Comparative evaluation of three methods of skin graft fixation for split thickness skin graft after release of post burn contracture of the neck

Securing skin grafts: A network meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Skin grafting is one of the most common procedures in plastic surgery. However, there are no defined guidelines for optimal fixation. The aim of this network meta-analysis (NMA) was to consolidate existing evidence by comparing various graft securing methods and determining the most effective approach for clinical practice.

METHODS

An NMA was conducted using a predetermined protocol after searching several electronic databases from inception to October 2023 for studies examining skin grafting fixation outcomes in adults.

RESULTS

A total of 27 studies were included in the analysis involving 1937 patients. Negative pressure wound therapy (NPWT) was the only method to significantly improve graft take percentages in comparison with the other modalities, whereas tie-over bolster (TOB) provided the worst results in take rates when examined as events. Fibrin glue (FIB) and TOB reduced hematoma and seroma rates when data were investigated in conjunction.

CONCLUSIONS

NPWT appears to be the most effective for skin graft adherence as opposed to traditional techniques. Its cost-effectiveness remains unclear, as NPWT is a relatively costly intervention compared with other methods. FIB and TOB are methods that can serve as a method of reducing hematoma and seroma rates in patients at high risk of bleeding.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

I.

Prevention and Treatment of Burn Scar Contracture: A Practical Review

Burn contracture affects close to one-third of all burn patients, leading to significant functional impairment and costs. Effective prevention and treatment strategies are necessary to decrease morbidity and unnecessary costs. This scoping review aimed to summarize prevention and treatment strategies used for management of burn scar contractures published in the literature since 2000. A comprehensive PubMed review was performed in October 2022 to identify methods of burn contracture prevention and treatments. Non-English, duplicate, and unavailable articles were excluded. Data were extracted including publication year, techniques, and outcomes. A total of 327 publications met criteria for inclusion. Most articles were published in 2011 (n = 22). Treatment strategies were discussed in 82.9% of studies, prevention in 16.5%, and both in 0.6%. The most common areas discussed included the upper extremity (n = 127) and neck (n = 102). Flaps were the most frequently used method (n = 208), followed by autografts (n = 89). Most preventative therapies were still in early stages of development. Burn contracture management requires a highly individualized approach with many available reconstructive techniques available. Further research is needed to improve prevention techniques and decrease morbidity and cost to patients.

[Surgical treatment of combined injuries of the neck and shoulder joints]

OBJECTIVE

To develop the algorithm for effective surgical restoration of shoulder joint and neck functions and acceleration of social and labor rehabilitation.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

There were 116 patients with combined consequences of burns of the neck and shoulder joints between 2012 and 2021. These ones amounted to 29.4% of all patients with lesions of the neck or shoulder joints. Simultaneous surgeries with correction of post-burn cicatricial deformities and contractures were performed in 66 patients (56.9%). Age of patients ranged from 18 to 72 years, and 96% of them were employable. There were 89 (76.7%) women and 27 (23.3%) men. We assessed spread and localization of cicatricial process, as well as restriction of mobility of the neck and shoulder joint to select optimal surgical approach. Classification of neck deformities and contractures of shoulder joints considering severity of cicatricial lesion and functional impairment made it possible to systematize the approach to reconstructive procedures. Reconstructive surgery included repair with local tissues including skin-fatty flap, non-perforated split or full-thickness skin autograft, rotated flaps including those based on perforator vessels, as well as preliminary skin stretching.

RESULTS

In general, 116 patients with combined lesions of the neck and shoulder joints underwent 314 surgeries. To accelerate rehabilitation, we performed simultaneous surgeries with correction of deformities and contractures in 66 patients (56.9%). Staged reconstructive surgeries were carried out in 50 patients. Acute dermotension and skin-fatty neck flap grafting were the most common for deformities and contractures of the neck. Skin-fatty axillary flap was used in most patients with contractures of shoulder joints.

CONCLUSION

Simultaneous surgeries can accelerate rehabilitation. Correct algorithm of staged surgical treatment reduces rehabilitation period and eliminates functional disorders.

The use of cyanoacrylate glue for skin grafts stabilisation: A retrospective multicenter study

Cyanoacrylate (CA) tissue glue is frequently used in various surgical procedures, and it is simple to use and may save time during procedures. We report the use, effectiveness, and postoperative outcomes of patients who have undergone skin graft surgeries in which CA glue was used to stabilise the graft. A retrospective study of patients who underwent skin graft surgeries where CA was used to stabilise the grafts between January 2018 and August 2021 at different medical institutes in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. The analysis was performed using the Statistical Package for Social Science, version 23.0 (IBM, Armonk, New York). A total of 36 cases were included. Five patients (13.9%) had diabetes. All cases received antibiotics preoperatively. Two types of harvested skin grafts were used: (a) a non-meshed split-thickness skin graft (n = 24, 66.7%), and (b) a meshed split-thickness skin graft (n = 12, 33.3%). The graft uptake outcome was 100% for 32 patients (88.9%). The most common underlying indication of skin grafting was burn 17 (47.2%), in which 5 (13.9%) developed partial graft loss. The percentage of skin grafts taken using CA was high and comparable to other fixation methods. Further studies may be needed to assess the long-term outcomes and cost-effectiveness.

Safeguarding Skin Grafts: An Evidence-Based Summary of Fixation Techniques

BACKGROUND

Effective skin graft fixation is vital in preventing sheering forces, seroma, and hematoma from compromising graft take. Yet, selecting the ideal technique for securing skin grafts remains a contentious subject, with significant variation in practice existing between surgeons. There is, therefore, benefit to be derived from assessing the literature for evidence-based recommendations to guide the decision-making process.

METHODS

A search of Medline and Embase was performed using appropriate key terms, yielding 419 articles. Reference lists were analyzed. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were composed. Level I to III studies, as defined by the Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine, that compared skin graft fixation methods were analyzed. Rayyan QCRI was used for abstract and title screening. After full text screening, 41 studies were included for qualitative analysis. All included randomized control trials (RCTs) were assessed for risk of bias using the Cochrane Risk-of-Bias 2 (ROB2) tool.

RESULTS

We identified 4 groups of fixation technique: "tie-over bolster" (TOB), "no TOB," "adhesive glues," and "negative pressure wound therapy" (NPWT). Twelve studies compared TOB with no TOB, with no difference in graft take demonstrated. Sixteen studies compared adhesive glues with traditional methods, with no difference in graft take demonstrated. Thirteen studies compared NPWT with traditional methods, with enhanced graft take demonstrated. Risk of bias was deemed low in 1 of 13 RCTs.

CONCLUSIONS

Based on the current evidence, only NPWT is associated with enhanced graft take. However, there is a scarcity of robust level I evidence comparing different fixation techniques, meaning that strong recommendations cannot be made. We propose examples of hypothesis-driven RCTs, in predetermined clinical settings, based on the theoretical benefits of the techniques that would add value to clinical practice.

Full-thickness Skin Graft Fixation Techniques: A Review of the Literature

Multiple techniques for skin graft fixation have been proposed, but the evidence underlying these techniques is unclear. This study aimed to review the literature for full-thickness graft fixation techniques. PubMed was electronically searched to identify relevant studies. The search strategy identified 91 relevant articles. These consisted of 2 randomised controlled trials (RCTs), 10 observational cohort studies (8 retrospective, 2 prospective), and 79 descriptive studies (case series, case reports, or expert opinion articles). Both identified RCTs compared the tie-over dressing against a modified tie-over dressing. The tie-over dressing was also included in all identified observational studies, and comparisons were made against quilting/mattress suturing (4 studies, 181 grafts in total), simple pressure dressings (3 studies, 528 grafts), non-tie-over dressings non-specifically (1 study, 71 grafts), hydrocolloid dressings (1 study, 62 grafts), and double-tie over dressings (1 study, 43 grafts). No significant differences were found between fixation methods for graft take, haematoma rate, and infection rate. No studies have found a significant difference between tie-over dressings and alternative graft fixation technique, with the most evidence for simple pressure dressings and quilting/mattress suturing. However, the evidence base consists mostly of small, retrospective observational studies. This article describes the current evidence base and this should be considered when planning future reports in the field.