterial stiffness: systolic to diastolic distance (∆T_norm), normalized rising slope (Rslope) and normalized reflection index (RI) were derived using a custom-built algorithm. Pulse arrival time (PAT) was calculated using ECG and PPG signals. The effect of sleep stage on these measures of arterial elasticity and how this pattern of sleep stage evolution differed with participant age were investigated.

RESULTS

BP, heart rate (HR) and PAT were reduced with deeper non-REM sleep but these changes were unaffected by the age range tested. After adjusting for lowered HR, ∆T_norm, Rslope, and RI showed significant effects of sleep stage, whereby deeper sleep was associated with lower arterial stiffness. Age was significantly correlated with the amount of sleep-related change in ∆T_norm, Rslope, and RI, and remained a significant predictor of RI after adjustment for sex, body mass index, office BP, and sleep efficiency.

CONCLUSIONS

The current findings indicate that the magnitude of sleep-related change in PPG waveform can provide useful information about vascular elasticity and age effects on this in healthy adults.

A new method of continuous blood pressure monitoring using multichannel sensing signals on the wrist

Hypertension is a worldwide health problem and a primary risk factor for cardiovascular disease. Continuous monitoring of blood pressure has important clinical value for the early diagnosis and prevention of cardiovascular disease. However, existing technologies for wearable continuous blood pressure monitoring are usually inaccurate, rely on subject-specific calibration and have poor generalization across individuals, which limit their practical applications. Here, we report a new blood pressure measurement method and develop an associated wearable device to implement continuous blood pressure monitoring for new subjects. The wearable device detects cardiac output and pulse waveform features through dual photoplethysmography (PPG) sensors worn on the palmar and dorsal sides of the wrist, incorporating custom-made interface sensors to detect the wearing contact pressure and skin temperature. The detected multichannel signals are fused using a machine-learning algorithm to estimate continuous blood pressure in real time. This dual PPG sensing method effectively eliminates the personal differences in PPG signals caused by different people and different wearing conditions. The proposed wearable device enables continuous blood pressure monitoring with good generalizability across individuals and demonstrates promising potential in personal health care applications.

Fully convolutional neural network and PPG signal for arterial blood pressure waveform estimation

Objective. The quality of the arterial blood pressure (ABP) waveform is crucial for predicting the value of blood pressure. The ABP waveform is predicted through experiments, and then Systolic blood pressure (SBP), Diastolic blood pressure, (DBP), and Mean arterial pressure (MAP) information are estimated from the ABP waveform.Approach. To ensure the quality of the predicted ABP waveform, this paper carefully designs the network structure, input signal, loss function, and structural parameters. A fully convolutional neural network (CNN) MultiResUNet3+ is used as the core architecture of ABP-MultiNet3+. In addition to performing Kalman filtering on the original photoplethysmogram (PPG) signal, its first-order derivative and second-order derivative signals are used as ABP-MultiNet3+ enter. The model's loss function uses a combination of mean absolute error (MAE) and means square error (MSE) loss to ensure that the predicted ABP waveform matches the reference waveform.Main results. The proposed ABP-MultiNet3+ model was tested on the public MIMIC II databases, MAE of MAP, DBP, and SBP was 1.88 mmHg, 3.11 mmHg, and 4.45 mmHg, respectively, indicating a small model error. It experiment fully meets the standards of the AAMI standard and obtains level A in the DBP and MAP prediction standard test under the BHS standard. For SBP prediction, it obtains level B in the BHS standard test. Although it does not reach level A, it has a certain improvement compared with the existing methods.Significance. The results show that this algorithm can achieve sleeveless blood pressure estimation, which may enable mobile medical devices to continuously monitor blood pressure and greatly reduce the harm caused by Cardiovascular disease (CVD).

Emerging sensing and modeling technologies for wearable and cuffless blood pressure monitoring

Cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) are a leading cause of death worldwide. For early diagnosis, intervention and management of CVDs, it is highly desirable to frequently monitor blood pressure (BP), a vital sign closely related to CVDs, during people's daily life, including sleep time. Towards this end, wearable and cuffless BP extraction methods have been extensively researched in recent years as part of the mobile healthcare initiative. This review focuses on the enabling technologies for wearable and cuffless BP monitoring platforms, covering both the emerging flexible sensor designs and BP extraction algorithms. Based on the signal type, the sensing devices are classified into electrical, optical, and mechanical sensors, and the state-of-the-art material choices, fabrication methods, and performances of each type of sensor are briefly reviewed. In the model part of the review, contemporary algorithmic BP estimation methods for beat-to-beat BP measurements and continuous BP waveform extraction are introduced. Mainstream approaches, such as pulse transit time-based analytical models and machine learning methods, are compared in terms of their input modalities, features, implementation algorithms, and performances. The review sheds light on the interdisciplinary research opportunities to combine the latest innovations in the sensor and signal processing research fields to achieve a new generation of cuffless BP measurement devices with improved wearability, reliability, and accuracy.

Evaluating and Visualizing the Contribution of ECG Characteristic Waveforms for PPG-Based Blood Pressure Estimation

Non-invasive continuous blood pressure monitoring is of great significance for the preventing, diagnosing, and treating of cardiovascular diseases (CVDs). Studies have demonstrated that photoplethysmogram (PPG) and electrocardiogram (ECG) signals can effectively and continuously predict blood pressure (BP). However, most of the BP estimation models focus on the waveform features of the PPG signal, while the peak value of R-wave in ECG is only used as a time reference, and few references investigated the ECG waveforms. This paper aims to evaluate the influence of three characteristic waveforms in ECG on the improvement of BP estimation. PPG is the primary signal, and five input combinations are formed by adding ECG, P wave, QRS complex, T wave, and none. We employ five common convolutional neural networks (CNN) to validate the consistency of the contribution. Meanwhile, with the visualization of Gradient-weighted class activation mapping (Grad-CAM), we generate the heat maps and further visualize the distribution of CNN's attention to each waveform of PPG and ECG. The heat maps show that networks pay more attention to the QRS complex and T wave. In the comparison results, the QRS complex and T wave have more contribution to minimizing errors than P wave. By separately adding P wave, QRS complex, and T wave, the average MAE of these networks reaches 7.87 mmHg, 6.57 mmHg, and 6.21 mmHg for systolic blood pressure (SBP), and 4.27 mmHg, 3.65 mmHg, and 3.73 mmHg, respectively, for diastolic blood pressure (DBP). The results of the experiment show that QRS complex and T wave deserves more attention and feature extraction like PPG waveform features in the continuous BP estimation.

Methods for Continuous Blood Pressure Estimation Using Temporal Convolutional Neural Networks and Ensemble Empirical Mode Decomposition

Arterial blood pressure is not only an important index that must be measured in routine physical examination but also a key monitoring parameter of the cardiovascular system in cardiac surgery, drug testing, and intensive care. To improve the measurement accuracy of continuous blood pressure, this paper uses photoplethysmography (PPG) signals to estimate diastolic blood pressure and systolic blood pressure based on ensemble empirical mode decomposition (EEMD) and temporal convolutional network (TCN). In this method, the clean PPG signal is decomposed by EEMD to obtain n-order intrinsic mode functions (IMF), and then the IMF and the original PPG are input into the constructed TCN neural network model, and the results are output. The results show that TCN has better performance than CNN, CNN-LSTM, and CNN-GRU. Using the data added with IMF, the results of the above neural network model are better than those of the model with only PPG as input, in which the systolic blood pressure (SBP) and diastolic blood pressure (DBP) results of EEMD-TCN are −1.55 ± 9.92 mmHg and 0.41 ± 4.86 mmHg. According to the estimation results, DBP meets the requirements of the AAMI standard, BHS evaluates it as Grade A, SD of SBP is close to the standard AAMI, and BHS evaluates it as Grade B.

Diagnostic Features and Potential Applications of PPG Signal in Healthcare: A Systematic Review

Recent research indicates that Photoplethysmography (PPG) signals carry more information than oxygen saturation level (SpO2) and can be utilized for affordable, fast, and noninvasive healthcare applications. All these encourage the researchers to estimate its feasibility as an alternative to many expansive, time-wasting, and invasive methods. This systematic review discusses the current literature on diagnostic features of PPG signal and their applications that might present a potential venue to be adapted into many health and fitness aspects of human life. The research methodology is based on the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guidelines 2020. To this aim, papers from 1981 to date are reviewed and categorized in terms of the healthcare application domain. Along with consolidated research areas, recent topics that are growing in popularity are also discovered. We also highlight the potential impact of using PPG signals on an individual’s quality of life and public health. The state-of-the-art studies suggest that in the years to come PPG wearables will become pervasive in many fields of medical practices, and the main domains include cardiology, respiratory, neurology, and fitness. Main operation challenges, including performance and robustness obstacles, are identified.

A Data-Driven Model with Feedback Calibration Embedded Blood Pressure Estimator Using Reflective Photoplethysmography

Ambulatory blood pressure (BP) monitoring (ABPM) is vital for screening cardiovascular activity. The American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association guideline for the prevention, detection, evaluation, and management of BP in adults recommends measuring BP outside the office setting using daytime ABPM. The recommendation to use night–day BP measurements to confirm hypertension is consistent with the recommendation of several other guidelines. In recent studies, ABPM was used to measure BP at regular intervals, and it reduces the effect of the environment on BP. Out-of-office measurements are highly recommended by almost all hypertension organizations. However, traditional ABPM devices based on the oscillometric technique usually interrupt sleep. For all-day ABPM purposes, a photoplethysmography (PPG)-based wrist-type device has been developed as a convenient tool. This optical, noninvasive device estimates BP using morphological characteristics from PPG waveforms. As measurement can be affected by multiple variables, calibration is necessary to ensure that the calculated BP values are accurate. However, few studies focused on adaptive calibration. A novel adaptive calibration model, which is data-driven and embedded in a wearable device, was proposed. The features from a 15 s PPG waveform and personal information were input for estimation of BP values and our data-driven calibration model. The model had a feedback calibration process using the exponential Gaussian process regression method to calibrate BP values and avoid inter- and intra-subject variability, ensuring accuracy in long-term ABPM. The estimation error of BP (ΔBP = actual BP—estimated BP) of systolic BP was −0.1776 ± 4.7361 mmHg; ≤15 mmHg, 99.225%, and of diastolic BP was −0.3846 ± 6.3688 mmHg; ≤15 mmHg, 98.191%. The success rate was improved, and the results corresponded to the Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation standard and British Hypertension Society Grading criteria for medical regulation. Using machine learning with a feedback calibration model could be used to assess ABPM for clinical purposes.

Towards a portable-noninvasive blood pressure monitoring system utilizing the photoplethysmogram signal

Blood pressure (BP) responds instantly to the body's conditions, such as movements, diseases or infections, and sudden excitation. Therefore, BP monitoring is a standard clinical measurement and is considered one of the fundamental health signs that assist in predicting and diagnosing several cardiovascular diseases. The traditional BP techniques (i.e. the cuff-based methods) only provide intermittent measurements over a certain period. Additionally, they cause turbulence in the blood flow, impeding the continuous BP monitoring, especially in emergency cases. In this study, an instrumentation system is designed to estimate BP noninvasively by measuring the PPG signal utilizing the optical technique. The photoplethysmogram (PPG) signals were measured and processed for ≈ 450 cases with different clinical conditions and irrespective of their health condition. A total of 13 features of the PPG signal were used to estimate the systolic and diastolic blood pressure (SBP and DBP), utilizing several machine learning techniques. The experimental results showed that the designed system is able to effectively describe the complex-embedded relationship between the features of the PPG signal and BP (SBP and DBP) with high accuracy. The mean absolute error (MAE) ± standard deviation (SD) was 4.82 ± 3.49 mmHg for the SBP and 1.37 ± 1.65 mmHg for the DBP, with a mean error (ME) of ≈ 0 mmHg. The estimation results are consistent with the Association for the American National Standards of the Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation (AAMI) and achieved Grade A in the British Hypertension Society (BHS) standards for the DBP and Grade B for the SBP. Such a study effectively contributes to the scientific efforts targeting the promotion of the practical application for providing a portable-noninvasive instrumentation system for BP monitoring purposes. Once the BP is determined with sufficient accuracy, it can be utilized further in the early prediction and classification of various arrhythmias such as hypertension, tachycardia, bradycardia, and atrial fibrillation (as the early detection can be a critical issue).

Prediction of arterial blood pressure waveforms from photoplethysmogram signals via fully convolutional neural networks

Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is one of the most serious diseases threatening human health. Arterial blood pressure (ABP) waveforms, containing vivid cardiovascular information, are of great significance for the diagnosis and the prevention of CVD. This paper proposes a deep learning model, named ABP-Net, to transform photoplethysmogram (PPG) signals into ABP waveforms that contain vital physiological information related to cardiovascular systems. In order to guarantee the quality of the predicted ABP waveforms, the structure of the network, the input signals and the loss functions are carefully designed. Specifically, a Wave-U-Net, one kind of fully convolutional neural networks (CNN), is taken as the core architecture of the ABP-Net. Besides the original PPG signals, its first derivative and second derivative signals are all utilized as the inputs of the ABP-Net. Additionally, the maximal absolute loss, accompany with the mean squared error loss is employed to ensure the match of the predicted ABP waveform with the reference one. The performance of the proposed ABP network is tested on the public MIMIC II database both in subject-dependent and subject-independent manners. Both results verify the superior performance of the proposed model over those existing methods accordingly. The mean absolute error (MAE) and the root-mean-square error (RMSE) between the predicted waveforms via the ABP-Net and the reference ones are 3.20 mmHg and 4.38 mmHg during the subject-dependent experiments while those are 5.57 mmHg and 7.15 mmHg during the subject-independent experiments. Benefiting from the predicted high-quality ABP waveforms, more ABP related physiological parameters can be better obtained, which effectively expands the application scope of PPG devices.

Estimation of Continuous Blood Pressure from PPG via a Federated Learning Approach

Ischemic heart disease is the highest cause of mortality globally each year. This puts a massive strain not only on the lives of those affected, but also on the public healthcare systems. To understand the dynamics of the healthy and unhealthy heart, doctors commonly use an electrocardiogram (ECG) and blood pressure (BP) readings. These methods are often quite invasive, particularly when continuous arterial blood pressure (ABP) readings are taken, and not to mention very costly. Using machine learning methods, we develop a framework capable of inferring ABP from a single optical photoplethysmogram (PPG) sensor alone. We train our framework across distributed models and data sources to mimic a large-scale distributed collaborative learning experiment that could be implemented across low-cost wearables. Our time-series-to-time-series generative adversarial network (T2TGAN) is capable of high-quality continuous ABP generation from a PPG signal with a mean error of 2.95 mmHg and a standard deviation of 19.33 mmHg when estimating mean arterial pressure on a previously unseen, noisy, independent dataset. To our knowledge, this framework is the first example of a GAN capable of continuous ABP generation from an input PPG signal that also uses a federated learning methodology.